Universal Laws of Record Collecting

This evening it occurred to me that my record collection, and my interaction with it, is governed by a set of universal laws whose existence can be proven under rigorous laboratory conditions. My subsequent experimental work has already uncovered the following principles:

(During the course of this research, record collections belonging to my younger brother and my parents were used as control groups.)

The Afterglow Effect

For every 500 albums there will be one whose presence in the collection is unexplainable and whose origins are clouded in mystery. This law was named after my discovery of a Sarah McLachlan CD ( a special edition of Afterglow that included a bonus live mini album) of which I have no recollection of purchasing or being given. The only rational explanation I can come up with so far, is that the dream I had where the Snowman I built in the garden came to life and then flew me to the Lilith Fair actually happened to me in real life! I know it sounds crazy, but as Sherlock Holmes once said: "When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."

Robinson Displacement Theorem

New material by The Black Crowes, or solo efforts by either of the Robinson Brothers, will eventually be displaced on the hi-fi by the band's debut Shake Your Money Maker or it's follow-up The Southern Harmony and Musical Companion.

Autechre's Singularity

Music that replicates the sound of a saucepan lid rolling around on a tiled floor will receive limited play.

Goldfrapp's Constant

Occasional pockets of depression or low energy, occurring within the vicinity of the collection's prime mover, will sometimes lead to periods of inertia. In such cases the same compact disc will remain in the CD player for a much longer period of time than is normal and will receive repeated plays.

What are the scientifically provable laws of your record collection? Also detail any experimental or field work that you may have undertaken.

The Huge Canon equation.

When a curator happens upon a new artist's ouevre, and is overcome with joy as a result, their collection will rapidly acquire the first three albums by the artist.

If the artist continues to produce new works over the following years, the number of titles from their canon of work which are subsequently added to the collection will decay in proportion to the inverse square of the number of years since the curator's original epiphany.

Thus an album issued 3 years after the artist's first appearance in the collection is nine times less likely to be added to the collection than the first album added.

Independent verification of this principle is most easily obtained by examination of a collection belonging to a fan of David Bowie.

The less well known "Dead Member" variation states that where a significant member of a band has expired, the effect is usually a rapid falling off of purchases, initially as an inverse cubic function, but eventually tending to zero.

These boundary condition effects are easily noted in collections belonging to devotees of The Grateful Dead, Little Feat, and so on.

The only known artists whose inclusion in collections is known to be free from any of these effects are Bob Dylan, The Beatles and The Rolling Stones. The inclusion of works from these artists more usually follow the difficult "Too Important Not To Have The Lot" principle, often constrained only by the so-called "Cash Flow" limit.

Vulpes Vulpes | 12 March 2008 - 3:34pm

I would contend....

...that The Rolling Stones are actually a classic example of the 'Mid-Life Peak' syndrome, whereby sales of early albums are perhaps surprisingly low as the band is primarily appreciated as a 'singles' band, rising to a massive peak at the height of its critical and popular acclaim in their mid-period, with a long and diminishing tail as both critical and popular acclaim slips away, to be replaced by the 'Big Tour' effect.

This classic 'normal' distribution may also be distorted downwards by the 'Psychedelic slump' whereby ill-advised sorties into unfamiliar and inappropriate musical areas reduce sales, and may be distorted upwards in later years by the 'Best Album Since' Bounce, although these mini-peaks tend to be short-lived and subject to the law of diminishing returns.

Paul Waring | 12 March 2008 - 5:22pm

Ha ha

I like the Afterglow effect... I have a Gallon Drunk album somewhere that I bought purely on the basis of hearing their cover version of The Bee Gees' To Love Somebody.

I've never listened to it again since the original purchase, more than 10 years ago.

I also give you the:
Missing Album syndrome

No matter how diligent you are at keeping track of all your CDs, and how anally you file them, there will always be one that you 'desperately' want to listen to, but has gone AWOL. And, for the life of you, you can't remember where it's gone - did you lend it to someone? Take it to a mate's house? One of the kids has nicked it?

Of course, if you buy a new copy, you can guarantee the original will turn up a day later!

robram | 12 March 2008 - 4:25pm

even worse

Ah yes. This problem can be partially solved by transfer of all CDs to an MP3 player of your choice, but this gives rise to the even worse Missing/Lost/Sad Faced iPod Syndrome

David Ellcock | 12 March 2008 - 5:28pm

you want more I gotta housefull

Missing Album Syndrome is a popular issue in my house. Or, more accurately, Missing Record Syndrome. This effect becomes most noticeable when the vinyl assortment is numbered into the several thousand items, necessitating a vague system of storage by genre in bookcases around the house. The problem is heightened when the curator has partaken of refreshment, and can then be described more accurately as "Yeah I know I have it somewhere but I can't find it right now, will this do?".

