Entertainment For Lively Minds
The worst band of all time
Posted by Chimney Singing... on 26 November 2009 - 11:49am.
Me and the people I sit with have been arguing for about a year about who the worst band of all time - so we've decided to settle it once and for all.
EDIT: This is not about 'sacred cows'.
The band must have absolutely no redeeming features and you can't like even a single aspect of them - so that rules out the likes of Coldplay, U2 and the Killers for example - because you might like at least one aspect of one of their songs or you can at least see why other people would.
I know the answer is Maroon 5, but would you mind filling out this quick survey anyway?
http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/S22GB7B
P.s Pass it on! I'll post the results tomorrow
- More from Chimney Singing Cheryl Cole.
- Login or register to post comments









Wot no
Mike and the Mechanics?
They didn't make the shortlist
because they have whistling and someone thought it was 'good music to paint to'
But But But
But that makes no sense as whistling should be universally banned and certainly never heard on a record.
pfft....listen to Mr W, eh...
No 1 suspect
He's one of the worst offenders. I just hate whistling in any circumstance. It makes me wince. I find it so irritating that I can't understand how anyone can find it acceptable but I suppose there are some people that don;t have a problem with nails down a blackboard.
arf - i'm sure he is...
i just know he's famous for whistling, but i think i've sucessfully avoided ever hearing anything recorded by him. I just thought the photo looked funny and couldn't resist posting!
Ennio Moriccone
Was fond of a bit of a whistle - can't be all bad
John Lennon
had a few whistling bits - Jealous Guy and there are a couple of others that I can't immediately recall
Peter Gabriel
Games Without Frontiers
Whistling tunes we hide in the dunes by the seaside
Whistling tunes we piss on the goons in the jungle.
It's A Knockout!
your majesty's
like a stream of bat's piss
one of Whistler's
One hit wonder time...
...who can forget Lieutenant Pidgeon and "Mouldy Old Dough" for outright annoyance. I recall some whistling in there but I can't bring myself to watch it on YouTube to check. Just try shifting that from your brain if you make the mistake of remembering the melody.
Allison Goldfrapp
could whistle round my place anytime.
Are you mad?
That's one of my favourite singles ever. Testament to the unforced pottiness of some of Britain's best pop music
aha!
game over - no-one can trump that lot
Starsailor
'nuff said
Spandau
Ballet
What he says.
But Razorlight will do for your purposes.
Except
they did Chant No 1.
Go West. Obviously!
Go West. Obviously!
No
King Of Wishful Thinking redeems them. Just.
no no no
Their first album is full of high quality pop-rock. Their first appearance on the Tube was impressive (on Youtube but no embedding allowed). There were plenty of bands in the 80's who could barely play, but not this lot.
It's got to be Yes
Horrible in every way imaginable and hard to imagine what anyone ever saw or heard in them. Shrill vocals, terrible, meaningless songs, every instrument made to sound as dreadful as possible, painful production, ugly album art. And just look at them - the clothes, the hair - in any incarnation.
Head and shoulders ahead of any other horrors and they've been that way for almost 40 years!
Tsk!
'Owner Of A Lonely Heart'!
A non-recurring phenomenon
I would suggest. But, yes, that's a great song. Imagine how much better it would be if almost any other band played it.
Well it was basically Trevor Horn
and the Art Of Noise making that record, so I suppose your point stands.
OOALH was, I understand, written and demoed
during Horn's active membership of the band. Trevor Rabin then did the guitar overdubs during the 90125 sessions.
Shurely Shome Mishtake
OOALH is almost entirely a Trevor Rabin song. If it were a Drama era tune, why Howe's ongoing awkwardness about it?
I am totally out of my depth here.
I'm going back to listen to 'Slave To The Rhythm' and the first Propaganda album...
Very wise
I may dig out Trevor Rabin's early solo albums. Maybe the contested authorship of OOALH means I can put Yes back on the hook
OOALH is Yes' worst song..
..after "Don't kill the Whale"
Like many totally original artists Yes come in for much flack, but for those with ears there is much to admire in their body of work.
The usual arguments simply do not add up..shrill high vocals? no more so than The Beach Boys, meaningless lyrics?...I give you "I Am The Walrus"..crap covers?..I think they're lovely..instruments sounding bad?..have you HEARD The Velvet Underground?
Yes?!
That's fighting talk. The Schindleria Praematurus hitmakers are superb.
What the hell…
… are the Troggs doing in that list?
I agree
I didn't like that either (or the Beautiful South) but I was over-ruled by democracy
Irony?
.
well obviously
far too clever for their own good this lot. It's almost like they wanted to commit commercial suicide. This was, I believe, their follow up to Donna and, not surprisingly it wasn't a hit. I mean it's great, but it's not a single is it?
and by the wonders of youtube, here they are:
Don't shoot the messenger
This may rile some of the massive, and I can only say that it's not my fault, by Crowded House are on the shortlist in that survey! Yes, really, and that in a world where Big Country were allowed to exist.
It was a democratic shortlist
....and Crowded House received a lot of votes
Democracy ain't all it's cracked up to be
Crowded House are one of the best bands ever! At the very least, they might be accused of being inoffensive.
Exactly!
I demand that Crowded House are removed from this list immediately, if only for the wonderful 'Into Temptation' and an excellent live show. Does no-one remember It Bites for Christ's sake? And let us not forget that current abomination known as Fall Out Boy.
