Entertainment For Lively Minds
Our poet laureate's Happy Christmas Poem

Posted by A passing drifter on 7 December 2009 - 4:26pm.
Words fail me - I wish they had failed Duffy... here's a sample...
I bought a magic goose from a maiden (comely).
This goose laid Joanna Lumley.
I bought a magic goose from a busker (poor).
This goose laid Anish Kapoor.
I bought a magic goose from a bargain bin, it
was the goose laid Alan Bennett.
------
the politicos in Copenhagen?
Did they twiddle their thumbs?
Or hear the drums
and hear the drums
and hear the drums?
- More from .
- Login or register to post comments









It's hardly John Betjeman is it?
!
It's not even John Hegley!
and of course JB never had a off day
She did a piece on the culture show using the names and mythology of pub names which along with the film that went with it was a very good and quite evocative.
Is the Poet Laureate a paid position?
Is it salaried? It's just that I think there are performance issues judging by the above. Comely and Lumley? Bin it and Bennett? Rhyme but no reason I'd say.
Yes
Paid about £6k a year plus a butt of Sherry*
*Note: this is not some sort of fortified wine enema - at least I don't *think* it is!
isn't it a butt of sack
?
rather that
than the butt of Cherie that other public figures had to put up with.
Erm actually forget that horrible mental image i just had
Duffy is the new laureate?!
Mercy!
No one's expecting 'V' by Tony Harrison
but a little more elbow grease wouldn't go amiss.
Primary school
It reminds me of my favourite line of poetry ever, written by an 11 year old classmate in 1985. It was about Father Christmas getting the presents on the sleigh:
Santa said, "Oh dear, we haven't got enough;
We'll have to miss out Brian Clough".
Take that, Duffers.
That is...
brilliant.
That is...
much better than Duffy.
Not quite the same standard as "Last Post"
The only other Duffy poem I've read since she became Laureate was "Last Post", which I thought was really rather good:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/jul/31/carol-ann-duffy-last-post
... but I must admit the Christams one isn't ... erm, quite up to the same standard.
Cor
Dylan and Carol Ann - who'd have thought it? Right pair of yuletide pranksters
the full text is a bit more interesting ...
see:
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/top-stories/2009/12/07/the-12-days-of-chris...
You are quite right
The full text is more interesting - I should have looked it up myself.
Interesting
Certainly, if that's a polite way of saying you feel embarrassed for the author.
I've looked at the full text.
I still prefer My Friend Billy.
I know the author of that
Carol Ann Duffy
Worst poet in the world?
I think so.
Had to study her for GCSE. But as a class we refused. Because instead of supposed reasoned criticism, we would have just ripped her poor choice of words and clunky sentiment.
For example, "Valentine":
http://famouspoetsandpoems.com/poets/carol_ann_duffy/poems/8116
"I give you an onion" ??
Is that the best she could come up with?
And having just read that "Last Post" poem, I'm sorry duco01, but that is possibly one of the weakest poems about the war. Compare it to Wilfred Owen, Siegfried Sassoon, Rupert Brooke or some of Edward Thomas' writings. There's just no comparison is there?
I think Valentine...
...is one of her better efforts. It's at least a pretty solid metaphor, if nothing else.
She's had moments of greatness - "Anne Hathaway", for example, is a genuinely beautiful poem - but in general I'm not a fan. For the most part, I don't understand why she writes poems. Much of her output is just prose with line breaks and rhymes: no startling language, no arresting imagery, nothing that makes you stop and wonder that anyone could put an idea so perfectly.
Like Coleridge said, prose is just words put in order. Poetry is the best words, in the best order.
And that Christmas poem's fucking horrible.
One suspects the goose passage is a respectful nod to
One supects the goose passage is a respectful nod to the magnificent William McGonagall and his playful, yet masterful, repetition of the “town/frown/crown” riff and, of course, the dazzling “goose/loose/abuse“ flourish.
The Christmas Goose (William McGonagall)
Mr. SMIGGS was a gentleman,
And he lived in London town;
His wife she was a good kind soul,
And seldom known to frown.
'Twas on Christmas eve,
And Smiggs and his wife lay cosy in bed,
When the thought of buying a goose
Came into his head.
So the next morning,
Just as the sun rose,
He jump'd out of bed,
And he donn'd his clothes,
Saying, "Peggy, my dear.
You need not frown,
For I'll buy you the best goose
In all London town."
So away to the poultry shop he goes,
And bought the goose, as he did propose,
And for it he paid one crown,
The finest, he thought, in London town.
When Smiggs bought the goose
He suspected no harm,
But a naughty boy stole it
From under his arm.
Then Smiggs he cried, "Stop, thief!
Come back with my goose!"
But the naughty boy laugh'd at him,
And gave him much abuse.
But a policeman captur'd the naughty boy,
And gave the goose to Smiggs,
And said he was greatly bother'd
By a set of juvenile prigs.
So the naughty boy was put in prison
For stealing the goose.,
And got ten days' confinement
Before he got loose.
So Smiggs ran home to his dear Peggy,
Saying, "Hurry, and get this fat goose ready,
That I have bought for one crown;
So, my darling, you need not frown."
"Dear Mr Smiggs, I will not frown:
I'm sure 'tis cheap for one crown,
Especially at Christmas time --
Oh! Mr Smiggs, it's really fine."
"Peggy. it is Christmas time,
So let us drive dull care away,
For we have got a Christmas goose,
So cook it well, I pray.
"No matter how the poor are clothed,
Or if they starve at home,
We'll drink our wine, and eat our goose,
Aye, and pick it to the bone."
Spike Milligan loved McGonagall
and wrote any number of pastiches.
Also two virtually plotless comic novels, 'William McGonagall: The Truth at Last' and 'William McGonagall Meets George Gershiwin'
Both filled with ridiculous verses but none of which top the man himself, I have to say, on this chilly day, In December, Which is not May, In any way.
Is there any chance..
That McGonagall was taking the piss, or was he really that bad?
I've seen his grave in Greyfriars Kirkyard, which is a fascinating place to look round.
I've seen both points of view argued
see http://www.mcgonagall-online.org.uk/
In fact, must check to see why I'm not getting the gem of the day ...
the joys of free verse
the joys of all current ' Modern Art '.
I know nothing about poetry
But even I can see that's utter toss. And so joyless. Where's the Christmas spirit? It's sits most awkwardly in the Radio Times.