Entertainment For Lively Minds
The Hollies
I just bought (and watched) "Look Through Any Window", a great doco about the Hollies from their beginnings in 1963 up to the mid-seventies.
Graham Nash, Allan Clarke and Tony Hicks are all interviewed individually, also Bobby Elliott (drummer) and audio from their EMI producer Ron Richards.
Amazing stuff for folks like me who are interested in this period of 60s pop - the most interesting bit for me is the filmed recording of "On A Carousel" - on the dvd you can see Tony Hicks playing his guitar part and also Bobby's drums, and also the vocals being out down, 3 singers round one mic.
It's a very honest film - at one point Allan Clarke says "we weren't The Beatles" - yet they had hit after hit back in the day. And their producer seemed to be very canny, working next door to George M and the Fabs.
Anyone else have an opinion about these guys? Here's some of the Abbey Road stuff
- More from Mousey.
- Login or register to post comments










Huge fan
Amazing harmonies, brilliant string of hits. Often overlooked and remembered solely for He Ain't Heavy
Here's my fave:
Spot on.
Bus Stop is one of the most perfect songs ever written and The Hollies absolutely nailed it. 2' 58" of shimmering gorgeousness. Graham Gouldman has said that what you hear on the single is exactly what he was hearing in his 19 year old head when he wrote it. If Lennon & Macca had penned it, it would be lauded to high heaven. One of the most underrated groups of the 60's. I also love this TOTP version.
When I grow up, I want to look like Graham Nash
A walking advertisement for the benefits of a rock n roll lifestyle decanted to Cali...
A fan too
Their golden years for me were when they started writing their own material and the Graham Gouldman songs but were they ever allowed to develop musically as a band? I often wonder if things might have been a shade different if George Martin had produced them. Fans see Ron Richards as being as much of a part of The Hollies as GM was to the Beatles. The departure of Graham Nash and Allan Clarke doesn't seem to have had much of an impact but if they'd been allowed to evolve would they still be around?
Great band
I much prefer pop to rock and The Hollies are popmasters. Some notes;
Really inventive guitar parts from Terry Hicks
Terry Sylvester was a superb replacement for Nash (as a vocalist at least)
Possibly the best Springsteen cover in 'Sandy'
Has anyone caught them live since Clarke chucked it? Any good?
I saw them a couple of months back
and they were a bit disappointing. The new singer couldn't hit all the big notes and didn't have much presence. I couldn't help but feel: it's your band, your careers and if you want to carry on then good luck to you... but it's beginning to tarnish the legacy.
Got to see them once before Allan Clarke left
It was late '90s, Guildford, around the time the 'At Abbey Road' discs came out. Not sure if it was coincidence, but as I remember, the set list seemed to be stuffed with goodies like this:
Don't Run and Hide
Great show. Haven't seen the recent incarnation(s).
Eek
I just looked at some fan video from their recent gigs and it's not good. Hicks (being the leader now, I guess) has far too much guitar (and banjo) noodling for my liking.
See if you can take 30 seconds of this.
I mean, you gotta ask yourself
How much more Nigel Tuffnell could that be?
And the answer is 'None. None more Nigel.
I'm such a Springsteen nerd
that I can't hear anyone covering his songs but The Hollies version of Sandy is just gorgeous. It is one of the very first covers of a Springsteen song (his original in '73, their cover in '75) and wasn't a hit. But I've always remembered it with affection.
I like both Springsteen...
... and the Hollies, but that is really horrible (IMO) - sounds like the New Seekers - and why did they let Les Dawson play piano?
See what you mean
That's a live take and nowhere near as good as the album version. The piano cluster notes sound much better too! (That's most likely Pete Wingfield on keys)
Yes
I remember them as a nipper. "Carrie Ann" was amazing with the Afro drums. First world music influences in pop? The guitar on "Stop stop stop" is stonking. And "He ain't heavy"', with the associated back story, always has me welling up. Great singles.
".. and so this is Christmas"
My opinion
They're ace.