Westlife
Stands to reason. Not them, per se, but the whole approaching Beatles' record number of No.1s, standing up sitting down, pubescent girls' bubblegum money lining louis Walsh's cynical little pockets is what rankles. Or maybe I'm just Irish and resent his success? maybe. Nah, they're still shite and my point remains valid.
Agreed
Voted before I read the thread. Rubbish band. No redeeming features (and even Spandau Ballet had a redeeming song - not Chant No. 1 though).
Shooting fish in a barrel
with Westlife. Shouldn´t we start going after sacred cows and kick up dust. I´ll start, The " Bleedin" Fall. ( I'll get my goat..I`m a shepherd )
Westlife aren't a band...
they're sexless amoebas in white suits.
Completely agree
A band should at least be able to play their musical instruments.
Where does that leave
all the great Motown vocal groups?
I chose Scouting for Girls.
I chose Scouting for Girls.
Me too,
but having seen the above I wish I'd plumped for Westlife
YES
I was going to go with the Stereophonics, but Scouting For Girls are just that bit worse.
how weird
I was wavering between Scouting for Girls and Stereophonics.
Chose SFG because the original post said 'no redeeming features' - and I Wouldn't Believe Your Radio and The Bartender and the Thief aren't entirely bad.
Indeed
As much as I hate to admit it, Stereophonics do have some vaguely redeeming qualities. I even have an acoustic version of "A Thousand Trees" that is (whisper it) quite pleasant.
Whereas "Elvis Ain't Dead" and other SFG atrocities.... mercy.
And funnily enough, I was just chatting to a mate of mine who happened to mention that she saw SFG live last week... she actually paid good money to go see them... I mean, why?!
Torn between
Westlife and King Crimson. They're so similar, how am I supposed to choose?
too easy
Westlife are an obvious choice - like shooting fish in a barrel. We ruled out boy bands as being too obvious, so go for King Crimson! They are just as bad
Westlife aren't a band.
They're a cynically created means of separating hormonally-addled teenaged girls and their pocket-money.
I think they count
according to their Wikipedia entry. They have progressed from being teen pop to a pop sound dontcha know....
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westlife
The Lighthouse Family
Had to go and see them with an ex many years ago. It was the dullest , boring longest 2 hours of my life.
They're a comedy band
Trouble is, the lighthouse family have a redeeming feature. They make me laugh! Whenever I hear a Lighthouse Family track I chuckle to myself that at some stage, in a studio somewhere, someone decided that they'd nailed it when what they have is dull, and without any sort of spark. I always wonder what the takes that didn't make the grade sounded like.
Agreed
The musical equivalent of cold tapioca
Oh yes
I posted this rather elegant diatribe about that lot a while ago. I am, I have to say, rather proud of it and I think it bears repeating...
"They are the epitome of bland, unchallenging and insipid wallpaper music. They have one dreary, mid-paced song that they re-hash time after time after time. Their singer has a range that starts at A and just about reaches B. They take music and strip out everything that makes it worthwhile in the first place - emotion, excitement, passion, energy. Even Mick Hucknall, Sting and any other bete noir of the Word massive you may care to mention, all have more musical ability in a single toenail than the Lighthouse Family. They have a stupid name. They are to popular music what the Findus Crispy Pancake is to haute cuisine. I despise them with an absolute passion."
I thangew.
Sir,
Why?
Why is everyone getting so wound up about the Lighthouse Family?
They made one good pop single in 'Lifted', and anyone who's ever made one good pop single is pretty high up in the pantheon as far as I'm concerned.
I rather liked Pauls summary.
Felt it difficult to argue with. I always have the impression that they had a couple of good songs that could have been majestic if recorded by someone with a more emotive and dynamic voice and an arrangement that lived a little.
But Westlife are worse. And 4 Non Blondes.
It sounds...
It sounds as if you want the Lighthouse Family to be something they aren't.
They were good for four minutes and 17 seconds. That'll do.
You're probably right
They are quite inoffensive and I don't mind a couple of the songs. Not my worst band.
LIFTED! Lifted!
the way that bloke sings it suggests otherwise "bored, we could be bore-ed' makes much more sense BASTARDS!
and while I'm here Travis!
I'd said to myself "Maroon 5"...
... even before I got that far in your thread. Closely followed by Stereophonics.
"Dakota"
redeems the Stereophonics. That aside, though...
Nah...
Gonna have to disagree with you, Mark. I heard all the arguments for 'Dakota' at the time, but to me, it's a bad Cars rip off. Plus, and this is the clincher: it has Kelly Jones singing on it in that earnestly fucking throaty way where he sounds like somebody undergoing amputative surgery. Just less so.
Local Boy In a Photograph
...is quite good. So's Bartender and Thief.
Local Boy
and the rest of the debut does lift them up a bit.
Agreed
The debut album is OK. The second album is also reasonable but after that...no thanks.
Steps
All that was wrong and evil about the world. Possibly not a "band", but definitely a "group" who sold far too many records and made me feel ill for most of my teenage years. Horrible.
Also, why were Sleeper on the list? "Inbetweener", "Sale Of The Century" and "Nice Guy Eddie" are 3 of my favourite songs of the 90s. A great band. And what I've read of Louise's novels (well, the one I have read) was really good.
Shocking behaviour.
Muse
What is the point?
Queen without all the entertaining camp bits...
not a recipe for good music.
If Queen are a marmite band
that would make Muse a Vegemite band.
Muse are more like a Tesco own label "Yeast based spread"
You clearly have never seen any footage of Muse live then
Chopin recitals on a full-sized perspex light-up grand piano? Camp as a gang of poodles in bow-ties carrying a spun sugar model of Barbra Streisand, sir.
