Entertainment For Lively Minds

Word RSS FeedsWord Magazine on YouTubeWord Magazine on Last FMWord Magazine on Share My PlaylistsWord Spotify PlaylistsWord Magazine on FacebookWord Magazine on Twitter

PC Gone Mad

David Wright's picture

Not wishing to do a Daily Mail rant, but PC in this country really has gone mad hasn't it?
I play in a Christmas concert with youngsters every year and we've now been informed we can't call it a Christmas Concert as it may offend those who don't celebrate Christmas in the area, so the concert will have a winter theme in the title to it instead.
I'm all for a mixed society etc, but this just seems a bit silly to me.

2

Well that's

Noddy Holder buggered then "It's wiiiiiiiiiiiiinterrrrrr!"

7
Dave Amitri | 13 November 2010 - 6:16pm

Funny

Doesn't quite have the same effect does it!?

0
David Wright | 13 November 2010 - 8:14pm

Particularly if followed by the words

Vomiting Virus

0
milkybarnick | 14 November 2010 - 12:50am

A mere 5%

of the population of this country regularly attended a Christian service of worship, yet we retain the right to be offended when we're "not allowed" to refer to our annual pagan pig-out as "Christ Mass".

I'm not a believer myself, but I think I know who SHOULD be most offended here...

2
Pax Romana | 13 November 2010 - 6:23pm

We don't refer to it as Christ Mass

We call our annual pagan pig out / religious festival / get together with the family and exchange gifts and a bit of midwinter cheer as Christmas. As far as I am concerned the meaning of the name has mutated with use. This Winterval business is bollocks of course. As Joe says, someone is being a tosser somewhere. My son's school did a little study of Diwali recently though most are not Hindu, and I expect they will do similar for Christmas in due course. Why not?

4
Twangothan | 13 November 2010 - 6:59pm

Harrumph.

The coin of the realm says, "Fid Def", the Monarch is the head of the Church of England, and there's some bearded bloke with a baffling grasp of reality called The Archbishop Of Canterbury. As long as no-one rams their religion down my throat, or obliges me to do, say, not do or not say anything they might claim to find offensive, and they don't blow me or mine up with explosives, they're all right by me carrying on with whatever rot and nonsense their priests tell them they should do.

But it's Christmas in England on December 25th, and they can bloody well get used to the idea.

14
Vulpes Vulpes | 13 November 2010 - 7:09pm

This is it.

I'm afraid that, at risk of being thrown out of public sector employ, I'm an integrationist rather than a multiculturalist. If I moved to Indonesia and got all humpty every time they celebrated Eid ul-Fitr... well, the idea's laughable. If you move somewhere, you try to fit in. You don't try to fit your hosts around you.

And that's the THING. No-one IS offended by Christmas. Anyone with half a mind who isn't Christian knows that the vast, vast majority of people in Britain celebrates Christmas and is just FINE with it. I'm a committed atheist, for God's sake*, and I'm fine with it. Why wouldn't I be?

To be frank, if anyone's got a problem with Christmas, they can fuck off. It's here, it has been for hundreds of years, it's part of the culture. Deal with it. Everyone does, barring the sort of fuckwits for whom it's impossible to legislate.

*See what I did?

23
Bob | 13 November 2010 - 7:23pm

In Dubai

There are carol singers and christmas trees in every shopping mall at christmas, no-one here is offended.

0
clivetemple | 13 November 2010 - 6:28pm

In the case the OP mentions

That does seem grossly unfair. I can't see why that would be done without good reason yet I'm struggling to think of one.

However, the phrase "PC Gone Mad" drives me up the wall. Political correctness is a good thing - it's about making sure people are treated equally and all voices get heard; I don't think anyone would disagree with that as a concept.

So, when something like this happens, it's not "PC gone mad" or "this country going to the dogs" or "Broken Britain", it's someone, somewhere, being a bit of a twat.

25
Joe R | 13 November 2010 - 6:44pm

Exactly.

