Entertainment For Lively Minds
Where next after Revolution in the Head?
Posted by Joe Robert on 26 January 2010 - 2:35pm.
Over the years I've read and re-read Ian MacDonald's Revolution in the Head to the point where I know certain bits of it off by heart. I want to find out a bit more about how the songs were put together and recorded. Can anyone recommend any other good Beatle books along those lines? I've seen the The Beatles As Musicians books recommended elsewhere, but my grasp of musical theory is zero and I gather you have to be fairly well up on that stuff to get the most of them (plus they're very expensive on Amazon). Any other suggestions?
- More from Joe Robert.
- Login or register to post comments









Best Beatles book, hands down, since Revolution in the Head
is Jonathan Gould's
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Cant-Buy-Me-Love-22Beatles-22/dp/074992988X/
Actually thats a quote from The Times but its true.
(assuming you don't have Mark Lewisohn's Complete Beatles Chronicle.)
Hmmmm....
Who are these Beatles, of which you speak?
Are they the games console fellas?
A few suggestions...
Can't Buy Me Love: The Beatles, Britain and America by Jonathan Gould is easily one of the best music books I've read, period. When it came out I thought, Christ another book on the Beatles!?? I've read quite a few, and up until that point I'd held Shout by Philip Norman and Revolution in the Head to have cornered the market. However, Can't Buy Me Love is equally as good as either of those, and I go as far to say it's better than Norman's simply because its more vibrantly written.
On one hand it's the Beatles story, told in fab (!) detail, but also sets their rise and fall into very colourful context. So, not only do you get their tale, but you're also treated to some brief, but highly insightful context on everything from the growth of the UK's rising fascination with colloquial accents, right through to how the Beatles came along just at the right time, where US television was concerned (they followed the assassination of Kennedy, and stations were looking for a new story). If anything the book shows how the Beatles phenomenon was actually a convergence of many different things, to which the band essentially became a collective figurehead.
Don't let this put you off, though, the book is really well written, expertly researched, and despite being a brick-of-a-thing is highly accessible and once you start reading you'll be hard-pressed to put it down.
Beyond that, the recent Lennon biography, also by Philip Norman is very good; and, again, despite being a hefty volume, highly readable and new enough in its style, approach and delivery to surpass all that went before. Quite sad, too.
I agree. There's also some
I agree. There's also some muso style analysis of songs a la Ian McDonald.
Keep an eye out for Jonathan Gould's book in remainder bookshops. Although it's only a couple of years old I've seen it kicking around for £4 which is a steal. HMV often sell them off cheap, I picked up Philip Thomas' Shout for £3 in the summer and I hear the Lennon biography is also going cheap too.
The Norman biography
is excellent, and as the_saint said, quite sad. Notable too for a far more generous assessment of Macca than in 'Shout'.
Recording the Beatles
It's expensive, but I'm told it's very, very good:
http://www.recordingthebeatles.com/
The Beatles Chronicles
Mark Lewishon as mentioned above..
I like "Love me do" by
I like "Love me do" by Michael Braun. Written in 1963, it captures them right at the beginning of their success. No revisionism or propaganda
It was mentioned by Hepworth in the latest Word
I think.
But the best book just in terms of reportage and "getting" them is Michael Braun's Love Me Do. I recommend that. Written in the early days before they became full on cultural behemoths, it basically observes them on tour and neither gushes or patronizes.
Curse your nimble fingers!
Oh well...
Snap!
great minds etc.
Is Mark Lewisohn
working on a massive three-part mothership of a biography? I can't remember where I heard that. I suppose he is the bloke to do it, although I wonder if his prose will have half the same luminescent wistfulness Philip Norman's did in 'Shout!' and (IMO) to a lesser extent, the Lennon book.
As far as I know, he still is.
The first volume is due out this year.
I imagine that one will take us up to "She Loves You", "With The Beatles", London Palladium "Beatlemania" etc at the very most; but wouldn't be surprised if it stops before Harrison has a chance to make any comments about George Martin's tie.
First Volume is now listed in Amazon
The 3 part series is called Fab!
Volume 1 is itself a 2 parter according to Amazon.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Fab-v-1-Beatles-Biography/dp/0316729604/
"Volume One tells the early part of the story in two parts: 'Passion' from 1940-62 discusses the beginnings of the band, and 'Explosion' focuses on 1963, the year when everything changed"
Only 19 months to wait....
Only 19 months to wait.... tum to tum....
I'm surprised
The swamp of Beatle-lit hasn't unearthed more about that tie. What did it look like? What aspects so offended young Harrison's delicate sensibilities? After all, in its limp, controversially-coloured way, it cemented the bond between Georges on that fateful day.
The White Album book
I enjoyed "Revolution: The Making of the Beatles' White Album" by David Quantick, it's going cheap on Amazon.
I agree, this was excellent
I agree, this was excellent and another great bargain I found in Selectadisc (RIP) in Nottingham.
More agreement from me
Makes you love the album even more...
Paul McCartney Many Years From Now by Barry Miles
It offers fascinating insight as far as the songwriting goes. It´s possibly the closest we´ll come to an autobiography by McCartney. I find myself returning to it quite often, reading various chapters.
Re: Revolution in the Head - other great Beatles Books
1. Although most seem to go to his later "Beatles Chronicles", I have always preferred Mark Lewisohn's 1988 book "The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions", which as the title suggests concentrates primarily on the recordings. However, it is a bit hard to come by at the moment:
http://www.amazon.com/Complete-Beatles-Recording-Sessions-1962-1970/dp/0...
2. From the previous decade, Roy Carr & Tony Tyler's "The Beatles: An Illustrated Record" was the earliest attempt I can remember of anyone analysing the Beatles recorded legacy. Originating from a consumer's guide Carr and Tyler published over several weeks in NME in 1973, it puts forward, for one of the first times in print, the (now widely accepted) opinion that "Revolver" is actually a better album than "Pepper", and exposes the "mix'n'match mess" that Capitol in the US offered to the American fans instead of the original LPs and singles (in order to make as much money out of them as possible). Although it does have its inaccuracies, it was invaluable at the time, and remains a good read.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Beatles-Illustrated-Record-Roy-Carr/dp/045005228...
A bit hard to come by indeed!
The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions: The Official Story of the Abbey Road Years 1962-1970 (Paperback)
~ Mark Lewisohn (Author)
4.9 out of 5 stars See all reviews (36 customer reviews)
Available from these sellers.
1 new from $1,669.95 6 used from $160.00
WTF?!
The Love You Make, an Insider's Story of the Beatles..
...is excellent. Much better thanm Shout!, I thought.