Entertainment For Lively Minds
Spotify stumbles
Posted by Niks on 30 January 2009 - 10:55am.
Spotify has been forced to remove thousands of tracks and restrict many thousands more in certain countries.
http://www.spotify.com/blog/archives/2009/01/28/some-important-changes-t...
Does this mean that the petty politics and outdated attitude of the music industry has stalled soemthing that could genuinely move things forward for online music distribution? Or was it all just too good to be true all along?
- More from Niks.
- Login or register to post comments









hurrah the world is moving
quickly, music socialnetworks are collasping nowadays before I even have chance to sign up. Soon their home pages will wink onto the internet like sparks from fire works and fade as quickly.
It's almost as though they want us to use Limewire etc.
I saw the....
blog last night, and then read through the comments. Out of all the bands mentioned I had only heard of Frank Zappa, and Tool. I can live without both of those, but am getting a bit worried that it will spread to a lot of the music that I do listen to. I'm presuming that the companies, and artists are worried that the public will stop buying cds, but don't they get a royalty payment from spotify?
not surprised
Filesharing is one thing, but a company that charges money is legally fair game to the record companies. They do have the law on their sides, and where there's money being made on their copyrighted material they have every right to go after it. Their entire business model is based on collecting royalties.
So many of these sites fail to iron out the legalities before going live.
If they ironed out the legalities first...
...they would never go live.
So how does Spotify...
...differ from the various Russian download sites that are legal under Russian law? Mp3sparks, Millisong, etc?
When I looked at Spotify I assumed it was totally legal and approved but recent events seem to suggest it's no better than the Russian sites.
According to..
Spotify they had licensing deals with the major labels as far back as October (http://www.redorbit.com/news/entertainment/1580569/spotify_announces_lic...). So why start taking music down now?
napster (second wave)
The current Napster (i.e. not the filesharing phenomenon) has been running a subscription service legally for quite a few years now. There's also Rhapsody in the US. It can be done.
But...
They're not free though, are they?