What's your other-half listening to...

Yes, yes, we all know The WORD massive has great taste in music but does this extend to your loved one? Or is it a source of discomfort?

Mrs. Nicodemus is currently wrestling for control of the kitchen cd player with this lot:

Michelle Shocked: Captain Swing.

Abba: Greatest Hits (yes, she recently went to see Mama Mia with her Mother)

Amy Winehouse: Back To Black

Duffy: Rockferry

Bruce Springsteen: Darkness On The Edge Of Town,

You were lucky

Every time I let the current Mrs Legg near the music she puts on The Lighthouse Family. To paraphrase Billy Connelly - never trust a band who's name rhymes with toilet.

Nigel Legg | 27 August 2008 - 7:02am

'Family'

doesn't rhyme with 'toilet' surely?

eddie g | 27 August 2008 - 7:58am

Lighthouse

Shitehouse maybe?

Sven | 27 August 2008 - 8:01am

Lighthouse Family joke c. 1994

"Where are the Lighthouse Family these days?"
"On the rocks, apparently"

Austin | 30 August 2008 - 8:16pm

My girlfriend...

has a playlist on her I-Pod of Italian pop from the '80s. It is scary stuff... very scary indeed.

Patrick Crowther | 27 August 2008 - 8:07am

Mainly female bluegrass singers

Alison Krauss and the like, mostly pretty great stuff. She does have a couple of Abba albums though and was first in the queue for Mamma Mia when it came out.

Niks | 27 August 2008 - 8:13am

The present Mrs K

has currently got Tom Baxter in the car. Now I yield to no one in my admiration of young Mr B but the GLW is inclined to play one cd to death and then put it away for months. (see Amy MacDonald)

Just wish she would rotate her choices a bit more.

Gordon Kerr | 27 August 2008 - 8:17am

I wouldn't know what the Management is listening to

Probably Radio Four. I will say this. If I met a previously unknown family and was called upon to choose which member of them I would prefer to choose the music, it would be MRS GLW every single time.

Men, as a sex, use music to position themselves. Teenage boys use music to annoy everyone else. Teenage girls tend to go for sappy things. Whereas women, particularly women who have learned that there are more important things in life, such as childbirth, tend to choose music which is primarily pleasant to listen to.

I'll take that every time.

David Hepworth | 27 August 2008 - 8:31am

Hmm interesting theory

But does anyone else find themselves doing that terrible thing when you go round someone's house you don't really know very well, like a party of your other half's work colleagues or something and you find yourself itching to go and look at the CD racks. After scanning them for a few seconds and clocking a couple of Coldplay CDs and an uplifting trance compilation you start feeling really superior, quickly followed by a yawning sense of your own social inadequacy?

No? Only me then.

Niks | 27 August 2008 - 8:50am

Probably where most music nightmares occur

Dinner at someone's house. Before we leave I'm told in no uncertain terms by the GLW I'm not to say anything about the background music. Enevitably 9 times out of 10 it's an aural nightmare. Once the whole night was Robbie Williams, Atomic Kitten and the like.
Needless to say our turn to host started with Sir Richard Thomson, Tom Waits etc till Sufjan Stevens prompted the cold eyes of my other half to force me to the "something they'll like" section.

Gordon Kerr | 27 August 2008 - 10:41am

Nick Hornby

You'll have read the bit about that in High Fidelity I am sure... I had to read it several times before I understood the point. "Good people can have crap record collections." Come again? It was a big ask. I got there in the end. Though not before friends got into the habit of asking me before they put music on (in their own houses). It was the look on my face apparently.

My reason for existing usually states her musical taste as "Dead Black Guys". She occasionally extends it to include "Dead Black Women" and Radiohead. She is definitely a WUD (Wife under duress) at Richard Thompson gigs.

paulwright | 28 August 2008 - 4:24pm

I am a fairly recent convert ...

...to Richard 'Tommo' Thompson (No, OK, thought I'd try it) and much to my joy my wife also enjoys him, she likes the timbre of his voice or something...needless to say we now play a lot of richard thompson and less paul weller, the beatles etc...

mattbrammer | 1 September 2008 - 10:29am

You sure

Depends how much you like to listen to Mike Oldfield's Music Of The Spheres or Trans Siberian Orchestra's Christmas CDs. Every week. On permanent rotation in the 5-CD house stereo.

