Tobacco and art: a few questions

ImageIt's just emerged that Henry Fonda and Clarke Gable were paid a small fortune to smoke in the movies. Clearly you can't do that any more but now that smoking has been largely driven underground, when it does pop up I think about it even more.

I went to a play last week in a small West End theatre. Some of the characters were smoking just a few yards away from me. The following thoughts went through my mind. Are my clothes going to smell? How do they choose which actors smoke and which don't? Does that one smoke in real life or is he just doing it for the part? Is that a real cigarette? Has she put that out properly?

In the extras for the BBC's adaptation of Patrick Hamilton's "Twenty Thousand Streets Under The Sky", which takes place in a pre-war fug, the director explained that it was common practice to use special theatrical cigarettes (of the herbal kind) in film work. Presumably this was so that the actors and crew couldn't complain about passive smoking. I gave up twenty years ago but if I were an actor I would worry that even a few puffs on one of these fake gaspers might be enough to tip me back into the real thing. Are there any actors out there who have had any experience of theatrical cigs?

Then there's the effect that smoking has on your ability to suspend disbelief. I've been watching "The Sopranos". This finished in 2007, a year after changes in the law made it illegal to smoke in public places in New Jersey. I realise that Silvio Dante would be unlikely to show compliance if this stricture were pointed out to him but I can't stop thinking about that every time he sits down at a bar or a restaurant table and sparks up. This already strikes me as anomalous in a "what's wrong with this picture?" way. You feel like saying "why don't you pop outside?" In the future will all movies and TV programmes be divided into pre- and post-ban? Will that actually be the most significant watershed moment in the history of this still young artform?

At the same time I've seen very few TV shows pick up on the changing ways in which smokers now smoke. In the final series of that show made by David Simon I note that the newspapermen at the "Baltimore Post" go into the loading bay to top up their nicotine level. Are there others? These and other questions concerning the intertwining of fiction and the weed continue to exercise my mind. And yours?

Clarke is the big-haired poet one, not the sticky-out eared one

I assume you were referring to the e-free Clark Grable, best known of course for playing Brett Rutland opposite Vivien Stanshall's Scarlett Johansson.

(Hang on, now I'll read the rest of it....)

Archie Valparaiso | 25 September 2008 - 9:14am

Huff - or should I say..Puff!

Huff was a comedy/drama with Frank Azaria and Paget Brewster as his screen wife about 3 years ago. At bedtime he would often be smoking and, even as a smoker myself of some 20 years standing, my thought was "no-one smokes in bed any more, do they?" (people over 23, I mean), particularly rich professionals in California like Huff. I don't even know anyone who smokes in their own house anymore.

Pat Phoenix used to smoke a cigarette better than Lauren Bacall could ever dream of doing. I wonder when exactly Coronation Street phased out smoking? It seems to have happened by stealth. But someone must have made a decision at some point. I think that decision could be the cultural tipping point between "Smoking Hooray!" and "Smoking Boo!" It's as good as any.

Austin | 25 September 2008 - 9:20am

They haven't

There's a smoking shelter out the back of the Rovers, where you'll find Liz, Deirdre, the Craig Charles character, Steve McDonald, etc.

People still smoke in real life. I'm one of them.

Five-Centres | 25 September 2008 - 10:40am

That's why you've been so long responding

You've been outside, haven't you?

David Hepworth | 25 September 2008 - 10:49am

Disgusting

I gave up when I left school at 16...

That explains a lot.

Beany | 25 September 2008 - 12:43pm

See the brilliant film "Thank You For Smoking"

It has a sub-plot about smoking in movies.

LOUDspeaker | 25 September 2008 - 9:35am

"My love and I. . .

huddled under the awning outside a small cafe"? Nah, that won't work.

Archie Valparaiso | 25 September 2008 - 9:36am

Only last night...

I was kooking at a page that compiled a load of "they wouldn't get away with that nowadays" cigarette ads.

Smokey

More here.

Fraser Lewry | 25 September 2008 - 9:50am

But then there's never been realism when it comes to such things

My favourite is the way that in many shows - particularly in the US - if someone dare drink more than two half glasses of piss-weak beer on more than one occasion, you can pretty much guarantee that person is soon to feature in a storyline about their alcohol abuse. No one is ever able to go out and get royally smashed even once without it being indicative of some major character flaw that requires major soul searching and apologies all round. It's never allowed to be a case of someone occasionally drinking too much but actually just having a good time with no negative consequences. It has to be commented on.

