Entertainment For Lively Minds
Thoughts on coolness
Bill Drummond says tommorrow is No Music Day and 'music is dead' - see Guardian. I don't agree, although I think there is too much music everywhere bombarding us - on TV, in shops, chav's mobiles on buses etc! Not that we can do much about it. But talking of who is cool - NME cool list, and Word cool wall of previous issue, perhaps the old guys are now the cool ones and current recent artists are not so much, for the most part. Old performers have often had their day, their new work not their best but that doesn't seem to matter, as they are hailed for their ground breaking earlier work (hello Led Zep, Sex Pistols). So are new bands all barely disguised tribute bands (hello Enemy, Editors?),and did it all go wrong when Oasis came along and made the blatant copying of old classic stuff pretending to be new, acceptable - they also produced some great music, don't get me wrong! So is it now all too predictable, like one of Radiohead said (Colin Greenwood was it?),which is partly why they released 'In Rainbows' as free download - see BBC news online, I think? Does anyone come up with anything really radical and original nowadays and really takes risks - is that possible anymore? Does music matter as much now (did it ever really matter that much or as much as some liked to think?) - probably it does to some? Was the last move forward in Rock back in the 90s when grunge made it's impact and brought about a new style? I loved the Strokes 'Is this it?' but it's a retro thing really that reminded me of past wonders - Stooges, Velvets, New York new wave from 70s. Everything now is so clearly categorised and compartmentalised - indie, classic rock, metal. You know exactly how it's going to sound before you hear it - which is so boring and, yes, predictable. Perhaps new artists are too reverential towards past masters as it were. Great music of the past was of course a reaction against what went before and often involved really saying something new.I do like new music too. Am I just a grumpy old git? It's quite likely!
- More from andyp.
- Login or register to post comments










Its a crazy mixed up and post-modern world
Music is still as important now as it always has been, despite the efforts of the marketing people at various corporations to try and compartmentalise everything and make every song a sales tool. (I blame Moby). And despite Noel Gallaghers mission to make everything sound like the Beatles.
Personally I listen to a massive range of music from reggae to heavy rock with jazz, blues, punk, and all points in between because access to all that music is easy these days.That doesn't make the music cheapened (only in the literal sense) in any way ...just means there is more of it. Which is great as far as I'm concerned.
Bill Drummonds declaration that "music is dead" sounds like a controversial statement for the sake of it...tell that to the Arctic Monkeys, Manu Chao, Arcade Fire, Cold War Kids, Kasabian, Queens of the Stone Age to name a few current acts who are producing interesting stuff inside the mainstream.
There are never going to be bands that mean so much to you as the bands of your teenage years when you had to save up for every LP release and they were treated like the tablets of the Gods and played to death. Thats just the way it is as you get older. But for kids these days there is a huge and exciting and relatively cheap musical menu to choose from.
Rock music now has a long history. That doesn't mean its dead, but, just like any other artform, it is gonna make it harder to be innovative and come up with something new...
There is good stuff out there
Good reply. Some very good points you made there.
Yes, age does change your perspective, and it's easy to let that affect your judgement of new stuff. I do find good things too - Battles (an acquired taste I admit but I acquired it eventually), Radiohead (new one is a grower), Arcade Fire I definitely agree with, and I am liking that new Roisin Murphy CD also. I enjoy that Peter, Bjorn and John whistling song very much too.
I agree about the long history thing too. It's harder to find a fresh way of doing things for sure.