Failing that, UKTV Garden or Food, just for the noise.

GGGGRRRRRRRRRRRRR!

Beany | 27 August 2008 - 9:30am

Not sure

I'm not sure I agree with you on that one David. In particular, in my youth when I was listening to 'complicated' things like Yes and ELP, my teenage girl friends were listening to classic soul and disco. I thought this sappy at the the time, but now I reckon that Barry White's 'You're the First, the Last, My Everything' knocks the spots off 'Siberian Khatru'.

Handsome.P.Wonderful | 27 August 2008 - 10:31am

My wife...

...listens to Radio 2 in the car a lot. That means that she's far more aware of things than I am; also I like it when she comes in from a 2 or 3 hour journey and says that she heard something that I'll like. Through the magic of the internet, within a minute we have found said song, even if she didn't know what it was called. Of course, then there are the times that she listens to The Fray. But you can't have everything.

Lucas Hare | 27 August 2008 - 8:41am

Mrs G

always asks me if whatever I'm about to play her is 'better than silence'. I must admit that it very rarely is.

eddie g | 27 August 2008 - 9:21am

Mrs H...

...currently has “Ultimate Disco Party” on in the car, a triple CD collection of 70s disco greats that “leapt off the shelf” at Tescos, with all the usual suspects and several forgotten gems - fantastic stuff, although it’s about the 6th similarly themed compilation that she’s got.

Also in her car are Orson’s first album, everything by Michael Buble, Carpenters Gold and the recent Take That album, all of which I’m now more familiar with than I ever thought I might be.

Her brother tends to put music on to deliberately annoy his wife and will skip anything that he knows she likes. And he frequently pours scorn on most of her listening choices. It’s an interesting family dynamic to observe !

Simon Hoyle | 27 August 2008 - 10:03am

My GLW

defines things as 'music' and 'boy music'. The distinction, as you might imagine, is a tad subjective.

Fraser M | 27 August 2008 - 10:10am

The sound of her own voice

I bought Mrs Wonderful singing lessons last Christmas (she's always enjoyed singing, but never been very good at it). It was part serious / part joke, but she absolutely loves it (a tip for you chaps as the festive eason approaches). As a result she tapes every lesson and plays it back in the car and on her iPod. Her usual Dylan selections have gone out the window, although an imminent Leonard Cohen gig means that both of us are swotting up on his ouevre.

Handsome.P.Wonderful | 27 August 2008 - 10:25am

The spots

are still on my Khatru.

eddie g | 27 August 2008 - 10:31am

My admittedly narrow and limited experience

is that the male of the household has the best music, not that I would use that as a basis for a generalisation about the world at large. My teenage nephews like their music, both play in bands. One of them loves Lynrd Skynrd. Their mother likes that one that goes 'I'm a big big girl in a big big house' for example. I've not yet come across a household where the woman's music was superior. I'm sure they exist though.

I like quite a lot of what my other half likes - REM, Radiohead. She is also keen on Editors, Coldplay, James Blunt and Jamiroquai. Generally Radio 2 is best way to listen to music together without dispute we find.

Sven | 27 August 2008 - 11:25am

I suspect...

That women simply care less about the minutiae of music, in the same way they probably care less about train-spotting, or brass-rubbing, or stamp collecting.

Play a man an unfamiliar record and ask him if he likes it, he'll probably ask, "who is it?" before responding, just to make sure it's OK for him to like it. Ask a woman, you'll more than likely get a plain and simple answer, without any consideration given to whether the bass player used to be in Travis or if the artist is as credible as they used to be or if song is too mainstream or otherwise.

Of course I'm generalising, but from my experience women have a much healthier attitude towards music. Men argue with themselves as to why they should like something. Women simply do.

Fraser Lewry | 27 August 2008 - 11:39am

Probably true.

That's fair comment.

Sven | 27 August 2008 - 11:44am

"He'll probably ask, "who is it?" before responding."

So true! I've just spent a week sailing round the Ionian sea with my brothers, and at one point put some early Porcupine Tree on, only to get that very question. I refused to answer.

