Entertainment For Lively Minds

Word RSS FeedsWord Magazine on YouTubeWord Magazine on Last FMWord Magazine on Share My PlaylistsWord Spotify PlaylistsWord Magazine on FacebookWord Magazine on Twitter

Stieg Larsson

bargepole's picture

Bargepole was intending to read his Milennium trilogy over the festive period,having heard good things about it.
However having got part way through the first volume, The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo, he is on the point of giving up due to the clunky and stilted translation from the original Swedish.
Has anyone read these books and are they worth persevering with ?

0

yes

Mr Drayton has. The first book is by far the best. The second is ok. The third is shit. Get Berlin Noir my Philip Kerr, superb books.

0
Mr Drayton | 12 December 2009 - 10:38am

I'm 3/4 of the way through

I'm 3/4 of the way through the first one and similarly struggled with the first half. It gets a lot better and the characters are really the most interesting part. I'd persevere to the end and see what you think after that.

0
toiras34 | 12 December 2009 - 2:42pm

I agree about the quality of the translation

It is only worth it if the story grabs you. I enjoyed all 3 but the key is whether you care why Lisbeth Salander is the way she is. If her character doesn't particularly interest you then it isn't going to be worth the investment of time.

0
Jed Clampett | 12 December 2009 - 3:00pm

Berlin Noir..

I'd just like to second Mr Drayton's comment on Philip Kerr. Berlin Noir is a classic - Kerr's been criminally overlooked as a writer and Bernie Gunther is his finest creation. Give it a go - you won't be disappointed.

1
Prestonia | 12 December 2009 - 3:09pm

These books...

Are great. And, no, the language translation isn't particularly stilted either - it's actually very well done (or so I thought).

Disclaimer: I've read them back-to-back, just around half way through the third.

Stick with them!

0
oktapod | 12 December 2009 - 3:44pm

Decent potboilers

I read the first one a couple of weeks ago and the second one on holiday last week. I enjoyed them and plan to read the third, but they're hardly masterpieces.
The second one is well over 500 pages long but still leaves unanswered questions (possible plot spoilers coming up) What happened to the men exposed in the scandal? How is Miriam Wu? Who's idea was it to introduce a professional boxer for unlikely plot reasons? (To be fair, many of the characters seem as surprised by this last one as I was.)
Some of it may be down to the translation. I winced when 'noisome' was used as a synonym for noisy, and I doubt that the same confusion exists in the original Swedish.

0
Gatz | 12 December 2009 - 6:40pm

Agreed...

The boxer reeks of deus ex machina...

0
oktapod | 12 December 2009 - 8:25pm

How is Miriam Wu?

if there was ever a pending Steely Dan song title...

0
Glenbervie | 12 December 2009 - 8:32pm

wasn't she

married to that doctor?

0
bargepole | 12 December 2009 - 9:24pm

Maybe Swedish

doesn't translate very well into English. I've always thought that the Wallander books are very clunky and extremely slow moving. Bit like an old Volvo really.

0
stinglikeabee | 12 December 2009 - 10:18pm

Wallander isn´t very good in Swedish either.

My parents´ old Volvo was a Ferrari when compared.

0
Ola Claesson | 13 December 2009 - 12:05am

The Martin Beck series..

..is where it's at in Scandinavian crime fiction, (a ten novel series, and all ace). But give Philip Kerr a go first.

0
Prestonia | 12 December 2009 - 10:39pm

You´re

Absolutely right about Martin Beck. One of the greatest reading experiences I´ve had. Sjöwall/Wahlöö really could write.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/nov/22/crime-thriller-maj-sjowall-s...

0
Ola Claesson | 12 December 2009 - 11:39pm
Privacy Statement    ©  2006 - 2012 Development Hell Ltd