Although not quite the same thing, it also brings to mind Stephen Fry's last 'Podgram' in which he rants about the Health and Safety people (AKA'compliance') on television shoots.

Fry explains that in a program such as Spooks, it is considered perfectly permissible for one person to murder another, but if a character attempts to use a mobile phone while driving a car - even if this might be a member of the security forces desperately attempting to avert a terrorism incident, for example, the compliance people will not allow that person to drive a car and call for assistance on a mobile phone even though that it blatantly what would happen in real life.

From the compliance guidelines:

"Safety & the law
We should normally observe the law, both in the UK and other countries, unless there is clear editorial justification for not doing so. This includes ensuring that presenters, actors and contributors use seatbelts, fit child car seats correctly, use crash helmets and the correct mobile phone equipment when driving."

But it's perfectly fine to shoot another human being dead.

So, my point is that TV was never that good at these things anyway.

Back on topic, are there actually many roles which actually unquestionably require smoking? It's normally down to the whim of the actor or director, isn't it, lovey-dahling?

Fraser M | 25 September 2008 - 9:56am

Look at "Friends"

They spent all their time in a coffee shop (not a pub) and make a big deal when one of them had a fag ("Chandler is SMOKING!!!"). The reality is, all of the main cast except David Schwimmer were smokers.

kidpresentable | 25 September 2008 - 12:00pm

Really?

That's how they stayed so thin.

David Hepworth | 25 September 2008 - 12:07pm

Indeed

Indeed, Schwimmer mentioned it in an interview on Channel 4 years ago. It always stuck in my mind due to it's conflict with the attitude of the show. I couldn't comment on if any of them have given up since...

kidpresentable | 25 September 2008 - 1:06pm

Couple of things

1. Although in general American networks are, as you say, prudish about drinking, we were only discussing the other day just how much drinking takes place in both "The Sopranos" and the programme that David Simon made. Every night after work the police and dock workers chase down their beers with rye whisky. Tony Soprano would have been run in by the traffic police most days if the amount he drinks for lunch is anything to go by. Maybe that's just HBO doing it because they can.
2. I think there are very few roles that require smoking. In the case of the play I saw the other day if none of the cast had smoked I wouldn't have wondered why. It's a convention I'm prepared to accept.

David Hepworth | 25 September 2008 - 9:57am

HBO

You're quite right about HBO. A superior broadcaster, in my opinion - the comedy specials alone (Hicks, Carlin etc) mark them out as in a league of their own.

Much as someone was saying about 'keywords' that would make you try music, the very letters HBO is enough to make me give something a try.

Fraser M | 25 September 2008 - 10:02am

Most of the actors I've met

are very well acquainted with "theatrical cigs". Fnarr fnarr.

Vulpes Vulpes | 25 September 2008 - 10:22am

Sport & smoking in the 70s

I enjoy moments in football coverage from the 70s where sportsmen are openly smoking. YouTube lacks it but footage from the classic 1979 Arsenal v Man U FA Cup Final shows much of the Arsenal bench smoking at some points, manager included.

Natch, the legendary ITV World Cup panel - Dougan, Allison, Cantwell et al - involves both cigarettes and alcohol apparently.

kb | 25 September 2008 - 10:23am

You need to get out more

But avoid the smoking shelter outside the door.

I much prefer the office scenes, late at night, when someone opens a draw to pour out a glass of whiskey. Has anyone here (who works in an office) ever done that? Sacking offence wherever I have worked. Except the brewery, of course, but I only had beer not spirits...

Beany | 25 September 2008 - 10:40am

On Kate Mossman's desk...

..there's a bottle of vodka. It's been there for years. Nobody has ever been tempted to open it. And that's not because anyone belongs to the Temperance Party. It's just that it would look so desperate.

David Hepworth | 25 September 2008 - 10:51am

You have

a good excuse tomorrow.

It's Friday!

Beany | 25 September 2008 - 11:01am

ooooh, Sir

can we have a Back to School Disco, Mr H Sir

there's no truth in the rumour that one of the senior prefects will be bringing illicit hooch along!

ivan | 25 September 2008 - 11:12am

Fags are yummy

The Dennis Waterman character in New Tricks - a pretty mainstream, prime time show - smokes. Not in the office though. He has to slip out for a crafty one. The “bike shed” scenario is, I’d have thought, a useful plot device. It brings people together - and smokers chat to each other in these situations, usually about the smoking ban - that wouldn’t otherwise meet.
I blame the smoking ban for there being no third series of Early Doors.