That's not what I meant by camp...
I meant a bloke with a cut off microphone and a big tache bending over and pointing his rump at the crowd whilst simultaneously doing something vulgar with his tongue.
Chopin recitals on a full-sized perspex light-up grand piano make me think of ELP with less taste.
On that subject, I happened to watch...
Queen At Milton Keynes this afternoon.
I quite like Muse
- I found their whole ridiculousness quite entertaining and despite having echoes of the dreaded Queen - I think they produce good pop. Preposterous often - but then so much great pop is
I miss Freddie Mercury...
I really do.
Now there was someone who knew that he was in the business of entertainment.
To truly appreciate Muse
is to see them live. I took my boys to Wembley Stadium a couple of years ago with some trepidation, after over 2 hours of stunning entertainment, lights, excitement and most of all Matt Bellamy's exsquisite musicallity on guitar and piano I was hooked. On record I can take them or leave them, live I would happily see them again and again. I truly recommend you give the live show a chance.
It 100% has to be.........
The Kooks! if I ever hear them I feel like cutting my own ears off! They are one of the few bands I can think off where I do not like anything by or about them!!
Van Morrison too actually now I think about it - see above reasons!!
van
maybe many things - for good or evil - but he is not a band
Fair point :o)
Fair point :o)
the flippin'
Clash. The biggest frauds in the history of rock. Pathologically unhumoured, self-righteous hippies in boilersuits. So contrived, so over-engineered, so freeze-dried that they make The Partridge Family look like Leadbelly.
Sadly there's too many people who can't see past their hetero boy-crushes to appreciate what total charlatans they were.
unhumoured?
where's middlerabbit when you need him?
If you can't find a word that fits...
...inventify one.
Cromulent, markiechops,
absolutely cromulent.
Couldn't agree more with
Couldn't agree more with every word. Even the made-up one.
Sorry to chip in so late
and to do so yet again, but if we're going to have a go at frauds in boiler suits, what about the Police ? Haven't seen them come up anywhere else in this thread....
Jazz/prog oldies play acting as punks.
Rarely managed to get a decent chorus in the same song as a decent verse.
Irritating beyond belief ('De Do Do Do' anyone ?)
Pretentions by the bucket load - 'that book by Nabokov'
er...
not sure that happened, sorry.
Yeah
A Mott the Hoople tribute act with a wardrobe from Kensington Market.
"Hetero Boy-Crush"
I can't get offended as I laughed so much at this!
I've stopped liking them
Didn't want to have a hetro boy-crush at my age. My wife would kill me as well (or laugh at me which would be just as bad).
On Mick Jones?*
http://static.gigwise.com/artists/Image/MickJonesWENN.jpg
*click through link on grounds of taste
Had a look
I find him resistible. I find it difficult to think of The Clash in the way I thought of Clare Grogan.
I feel The Clash are somewhat over represented...
... but whither The Fratellis?????
Barclay James Harvest
I remember them being terminally dull in the seventies but gave them the benefit of the doubt by spotifying them just now. Needless to say I was right and I submit in evidence "Titles" from Time Honoured Ghosts. I'm no fan of the HJH but even I can see this is wrong in every way. Ghastly! And Lord help us they're still going.
gracious lawdy mama yes
I had a trendy Christian teacher who used to play a song by them called "Hymn" or something in assembly to try and convince us how cool Jesus wais.
Tin Machine
Queued all night for tickets, left after about 10 minutes - shite!
That was the soundcheck
and you should have stayed for the gig! I think Tin Machine qualify for the Most Misunderstood And Wrongly Maligned Band Of All Time Award.
Why can't The Killers or Coldplay
be included by the way?
Hey, we haven't bashed Keane for a while, are they now acceptable or something?
Catatonia - worse band for me - sounded like Gladys Pugh from Hi-De-Hi fronting the Sterephonics.
I've just voted for Keane
and they weren't even in the short-list on page two of the survey.
The re-release of the first album probably includes all 9 styles (not mixes) of the album that were put forward to a panel of eggsperts who figured out which one would sell the most. Probably.
It definitely does include sleevenotes by Steve Lamacq. WTF Steve?
Hurrah someone talking sense
at last the answer is always "Keane" and always will be "Keane". The rest are just indifferent with except of the spindoctors the canadian "Keane"! why bother survey the answer is Keane.
I was getting worried
by the absence of Moonfaced caused disgruntlement in you recent postings. You were clearly just biding your time.
fraid I missed this
post when it first appeared I do think it's a waste of time all the time laughing boy and his bunch of piano botherers are still hanging around in recording studios I'm hoping the new decade (whenever it starts) will see Tureen chops et al finding useful things to do ideally sweeping up leaves, sorting recycling or running the library in a small Cottage Hospital that sort of thing.
Tureen chops
Excellent.
Catatonia
'Gladys Pugh from Hi-De-Hi fronting the Stereophonics'
Well that's my day made. Wonderful image.
Toploader
Onka's Big Moka.
Dancing In the Buggering Moonlight
The single redeeming thing they did was split up.
Does that rule them out?
GOOD CALL!
Yeah, forever linked to footage of smug-as-can-be Jamie Oliver in his fake "pad" sliding down the bannister etc and welcoming in all his gak head chums on his TV shows ... Aah, truly awful stuff!
I am struggling to think of a worse band than Warrant...
Not good.
Winger?
at least the Warrant videos were easy on the eye...
Warrant: The band Winger always wanted to be
Sleeper
How can you have them in the list? "Sale Of The Century" is a brilliant song.
