Entertainment For Lively Minds
Two songs, same backing track.
Posted by Dave Amitri on 5 November 2011 - 11:05pm.
The Kane Gang vs The Human League. Only in the 80's or are there any others? (I love them both by the way)
The Kane Gang "What Time Is It?"
The Human League "Human"
- More from Dave Amitri.
- Login or register to post comments










Similar tempo and "sound palette" certainly.
Human League produced by Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis course, and presumably the Kane Gang were aiming for a similar style, but presumably on a fraction of the budget
I didn't know until I read their Wiki entry that 'ver Gang also performed the 'Oooh Gary Davis' jingles on Radio 1.
Gary Crowley
They also did the same for Gazza back in the 80s, on Capital. Also Big Sound Authority did one for Mr Crowley, based on their Soul Man song.
One word
Reggae.
Two more: Brian Wilson. (Although those which use the exact same backing track tend to be his Beach Boys-sung demos for songs he was to produce for other artists. "I Do" by The Castells is a vastly inferior recording to The Beach Boys' own demo of same, now found as a bonus track on the "Surfer Girl"/"Shut Down Vol. 2" CD.)
I once did a mash-up of "He's A Doll" by The Honeys and "Drive-In" by The Beach Boys. Different back-track, different keys, same melody. (Cf. the verses of "I Get Around" and "Don't Back Down" which interestingly bookend each other on the "All Summer Long" LP - the opening and closing track have the same melody in the verses.)
Edited to include the following illustrative clips:
"I Do," vocal demo by the Beach Boys:
"I Do" by the Castells, same backing track:
"He's a Doll" by the Honeys:
"Drive-In" by the Beach Boys (different backing, same melody in the verses):
"I Get Around" by the Beach Boys:
The master take of "Don't Back Down" doesn't appear to be on YouTube, but the vocals are here with the backing track dodgily filtered out - again, same melody in the verses (I first noticed this when I had the sheet music, before I'd ever heard the record):
Finally, some reggae:
"Liquidator" by the Harry J. All-Stars:
"Tons of Gold" by Val Bennett (same backing, speeded up):
"What Am I To Do" by Tony Scott (different recording of the same backing (they will not synchronise however much I change the pitch), but sounds as though it's from the same session but with a piano added during the vocal overdub):
A couple more Brian Wilson remakes
The Survivors was Brian and couple a couple of mates. Their single was a rewrite of a Beach Boys album filler Car Crazy Cutie.
"Thinking About You Baby" which BW wrote and produced for Sharon Marie was later "adapted" to become the Beach Boys single "Darlin'"
A couple more Brian Wilson remakes
The Survivors was Brian and couple a couple of mates. Their single was a rewrite of a Beach Boys album filler Car Crazy Cutie.
"Thinking About You Baby" which BW wrote and produced for Sharon Marie was later "adapted" to become the Beach Boys single "Darlin'"
Plastic Bertrand
Was Elton Motello's Jet Boy Jet Girl with a different vocal.
Cool For Cats UK
Phwooarr!
OP Re:The Human League
Being Boiled + Fade To Grey = £££
Red Money
the last track on David Bowie's Lodger is essentially the same track as Sister Midnight from Iggy Pop's The Idiot.
Move On from the same album also uses some of the melody from All the Young Dudes played backwards.
Portishead and Tricky spring to mind
and here's the source
Jimmy "Soul" Clark v Eric & The Vikings
Northern Soul is Full of this
Same Backing track,bits added and taken out.
Radio 4 Saturday 5/11
Yesterday morning there was a programme presented by Guy Garvey about this very thing - when does 'homage' or nod of respect to something trip over into outright theft?
V interesting, should be on listen again...
Bryan Ferry and The Smiths
New Order
the basic backing track for World In Motion had already been used as the theme tune for 'Reportage' (80s Janet Street Porter/Def II current affairs series for ver Yoof)
A lyricless "Vanishing Point"
was used as the sig for BBC Manchester's "Making Out." I've a feeling the series came slightly before the record.
Ooh I never knew that (about World In Motion)
It really works as a tv theme too
Dre
Dr Dre's What's the Difference and Blu Cantrell's Breathe
http://m.youtube.com/index?desktop_uri=%2F&gl=GB#/watch?v=AHwXYgzAXPI
Same melody, same composer, different rhythm
Both by Neal Hefti. A neat bit of recycling.
First up - Batman
and then, The Odd Couple
Neil Young
Two songs, ON THE SAME ALBUM, have identical backing tracks - Train Of Love and Western Hero, from the excellent Sleeps With Angels (his last great album? Discuss...). Can't find a youtube clip for Train, so you'll have to listen on Spotify, or just take my word for it