This is a case of someone fundamentally failing to understand the point of political correctness (or, as I like to call it, good manners and consideration). The person responsible for this isn't PC so much as thick.

1
Bob | 13 November 2010 - 7:00pm

Yes, but...

Political correctness is fine as an idea. But, like so many things, taken to a extreme it becomes utterly ridiculous.

1
Lucas Hare | 14 November 2010 - 12:42am

Political correctness & Health & safety

Who would have thought they would have so much in common?

The fact that Christmas is under attack at all is very sad indeed.

It would seem that most of the faiths don't really want to get on with each other from the the top down. Why haven't they all got together and celebrate a day/time together once a year and share some much needed PR?

The answer seems to be that they don't want to. They would much rather carry on the wars that have been going on forever.

Amen.

1
Lunaman | 14 November 2010 - 10:23am

christmas

isn't under attack

5
Chris G | 14 November 2010 - 11:55am

It is from where I'm standing.

The Christmas festivites are under attack from those who think that we have to change the traditional celebrations at christmas.

0
Lunaman | 14 November 2010 - 12:18pm

But...

...every time I ask anyone about this (except Ian on this thread who has a definitive example) the answer is vague.

Who is changing Christmas? "they are". Who are they?

Every example is vague, a friend of a friend, someone told me, a town not actually lived in by the person, etc.

Perhaps Christmas is changing slightly, but then it wasn't the same for my parents as it was for me. That is just life. Things change.

4
JoLean | 14 November 2010 - 12:25pm

Pooles Park school - Islington

Has not been able to do a nativity play for years. This year there is no Santa groto but you can have a snowman theme. Is that Ok now?

1
Lunaman | 14 November 2010 - 12:31pm

What about my comment on religions not wanting to get together?

Any thoughts on that?

0
Lunaman | 14 November 2010 - 12:33pm

They're all defending man-made bollocks, that's why.

Person the first: "Hi guys, at this time of year we celebrate the festival of 'Diddlysquat', when our saviour was born to save the world."

Person the second: "Wow! Well we celebrate at the same time of year too, but we have 'Oojamaflip', which is the anniversary of when our prophet first had a celestial vision."

Person the nth: "We celebrate (insert name of ridiculous tradition) at this time of year because (insert irrational reason for celebrating at this time of year)."

Persons 1 to n, simultaneously: "You people are all wrong, let's fight!"

Voice of reason: "FFS, it's astronomy: enjoy the Winter solstice."

2
Vulpes Vulpes | 14 November 2010 - 5:05pm

Nice

one :)

0
Lunaman | 14 November 2010 - 6:24pm

"Broken Britain"

Makes my teeth curl and puts my toes on edge, it's that irritating a phrase. Pessimism writ large in an alliteration.

0
milkybarnick | 14 November 2010 - 12:52am

Usually coined

By dem what broke it innit?

0
clivetemple | 14 November 2010 - 5:19am

Do you mean

"ConDem wot broke it"?

0
Black Type | 15 November 2010 - 1:29am

What I object to

is the use of "It's just political correctness gone mad" as a lazy argument. Politicians use it in interviews and having said it, seem to think that it's the end of the argument. Game, set and match. They never seem to get challenged by being asked to define what it is exactly that they are objecting to.

Sometimes they might be right. Frequently it's a cover for objecting to a change they don't like.

I agree with Joe. It was originally about mutual respect and among other things not using inappropriate language, like the n and s words. Which of course some people objected to, because it had always been a part of our language. It's just political correctness gone mad, I tell you!

2
Carl Parker | 14 November 2010 - 1:41pm

what you haven't told us

...is which area of the country. Just so the massive can descend on it en masse and point at and otherwise redicule the morons who come out with this rubbish.

It's not often I agree with the Daily Mail (happens more as I get older, worryingly) but on this they're spot on.