Sleeper
They came up on my iPod this evening whilst driving home and Sale of The Century and In Betweener are top tunes.
No way are they a bad band.
Sleeper........
My God were they terrible live though.....
Saw them at Brixton whilst desperately trying to cop off with a Louise Wener look a like. Never heard such a muddly, treacly sound combined with very poor playing...
I nominate...
... Wang Chung.
Sorry Billybob...
... their soundtrack to "To Live And Die In L.A." is ace. Mind you, "Everybody Have Fun Tonight" ("Everybody Wang Chung tonight," lest we forget) is truly one of the worst singles of all-time, so I will accept there is seam of crapness that runs through them.
Mentioned elsewhere, I'd argue that Sigue Sigue Sputnik, now the hype has had 25 years to wear off, sound remarkably "now" if anyone's prepared to give them a chance.
My own bete noire would be the appalling Roxette, pretty much the only act I've regularly changed channels to avoid in my lifetime. they're everything inspiration-free and pre-digested that I hate in popular music.
Placebo...
simply ghastly.
The first album's jolly good.
Well I think it is.
Shed Seven
or maybe the Bluetones. The template of landfill indie.
Go back and listen to Dolphin
That is a top tune.
There is only one answer
Limp Bizkit
How - and I mean how - did I forget about them?!
You've nailed it, Pat. Search over.
Pat's right. As is Patrick.
At least until I scroll further down to find more horrors.
True, true.
They existed merely to divert hundreds of corn-fed sociopaths who would otherwise have killed their school chums in the years before Guantanamo Bay opened to provide them with gainful employment.
"Break Stuff" is the funniest song in the history of er...songs.
Black Lace
those responsible for inflicting "Agadoo" on the human race deserve this honour.
No.
Black Lace KNEW they were shite. They had tongues jammed solidly in cheeks. They knew what they were doing, churning out bilge for plebs. It wasn't supposed to be High Art, just a way of earning a few bob and appearing on Top Of The Pops.
And how many grannies have enjoyed doing Agadoo and Superman with their grandchildren? Isn't this, in it's own way, what music is all about? Letting people dance and enjoy themselves?
Just don't play it when I'm around. Even though I do know all the words. And actions.
These two would certainly agree, Lenny
Back in the early 80s, I did some work with Alan Barton
the 'evil genius' behind Black Lace. Believe me, he knew *exactly* what he was doing when he put together Agadoo, Superman, etc. :-)
But they deserve respect…
… for 'We're Having A Gang Bang' if nothing else.
Has to be Rothko
Who? Just take it from me, a band that consists of 3 bass guitars is not going to play anything to dance to.
I beg to differ
Things I'd rather be doing
than listening to Black Lace, or the Tweets 'Birdie Song'.
1. Root canal
2. Full body dermabrasion and dipped in salt
3. Water boarding
There's probably many more but I can't for the life of me believe I would have survived much past this.
I did two molar root canals today.
Whilst listening to The Feeling.
OK.. I was on the doing end, but the patients were both happy.
Now there's something...
Maybe root canal work, dermabrasion and water boarding should be worked into the actions in "Superman" to give it a more modern feel.
A DOUBLE WHAMMY OF EIGHTIES FILTH
1. Worst band of all time: T'Pau.
2. Worst duo of all time: Go West.
C'mon everybody, the Clash as worst band? What planet are you on? Ditto for Coldplay or U2. Else you're all correct, and Brian Eno is wrong? Now you know that THAT just isn't possible!
AN ADDENDUM
Forgot to add that my rationale is that it matters that said acts took themselves awfully seriously and truly believed that they really were bringing something to the table - ruling out the likes of Black Lace etc who were clearly only in it for the laugh and a few shillings while the going was good.
While I'm smacking the 80s with all I've got, on the shame front I must add that I do remember reading in Smash Hits in 1983/84 an interview with Gary Kemp which ran under the banner "Is this man the new Bob Dylan?" Err, Messrs Hepworth & Ellen: anything to say for yourselves regarding this?
THAT'S IT ... WE'RE SPLITTING UP!
To my astonishment, having just had a quick chat with my girlfriend re the awfulness of Toploader - see above - she has just informed me that she did indeed buy Go West's album back in the day ... "They were a girl's band," she insists, "and they weren't for you anyway."
"Is Gary Kemp the new Bob Dylan?"
To be fair to Messrs E&H, it was a reasonable question to ask. The answer was always going to be 'no' but there's nothing wrong with asking the question.
...and at least Gary Kemp hasn't released his Christmas Album yet :-)
Worst Songs
would I be redundant referencing/recommending Dave Barry's "Worst Songs Of All Time" articles and book ? I know a lot of them were one-offs, but there were some serial offenders in there that might qualify here, like Chicory Tip.
Similarly, Joe Queenan's "America" has a hilarious, savage and highly articulate destruction of Billy Joel, Phil Collins, among other things. Does Billy Joel count as a band ?
And where's Jonathan King in all of this ? He's got a lot to answer for with all the 'bands' he put together.
Yeah, but ...
the trouble is, J King wrote "Everybody's Gone to the Moon" - subsequently covered rather wonderfully by Nina Simone.
Billy Joel: always thought Oasis could have done a great cover of "Captain Jack" ... No, seriously ... It's a great song!
Phil Collins: Whatever you may think about his singing, his lyrics, his politics, his dress sense, the very cut of his gib, he has THAT drumfill - and that's all he needs to survive this here cull!
......
.....no, I'm speechless.