As pointed out above, "Bus Stop" is great. The other Gouldman cover, "Look Through Any Window", is maybe even better. Two of the best pop singles of the Sixties.
They should have moved left field in 1968 rather than cabaret-wards; Nash's departure essentially came from their decision to do an album of Dylan covers, after two decent psych albums bombed commercially. Shame. If Nash had stayed, and if they'd developed their songwriting, they might well be remembered as highly as the Beatles. As it is, that Dylan album contains one of the worst covers known to man, their execrable take on "Blowing in the Wind", in the style of Sinatra (it's even worse than you think).
If anyone with Youtube access (unlike me at work) could post "Dear Eloise", I'd be a happy man (can't tell at work if anyone already has, as I can't view YT videos).
Writing this letter, to make you feel better
Massive fan here :-)
And for ace hair alone....
(Great song, of course...)
in my opinion...
humble as it is, and if you can ignore the awful steel drums in the middle of the song, Carrie Ann has one of the greatest choruses ever heard in popular music.
Agreed.
It has always struck me that CSN would have done a great version of Carrie Ann.
CSN play the hollies catalogue
would've been pretty amusing
For anyone still in any doubt
have a look at these 3 classics - and check out Frankie Avalon introducing them on Hullabaloo in the States before Look Through....as stated above, the second jewel in the crown fashioned by Graham Gouldman.
all the kids in the audience going 'where the heck is Blackpool?'
King Midas in Reverse
Never took any interest in them until I heard King Midas in Reverse on an UNCUT British psychedlia comp and have been intending to buy whatever album it is on ever since. Not got around to it yet. Epic slice of psychedlic pop with a fantastic fanfare ending.
It`s on the album I name
It`s on the album I name below Mr. Wickerman.
Great Pop Band
Always had a soft spot for the Hollies when I was a teenage lanky streak of..., superb harmonies and the `Butterfly` album deserved greater recognition, pop psychedelia at it`s finest.
I always remember St. George saying some very uncomplimentary and undeseved things about `If I Needed Someone`, which I thought were rather bitchy at the time.
According to Bobby Elliott...
The Hollies thought that George had written If i Needed Someone specially for them and were quite flattered. It was duly recorded and released only to find The Beatles were bringing it out on Rubber Soul. George apparently went on to say "they sound like session musicians", to which Bobby Elliott said that he always wanted to be a session drummer!
And just because we can
Here's another slice of sheer brilliance
Thank you...
...I wrote it.
You're a legend
and also the Ha! Ha! Said The Clown and Me, The Peaceful Heart songsmith then.
Indeed,
I am that man.
"She took all the love that
a poor boy could give her ..."
I absolutely adore that song! Thanks for writing it.
And..
thank you Mr F for your kind words.
How totally cool.
You must have GREAT stories.
I do,
but that's why I tend to keep quiet, otherwise I might appear to be name dropping or blowing my own trumpet, neither of which feels comfortable.
Oh please do..
I posted on here last month http://www.wordmagazine.co.uk/content/uk-songwriters-60s-70s that I was feasting on the great late 60s/early 70s British 'producer pop' (for want of a better phrase), and someone mentioned that I had not included your good self. So I went away and brought up your songs on allmusic and had a spotify at them. Great stuff. Some I knew and some I didn't (I played Fox On The Run for years in pubs).
I would love Word to do an article on this subject and it turns out we have an insider right here!
Feel free
to email me direct.
I don't know how
I missed this thread in December. I might have put in my two pennorth. I knew/know many on the list.
Please do...
I don't have any specific questions to ask but I just love that whole period when rock and pop went in different directions. I'm glad I was young enough to be into the charts at that time, and not at all the perfumed garden or whatever.
Tony MacAuley, for one, wrote some great great songs.
Hello Maureen, what you plan to do today?
And hello Mr. Hazzard... :-) A legend in our midst!
That seems
to have become a 'psych-pop' classic, for which I'm grateful. Unfortunately, being classic doesn't necessarily mean sales, but at least it means some people value it.