1
stuinwolves | 13 November 2010 - 6:50pm

It's interesting to hear

from someone who actually has first-hand experience of this sort of nonsense. I'm always a bit dubious when I read about it in the papers.

The ridiculous thing is, of course, that the vast, vast, majority of followers of religions other than Christianity would not be remotely offended by the title "Christmas Concert".

0
Johan | 13 November 2010 - 7:07pm

If someone really is offended

by the word "Christmas", then just rejoice in the fact that the next seven weeks are going to be truly miserable for them!

3
renkadima | 13 November 2010 - 7:14pm

No chance of it being a misunderstanding?

Can we have some more specific details - the building the concert will be held in, the area it's in, and who has asked for the name change, and their authority for doing this? There may be some crossed wires somewhere. If it's a council decision, you could to talk to your councillor about it.

I live in an area often caricatured as the home of PC - the London Borough of Camden - and Christmas concerts are being advertised here and it's mixed as anywhere.

4
Melville | 13 November 2010 - 7:23pm

must admit it all seemed

vague. Who had decided? And who was going to be offended? I 've of many supposed changed xmas names but no examples and definetly no one who's offended by someone's elses carol concert.

1
Chris G | 14 November 2010 - 8:37am

Interesting

I always thought such stories were fabricated, or deliberately mis-interpreted, by the Daily Express.

Of course, no non-Christian would be 'offended' by a Christmas concert. The decision will be down to some right-on, white, english individual grasping the wrong end of the PC stick.

1
Spartacus Mills | 13 November 2010 - 7:37pm

Birmingham

It was Birmingham council, years ago

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/210672.stm

Though it seems it has not resurfaced

http://tabloid-watch.blogspot.com/2010/09/winterval-stories-begin.html

Though I'd be interested to know where the OP came across it.

I liked the John Humphries joke that Santa has been banned from saying "Yo ho ho" as it is offensive to women. Arf.

0
Twangothan | 13 November 2010 - 8:07pm

these stories like the 'winterval' one

usually turn out to be utter balls when anyone bothers to check em. And mr wright just tell the person who told you that they are clearly talking out of their hat and find another venue to do your gig. In these financial times there will be plenty less picky

Mr Stewart Lee

6
DogFacedBoy | 14 November 2010 - 1:44am

Use the Grace Murray Hopper technnique

(see her bio for background on one of the coolest women ever - if you're a geek)

One of he most famous maxims is this:

If you have a good idea, go and do it. It's always easier to apologise afterwards than it is to ask for permission.

So tell' em you're doing your "winterval" thing and then just do a Christmas concert. If they complain. Say sorry.

0
illuminatus | 14 November 2010 - 9:12pm

I like the quote, but...

I have heard it used to charmlessly justify some ill-thought-out nonsense that caused trouble and cost thousands to put right again.

0
Austin | 15 November 2010 - 1:36am

Yeah

It only works for good ideas :)

0
illuminatus | 15 November 2010 - 8:26pm

You should read his new book

"How I Escaped My Certain fate" - excellent stuff.

1
Douglas | 14 November 2010 - 9:41pm

You've been informed - by who?

Just tell them to sod off.

0
Paul Waring | 13 November 2010 - 8:56pm

If I Could

In an ideal world I would, but I'd probably get fired!

0
David Wright | 14 November 2010 - 2:17am

Potential embarrassment

Several years ago, I used to buy petrol regularly at a filling station run by Sikhs. One January, they asked if I'd had a good Christmas. Being ignorant of their customs, I was unsure how to ask a similar question in return, but I hit on 'Do you have any festivals at this time of year?'

'Yeah, we do Christmas, we celebrate everything, Diwali, Eid...' was the response.

Is anyone really offended? I've had Christmas dinners with Jews, Hindus and Muslims - they seem to be interested in the different traditions rather than upset by them.

0
PeteWingrave | 13 November 2010 - 9:02pm

Everyone loves a chance to celebrate

and given half a chance, I'll celebrate Diwali, Eid and Rosh Hashannah. It's interesting, fun and a chance to spread the love.