Fraser M | 27 August 2008 - 11:50am

"Some early Porcupine Tree"

That's when you know you should get out more - when you start dividing Porcupine Tree into periods.

David Hepworth | 27 August 2008 - 12:53pm

Why?

Their output has had 3 distinct periods. The first three albums are dance/ambient space rock, the next three were informed by classic 70s rock and and emphasis on songwriting and their last three albums have all shown a significant metal influence.

If you're just having a more general pop at either Porcupine Tree or my taste, I'm going to have to flick you a rude guesture!

Fraser M | 27 August 2008 - 1:19pm

The other half is digging

Albums by:
Last Shadow Puppets
Sharleen Spiteri
Duffy
A homemade compilation with an MP3 of Feist's Sesame Street turn as the first track (A subtle plea: THERE ARE 20 OTHER TRACKS TOO DARLING)

And enjoyed Reading-Festival-Coverage-on-TV-wise:
Queens Of The Stone Age
The Killers

But didn't see 'the point' of Justice.
Hmmmm.

lovelyian | 27 August 2008 - 11:31am

I'm very lucky

as Mrs Kitson and I share very similar musical tastes and in fact it was our mutual love of The Clash that sparked the romance. She also dislikes the same stuff as me which is handy as I don't have to accompany her to naff gigs.

Actually, Mrs K did broaden my musical horizons in introducing me to reggae and other bands that I considered wimpy pap when I were a young punk rocker like Roddy Frame, Monochrome Set etc.

Strange thing is that as much as she loves music and has good opinions on music she will never write on a forum or web-site and has an unhealthy disregard for making lists and filing the CDs and albums in the right order!

Retro Man | 27 August 2008 - 11:51am

Seems i'm quite lucky

'Er Indoors or Ella en Casa has cool taste.
Next to the Cd player we have
Thalia Zadek-Been Here And Gone
Be Good Tanyas-Chinatown
The Evens-The Evans(Ian Mackaye from Fugazi and Minor Threat)
Cat Power-Jukebox ,Special edition
It must be said i've heard Thalia Zadek more times than i care to mention and just got punched for writing that.

paul beard | 27 August 2008 - 11:51am

What if your other half is male ?

Seems like there's an assumption here that your other halves will all be female and you can have a bit of a laugh/moan at their 'poor' taste in music when compared to yours. My other half is currently listening to the latest Randy Newman album, which to me is my greatest nightmare, but I guess many male Word readers probably think is a good thing.

Me ? I'm listening to the Ukrainians most recent live CD in the car. Not sure where that places me amongst female music lovers. But then, my taste may also be coloured by the fact that I haven't experienced childbirth either, which Mr H feels may colour the ladies' tastes.

Janice | 27 August 2008 - 12:35pm

I don't think I said anything about childbirth colouring tastes

Merely that once you've been through that you're unlikely to get involved in an argument about whether Brian Wilson lost it after "Good Vibrations".

David Hepworth | 27 August 2008 - 12:55pm

Ah well

Unlikely to get that involved in that type of argument with or without the childbirth/children experience ! And yes, the sex of the other half is irrelevant, it just seems that most of them are female.

Janice | 27 August 2008 - 4:53pm

The sex of your "other-half" is irrelevant...

... (if that makes sense?).

Nicodemus | 27 August 2008 - 3:38pm

Randy Newman

I'm very happy to say that MrsP came home from work the other week with Randy's new CD in her bag.
Other stuff she currently plays:
Duffy
Van Morrison - Magic Time

Carl Parker | 27 August 2008 - 10:05pm

Bong

My other half is male too. Fancy that!

lovelyian | 28 August 2008 - 10:25am

Can't complain

Mrs Diz has a pretty catholic taste in music but never (ok rarely) knows who any of the music in our CD collection is actually by. So by and large she is pretty tolerant of what I buy but can roll her eyes at some of the more obscure stuff.

Left to her own devices more aften that not she will listen to the radio and usually Radio 4 over and above Radio 2. When she does pick something out to listen to it is often one of the following:

Hootie and the Blowfish - I know but we have been here before...
Joni Mitchell - not an artist I have ever really appreciated
John Martyn - much better!
Led Zeppelin - yay!
(Sir) Richard Thompson - and is pleased we have got tickets for January's tour.
Altan - a bit too acoustic for me but good enough

But as I have posted before, she rarely buys any album herself so I'm not really sure what she would go for given a complete choice.

