Entertainment For Lively Minds
Silent Running. Is it any good?
After putting it off for 38 years, finally got around to watching the 1972 film Silent Running last night. It's a film that Doctor K often refers to as a classic and indeed an inspiration for future sci fi movies (notably Wall E).
I can see why people enjoy it, but for me it hadn't aged particularly comfortably.
I do possess a pair of 1972 eyes with which to view it, but even those gave out from time to time. The deliberately wooden acting and the "Hey Nonny Nonny" Joan Baez songs particularly jarred (and that's rich coming from a folky such as me).
I sat my wife and daughter(15) down to watch it on Dr K's recommendation. Strangely enough the person who enjoyed it the most was my daughter (who hadn't lived through the period in which it was made).
The robots are cute and the (Spoiler Alert) image of the lonely robot with the watering can at the end particularly appealed to her.
As for my wife, I think that's one I owe her!
Anyone else seen it? Does it deserve a place in the cannon?
- More from Martin Simmonds.
- Login or register to post comments










I like it
and even bought the OST LP for the Baez songs. But I can see that not everybody would.
The music is a bit twee
but the movie itself is wonderful. It's kind of one side of the 70's really, with the cold war hanging over the world and the birth of environmentalism.
Now, on the flip side was Dark Star, which presses some of the same paranoia and madness buttons, but in a slightly different fashion.
Unlike Silent Running, though, Dark Star is very, very funny. Well, it is if nuclear bombs with an existential crisis are your bag.
Dark Star
Also has Pinback, the patron saint of disgruntled bloggers everywhere:
Pinback: [making video diary entry] I do not like the men on this spaceship. They are uncouth and fail to appreciate my better qualities. I have something of value to contribute to this mission if they would only recognize it. Today over lunch I tried to improve morale and build a sense of camaraderie among the men by holding a humorous, round-robin discussion of the early days of the mission. My overtures were brutally rejected. These men do not want a happy ship. They are deeply sick and try to compensate by making me feel miserable. Last week was my birthday. Nobody even said happy birthday to me. Someday this tape will be played and then they'll feel sorry.
Sadly the DVD copy I have is truly poor quality but I feel a viewing coming on, nonetheless ...
Bruce Dern
seemed to be everywhere in the early 1970's cinema didn't he?
I don't think the film's aged well and have always been suspicious of Dr K's veneration of it. There's too much of the Hippy Hangover thing going on.
Now "Soylent Green" - There's a real early 70's eco-miserablist parable that's stood the test of time..almost.
It's one of the finest....
...SF movies ever.
Fascinting fact: the robots' weird gait was achieved via their being operated by leg-amputees walking on hands.
Still a very good film...
... though like all good SF, it says more about the time it was made than the time it's portraying. In the case of "Silent Running" in manifests itself as the eco-message (now back on the agenda - "Wall-E" is clearly indebted to it) and the folk songs, which are really what dates it, aside from the (state-of-the-art at the time, but now rather quaint) special effects. The story is still very moving though, and there's no way Bruce Dern would be a leading man these days...
One of my faves
Oh dear, always loved this film, the hippy-dippy message, the folky tunes. Remember seeing it as a highly impressionable teenager and just being completely bowled-over by it. And still 30 odd years later it twangs the heart strings ever so.
And can also see why it's a complete turn-off for others, my gorgeous other half included.
I love it
I think it's Bruce Dern who makes the film a classic rather than its sci-fi themes. It may have aged in terms of its visuals, music and stylisations but it's genuinely moving and thought-provoking and Dern's performance is superb. He's magnetic.
He wants to be careful, then
With all those robots around:
-- http://www2.warwick.ac.uk/about/warwickmagazine07/warwickmyths/
Sadly I can't find the pic ...
Another vote in favour
Easily in my top twenty and obviously a big influence on "Moon".
It is superb.
The 'Dark Star' shout is a good one too.
Very, very funny.
I thought it was ok.
Not as good as Dr K made it out to be, but one of those films that I certainly didn't regret watching and definately an interesting period piece.
I will say this though. My own FPO had never seen 2001 A Space Odyssey till last night when I took her on a dream date to see it on the big screen at London's fabulous Prince Charles Cinema. I myself had never seen it on a big screen.
There's little chance, I fear, that Mrs Simmonds could have hated Silent Running as much as Mrs Sprocket hated 2001 A Space Odyssey. Blood was nearly spilt round about "Beyond The Infinite."
Mrs Sprocket, I should say, loves sci fi. The Alien Films, Firefly, Battlestar Galactica and many others are among her faves.
Hope you get a chance to see it in 70mm some time
http://www.ast.cam.ac.uk/public/2001/2001.html
This thread is all really spooky
as I was just talking to my mate Con at lunchtime about both Silent Running and Dark Star. Dark Star was so influential mainly because of the late Dan O'Bannon's input in creating the non pristine spacecraft which also featured in Alien (which he also wrote).
Dark Star = Alien
[SPOILERS AHOY!] Spacehip on ultra-long voyage, crew in hypersleep, alien invades spaceship, ship destroyed in the end except for one survivor, QED.
Surely that's
Alien = Dark Star + Ridley Scott + Giger + Sigourney + John Hurt+ a few bob ;-)
No.
And I will read no further.
How dare you mention Mike And The Mechanics songs on this blog!
and the Ripple Hitmakers for that matter