About 20 years ago, I was in Bangladesh at Eid. I knew nothing about it but was invited to join in the party. My hosts didn't hold it against me because I was from a (nominally) Christian country, they wanted me to join them in a happy time.

I strongly suspect the same is true in reverse.

2
stimpy | 13 November 2010 - 9:27pm

As usual...

Frank Costanza has the answer

4
Slotbadger | 13 November 2010 - 9:01pm

Just call it Christmas

Tell them you're offended if they don't.

3
Leedsboy | 14 November 2010 - 7:34am

Oh, it's true alright

we live in Stoke Newington in Hackney. Both our children have been through primary school here, and for the last 10 years we have been to 'winter festivals'. Not once has Christmas been mentioned in these entertainment extravaganzas.
I have no doubt this has nothing to do with the non-Christian parents attached to the school, and everything to do with the white, middle class, muddle-headed headteacher and his equally limp staff.
The children learn about Sikh, Hindu, Islamic and Jewish festivals, which is wonderful because it gives them all an understanding of the communities that live in our corner of the capital.
The one religion they don't learn about is Christianity, which is clearly bonkers. And I speak as an atheist with a Hindu father and Catholic education.
Bt be clear - this is not religious minorities who are demanding this madness, it is white liberal school management terrified of offending people who don't have the least intention of taking offence.

6
IanP | 13 November 2010 - 9:36pm

That's genuinely odd...

...I live not far from Stoke Newington, and I have been to a nativity every year for the last 15. I'm am also booked to go to a carol service at a primary school in, erm, Stokey.

0
JoLean | 13 November 2010 - 9:40pm

I should be clear

that I am talking about one particular primary school in N16.
I have no idea about borough-wide policy, I wanted to make the point that I have not heard or read the word 'nativity' at my children's school in 10 years.

1
IanP | 13 November 2010 - 10:01pm

Keep calm and carry on

- but ffs keep calm. No-one is bothered, do what you like and wait for the law suit. It won't arrive.

And stop reading the Daily Mail.

1
happy harry | 13 November 2010 - 11:41pm

Just call it Christmas

And let the debate start after that. It is misguided, afraid to offend, White liberals with no understanding of other communities. These stories have rather gathered a foothold in the popular imagination and need to be challenged.
Let it be stated that The Express won this year's race to the coveted 'Christmas cancelled' crown with a story in October.

0
PaddyH | 13 November 2010 - 11:49pm

If it wasn't a KET day

I'd give you all up arrow

0
Mousey | 13 November 2010 - 11:52pm

My PC has gone mad

Won't connect to t'internet but MacBook, iPhone, Sonos will. Any ideas?

1
GunsOfBrixton | 14 November 2010 - 2:09am

you can't call it that

It's a multimedia entertainment unit.

1
Los Aromas | 14 November 2010 - 6:12am

but how traditional is

Christmas? The idea that xmas is fixed is odd . Particularly in families a 'tradition' can be something you've done twice! I have friends for whom ice skating on artificial rinks is traditional but these rinks have only been around for last 8-9 years. Even long held traditions change the xmas pudding we eat is different from the victorian version. Not saying we should change the name I like having an annual celebration of Chris just that Chrismas changes every year.

1
Chris G | 14 November 2010 - 8:54am

Winter lights

It seems there are those who worry about offending others who they don't actually check with to see if they will be offended, and it turns out they aren't actually bothered - a peculiarly English worry among the right on brigade who give the good intentions of political correctness a bad name and shoot themselves in the foot. Here's a story about christmas lights in Oxford to show it does happen, though the level of outrage may exaggerate the extent of the issue:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/3367390/Christmas-banned-in-Oxfor...