Richard Lowe | 25 September 2008 - 10:43am

Early Doors

I've just bought both series (£5 each from HMV) and the fact that everyone in the pub is smoking is the first thing you notice - that and the fact beer is only £1.98 a pint. A very funny series which was I think missed by most - well worth the small investment.

I loved the line in series 2 about James MacAvoy whe ditched his girlfriend, the landlord's daughter - "it was shameless".

JohnB | 25 September 2008 - 11:11am

The Smoking Room

In which slipping out for a fag served as the plot of an entire programme!

They stopped making this before the ban, iirc but the whole premise of the show will become increasingly anachronistic as time goes by.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/comedy/smokingroom/

MikeEagling | 25 September 2008 - 4:33pm

Mad Men

They smoke everywhere - and I mean EVERYWHERE - and drink all day long. The office is a fug of smoke.

I'm just old enough to remember when you could smoke in the office, and even being a smoker is wasn't pleasant.

I've never been one for smoking carriages, etc., and so I'm glad they've vanished.

I don't like smoking shelters either, or the knot of smokers outside every workplace in Britain, but you do what you have to do.

Five-Centres | 25 September 2008 - 10:44am

what about the children

Was Kes the last film to show kids smoking on film, Kids do smoke but i can't remember seeing them doing it on tv in ages even after 9pm. Has anyone be caught tabbing it on eastenders by their mum?
Also as smoking is beaten out of films how are poeple going to light sticks of dynamite, burn through ropes, improvise a molotov cocktails is ray mears going to be on over time with his flint and tinder.
lastly there never going to get a decent cover shot for jazz cd ever again.

Chris G | 25 September 2008 - 10:54am

Hope and Glory

As a committed and enthusiastic smoker I'm disgusted by the fact I have to see a billboard advert opposite my office every day promoted by this lovely bunch of health nazis:

http://www.d-myst.info/index.php

The billboard calls for a ban on smoking in films. Liverpool is very good at this sort of thing - they are also currently looking to ban happy meals in McDonalds in all Liverpool stores.

However, as anti all this business that I am I can actually say that films did cause me to smoke. Aged 10 years old I did a lot of acting / child modelling and won a part in John Boorman's mid-eighties film 'Hope and Glory'. I played one of the gang of tear aways who run riot on the bomb sites and throughout the scenes we were required to smoke. As far as I can remember this was with real cigarettes - we even had a bloke from the crew teach us how to do it. Can I sue John Boorman?

I've tried to find a clip of me smoking in the film but could only find this one. I'm the kid in a green jumper on the second row looking at the camera:


Jamie_Bowman | 25 September 2008 - 11:46am

top stuff

I think you got into the part really well!
I think there's some smoking in Gregory girl and do Shane meadows kids smoke?

Chris G | 25 September 2008 - 11:50am

I heard about this

There also was an MP in Manchester who wanted to make any film containing smoking an 18 certificate.

It's fine if people want to smoke outside the cinema though.

kidpresentable | 25 September 2008 - 12:02pm

I'm smoking a fag!

Per-fwhat a coincidence - as a teenager I was also on the set of this film because a friend's dad held the furry sausage thing and she suggested we all go and have a look.

In between "takes", we were standing in the dark, smoking, and Sarah Miles told us off! "You're far too young to smoke!" she snarled. My rejoinder should have been "At least I don't drink my own piss!". But instead I looked down at my shoes in silence.

Austin | 17 October 2008 - 4:24am

Replacing History

This is the cover for The Beatles Capital Albums Vol.2.

They photoshopped it to remove something from Ringo's hand...

kidpresentable | 25 September 2008 - 12:05pm

Give a baby booze

As a non-smoker I have found the smoking ban has actually made me want to re-introduce smoking in some places. For example being in a band it's really annoying that when you play a gig, everyone loiters outside the pub smoking until they notice the band has started playing, and then meander in, so you often play the first song or more to a very sparse crowd - I think this will lead a lot of bands to play some kind of warm-up/filler-jam for 3 minutes at the start of their sets. And a lot of pubs/clubs now just smell of sweat, stale beer and flatulence, all of which are pretty unpleasant and may well be contributing to the demise of many pubs since the ban came in. (Almost all the local pubs in my area are up for let).

On a vaguely related note, when I was involved in drama at secondary school there was one play we did that had a bottle of Drambuie as a prop, and it actually had Drambuie in it. Needless to say, as the rehearsals and the shows progressed, the level in the bottle gradually diminished.....