Diz | 27 August 2008 - 1:34pm

Good lady fiancée...

Listens to: Abba, Smiths, Morrissey, Motown chartbusters, Prince and other similar stuff. I can't complain at all, since she used to listen to 'All Woman' compilations featuring the likes of Beverley Craven, and may still do given the house to herself. I'd say my tastes are more antisocial (a lot of Wilco and Replacements).

Jon | 27 August 2008 - 2:13pm

What, pray,

is "similar" to Abba, Smiths/Morrissey, Motown chartbusters and Prince?

Archie Valparaiso | 27 August 2008 - 5:39pm

Mrs SPT's August listening

Hendrix
Zeppelin
Devandra Banhart
Joanna Newsom
John Cale
Gogol Bordello
Kate Rusby
Beatles

and by demand of our two year old - Blondie - lots of Blondie.

All good, nothing bad.

She is officially a Word subcriber, having signed me up for my birthday this month and forgotten to put it in my name.

spt | 27 August 2008 - 2:25pm

My other half

has good taste in music...she probably picks up on new stuff more than me.

She introduced me to Band of Horses, Broken Social Scene and many others that I now enjoy.....and she made me like The Smiths and Morrissey, which was a some feat.

We disagree on certain music...she's not too keen on Nick Cave while I think Van Morrison is only ok in small doses

In previous relationships I have been subjected to the aforementioned Lighthouse Family and Celine Dion...so my soon to be GLW is a keeper!

David Sutherland | 27 August 2008 - 2:32pm

my better half's

playlists include selections by:
The Who (Sell out)
Alabama Three
Big Audio Dynamite
Dead Can Dance
and
Dar Williams

her fave album is The Hounds of Love

badartdog | 27 August 2008 - 3:44pm

Porcupine

Who??

eddie g | 27 August 2008 - 3:58pm

Tree.

British progressive (small 'p') band, lead by Steven Wilson, featuring former Japan man Richard Barbieri on keys.

Steven Wilson also plays with the band No Man (once described by the Melody Maker as 'the most important band since the Smiths', no less!), Blackfield, with the Israeli superstar Aviv Geffen, the Krautrock band I.E.M., the Warp-esque Bass Communion and soon to release a solo album. Pretty much the dictionary definition antonym of 'workshy'.

Anyway, PT - been around since the early 90s and have different periods and everything.

Space Rock


Classic Rock/Pop era (though this album is quite krautrocky in places. May I suggest Waiting Phase I?):


Metal-influenced period:


Caution - listening may inhibit getting out a bit more, apparently...

Fraser M | 27 August 2008 - 6:44pm

Tree

Great!

Beany | 27 August 2008 - 7:44pm

Mrs Dolly has superb pop picking ears

She has an uncanny knack of spotting a hit from a mile off. The source can be radio 2, capital radio, one of my records or somthing of the kids. Mrs D will be busy hoovering or dusting or making a nice omelette or whatever & then suddenly something will catch her interest & she'll enquire "Ohh what's that - I like it" and she listens intently for while. The song always goes on to be a big hit. Its uncanny. And it doesnt matter what type of music it is.

She's like a pig after truffles.

And like somebody up there ^^^^ mentioned about their other half, she will proceed to play the song to death.

Reverse side is when I try to play her something a little bit off the beaten track - in which case its 3 seconds, a look over the top of her glasses and then a brisk "Off Dolly!".

She will not listen to The Fall or Captain Beefheart.

dolly | 27 August 2008 - 5:53pm

I think I may have mentioned this before but...

On my iTunes: 48,783 individual songs.

On Mrs W's iPod: 366 individual songs.

Whatever she loves me for, it's not my musical taste.

And vice versa.

We both like The Wire though.

Paul Waring | 27 August 2008 - 6:13pm

Yeah, women buy iPod Nanos

I know someone who bought a 8Gb Nano for £130 for his wife. For an extra £29 she could have got a 80Gb Classic! Apparently she didn't want a Classic because it was too big. Not the Gb, but the physical machine itself! The Classic is a long way from being a big heavy brick! My take on it is that women want something small to rattle around in their handbags along with their make up etc. And they rarely bother with complete albums, and instead favour favourite tracks only, mostly played on shuffle.