For anyone who doesn't know it...
This song seeps deep into my 'psych-pop' genes... *sigh*
Fade Away Maureen - Cherry Smash
Did you write it for them?
Or - the doco in the OP mentions several times that Tony Hicks would do the rounds of the publishers looking for songs - is this how they found it?
No,
my publisher offered it to them. I did write another song, which I thought would suit them, and played to them at the 'Listen To Me' session at Abbey Road. Graham was very keen on it and thought we could have a series of hits together but I think the split was already occuring. It was the last song they did with Graham. I later produced the song with The Swinging Blue Jeans but their light was dimming by then and it wasn't aired sufficiently to make an impact
respect
You've written some top songs H. Respect.
Thank you...
Mr T.
Cornish connection ?
Yes I go along with what has been said - some great songs Mr H!
By the way are you still a near(*) neighbour of mine down here?
(*) near as in 15 miles or so!
Depends
where you are, Daff.
The One in the Middle
Bodmin.
UK Route Planner
says 14.3 miles. So you're west of the moor and I'm just south of it, but within spitting distance. Which means Bodmin Moor precipitation precipitates over my house. :-(
The 'Moor' the merrier!
No spitting please!
It is funny how the Moor influences the weather - sometimes we are just on the edge of the rain here - It can be wet at home and, drive a couple of miles south, and it is dry! It makes deciding which way to go on my bike interesting! (Goss Moor trail on Friday was good)
Love The Hollies
That's all. Love 'em.
Butterfly
Wonderful album.
For £10.99...
...you can own all of their Graham Nash era material. I bought this, it's total VFM.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Clarke-Hicks-Nash-Hollies/dp/B004QJL4D8/ref=sr_1...
The odd one out
You would get loads of pointless zeros for asking most anyone about this one. AFAIK, the only Hollies hit without Allan Clarke. The singer here is some dude called Mikael Rickfors (there is a Youtube vid with him singing this).
It just doesn't sound like The Hollies.
I always loved this!
Clarkey had gone off in a strop and this guy was with them for a couple of singles and an album. I just think the song is great, but God knows what it is about....!
At last a thread about The Hollies
I've loved them since He ain't heavy was re-released back in 88 and subsequently played their All the Hits and More (on double cassette)to death. Vastly underated particularly Tony Hicks. I saw them several times in the early nineties when Allan Clarke was still singer and they were always fantastic, not a whiff of 'chicken in the basket'. They always had time to chuck in a few cover tracks too including Purple Rain! When Allan Clarke retired i saw them once with Carl Wayne before he sadly died and they were still really good. Not seen them with the new guy who joined along with another guitar player after long serving member Alan Coates left but clips on Youtube seem a bit worryingly cabaret. It's the bands 50th Anniversary this year and whilst they are touring there doesn't seem to be any special event planned to reunite with former members who rarely for a 60's band are all still alive. Most did turn up for the induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of fame last year in USA apart from Tony Hicks and Bobby Elliot chose to perform with the current band in London that night.
Would You Believe......
I grew up on the Hollies - they were part of the soundtrack to my life in the 60's
As mentioned somewhere above you could do a lot worse than spend £11 or so on the multi disc set that includes all the 'Clarke, Nash, Hicks' stuff That was really their Golden Period - hit after hit from 63 through to (I think) 68.
An interesting but possibly boring fact - the Hollies are now one of the very very few 'beat boom' groups who could reform with ALL the original members as Clarke, Nash, Hicks, Haydock and Rathbone are still alive!
Cock a Hoop!
I've just realised that Paul Jones, Tom McGuinness, Mike Vickers, Mike Hugg and Manfred Mann are all still with us so the original Manfred Mann could reunite along with the Hollies........
Manfred Mann
That'd be worth going to see. The Manfreds have always been a favourite of mine.
Manfreds
are still touring, but without Manfred.
And they're always
a great night out.
Is it the original line-up?
Minus Manf obv.
It seems to vary.
