Entertainment For Lively Minds
The heart - an organ pop music really knows about
I've been thinking about hearts. There's a Feist song called "How The Heart Behaves" which has the line "a calm heart will break if given a shake". There's a song on the new Mary Gauthier record which goes " you can't tell your heart what to feel". Both true. Seems to me that the heart is the one organ of the body that pop music simply can't get by without. And in return pop music is pleasingly eloquent on the subject of the heart. I mean, I wouldn't take pop's word for it when it comes to the mind or even the soul but in matters of the heart Johnny Songwriter gets it right more often than not. "Some say the heart is just like a wheel. When you bend it you can't mend it" as the McGarrigles had it. "A heart needs a home," as Richard Thompson sagely pointed out.
Any favourite heart songs?
- More from David Hepworth.
- Login or register to post comments









Love Needs A Heart
And it may be the hardest thing I've ever done
But apart from all that I hope to find
Where's the heart that's been looking for mine?
I hope it finds me in time
Love needs a heart and I need to find
If love needs a heart like mine
Jackson Browne
This is my favourite
(coat)
Oh I say
That's rather spiffing. Not seen that version before.
Classic.
Only love can break your heart
{starts blurry}
Good song but not strictly true...
...as football can clearly break your heart.
Well, it is summertime and they got me into Neil Young
And did Pete Wiggs know something about this Sunday's result all those years ago?
But, David...
...isn't it your *love* of football which causes it to break your heart?
Enjoy every sandwich
I realised some years ago that, having heard only "Werewolves of London", the GLW thought Warren Zevon was some sort of novelty act. As evidence that he was much more than that, I played her various favourite Zevon tracks, including The Heartache...which isn't to be found on YouTube. Ah well, he also did Searchin' for a Heart, which is.
He also did this
Sad and heartwarming too.
Ron Sexsmith - Secret Heart
This very secret you're trying to conceal
Is the very same one you're dying to reveal
Go tell her how you feel
I like the Feist version too.
Pet Shop Boys
Heart (With Gandalf in the video), This Old Heart Of Mine The Isley Brothers and this:
No user serviceable parts inside
And another...
how about this gem?
All together now...
Everybody's got a Huh-Uh-Ungery Heart......
You prefer the Springsteen version?
;-)
Irony?
I'm not sure whether or not you were gently taking the mick out of the comely Ms Driver, but I really like that version. It's a lovely arrangement, and she doesn't faff around changing genders.
Her first album had at least two good tunes on it. I might see if I can dig 'em up on Spotify.
She certainly has the right surname for someone covering a Springsteen song, eh?
I gather she has a sister called
'Escort' and a tired brother called 'Knackered Y-Reg Transit'.
She certainly looks better on the album sleeve than Ver Boss, I'll give her that much :-)
Mmmmm...
Double post
Damn this slow broadband connection!
Closer To The Heart
I always had a soft spot for this
Whilst we're with Ron Sexsmith...
(and clearly this was meant to link with the comment above. I'm tired.)
Loads!
While I'm tempted to nick all the ones from Bob Dylan's 'Heart' episode of Theme Time Radio Hour http://www.notdarkyet.org/tt-heart.html, there are so many more. Today my choice is one of my favourite Charlie Rich recordings, Have A Heart - a song which, lyrically at least, should come across as nothing but self-pity: I'm drowning, I'm hungry, I need you, please love me. But in Rich's hands it is one of the most inspirational songs that I've ever heard. Literally. You can hear him breathe.
(Spotify link also included for those with no stomach for saccharine, literal YouTube visuals:)
http://open.spotify.com/track/4PXu8JOHt9IvEuoZ1PWDNZ
Somewhere in my heart - Aztec Camera
Somewhere in my heart
There is a star that shines for you
Silver splits the blue
Love will see you through
Bright Eyes
That's from Lua, which for my money is the redoubtable Mr Oberst's finest song. I went on past the lovely bit about the heart, just because I think it's such a great lyric.
this gets me. every time.
I was just
going to post these two songs: Lua *points*↑↑ and Anyone Who Had A Heart *points again*↑
That's the Borg-like mind of the Massive for you. But very pleasing that they're next to eachother in this thread.
Patience and Prudence
Surely one of the prettiest melodies ever...
My heart is like a wheel...
...let me roll it to you....
Classic
The Mothers
Oh yes...
♫ I left my heart ...
... in Papworth General ♫
Lonely places
Mary Chapin Carpenter provides a great line in this verse from Outside Looking In from Stones In The Road;
And tonight I drove around, and the street came up before me
I took a turn and then I found this old house coming toward me
I heard the sound a heart must make when a memory's caving in
Oh baby, what a hungry place, outside looking in
Jackson Browne's In The Shape Of A Heart contains these cautionary lines;
You keep it up, You try so hard
To keep a life from coming apart
And never know
What breaches and faults are concealed
In the shape of a heart
Marvellous Motown and something else
Couldn't resist spoiling it with this stinker:
Red Foley
Dear Red Foley could prove to be a part time Christian Barnard as he could :-
"I'm picking up the pieces of a broken heart "
he manages the exercise that any cardiologist would advise by " I'm waltzing with a broken heart "
Maybe as the night wears on and his mood turns morbid he sings " When God Dips his love in my heart "
FZ...
