Entertainment For Lively Minds

Word RSS FeedsWord Magazine on YouTubeWord Magazine on Last FMWord Spotify PlaylistsWord Magazine on FacebookWord Magazine on Twitter

What is the worst Rolling Stones song?

walker182's picture

There are, no doubt, some absolute turds lurking in the back catalogue of the Rolling Stones. I must admit I am not 100% qualified to give my opinion having never listened to the legendarily ropey Dirty Work from 1986 (other than the carbon copy cover of “Harlem Shuffle”). However, it is unlikely that many of the massive have plundered such depths of sonic misery, so I suspect I am not alone..

So for my money you’d be hard pushed to find a tune within their extensive portfolio more awful than 1991 single “Highwire”. This embarrassing piece of nonsense was tagged onto their live album, “Flashpoint”, and was their commentary on the Gulf war. Now the Stones have never been the most gifted of wordsmiths but provided they churn out the standard rock clichés the words can go largely unnoticed. On this occasion, however, they chose to tackle politics in so ham-fisted a fashion as to make Culture Club’s, “War Song”, sound like an edition of The Today Programme by comparison.

Sample lyric: “Its Just a business, You can pay us in crude, You’ll love these toys, Just go play out your feuds”.. This wouldn’t be quite so bad if the music offered something new, but the lazy recycling of the (already recycled) riff from “Start Me Up” only adds to the insult….

Anyway, I’m intrigued to hear whether the massive can do any worse?

0

Undercover Of The Night

Is also legendarily awful, syndrums agogo for Mick's incisive commentary on the murderous behaviour of juntas in South America in the eighties. The video as well as slo-mo satin sheet and wafty curtain totty action also features executions, balaclava'd hit squads etc. I seem to recall this 'important statement' was shown in cinemas as a short at the time (83) - a standard statement that this was much more than a mere music video, it was art.

0
Moseleymoles | 16 March 2010 - 2:25pm
stimpy | 16 March 2010 - 3:37pm

Sweet Neo Con

off the last album takes some beating, terrible lyrics about corporations running the governments of the world and turgid music to match.

0
Pat Carty | 16 March 2010 - 2:35pm

Sweet Neo Con

I've never heard that song before, and you know what, I'm going to ensure I never hear it again. Appalling.

1
andrew_thompson | 16 March 2010 - 7:24pm

Going Home

This bloody well nearly ruins an almost perfect album, Aftermath. Buried among some of the sharpest, darkest and most concise pop songs of all time is this 11 minute blues jam, which would be inoffensive if it were a quarter of the length. It appears at the end or slap bang in the middle, depending on which edition you have, and it is so irritating because its inclusion reeks of nothing but misguided arrogance. Why did they include it, you ask? Depressingly: because they could. The worst reason for doing anything.

4
Lucas Hare | 16 March 2010 - 2:46pm

Having said that

I remember hearing You Got Me Rocking on the radio and thinking it was one of the worst songs I'd ever heard by anyone, let alone the Stones. Got a nasty feeling it might have been one of those remixes that only Radio 1 in the 1990s would have gone near.

I also happen to think that their version of Like A Rolling Stone is so, so misguided. And not because I'm some kind of humourless Dylan purist. I just think it's bad bad bad.

1
Lucas Hare | 16 March 2010 - 2:49pm
Chris G | 16 March 2010 - 3:38pm

But it does contain Losing My Touch

Which is ace.

0
Joe Robert | 16 March 2010 - 4:10pm

Miss You is great though!

1
kidpresentable | 16 March 2010 - 6:48pm

Undercover of the Night ...

I think it's brilliant. The lyrics may not be up to much but it has a tremendous urgency and atmosphere. Highwire has a half decent tune.

I'm with Pat C, Sweet Neo Con has zero redeeming features. There are half a dozen decent tracks on that album though.

0
dai | 16 March 2010 - 4:00pm

Lyrics aside, I like 'Highwire'

within the scope of the term Post-Some Girls Stones music

0
stimpy | 16 March 2010 - 6:35pm

Perhaps it's too easy...

to pick on later Stones tracks. Even then, I've always had a soft spot for Highwire (if you ignore the lyrics); there was another studio track on Flashpoint, though, think it had 'sex' in the title, and that was truly awful. Note: using the word 'sex' in lyrics or title is an almost cast-iron guarantee of unsexiness. Possible exemption for Marvin.

And 'Undercover' has a great, great riff.

No, to get this right, I think you go for bad early Stones. I'm with Lucas, start with Going Home. Never the greatest of straight blues bands, this is interminable.

Next up, Factory Girl, which at least has the virtue of brevity.

And pride of place goes to Country Honk, a frankly baffling recasting of Honky Tonk Women, which removes everything that was fantastic about the single, starting with Charlie's unbelievably funky drum part. What were they thinking?

0
Captain Spaulding | 16 March 2010 - 5:05pm

I Love Factory Girl

although I'm not crazy about Dear Doctor or Jigsaw Puzzle

0
Pat Carty | 16 March 2010 - 5:18pm

Country Honk/What were they thinking?

They were thinking, "What would Gram Parsons do?"

0
Lucas Hare | 16 March 2010 - 5:35pm

not trolling or trying to be controversial, but...

Sympathy for the Devil, I mean WTF is all that hoo-hoo about?
It sounds awful and anytime Planet Rock play it (rather too often) I switch station.
To me it says drugs, money and hanging out with the arty set do not equal talent.

as you were

0
James Blast | 16 March 2010 - 5:13pm

Brave Man

I think whatever you make of Mick's performance, it is one of the best grooves of all time, as Primal Scream amongst many others, can testify.

