Entertainment For Lively Minds
Plant, Krauss, Marcus, Believer - a revelation and a recommendation
So I never really got with the Plant/Krauss album. I liked it and all but it never grabbed me, you know, right there. Then I read the current issue of the very fabulous Believer magazine - http://www.believermag.com/ - and saw Greil Marcus discuss it as follows:
Robert Plant and Alison Krauss - the old rocker and the bluegrass queen: Very nice people. Very polite. To each other and the songs, and to you. But all the singing is whispering and it was the dullest album of the year.
Onstage, though, fevor comes out - especially for Led Zeppelin songs that go back through the woods. On YouTube videos from this year's New Orleans Jazz and Heritage Festival, the Druids in "Battle of Evermore" take to the skies: two final minutes of furious mandolin slashing and Plant's snaggletoothed hair bucking ("Bring it back! Bring it back!" My God, are you sure? Bring that dragon back?) as if the notes have him on a trip wire. For "When the Levee Breaks" with Plant quieting Krauss's keening fiddle to let lines from Bob Dylan's "Girl from the North Country" float through to be lost in the flood, the song sweeps up Memphis Minnie and Kansas Joe McCoy, who recorded it in 1929, and walks their ghosts across the stage.
I bring this up because: a) He's entirely right about how astonishing the live renditions are. Watching it now the hairs on my arms are standing up all over again. b) It made me realise how much I think the Believer mag hits the same spots as The Word, and thus I felt I should recommend it here.
- More from Joe Muggs.
- Login or register to post comments









Plant was ever thus...
...hence my 400 Led Zep bootlegs. I think he needs the spontaneity of the stage to bring him alive; on album he's always so-so by comparison
Apologies,
there should be two paragraphs in bold to indicate quotation there... in case it's not obvious the quote from Marcus ends "...across the stage."
Aha
For that you'll be wanting to use the "blockquote" HTML tag. Duly amended.
Clever clogs
Thanks for altering the Ritchie Blackmore photo as well.
Whatever they pay you...it's not enough!
I hate to say this...
..(and don't ask me how I know) but Les Mckeown from The Bay City Rollers recorded "Killing The Blues" first, and it's better than theirs.
(Shawn Colvin's is the best, however)
You are all wrong
It's Joe Brown's
Dullest?
Dullest alblum of the year is a tad harsh i think! I enjoyed the record when it came out (i first heard the single played on the Rounder Records podcast). I really enjoyed it. Laid back certainly but not dull. What the record did do however was get me interested enough to buy a ticket for what was the greatest gig of the year (bar none!) when I saw them at Wembley.
He may be right about the live perfomance
But he lost me when he said that "Raising Sand" was the dullest album of the year. Really? Dullest in all categories or just the category of albums made by "ageing rock legends and bluegrass stars."
I love "Raising Sand" but then I was never a huge Led Zep fan (although I don't dislike them) and so I wasn't hoping that Plant would recreate the good old days in the same way that this reviewer apparently did.