CDs are easy though, since I only have a few dozen of those.

PhilC | 17 March 2008 - 2:28pm

Quantum Entanglement, Re-Issues & Remasters

The probability (E) of any collection (C) containing albums re-issued in a remastered format (M) is of the order:

E=MC2

If the number of albums in the collection by an Artist (A) is equal to (T-1) where T = the total number of available titles by that Artist, then E tends to infinity.

Hence, having only one more album to acquire by a given artist ensures that the artist's entire back catalogue will be reissued in remastered form within a week.

Vulpes Vulpes | 12 March 2008 - 8:42pm

Zimmerman's Razor

I always have to think very carefully before playing any Dylan as there is every chance that the result will be several weeks where only Dylan is on the stero. The last time this happened, I ended up knee-deep in botlegs and buying albums MTV Unplugged and playing Dylan on the ipod while reading Down The Highway.

Paul Chandler | 12 March 2008 - 8:19pm

It's not a term I'm familiar with;

is a "botleg" the compressed form of a bootleg, rather like an MP3 is a compressed form of a CD track?

Vulpes Vulpes | 12 March 2008 - 8:39pm

A botleg,

is the name given to a bootleg when it is in a digital form.

Paul Chandler | 12 March 2008 - 11:33pm

Threefer's Dilemma

cf the existence of an Aerosmith CD in your collection as that was the only other thing you could find in the special offers rack after you'd picked up 'Low' and 'Desire' and needed one more to get the twenty quid special offer.
Not to be confused with Tesco's Algorithm, whereby even once you've peeled the £3.99 sticker off the DVD, you still never get round to watching Music and Lyrics.

skirky | 12 March 2008 - 8:43pm

No dilemma there...

just so long as the Aerosmith CD is either 'Rocks' or 'Toys In The Attic'... both gems.

Patrick Crowther | 13 March 2008 - 9:05am

Three for £20 offers

I don't think record stores really sell albums that way now. Thankfully as you always ended up buying a dud as the last item.

When is a free item not free? When you have to buy two to get the third one three, and you only wanted the one item in the first place. They've just snookered you into spending twice as much money. These are clever people and they scare me with their economic witchcraft.

Tower Records were the worst as they had 4 CDs for £20. The crap I bought because of this? Dirty Works and Emotional Rescue by The Rolling Stones, Coda by Led Zeppelin, Young Americans and Pin Ups by David Bowie, The Freewheelin' by Bob Dylan etc (some of those are classics I know but they do nothing for me).

LOUDspeaker | 30 March 2008 - 12:49pm

Dumpbin Conditional

If there is a dumpbin, then I must search through it - in case there is something worth having at greatly reduced price.

A variation of this exists, If there is a charity shop with a CD shelf, then I must check the contents.

The "I always meant to get that" theorem - whereby you purchase an album you do not own but always meant to get when it is on sale for 2.99. And then you never actually play it.

Em | 12 March 2008 - 9:37pm

Charidee shops

I don't mean to be disrespectful, but having culled my monthly magazine CD's by downloading the best songs and then handing the CD's into the local British Heart Foundation shop, I then find them on sale at £2.50 each despite the prominent 'Not For Resale' info on the sleeve. Can I start a new subject for debate........"Are charity shops taking the piss or are the staff just clueless ?". Over to you.

ragmule | 15 March 2008 - 12:36am

The Gift Horse Imperative

The phenomenon whereby an acquaintance or semi-distant family member hands you a CD or DVD as a present with the phrase "I thought you might just like this..." and you can guarantee that it will remain in its cellophane shrink wrap in perpetuity BUT you are always that little bit guilty that you've never even opened it, let alone listened to it: cf Phil Collins "But Seriously...", Natasha Beddingfield "NB"

Trevor_Raggatt | 12 March 2008 - 11:32pm

Oxfam......