3
Moseleymoles | 16 March 2010 - 5:34pm

There's a wonderful clip in the Godard movie,

(by whichever title you know it) where the band is grooving on the main samba riff to SFTD - without Mick

0
stimpy | 16 March 2010 - 6:39pm

Thank you Brother Blast

I'll join you with a thumbs down for SFTD. I'm not too taken with Street Fighting Man either which, although lyrically risible, does have the benefit of a great riff.
I can't stand Dear Doctor, also given a thumbs down above, but I'm perfectly alright with both Factory Girl and Country Honk.
I think the worst Stones song is a toss up between Angie, (or Eaannnggeeee as Mick prefers to call it) and Star Star. The latter is popular because it uses naughty words. Ooooh!! they still had that rebel spirit, but heavens to murgatroyd it's a lame song.

0
Carl Parker | 16 March 2010 - 6:58pm

Please allow me to intr.... click

I'm a man of (no) wealth but some taste, SFTD is just wank.
Street Fighting Man has a siren on it, so that makes it good.

I probably shouldn't be here as I have never been a Stones fan, but my hatred of SFTD knows no end.

The Sisters did a damn fine cover of Shelter, Gimme The Who any day.

and as usual Brer Carl, we agree on certain things, how long have we known each other via this internets...?

0
James Blast | 16 March 2010 - 8:57pm

Time keeps on slipping, slipping slipping into the future

Word is now on issue 86 issues makes it just over 7 years old so it must more than 6 years now.

0
Carl Parker | 16 March 2010 - 10:47pm

Call me Mr Right On...

... but I really hate Under My Thumb.

Sadly I like Brown Sugar.

Consistent? Moi?

0
ganglesprocket | 16 March 2010 - 6:52pm

ditto

have always cringed

dont care that it was the sixties

and yes their version of like a rolling stone is atrocious

0
Junior Wells | 16 March 2010 - 9:04pm

There's so much good music around

that I struggle to keep up with what I do like; I can't be doing with memorising the stuff I don't like as well. "Lady in Red" is the worst song of all time ever in the entire galactic history of the world as we know it. Beyond that, who cares? My favourite is "Time waits For No One" but that never gets in Stones' 'best of' lists so it'll probably crop here. I'll still like it.

0
Mark JF | 16 March 2010 - 7:37pm

how long have we got?

the cover of "Cherry Oh Baby" from Black and Blue takes some beating. Actually, there's never enough beating for it.

2
Sheev | 16 March 2010 - 10:06pm

I'd say we have a winner here

i prefer UB40's version ... 'nuff said.

0
Steven C | 17 March 2010 - 9:10am

Miss You

Just annoys me - all that "aaah aaah aaahing" and "what's the matter wit' you boy?" stuff

0
moleye151 | 16 March 2010 - 10:22pm

Angie

AaaaaAngie. Has someone trodden on his toe?

0
Dave Amitri | 16 March 2010 - 11:16pm

Alternatively

the best Rolling Stones song NOT by The Rolling Stones

0
Dave Amitri | 16 March 2010 - 11:19pm

Slight tangent

I spent much of my childhood LOVING the really early stuff, covers 'n' all. But, largely, these covers disappear into oblivion when confronted with the originals. As soon as I heard Marvin Gaye's Can I Get A Witness, The Drifters' Under The Boardwalk (yes, yes, I know...), and Irma Thomas' Time Is On My Side (although I returned to the Stones' version with open arms recently and found it utterly sublime), I really had no need for those Stones versions any more.

However - and you can tell I've not really thought this through - I listened to their version of Solomon Burke's Cry To Me the other day and it's really, really good. In fact, I'll have Carol and Route 66 over the originals. But not Down The Road Apiece.

Beg your pardon. It appears I don't have a point. One more cup of coffee.

0
Lucas Hare | 17 March 2010 - 7:26am

Mixed Emotions

Mixed Emotions always sounds like something Rod Stewart and Tina Turner would've duetted on in the mid-80s. Dreadful. And Emotional Rescue makes me feel ill. Miss You is great, though.

0
peterthecook | 17 March 2010 - 9:15am

Gimme Shelter

A very personal opinion that I don't expect any support for. I just can't square the subject matter vs. the way it's delivered. The soulful 'Oh baby baby' type of singing, except about rape and murder. This coming from a band who thought it was a good idea to buddy up with the Hells Angels.

There's plenty of their songs I do like, dotted around their catalog in unexpected places. Hand of Fate might be my top pick.

0
Andrew Bradley | 17 March 2010 - 9:38am

yes you are right

don't expect any support at all :)

0
Junior Wells | 17 March 2010 - 10:23am

Not Gimme Shelter!

I love it, but must concur that Hand Of Fate (and also Memory Motel from the same album) is a hidden gem.

As for the worst, it has to be "Indian Girl" off Emotional Rescue. Pure Crap.

0
Iainso | 17 March 2010 - 10:31am

Little Indian Girl, Where Is Your Mother?

So bad, it's good. Jagger has passed self-parody to such a degree that he wouldn't be able to see it in the rear view mirror.

1
Pat Carty | 17 March 2010 - 1:42pm

I'm pleased I started this thread..

..I can tell by the titles alone that I'm going to have a jolly good chortle when I put this lot onto a playlist this weekend.

Part of the appeal of the Stones is the fine line they walk between the sublime and the ridiculous and for me this makes them one of the few bands for whom digging out the dodgy stuff can be a real pleasure.

0
walker182 | 17 March 2010 - 1:50pm

Excellent idea!

A Worst Of The Stones ("Low Tide And Parched Grass") playlist

Send us the link when you've started it :-)

1
stimpy | 18 March 2010 - 12:57pm

Shattered

Although, I admit, that is stretching the definition of the term 'song' to its outer limits.

0
skirky | 30 March 2010 - 7:48am
Privacy Statement    ©  2006 - 2012 Development Hell Ltd