LOUDspeaker | 28 August 2008 - 9:24am

Equality

I think we're fairly equal in our house - I like Richard Thompson and rock/prog more than Himself, but that is probably balanced out with my love of pop cheese.

Recently I have been listening to Jarvis, PJ Harvey, Fleet Foxes, Sebastien Tellier, Shortwave Set, Seasick Steve, Duran Duran, Motown Chartbusters and Martha Wainwright.

But it doesn't matter who it is, cred or not, if I like it, I like it - eg, don't like Robbie Williams, but I love No Regrets because of the fab backing vocals by Neils Hannon and Tennant. The fact that it is Robbie williams doesn't spoil my listening pleasure.

Em | 27 August 2008 - 8:33pm

the other half...

The earlier comment on Radio 2 summed it up - the middle ground

Recent downloads on her behalf have been Amy McDonald, Duffy and the latest from a German acapella group called the Wise Guys. If you understand German then Nur für dich (an older song) is actually quite good - here it is on youtube translated via torch wood


Martin Langkjaer | 27 August 2008 - 10:24pm

Glad to hear I'm not the only Porcupine Tree afficionado

on the board of the Word massive. While recently they have been metal influenced may I recommend the beautiful "Lazarus".

Enjoy.


lemagician | 27 August 2008 - 10:26pm

Tree

I bought some Tree following recommendations in the blog - good stuff.

Twangothan | 28 August 2008 - 7:08pm

Porcupine Tree

Thanks for the induction guys. However, in this instance, both Lady G and myself infinitely prefer silence.

eddie g | 28 August 2008 - 6:57am

An Acquired Taste

If PT does not rock your boat, Steven Wilson will batter you about the head with his other projects; No-Man, Blackfield or solo CD here:-
Steven Wilson - Insurgentes (trailer)


Beany | 28 August 2008 - 8:03am

Nice Chap

I used to work with Steven Wilson (we were both in IT). He's a very nice chap and one who deserves all the success he gets. Having said that, try as I might, I found No-Man a bit dull. I'll give his solo stuff a go though.

Handsome.P.Wonderful | 28 August 2008 - 9:45am

Little if no interest in music.....

My wife has little if no interest in music so I tend to create compilation cd's for car journeys that try and cover things that she likes i.e. The Beatles, Abba, Blondie, Van Morrison, various Motown and Stax tracks amongst others. I've given up in throwing "curveballs" into the proogramming - finally accepted that she will never like The Gang of 4, Red House Painters and Pere Ubu amongst others.

Steve Hill | 28 August 2008 - 10:51am

It's a delicate subject this ...

I agree with those above who say that, speaking generally, women admit what they like and men have to weigh up the credibility first. Too popular and the band loses it's cool (always exceptions to this rule, such as The Beatles). We bemoan the fact that Ron Sexsmith, The Swans, The Go-Betweens, et al are/were not recognised, as they should be, but we don't really want them to become popular, do we?

I have trawled through my wife's dance/chillout collections - there are some nuggets but it's a bit like panning for Gold. For every Midlake remix there are dozens of Zero 7 yawn fests. I think that by now I know what she likes and so I save Nick Cave, Tom Waits, Led Zeppelin, and my Jazz and Blues cds for those long lonesome car journeys.

steve.wilkinson... | 28 August 2008 - 9:17pm

Dragged to gigs...

Mrs T is not too interested in music. Similar to an above comment my iPod has about 11,000 tracks on it (and I really should have bought a bigger one!) - hers has maybe 200. Coldplay, U2, REM. And R&B - I recently bought her 100 R&B Classic Anthems (which has some great tunes and some absolutely dire ones).

Normally I drag her to gigs (although I've given up on this recently) but two weeks ago she dragged me to Alanis Morrisette & Lenny Kravitz.

Can I get some sympathy please!! (OK, I'll admit, I enjoyed a few of Lenny's old tunes - Let Love Rule, Fields of Joy...anyone, anyone?)