...in Moseley Village, B'ham (as in Moseley Shoals/Ocean Colour Scene, pop-pickers)has a an Oxfam shop with a selection of vinyl LPs in the window, specifically requesting people to donate their old collection, and for CDs as well. Well, of course Ihad to go in. Not the worlds greatest selection, but what a good idea. I had read that charity shops were feeling over-inundated by unsellable vinyl and CDs, but here is an example of embracing the opportunity that can only be to their interest.
What did I buy? Helen Watson/Notes on Desire: pretty good Christine Collister acolyte. Sounds a bit like, or the songs do, a female John Martyn. Marc Cohn's eponymously titled: the Walking in Memphis fella. Not bad, bit samey. Barry Adamson/Stranger on the sofa: part,um, interesting, 2 good instrumentals. Part unlistenable claptrap.
Not bad for £5.48 all in!

Retropath2 | 13 March 2008 - 10:25am

The Asperger's Rule

I remember a documentary about people with Asperger's, the wife of one was exasperated by her husband's latest arrangement of their large CD collection, in order of the date of birth of the composer.

PaulB | 12 March 2008 - 11:31pm

He should file for divorce

that's an eminently sensible way of filing classical music.

Must go, I need to top up my range of toothpaste brands from Tescos, I'm short a tube of Whitening Sensitive Freshmint with Bicarbonate of Soda in a large size travel set Three-for-Two blister pack.

Vulpes Vulpes | 13 March 2008 - 9:27am

I daresay

that would infuriate me too, but I still think it's FANTASTIC!

The Mr thinks my habit of having CD singles separate from albums is untenable...

And despite having them in alpha order, I generally tended to recognise them by the colour of the spine.

Em | 13 March 2008 - 1:46pm

What?????

"The Mr thinks my habit of having CD singles separate from albums is untenable..."

Untenable? Prerequisite more like!

Trevor_Raggatt | 13 March 2008 - 11:24pm

What's a single?

.

Retropath2 | 14 March 2008 - 9:13am

"The black hole" aka mrs dolly's approach to cd's

My wife always puts the last CD on the machine into the nearest available CD box irrespective of whether its the correct box.

So if you are in the mood for a bit of Gene Clark, say. You open up the Gene Clark box and find daughter #2's Hannah Montana Cd. If you fancy a bit of Fela Kuti, its the boy's scratched copy of My Chemical Romance.

This drives me UP THE WALL.

My wife refuses to be moved by either my rage or logic that this is an incredibly annoying practice. "They all work their way back to their proper boxes in the end" she says.

I become more like Victor Meldrew by the day.

dolly | 14 March 2008 - 7:44pm

Have you tried

bending her knitting needles in retaliation?

Vulpes Vulpes | 16 March 2008 - 1:37pm

A simple solution

Try never leaving CDs in the machine and instead putting everything away yourself ASAP.

LOUDspeaker | 30 March 2008 - 12:53pm

Wrong song titles

Oopsey doopsey ! I've just gone into a black hole by logging on. I was going to say that 'Pump' is quite a good Aerosmith album but i'd now like to sat that the 'botleg' answer was smart but 'spoddish' and the wife is clueless on song titles. Only this evening she said, "oh ! That's 'A Town Called Alice' by The Jam isn't it ?
Now, I don't know if Paul Weller read Neville Shute's account of Outback life when he was a teenager but I still felt an irrational annoyance. I think she does it deliberately. Can we have a section on the wife deliberately winding you up about music ? That might work.

ragmule | 15 March 2008 - 12:28am

(M) alice Aforethought

Perhaps I'm being thick, but surely the whole point of the title of the Jam song was that it was a pun on the title of Shute's novel? Wasn't it?

David Ellcock | 15 March 2008 - 1:20am

The support band law...

...states that if you like the previously unknown support band at a gig and buy their latest album, you will hate it at first listen.

I've repeated this pattern many times over the years, but the most shocking examples go back a long way: "Marks" by Dutch band Alquin (support for Golden Earring at Newcastle Mayfair, mid-70s) and "The Piranhas" by The Piranhas (support for The Jam, Manchester Odeon, late 70s). Still own them mind... can't fathom this new-fangled "giving stuff away" trend.

There are occasional exceptions: I saw the Kings of Convenience supporting Eileen Rose at The Borderline a few years back and have loved them ever since. Oh, and I've just remembered that I first saw Gong supporting Faust at Newcastle City Hall a thousand years ago and currently own about 92 Gong-related albums. Not such a universal law then.

BrianH | 15 March 2008 - 1:29am

Not to mention

the perennial support band of the early 1970s, "Byzantium", who were most excellent live, but never really got the same effect on vinyl. I've got the albums, but they don't stack up to the gigs.

Vulpes Vulpes | 16 March 2008 - 1:39pm