Dave Barry
Has he come up on The Blog before? A man of genius. Any other Barrophiles out there?
Yep
Brilliant in his day and had the nous to get out when he realised that he had started repeating hinmself.
I'd rather say least favourite
and I give you...............R.E.M.
There are way too many to name just one...
...don't fence me in.
Can we have a Top 10?
I mean, how can one choose between The Cutting Crew? Or Mental As Anything? Or Linkin Park? Or The Ordinary Boys? Or Creed? Or The Levellers? Or Tin Machine? Or Primus?
A Top 20 maybe?
Primus??
A fine, fine band...
(and Les Claypool can play a mean slap-fretless)
Menswear
Although I can see the merit in Westlife and Lighthouse Family nominations, their considerable success must count against them in this poll i.e. they seem to have some appeal.
Menswear contrived to be a cross between Pulp and Blur - but were actually a pulpy blur (or a blurry pulp). Bad, instantly forgettable songs. Not that this matters because they could have been rescued by a charismatic and witty singer. Nope. Don't even remember his name or anything he said in the many interviews they managed to secure at the time. At the height of pop's last hurrah in the mid 1990's, when records were selling by the million, they sold about twelve.
The only Menswear song I've knowingly heard
is "Daydreamer" and I fucking hate it. So I'm total agreement with you, despite knowing nothing at all about them other than the fact that one of their biggest hits is terrible.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but...
....I don't think taste, quality or value have anything to do with popularity or success. See above.
Men swear
about Menswear.
I love this blog. \m/
'Stardust' is a top song:-
Menswear - Stardust - MV - ดูวิดีโอทั้งหมด กดที่นี่
I'm torn between which is worst
Cradle of Filth? Or The Mars Volta? If they were to perform together on a double bill, the entire universe would vanish into the resulting vortex of suck.
The Sex Pistols
Fucking horrible tuneless piss weak band
BBB - boring beyond belief
Unlistenable
Singer can't sing. No melodies.
"Energy" - wot? Listen to The Who
"Rebellion" - smartasses with clever manager
"DIY" - OK, but doesn't make for Good Music
(Phew - gasp - feels good to get that off my asthmatic babyboomer HJH loving chest)
Everyones entitled to an opinion
but you are SO wrong
OK, once Matlock left they were merely a cartoon of their former selves, and Never Mind The Bollocks is a mastery of production when compared to the originally released Spunk set, but there's no way they can be considered as the worst.
ASH
the godfathers of landfill indie. I find it almost impossible to understand how anyone could be an actual "fan" of this band.
Finally!
Great call.
nonsense
their greatest hits album is ace.
definitely a singles band
They're still producing good stuff. I loved this song from this year, but sadly it wasn't on spotify to add to the 2009 playlist.
Good track though. Decidedly un-landfill as well.
it's not BAD
a bit U2-circa-Achtung-Baby-lite, but it's not exactly characterful is it? I mean it could be anybody. It just doesn't seem to have a heart.
I saw them on Later...
when they were about 12 and thought they had a certain charm; but only in the same way that watching your kids' first band rehearsing is cute ("Awww look, they're just like a proper band").
It was this appearance:
The Pet Shop Boys
I have always disliked them. They are hugely overrated and lack the very things that make soul music great - funk, emotion, excitement. I will make an exception for 'What have I done to deserve this', but only because of Dusty. I have nothing against synths and drum machines. I am a big fan of Scritti Politti.
what in the name of god
makes you think you should expect 'soul music' from Pet Shop Boys? D'you expect jazz fusion from Metallica? Are you disappointed that Daniel O'Donnell has yet to enlist the services as Aphex Twin as producer/arranger on his next long player?
FFS, Pet Shop Boys are a pop group. If you don't like them, that's cool, but not liking them because you expect them to be soul music is a bit much, isn't it?
i used soul
in the sense of emotion, feeling - I don't expect Otis Redding, but I find their delivery, not just vocally but musically, lacking in the very things that make most other music uplifting. But I think you probably knew what I was driving at, you just wanted to vent. That's cool...
The Pet Shop Boys have soul in spades IMHO
I'm not even a huge fan per se, but songs like 'It Couldn't Happen Here' make me well up. Even if you continue hate them, I challenge you to listen to that song and still justify 'worst band' status.
no - i wasn't 'venting' at all..
I genuinely (and perhaps foolishly) took your description of 'soul' music at face value and was rather puzzled, hence the 'rant'.
point taken on the delivery. We'll agree to disagree...but as joe says, I think that it's a tad harsh to lump 'em in the 'worst band' bucket!
yeah, you're right
of course it's harsh, and I knew I would be flamed for stating it, but it felt good getting it off my chest. Sorry Joe, I listened to 'It Couldn't Happen Here' and I haven't changed my opinion.
The Fall!?!?!?! (not my opinion!!!)
I was talking to my girlfriend about this thread last night & without a moments hesitation she said 'The Fall'!!!! I did consider our future together until she admitted the kooks were piss-poor!
I have yet to meet a lady who actually likes The Fall! Why is that?
p.s. I got my own back by playing 50 year old man, rowche rumble & the container drivers quite loud.....she didnt change her mind!
There were five ladies IN The Fall
who claim to have quite liked it.
haha, thats a fair point. I
haha, thats a fair point. I bet that is it though :o)
The Fall?
They played played Psykick Dance Hall last week, right now M.E.S. is close to godlike again
The Fall
it is the assumption of intellectual superiority, it is the alleged subversiveness, it is the sub-Beefheartian racket they make - but above all - that combination of northern miserabilism and sneering "wisdom" makes everyone who listens to them unhappy after doing so. They are less than life enhancing.