AndrewtheWood | 25 September 2008 - 12:43pm

As a non-smoking sometime-singer...

...I find you sing alot better if you're not breathing in smoke. Big advantage, I'm saying.

kidpresentable | 25 September 2008 - 12:45pm

Hasn't the idea that

pubs etc now just smell of stale beer and farts been over done I've not noticed any major whiffs and it's not much of reason for bringing back gaspers.

Chris G | 25 September 2008 - 12:57pm

No, but the demise of the

No, but the demise of the pub gig audience is: half the pubs we used to play have given up having bands since the ban - people are just staying home, rather than have to stand outside in the rain to smoke. The law of unintended consequences strikes again....

martin scott | 25 September 2008 - 1:03pm

but...

There is that, but it would suggest that the ones staying at home are people who weren't likely to be as enthusiastic about going to local gigs. That said, we are continuing to experience "the rise of the talkers"...

kidpresentable | 25 September 2008 - 1:11pm

One strange affect of the

smoking ban is to give the impression that some pubs are heaving because of the number of people outside only to find relatviely quiet inside.

Chris G | 25 September 2008 - 1:46pm

I saw...

Andrew Eldritch (yeah, him again) flaunting the smoking ban live onstage in both the Leeds University Union and Glasgow ABC on The Sisters 2006 tour. Me, I had to nip to the bogs for a quick one.

Smoking's great and should be made compulsory again.

James Blast | 25 September 2008 - 4:29pm

Other strange phenomena...

I see the same knot of smokers standing outside different pubs over an evening in my locale. They'll go to one & then stand outside, proceed to another & stand outside that & then on to a third to stand outside that. Why don't they stay outside the same damn place? I don't think each change of scenery causes them to reach new heights of wit & repartee.
I'm also gobsmacked by the way smokers (and I'm one, albeit a rather fey 5-a-day man) suck down one fag after another at any contact with the great outdoors, almost sticking two fingers up to the society that's marginalised them. Where I work, three or four dedicated puffers work their way through four fags each in their lunch half-hour, in all winds and weathers.

Graham Johns | 25 September 2008 - 2:44pm

Bloody antis. Spoilsport health Nazis.

I used to love smerking tabs. Now I'm too scared to try keeping a lid on it at one pack of Capstan Full Strength a day, so I stay nicotine free. Sometimes I think I'd be happier ignorant and poisoned.

Vulpes Vulpes | 25 September 2008 - 2:50pm

Good Night and Good Luck

As a confirmed smoker watching this film was torture.

David Strathain - V underrated actor in my opinion - plays the journalist Edward R Murrow, and I swear that he has a cigarette on the go in almost every scene.

Filmed in black and white and with every set looking grey, you see the swirl of cigarette smoke almost seeming to fill the screen and it makes me, every time I see the film, want to grab a large whisky, light up, and settle back to enjoy the movie (a deliberate use of that word to describe this particular film). As you can tell I like the film!

See

as an example.

Mind you Joe McCarthy would have nothing on my other half were I actually to light up at home! I would probably be alright with the dram..

nc4586 | 25 September 2008 - 3:39pm

Players No.6?

I was astonished to see a picture of Dimitar Berbatov smoking a fag the other day (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/foo...ing-loner.html). Do professional footballers still smoke? Clearly he thinks he is the next Albert Camus. Thank God he didn't sign for City.

Martin | 26 September 2008 - 3:46am
Jamie_Bowman | 26 September 2008 - 9:31am
Gatz | 26 September 2008 - 2:23pm

Exhale on Main Street...

...One meets a far more interesting type in the knots of confirmed smokers outside buildings. Commonly known as snoutcasts or exhales, I remember being at a modern dance performance long ago at a theatre where smoking was forbidden and almost all the smokers outside were dancers who were nevertheless capable of astonishingly balletic moves

francisreavley | 29 September 2008 - 6:44am

Keep on coughing in the free world

Here in Beijing I can smoke pretty much where I please - except in taxis. Now BAT, Philip Morris et.al have no market left in the EU and North America, they are flooding this one and competing in a price war with the local brands. Cigarette prices start from about two pounds a carton.

In China, no soap opera would be complete without the underdog hero (generally a policeman, fireman or soldier who has lost a girlfriend/wife/family in tragic circumstances) being proffered a consoling snout from a product-placed packet.

James EB | 29 September 2008 - 11:36am