0
Sven Garlic | 14 November 2010 - 1:59pm

That's undeniably what a newspaper said

Oxford Council's website said in 2008:

""Oxford City Council has not 'banned Christmas' and has not banned the use of the word 'Christmas'. The Council's website said:

"Oxford City Council will celebrate Christmas 2008 in the same way as it has celebrated all previous Christmases: we will have Christmas trees in the Town Hall and in Broad Street, the Lord Mayor will host a Christmas reception for community workers and will hold the annual Christmas Carols event, and we will be sending out Christmas cards."

I have taken this from a website called fivechinesecrackers.com, which specialises in debunking some of the dafter press stories. It's interesting that this one started in The Observer -the classic "liberal" paper. So it's not just the right-wing press which get outraged about things they haven't researched properly.

I don't doubt that there are some people in authority making silly decisions - but I also don't doubt that there are some sloppy journalists misleading us.

You can get the full story here:

http://www.fivechinesecrackers.com/2008/11/they-banned-christmas-it-pc-g...

1
Melville | 14 November 2010 - 3:37pm

It's a fair cop I guess

It seems an organisation called Oxford Inspires organises certain celebratory festivities on behalf of the council and they refer to the lights and associated wintry luminous goings on as 'Winter Light' rather than Christmas lights, which is of course not the same as a conspiracy against Christmas. But it can be interpreted as a rather overly sensitive way to avoid the traditional term for unwarranted fear of offence, and represents a distancing from other Christmas celebrations. So I think my point still stands. I did acknowledge the exaggeration of the issue. It's true that it's not much of a story really.

0
Sven Garlic | 14 November 2010 - 5:42pm

I agree, it is the exaggeration which is annoying

Even when these things happen, and there does seem to have been a bit of a muddle here initially, they can be built up, with people who don't know the full story being asked for outraged quotes by papers.

It's a bit like (and this may be a bad comparison) the kerfuffle around the comments that Stephen Fry made about women and sex the other week in his interview with Attitude magazine. He did make them, but the Observer wanted to build up a story about it, which then went around other papers for a couple of days before the various columnists lost interest and moved onto something else.

Anyway, I only knew of this one in Oxford because I remembered reading about it on the fivechinesecrackers site, which can be quite entertaining when it takes apart these stories.

0
Melville | 14 November 2010 - 5:56pm

Winterval Myth

"Perhaps the most notorious of the anti-Christmas rebrandings is Winterval, in Birmingham, and when you telephone the Birmingham city council press office to ask about it, you are met first of all with a silence that might seasonably be described as frosty. "We get this every year," a press officer sighs, eventually. "It just depends how many rogue journalists you get in any given year. We tell them it's bollocks, but it doesn't seem to make much difference."

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2006/dec/08/religion.communities
(and that was 2006)

Still it goes on: see
http://tabloid-watch.blogspot.com/2010/09/winterval-stories-begin.html

If anything i'd suggest the UK uses and promotes the word Christmas for a longer period/with more intensity than ever before. See supermarkets, advertising, shop fronts and so on.

1
ChaileyJem | 15 November 2010 - 11:15am

oops

just noticed someone had shared the tabloidwatch link earlier up in the thread. apols

0
ChaileyJem | 15 November 2010 - 11:17am

Only once...

...a few years ago I received a leaflet from Lambeth council which mentioned "winter festival" numerous times but Christmas not once. It was incredibly badly written and conceived and seemed to be almost as though it was printed just to put peoples' backs up.

0
Richie B | 14 November 2010 - 3:37pm

The problem...

...is never with non-Christians themselves. As has been said already, it's with woolly, right-on, white, middle-class people who have somehow managed to get so confused about life that they think anything that's representative of the mainstream of British culture is reprehensible and shameful.

I doubt there are many of these people, but I have worked with one or two in my time. It's not their fault: they've mostly been a bit on the dim side, but educated enough to get promoted, and I think a lot of their promotions happened in the first flush of PC becoming mainstream - the nineties and early 2000s.

They're still hanging on in places, and haven't realised that they're obsolete.