They are the second worst band of all time. The worst - hands down - being Queen
Everyone?
Whenever I listen to the Fall I feel uplifted for all sorts of reasons - some serious, some less so.
I might only listen to them once a month or so but whenever a Fall track comes up on the jukebox it makes me realise that I'm glad MES exists and has the resolve and/or sheer bloody mindedness to carry on (mind you, what else could he do - other than read the football results?)
My world is a teeny tiny bit better for them being here.
Couldn't have put it better
Exactly my sentiments
well said Stimpy
City Hobgoblins or the Laughing Gnome? The answer ain't Bowie, Sheev ;-P
Who
makes the "assumption of intellectual superiority"? Anyone who enjoys a Fall record? It sounds to me like you have had a bad experience with a Fall fan and it's them you're complaining about more than the band....
Stereofuckingfuckphonics....
A true waste of electricity. All the more worthy of the crown as they (well Kelly Jones) really does reside in a vacuum believing that they are important, cultured, talented and liked. Not the vaucous, narcissic, talent free pub rockers they clearly are.
I think 'Dakota'
may stop them from being the worst of all time. It's a classic of the 'terrible band accidentally writes a good song' genre
Curiosity..
..Killed the Cat. Posh boys defer going into City jobs to form hateful band who go on to record truly hateful debut Straight Back Down to Earth, (being a string of well worn lyrical cliches delivered against a discarded Matt Bianco backing track). Singer Ben Volpeliere Pierrot sports the most punchable face pop music ever produced. I rest my case. Don't say he redeemed himself by not marrying Patsy Kensit. It's not enough.
Gay Dad
I mean WTF, as young people have it..
Scouting For Girls
Hang on..
..I forgot about Northside.
Dermo............!!
They're saved.
I liked the innocence of "Shall We Take A Trip" and the, yes, funkiness of Chicken Shake!
Too daft to be the worst....
A vague and half hearted defence of Northside
Everyone seems to have it in for Northside, they've become shorthand for Madchester landfill. My Rising Star came up on random suffle last night and it's not a bad tune at all. Shall We Take a Trip was deemed good enough to be used on Granada's goals round up.
Certainly niether tune was any worse than anything the Charlatans were knocking out at the time - The Only Song I Know.
Worst band ever - not really.
Belle and Sebastian.
Again. I've not gone on about it for a while because others accused me of bringing down the whole vibe, like, man. But here, now, is the platform.
Belle and Sebastian.
I say it again. I hate them. Worst band. Ever. Fey, pretentious, posturing tripe. Turd-polishing production, oh-so-terribly-ironic-yet-doggerelic lyrics, nursery-rhyme melodies all compounded by the love of them by so many tin-eared music journalists. No other band makes me so reach for the radio whilst looking for the nearest window.
And The Fall are fucking shit as well. Sorry. Fucking-ah shit-ah as-ah well-ah.
And The Alarm! Why has no-one mentioned them yet?
Presumably, no-one wants to mention The Scottish Band. (R**R**.. can't type their name for obvious reasons..)
Someone else still probably nailed it with Then Jherico.
And you can't have a go at the Shitehouse Family. It's like kicking a puppy for shitting on the carpet.
"And The Fall are fucking
"And The Fall are fucking shit as well. Sorry. Fucking-ah shit-ah as-ah well-ah."
I feel very sorry for you.
Sorry.
I-ah feel-ah very-ah sorry-ah for-ah you-ah (yawn).
+1 on Belle & Sabastian
Twaddle. Complete and utter.
I was going to say......
.......The Beatles, because I hate them so much but it wouldn't be within the concept so then I was going to say Queen but the same applied so it can only really be..........
.....Sigue Sigue Sputnik
Easy, Shed Seven. Anyone who
Easy, Shed Seven. Anyone who names one of their songs after a day time quiz show hosted by Henry Kelly deserves banishment to hell.
have we mentioned Nickelback yet?
Properly hideous. I even get panicky when they come on the radio, I just can't turn it off quick enough.
Chad Kroeger..
..is a creepy looking dude. That's for sure.
LIVING. IN. A . BOX!
Earlier I piped up about Go West, who were truly awful, but it's this lot I was really trying to summon up from memory.
I've always liked that song
and surely one-hit wonders shouldn't be candidates for Worst Band Ever! I think we need to consider those with truly execrable - and even large - bodies of work that were (or are) mystifyingly and disproportionately successful in a commercial and even critical sense. The two most egregious examples I can come up with are Queen including and after Bohemian Rhapsody (they were great before then) and Yes passim.
Me too; the Bobby Womack
Me too; the Bobby Womack cover was great as well.
Admissions of guilt
I actually did have the Living In A Box album this came off - yes, there was one. Not particularly long on tracks - I think it was padded with remixes, and in my defence I don't think I played it more than two or three times. Well ok, that's no defence for buying it the first place. I feel another thread coming on....
Go West - "truly awful"...
well, yes - I suppose so. I see what you mean. But actually get beyond the mullets and the jackets with sleeves rolled up and all that horrid 80s production - they were actually quite good.
I confess to not only owning the first album which I think everyone did (that and Sade's Diamond Life) - but also the second one Dancing on the Couch. On which "Crossfire", "Masque of Love" and "From Baltimore to Paris" are all excellent songs.
At their worst they could sound like the worst bits of Thompson Twins and Level 42 in an unholy brew - but at their pop-soultastic best - they weren't far short of Hall & Oates class. Peter Cox belongs in the first rank of Brit white soul voices.