The last time I saw them, both Paul Jones and Mike D'Abo were singing, with Mike playing keyboards, too. Mike Hugg played keyboards. Tom McGuinness played lead guitar. Sometimes memebers of The Bluesband take part.Cetainly the two Mikes, Paul and Tom are still with them. You'll notice they never gig at the same time as The Bluesband since both bands share members.
It seems to vary.
The last time I saw them, both Paul Jones and Mike D'Abo were singing, with Mike playing keyboards, too. Mike Hugg played keyboards. Tom McGuinness played lead guitar. Sometimes memebers of The Bluesband take part.Certainly the two Mikes, Paul and Tom are still with them. You'll notice they never gig at the same time as The Bluesband, since both bands share members.
Curses!
Pressed "go" too early on both occasions and still didn't get it right!
Ha Ha said the Clown
This probably makes you feel a bit old Mr. H, but my mum used to sing it to me when I was a nipper. So, thanks!
Thanks, Richie,
but, face the facts, I am old.
Just found this one
Another of yours, Mr H. The Family Dogg - A Way Of Life. I didn't know that one. Features Hammond & Hazlewood according to Wiki....
Actually,
Family Dogg recorded 'Brown Eyed Girl' (my song, not Van's) as a single. Albert Hammond was certainly on the record, with Steve Rowland singing lead. 'A Way Of Life" was the title of the album (and presumably one of the tracks?). I didn't know BEG was on the album.I certainly remember attending the recording session at Lansdowne Studios.
Can't trust that internet.
I'll go find your Brown Eyed Girl. That title must have caused a bit of confusion.
Excellent... I'll keep an eye out for them playing locally
Saw them in September
...and they were supported by Maggie Bell and Dave Berry. Was a great night, and Paul Jones and Mike D'Abo spin a great yarn or two!
I love The Hollies.
Saw them late 90s (I think) with Carl Wayne on lead vocals and yer man from Mud on bass. So we got all The Hollie hits plus most of the Move ones and Tiger Feet as the encore. Pretty fantastic stuff. Would love to have heard Clarke sing - severely underrated vocalist. Hicks seems to have that youthful look that Johnny Marr and John Squire have inherited from him, as well as the magic jangle.
My favourite song - I Can't Let Go - so much energy.
All of the above...
..and amazing Balearic Disco, too.
Love them too..
Can't Let Go is probably their best performance, but there's so much more. How about I'm Alive:
Not the original but quite good
Oh, okay..
Niall already did this one.
How about this one then..
Just One Look
Tony Hicks'...
... son Paul - is doing extremely well for himself as a sound engineer - worked at Abbey Road - involved in the Beatles' remasters and also has worked with Pink Floyd and Macca, amongst many others.
...with leather waistcoats, 6 string bass and malfunctioning car
Brinsley Schwarz covered this one
Two Yanks In England
by the Everly Brothers heavily features the Hollies and 12 of the songs are credited to L. Ransford, the Hollies' writing pseudonym.
In another tenuous Nick Lowe/Dave Edmunds/Hollies/Everlys link, Dave Edmunds produced New Favourites of Brinsley Schwarz, which featured Now's The Time and went on to record the Nick Lowe and Dave Edmunds Sing the Everly Brothers EP which was released with the Seconds of Pleasure LP.
Here's the Brinsley Schwarz version of Now's the Time.
If you really, really like them...
Admiitedly on quaint old-fashioned CD - but you do get six of them for £10.99 - and the whole thing gets good reviews...
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Clarke-Hicks-Nash-Hollies/dp/B004QJL4D8/ref=sr_1...
The Hollies were one of the first live bands
I ever saw. They were second on the bill to The Dave Clark Five on one of those pop package tours in the 60's which also featured "one hit wonders" Goldie & The Gingerbreads (Can't You Feel My Heartbeat) and Mark Wynter (Venus In Blue Jeans). Unknown opening act was The Kinks who ended their short set with their new single You Really Got Me.
I've always loved this early "B Side".