NealT | 29 August 2008 - 12:38pm

Mrs Bruised

wants the new Duffy CD and likes Van Morrison. She would never, ever come home with a Randy Newman CD. One of her most annoying habits is "surfing" through radio stations in the car trying to find "some decent music." Needless to say she passes on some splendid sounds - Ben Folds, Newman, the new Glen Campbell, etc, proclaiming that "you are always listening to the same kind of stuff." I have no defence, she is quite right.
Does anyone have a solution, a middle-ground, or should I find a replacement?

Bruised Mike | 29 August 2008 - 3:29pm

My missus...

.....would dance all night but strangely enough she doesn't ever listen to music! I've been with her over 20 years and I don't think I've ever known her to put on a record.

I have a wide taste and a varied collection of genres and I know she'd love some of it if she took the time to rake for something, but she won't as she thinks it's all Tom Waits, Nick Cave and Loudon Wainwright III.

If I put on Booker T and The MGs or Al Green she'll come through and say "that's not your kind of music?"......gimmie strength!!

bigsteviecook | 30 August 2008 - 12:47pm

The penny dropped...

My wife generally like heavier music than me. She has a real problem with music like Prefab Sprout which she has an almost physical reaction too and if I try it she will leave the room. She's taken a recent dislike to Elvis Costello and is also none too keen on the folkier side of singer songwriter stuff I play. And anything by The Beach Boys!

Recently though they has a been a bit of a revolution. We put all the music on an apple tv connected to the stereo and she's playing more stuff and getting into playlists.

After what must have been three years of dismissing Ryan Adams as 'being too country' the penny finally dropped and one day she suddenly said 'Ok, I get him now' and she's become a big fan - we've just bought tickets for his latest tour with the Cardinals.

We went to see the Who a few years ago so their tracks are now played more often.

I bought a cheap Peter Tosh best of compliation on holiday and she's also developing a taste for quality reggae and some ska. Step forward Dennis Brown and the Skatalites.

But some things she continues to be immune to. Is it just me but is it mainly men who like The Decemberists, XTC and Steely Dan?

russell123 | 30 August 2008 - 7:25am

Music's not that important to my wife

Hence when left to her own audio devices it'll generally be Queen, Meatloaf or some compilation of "uplifting eighties anthems". And she hates, it seems on principle, any of my faves reserving especial scorn for Kate Rusby, Richard Thompson and Lucinda Williams.

Tony Fry | 31 August 2008 - 8:59pm

One For Your iPod

If I play her something new and she says this, she means "you may like it but don't play it to me again". Usually she reserves this comment for the sort of music reviewers would call "dark".

Dave P | 31 August 2008 - 9:48pm

Bloody Great Big Green Ogre ( Shrek, not my wife )

My wife has the three Shrek CDs on in the car most of the time, some pretty good stuff but I wouldn´t mind a change.

On The Fence | 1 September 2008 - 10:08am

I always used to say...

...I would never consider a 'significant other' who couldn't name all four Beatles and at least five people who were, or had been, Rolling Stones. Then I moved to China and the field narrowed somewhat.

Currently, I have the pleasure of listening to Rain, South Korea's answer to Robbie Williams (without the fat period, the drugs and the UFOs). If I'm really lucky, I get Hang On The Box.


James EB | 7 September 2008 - 4:52am

So it's not just me then ...

Most of these comments definitely ring bells with me. Some observations from our own household:

1. Mrs BHKM grew up admiring her older brother's lifestyle, including his musical taste, so she has a strong liking for 70s rock & prog-type stuff.

2. As pathetically immature as I know it is, I do get a genuine sense of pleasure when she honestly mistakes some "music" I'm playing, for a noisy fault with the washing machine.

3. Strangely, although she bravely puts up with most of my (often industrial-based) grunge, she absolutely draws the line at Joni Mitchell (whose voice she finds impossibly grating).

douglas_green | 19 September 2008 - 6:20pm

It's normally the case...

... (and its proved above) that, no matter how important we might place music in our lives, it means nothing compared to finding our "other half".

Nicodemus | 19 September 2008 - 7:26pm

I know I'm a bit late...

Essex FM.

Thank you.

Paul Chandler | 22 September 2008 - 9:25pm

Road to Damascus

MrsP had bought that last Eagles CD, but now she tells me to take it down to the charity shop next time I#m going.

Carl Parker | 22 September 2008 - 9:46pm