And "Goodbye Girl" was the soundtrack to my break up with Jenny Mayfield. She went off with Richard Donohoe. Who was a bell-end as far as I could see. Actually, he looked a bit like the one with the dark hair in Go West. You're right - Go West were crap. Evil.
Now you mention it, Sade at the Ally Pally
I'll also admit to owning a few of Ms Adu's offerings. Yes, can be a bit insipid, but -- and it is a huge but -- I went to see Sade at the Ally Pally many moons ago just after it re-opened (largely because of a girl I conspiciously failed to get anywhere with), and I have never in my life been in a room with so many attractive, well dressed women, and we're talking a huge room with way over 50% female attendance. Sort of thing that sticks in your mind coming from a background of Thin Lizzy/AC-DC concerts.
Athlete. The prosaic,
Athlete. The prosaic, mawkish premature-baby-at-Christmas "Wires" makes my skin crawl.
Bush
a dreadful president - and a truly awful band. Actually - you listen to all that sheeny sludge coming out of America these days - Green Day, Killers etc - I'm sure it's all Bush's fault.
They were Brits too - but we had the good sense to give them the cold shoulder - unlike our friends over the pond.
How about a no-hit wonder...
....Russell Crowe's "30 Odd Foot Of Grunt", a vanity project with some of his Australian mates. If he's ever making a movie round your way and this lot turn up, make plans to be somewhere else. Made a big mistake seeing them a few years back.
Also, how come The Red Hot Chili Peppers haven't been mentioned ? Annoying, pretentious, take themselves very seriously etc.
Keanu Reeves' Dogstar
The 'Happy Shopper-brand' Tin Machine.
Not Lidl?
Thanks for changing, Stimpy ;-)
Why not go for a proper target? The Clash
In recent years it's become apparent to me that the Clash are probably the most bogus band ever.
Everything from Joe Strummer, an ex-public school boy, acting all prolier than thou to their fake political posturing. How bloody pretentious is to call an album Sandinista? His most quoted pearl of widom was 'he who f**** nuns will one day join the Church', really profound that Joe!
They sacked their first drummer for merely saying he would like to buy a sports car. They signed to the largest record company in the world, and went on moaning about being 'artistically free'.
Complete hypocrites!
That makes no mention of the music.
I was merely a distant twinkle in my father's eye when The Clash were at their peak, so unless I choose to familiarise myself with the history, I've only got the music to go on, and that particular ingredient is a major factor that determines whether or not I think a band is good/bad.
The ex-public schoolboy
The ex-public schoolboy thing is overplayed. Strummer got a place in public school due to his Dad's relatively lowly diplomatic role. Insinuating that he is some sort of toff is well wide of the mark.
Wet Wet Wet
By a mile
I'm going to Tweet this
so we get a larger and more representative sample. Chimney-Singing, when do you want to announce the results?
End of the week?
To be honest, most of this has come from other sources. I posted it on here after we had circulated it by more conventional means
You can see the point when people here get involved as you start getting bands like The Smiths appearing!
Would love a bigger sample size - we're up to about 400 so far.
Just Tweeted it.
Prepare for the deluge...
What's the link
for the twitter feed? My colleagues are loving the fact we've 'gone viral'
Twitter
http://twitter.com/TheWordMagazine/
Thanks Fraser
I should point out that someone has just posted 'The Frames' as the worst band of all time - it appears we're going properly Word.
I expect the Oasis/ Stereophonics count to rise significantly
I think manufactured bands
I think manufactured bands of the likes of Westlife and Boyzone should not even be considered here. They are little more than karaoke anyway.
As for the worst band of all time I think it has to be someone that takes themselves seriously and even has a modicum of success and has some fans. The band I just don't get at all, and who's success completely baffles me is Snowpatrol.
Listening to paint dry would be more exciting than this boring insipid old twaddle.
Oh and I don't like Oasis either.
A word in Snow Patrol's favour
I play bass in an indie covers band and Snow Patrol tunes are so easy to play I treat them as rest breaks. Terrible songs mind.
another word in Snow Patrol's favour
Their second album "When It's All Over We Still Have To Clear Up" was genuinely a great album. Its a shame they've been less than that album implied by being blander and blander every time they release something.
This album contained beautifully written emotional vignettes such as this one:
Texas or Toploader
I can exclude Westlife, Aqua and all the karaoke puppet bands who've never claimed to be anything they're not, or so-so bands who went dull with success (Stereophonics, Snow Patrol etc). Pompous old duffers who think they're really cool and relevant make me nauseous
(those three descriptions cover pretty much all music made in the late 90s, come to think of it. No wonder I was a bloody miserable teenager...).
Guilty Secret
I actually enjoyed Toploader's debut single Achilles Hell.
You want sacred cows?
In that case the worst band of all time has to be The Incredible String Band. Whenever I heard anything by them over the years I always thought, "that sounds terrible, but loads of people think they're brilliant". I must give them a proper listen sometime.
So about a year ago a pal gave me their entire catalogue as MP3s (purely as sampler material of course) and I started to plough through it. But I gave up after an album and a half. I just cannot be doing with that allegedly "microtonal" singing and the suffocating tweeness.
To listen to any more would be a form of torture.
Definitely agree with that
However, sacred cows are definitely not what we are after...
This doesn't apply to you, but seems a good time to remark that we keep getting the sort of responses that people want to be seen to be saying rather than what the actually think - which is odd for an anonymous poll.