3
Bob | 14 November 2010 - 4:02pm

Whether it is Christmas

or something else unrelated, PC is censorship bollocks and the only thing that surprises me is that we have all allowed it to seep into our society. It's too late to do anything about it now, the fuckers have got us by the bollocks and will squeeze whenever they feel like it.

1
Steve Turner | 14 November 2010 - 5:54pm

You can't say bollocks

It's reproductive orbs.

1
Spartacus Mills | 14 November 2010 - 9:01pm

Shame on you!

All of you.

I tee up this golden TMFTL opportunity and nobody fires it home. Tsk!

0
Spartacus Mills | 15 November 2010 - 11:22am

Golden TMFTL

TMFTL

1
DogFacedBoy | 15 November 2010 - 11:38am

Tsk!

TMFTL

0
Leedsboy | 15 November 2010 - 10:50pm

I thought it was

spherical essence containers

0
DogFacedBoy | 15 November 2010 - 2:44am

Spherical essence containers

And-uh their drivers....

1
Spartacus Mills | 15 November 2010 - 12:06pm

This seems to be a much

bigger issue than the re-naming of Christmas festivals or a matter of competing faiths and who believes what. The bottom line is that this country is based on Christian principles of the enlightenment and Christmas, Easter are part of our traditions. Whether people go to church to celebrate is an irrevalence. By celebrating Christmas, we are not excluding anyone of non-Christian faith nor are we ramming the message of Christmas down anybody's throat. Yes, of course, we should have a mixed society where everyone and their faiths have equal rights and I think we come pretty close to that (it's not perfect but it's a work in progress because things change), but what I find hard to tolerate is the great and the good being embarassed about what should be good in this country and for which many people better than I fought hard for, and letting this all go hang just for some dreamy version of multicultural nirvana where minorities are allowed to live in a bubble and can adopt a take your pick attitude about what they can accept. I am not talking about superficial issues here, am not suggesting that everyone should eat fish and chips but am talking about fundamental rights on which this country is based upon (i.e: freedom of speech, worship and the right to be offended). In other words, a fully integrated society. We ought to be proud of the fact that this country is based on immigration and their integration and absorption into the values of the country whilst also making positive contributions themselves. It doesn't do this country any good in the long term to allow pools of discontented people who have no identification with the values of this country and the fact that I am talking about 2nd generation immigrants should be a worry for us all. A little more clarity and thought about what this country represents and less shouting from the rooftops and pandering to newspaper headlines might help but I'm not holding my breath. Just one more thing; I have always been taken how American immigrants tend to refer themselves as American-Italians etc don't see that happening here.
Sorry, bit of a rant and probably not the place for it but it's an issue that gets me every time being the 2nd generation son of Irish/Italian parentage.

4
Francis Barry-Walsh | 16 November 2010 - 12:34pm

Personally,

I'm the 102nd generation son of Dumnonii/Durotriges parentage, and I too fail to see why people can't just fit in and rub along.

0
Vulpes Vulpes | 17 November 2010 - 12:17pm

Nothing like a prick

to a pompous rant, but yes, no reason why we shouldn't all rub along nicely. Would be nice, wouldn't it.

0
Francis Barry-Walsh | 17 November 2010 - 12:53pm

2nd generation

I can't stand Christmas. Nothing to do with being offended, I'm just a miserable sod (:-)

4
man.of.soup | 16 November 2010 - 1:39pm

Christmas

I offer to work shifts at Christmas to let my colleagues with young families be with them.

Meanwhile, I sit in the control room of a stand by power station, drinking tea & eating mince pies while listening to the radio.

Easy life.

I wish it could be Christmas every day.

0
jackthebiscuit | 20 November 2010 - 3:46pm

Will think of you

as I'm avoiding the Eastenderscasuality marathon by putting on the kettle and microwaving a cold roastie on the sly in the kitchen.

0
Chris G | 20 November 2010 - 3:50pm
Lucas Hare | 20 November 2010 - 8:37pm
Privacy Statement    ©  2006 - 2012 Development Hell Ltd