S-bends

I was listening to ABBA again last night (yes, I know, but it's weaning me off Millican and Nesbitt, so don't complain), and I was struck by something I'd never noticed before: Agnetha and Frida's inability to get their mouths around voiced alveolar fricatives (sounds painful, I know, but it's just elocution-lessons talk for when an "s" sounds like a "z", like the second one in "sounds").

According to ABBA, it was a rich mance world with tierce in their ice.

I once worked with a female vocalist whose CV as a backing singer was achingly impressive. And to match the pipes she happened to be a looker of Beyoncesque proportions. But she couldn't get a record deal. I assumed her case was just another of life's many A&R unfathomables. . . until she came bouncing into the studio and opened her mouth.

"Hi! What thtyle you want me to thing — thoul, gothpel-type thtuff or thomething elthe?"

Oh. Bugger. We soldiered on, but despite the engineer's best efforts her vocal still sounded like Whitney Houston doing a Freddie "Parrot Face" Davies impression. In a backing group she was the business, but tragically she just wasn't viable as a solo artist.

This set me thinking about whether any other speech idiosyncrasies or full-blown impediments have hindered or even helped any careers. (Kate Bush doesn't count, because although she has evident "r" twouble in interviews, it's not noticeable when she sings.)

In fact, I can only come up with one singer with, er, phonetic orthodoxy issues who ever made it: shlkhstand up and be counted, Mishlkhs Toyah Willcoxshlkhs, whose alveolar fricatives sounded like Parisian plumbing at 3 a.m.

But can you think of anyone elshlkhse?

Me And Miffiff, Miffiff Jones

How can you forget Billy Paul's classic soul tune? Cracks me up every time...

SimonL | 19 May 2008 - 9:47am

'Impediments' that add a distinctive quality

Damon Albarn and Kevin Rowland spring to mind.

badartdog | 19 May 2008 - 10:30am

Its a nors(h)e problem

As any listen to the Cardigans/Nina Persson, Aha or Ydragassil will demonstrate.
I have previously commented on many americans inability to say R, hence leaving it out altogether, Suzanna hoffs and Natalie Merchany being prime exemplars. They are always "deaming" rather than dreaming.

Retropath2 | 19 May 2008 - 11:04am

Pete(r) Murphy

of Bauhaus fame has trouble with his Rs (and cannot pronounce Oedipus - although not an impediment as such), which I've always thought added a certain good-humoured charm to their gloomy art.

Richieboy | 19 May 2008 - 11:09am

Thanks

sounded like Whitney Houston doing a Freddie "Parrot Face" Davies impression
the image of which is going to keep me chortling all day

Riccardo Gargiulo | 19 May 2008 - 11:13am

Scatman's World

Don't forget the late Scatman John, he built his scat-singing style around his stutter.


kidpresentable | 19 May 2008 - 11:17pm