Entertainment For Lively Minds
World cinema stars in Hollywood (I refuse to name this post "Lost In Translation")
Delivering her verdict on Almodovar's "Broken Embraces" in the current issue, Kate Mossman poses the question, "Why is Penelope Cruz so good in Spanish movies and more than a little bit annoying in Hollywood ones?"
It's a fair point: nobody would argue that anything Cruz has done Stateside could ever hold a candle to her European work (even if she did, by many accounts, act Ben Kingsley under the table in "Elegy"). But why the belief that Cruz is uniquely afflicted in this way? Isn't it simply that she, like just about every other continental European or Asian arthouse star who has ever had a crack at Hollywood, has found good parts much harder to come by Stateside than at home?
Let's face it, unless they can pass themselves off as Americans, all Hollywood seems to offer to European and Asian arthouse actors is a dispiriting rogues' gallery of national stereotypes or bizarrely half-baked hybrids you'd never find in the real world (though if they're male and cut from a suitably lugubrious cloth, there's always the Bond/other franchise movie villain option). Is it any wonder, then, that the stars of world cinema all too often seem to mislay their mojo in Tinseltown? While Cruz has given us a fair few Hollywood stinkers, so have Juliette Binoche ("Dan in Real Life"? "Wuthering Heights"?) and Gong Li ("Miami Vice"? "Hannibal Rising"?), to pick some examples at random. Just because Vincent Cassel seems physically incapable of being dull on screen, does not mean I ever want to sit through "Derailed" or "Ocean's 13" again.
Of course, some get lucky and land meaty roles, such as Javier Bardem's turn as Anton Chigurh in "No Country For Old Men" and Binoche's performance as Hana in "The English Patient", but am struggling to think of many more. Can anyone think of any other good or even great performances by continental European/Asian actors in Hollywood films?
- More from graceunderpressure.
- Login or register to post comments










What about...
Ingrid Berman? And Haing S. Ngor is The Killing Fields? Errr, that's it.
Max Von Sydow
in The Exorcist?
isabelle huppert
in hal hartley's 'amateur'
gerard depierdeu 'green card'
Babel
Don't know if it counts as Hollywood, but lots of great foreign actors. Mainly Rinko Kikuchi as the deaf girl.
And I liked the Grudge films. Which obviously had a load of Japanese actors in them. But again, not sure if they count as Hollywood or arthouse.
Sorry, mental block!
I should have thought of Ingrid Bergman (though I prefer her performance in the other I. Bergman's "Autumn Sonata" to her Hollywood stuff).
Ref Isabelle Huppert in "Amateur": fair enough, though I deliberately overlooked US indies and English-language films from outside the US (aside from Hollywood co-productions) as these seem to offer more diverse non-American roles, but it looks like we're going to have to cast the net a little wider anyway...
Funnily enough
I was thinking about this the other day, because I remember this topic being the subject of a question on Family Fortunes many moons ago - I kid you not.
'We asked 100 people to name a famous Hollywood star who is not British or American1 (something like that!)
To show you how long ago this was, the top answers were Omar Sharif and Yul Brynner!
Arnold Schwarzenegger
Terminator
I'll get the Exo-Skeleton.
Armin Mueller-Stahl
I submit " The Music Box" and "Shine" as evidence
Charlotte Gainsbourg
She's only half-French, granted, but started off in some French films before doing music, and also staring in an adaptation of Jane Eyre and also Antichrist that's just come out with Willem DeFoe.
"Bloody" Marlene Dietrich
Destry Rides Again. Among others.