So, there's lots of Beatles, U2, Queen, Dylan, Smiths...fair enough if you don't like them but are they REALLY as bad as Nickelback, Maroon 5 and the Lighthouse Family?!
With you all the way
on that one BrianH. I did the same about 9 months ago. I guess you had to be there. With a half-smoked Camberwell Carrot dangling from your lips. Twaddle of the first order.
I'll have the Black Eyed Peas
Shocking rapping and no tunes. And can I also vote for The Script. Completely insipid uninspired mince.
Manic Street Preachers
..all that frowning, sloganeering and general earnestness - and I could never figure out exactly what it was they were cross about.
have you been to wales?
If you think the manics are bad.....
Try living in North Wales knowing you're sharing the air with the Alarm. Now that's horrifying look you boyo.
Eleven times this year alone...
..but only North Wales, and I know they're from the South. I just can't see how All Surface No Feeling or Motorcycle Emptiness relate to economic hardship in The Rhondda, (if that's what you're suggesting I've missed). It always sounded like sixth form pretension to me.
The Manics were once described...
...as someone doing The Clash in a school play :)
That said, their run of singles from A Design For Life through to Tsunami is as good as any other band's.
2 things
my very posh friends kids did a song and dance piece to the Clash at their fee paying schools xmas show recently.
When another friend who grew up in llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch told stories of his youth living in north wales; of whizzing around the snowdon hills etc on crappy hondas and shagging on the roofs of electricity sub stations (for warmth) the first thing I thought of motorcycle emptiness.
Puddle Of Mudd.
How do I claim my prize?
Not only do they have a truly horrible name...
they can't even spell it right.
but, spell it wrong and
it can then be trademarked!
Have
The Cranberries been mentioned yet? If not they bloody well should have. Just an awful awful racket.
Get IN...
..forgot about them.
Uh-huh, uh-huh, uh-huh...
couldn't agree more. She makes a noise like a fat duck being tossed down a flight of stairs.
Can I change mine to Roxette?
I actively dislike bands that make an effort to look all dangerous and rock & roll - but are actually bland, business-like and boring.
Rock musicians with acres of tattooage, hair colour and enspikement and piercings a go-go promise to be entertaining individualists and free-form thinkers yet, often, have the personality of Alan Partridge.
Bland, business-like and boring
Doesn't "bland, business-like and boring" cover just about every successful band that makes an effort to look dangerous and rock 'n' roll?
Add comical, self-important and venal
to that list and you have Metallica, of course.
Which brings us neatly to...
..Marilyn Manson. Case surely closed?
Bill Bailey
sums up herr Manson the best:
"There's nothing quite like seeing a 6ft freak wearing a corset down on his knees shouting "MILTON KEYNES! MILTON KEYNES!""
You gotta love Brian haven't you?
Although of the massive, I am probably Mr Warner's only supporter. Nevermind.
He's done a couple of good songs
The Dope Show, I Don't Like The Drugs But The Drugs Like Me, Mobscene and Beautiful People are all pretty good.
I'd rather he was around than not around He fulfils a useful role although has become increasingly self-parodic as the years have gone on
.
"I'd rather he was around than not around He fulfils a useful role although has become increasingly self-parodic as the years have gone on"
Manson or Dylan?
No offence to the OP
but I can't help thinking this thread is pointless. By definition, we'll never have heard of the 'worst band in the world' as they will have zero musical ability or star quality.
The above suggestions are just people's subjective opinions.
Sorry to be boringly rational about it but there you go ;-)
Well, how about...
... the most inexplicably successful, then?
Dougie J
"worst" is different from "bad". Worst implies the ability to do better but wilfully choosing to do evil. That is why Keane win hands down. Bad groups are just inept and can't play etc. Bands like lighthouse family however can all keep a beat, play a melody on a keyboard but use their skills to produce bland crud and therefore are "worst" after Keane of course, who squandered hours scrapping away in Hasting's Junior Youth Orchestra and further hours of private viola lessons only to release their heart sappingly dull dirges on the world.
I'm not a huge fan of Keane,
but the boy can sing a bit, no? They've also written some pretty fine melodies - Everybody's Changing and Crystal Ball, off the top of my head and not having access to Spotify. Like I say - subjective opinion.
Dougie - leave it
Chris will not be swayed on matters relating to Mr Visage de Lune.
Fair enough
I'm pleased that lots of people disagreed and got involved though - it's been a fun experiment.
As I said in the original post - it was to settle a discussion at work, and have a bit of fun, not to be taken too seriously.
And also - what Chris G said.
Starshit
Ship happens.
Oh come on...
they were kind enough to inform us that we built this (unspecified) city on rock n' roll! What's not to like?! ;-)
Has no one mentioned Kasabian yet?
Awful awful awful.
Also Muse, as discussed above.
Kasabian - a Kula Shaker for the noughties...
why is it that bands whose names start with a 'K' are invariably krap?
You're not a fan...
...of the Kinks then, Patrick?
I thought about them...
but then realized that their name starts with a 'T'.
Oh come on..
..we all know who it is
The K rule stands up I think
..
The K rule stands up I think
..
There might be something in this K theory..
(The) Kinks being the exception that proves the rule..
anybody done ocean colour
anybody done ocean colour scene yet?.......
Worst band
Golden Earring,the only time i saw the whole crowd get up as one man and go to the nearest pub.
Surely...
it's Embrace!
They went from second-rate Oasis copyists to second rate Clodplay copyists.
They also managed to produce the worst ever official England World Cup record in the process, which given the competition is somehow hard to believe.
These
..may not be the worst, but theyr'e certainly the funniest !