Lenny Cohen
Couldn't of said it better..
"For the heart with no companion
For the soul without a king
For the prima ballerina
Who cannot dance to anything"
First you...
...take a heart.
And this...
..improves on Marvin Gaye's version, I think.
Jacko
A prog one..
Hadn"t heard this in a while..
Bill's good tonight, innee?
In later years they returned to the subject twice...
Ain't No Love (in the Heart of the City)
Bobby Bland
How good is this?
Heart of the City
Nick Lowe
ooh I jus' loves it
Mighty Sparrow
"Only a Fool Breaks his own Heart"
Reg and Pauline are here
-you can all go home.
That's a good shout
For the cheapskate videos thread.
Gram and Emmylou...
Really rather good.
Stevie Nicks/Tom Petty
"Stop Draggin' My Heart Around"
"an organ pop music really knows about"
Er.. hate to differ here..
No it doesn't.
None of this discusses the heart as an organ, merely as a concept. Any songs mentioning atria, ventricles, valves, coronary arteries, aortae, myocardia?
No. Ask any of the artists above to draw a schematic diagram of the heart; I don't think so.
There are, however, some organs which pop music and pop musicians know ALL about.
Dangly rude male ones. Lots of songs about them. And girly bits as well.
Oh. And Hammond B3s.
I beg to differ
This mentions ventricles (while admittedly taking in other body parts):
Can only have 1
then i'll go for this...great Choice by Chris G
Hank
Amazed it took this long for a Hank Williams song to rear its head. Here's my favourite version of this song:
S** it
I'm having another. There's also a great version by Sinead O'Connor
Spotify playlist
Can anyone be bothered to turn this thread into a Spotify playlist? It deserves it.
There's just so much heart music......
darlin thats all you have to do...
show me a sign, a word or a line
one stitch in time to save this poor
heart from breaking.....jus say my
name, you dont have to say it loud,
ill still be true, ill be waitin jus for you
Mother Tongue
Interesting to note that in obvious sympathy with his interviewer, JM reverts back to Glasgow. Never heard him so Scots...
Heart of Mine
I couldn't find Dylan's original but this a pleasant version for a Sunday.
Pump It Up.
And now....
Hearts in many shapes and sizes
“I was made with a heart of stone to be broken with one sharp blow!” yelps Jane’s Addiction frontman, Perry Farrell in Ocean Size, apparently relishing the prospect. Behind him the band works itself into a sonic tsunami.
Jeffrey Lee Pierce’s inability to knowingly sing in key made him a keen articulator of those moments of emotional crisis that are low on composure. “If you’re gonna go, don’t look at me,” he moans in The Gun Club’s Hearts, distraught and overwhelmed by the end of a relationship. Performed live the song lost its measured tempo and was transformed into wayward, off-kilter punk with a snarling Pierce lashing out blindly.
Steven Jesse Bernstein poured a lifetime of pent-up rage, thwarted ambition and humiliation into This Clouded Heart: “You fucking phony genie, give me my wish! Under the auditorium stairs this time, and no bullshit - show up this time or I'll swipe your glasses and never give 'em back!”
It’s darkly comic, like an accidental trip on a paving stone that robs a beaten man of his last shreds of dignity; you know that you shouldn’t laugh but sometimes you do anyway. Bernstein killed himself soon after recording it.
The clinical deadpan electronica of Saint Etienne’s - Heart Failed in the Back of a Taxi chronicles those moments when what is financially astute takes precedence over what is right.
“Sold the ground to a PLC
moved the club out to Newbury
sod the fans and their families...”
Similarly, Midlife Crisis by Faith No More’s picks holes in the narcissism that underpins Madonna’s public image – a woman whose “menstruating heart ain't bleeding enough for two.”
There is nothing metaphysical about the heart in The Pogues’ Tuesday Morning. It’s an organ in the body that keeps you vital and makes your eyes shine, so that you can live in the here and now. When it stops it’s over. “All you had to throw away was a cowardly pile of sheets and a heartbeat that couldn’t carry you,” sings American Music Club’s Mark Eitzel in All Your Jeans Were Too Tight as he morbidly sifts through a dead friend’s possessions and wonders out loud whether anyone really needs to own the soundtrack from Diva.
Died was the last song that Layne Staley recorded with Alice In Chains, penned for his late girlfriend Demri Lara Parrott, whose demise seemed to act as a knock out blow that sent him spiralling towards a fatal drug overdose aged 34.
“My heart is dried up, beating slow, it's been deflating since you died.”
When his body was found in his apartment by police officers he apparently weighed just 86lbs.