Entertainment For Lively Minds
One Play Guilt
Posted by David Wright on 18 April 2011 - 10:45am.
I wondered if any other members of the massive ever suffer from “one listen only guilt” to albums. The last time it happened was when Prince gave away another album free with a newspaper. I listened to half of it, then gave up and filed it away. Like a Talking Heads live album I bought a few years ago, I doubt it will ever be played again. Both still haunt me… I should really give them another chance, but there’s just too much other stuff that needs listening too and not enough hours in the day.
- More from David Wright.
- Login or register to post comments










One Play Guilt
I have loads. A few No Play Guilt contenders too. It shouldn't bother me, but it feels wasteful. I feel I should send my family on a week's holiday and immerse myself in neglected purchases.
If it makes you feel better
I have both of the recent-ish Prince CDs given away with newspapers (both picked from charity shops) and haven't listened to a note of either, and I quite like Prince.
Cheers
I think quite a few charity shops will have copies of Prince's last free albums in stock by now! The last Prince album I bought was Diamonds And Pearls, good album.
Florence
and her machine-thingy
Really tried to like it, but was crying with boredom by the end.
Perhaps I never forgave her for that terrible cover of 'Fairytale of New York' that she did with Herr Bragg a couple of Xmases ago.
Lungs sits in the car and looks at me reproachfully, but I stand firm (well actually I sit down, as it's quite hard to stand up in a car)
No guilt
Just chuck 'em on eBay. Fleet Foxes, Bon Iver, Jason Downs, various American and country rock monstrosities have all made me some cash over the year.
It's supposed to be fun
Don't turn it into a duty.
I wouldn't mind betting that a lot of "played just once" records are those that you've bought:
a) as soon as they came out
b) because you've got their earlier stuff
Just because an artist wants to keep on making records, it doesn't mean that you have to keep dutifully buying them.
Slap Guilt
This is kind of true and Level 42 applies to b). I bought and only listened to their last album once out of loyalty to an old slapper. The last Crowded House album has only had about four plays in total I’m afraid!
Guilty as charged
Loyalty to an artist when all they're doing is fulfilling a contractual obligation has been very consuming of my hard-earned in the past but these days I 'test the water' first with mp3 download previews or We7.
Impulse buys can be far more rewarding but as pointed out elsewhere are best made sober.
Fopp's £3 range
is great for this. I went in on Friday, bought four albums I'd always meant to buy, got home, played them once, realised why I never bought them originally and duly shelved them. Actually I should stick them on Ebay - there's every chance I'd end up with a modest profit.
Just wondering
What did you buy?
Gentlemen Take Polaroids
Oil on Canvas / Brilliant Trees and Secrets of the Beehive. Then I stopped at Boots for a binge on the new No7 range. It wasn't a good look at 16, never mind 43.
Why not return them?
FOPP are quite good about this on their suck it and see policy. Especially good for Mr Forgetful here who buys things only to get home and realise I've already got them. Most recently English Settlement by XTC.
This raises another issue altogether. When did I last play it if I didn't remember owning it? And why do I feel that it's an essential purchase when met by a bargain copy in the shop but don't feel it's essential that I listen to the thing? (Some allowance to be made for the XTC CDs living in a harder to reach part of the collection than the XTC box set which I play relatively often).
Far too many to list...but it's all part of the fun of music
really. What is perhaps a more interesting question is why do we then keep them around for years, and not bin them pronto?
Because taste changes.
In a few years, the records you loved will be in the "What on earth did I see in them?" pile and the ones you've only played once will be in the "Why didn't I play that one again? And again and again and..." pile.
You then file them all away and lo! in a few more years, they've swapped piles again.
I just put it down to that sort of male semi OCD thing...
were you just can't bear to part with stuff once you've got a "collection" of something, anything,going.
Even if you don't actually like it.
Possibly but it's also because
at my advanced age I know I can dip in and out of my collection and still suprise myself (good and bad) when going over some old records. Which is what music should be: not so much OCD but plenty of OMG.
If the Talking Heads live album
is The Name of This Band is Talking Heads dig it out again sharpish. It's bloody great, contains pretty much all the Talking Heads you'll ever need, in versions often superior to the originals. My most listened to Heads album by a considerable distance.
Will do
I'll dig it out tonight and give it another go as it is the only Talking Heads album I own!
Goodo
How was it then?
Talking Albums
Really good actually, glad I've played it again. Where would you go next for Talking heads?
Talking Heads
Fear Of Music and Remain In Light.
Stonewall classics.
Yep, those two
then Speaking in Tongues and Stop Making Sense if you want more.
Don't forget
77 and More Songs About Buildings and Food. But you've actually got a good 80% of those first four albums on the expanded The Name... Often in better versions.
Last three albums Little Creatures, True Stories and Naked are pretty ignorable apart from a couple of tracks on each (but make sure you get Nothing but Flowers, one of the greatest songs of the decade)
I beg your pardon!
Little Creatures is an absolutely splendid chapter within the Talking Heads canon. Far from there being only a couple of decent tracks I'd vouch for everything, except maybe Walk It Down.
Listen Again...
I've had a few of these and I tend to find putting them away for 5 years and then having another crack at them yields great results - Hounds of Love by Kate Bush being one example (look, I don't know why I didn't like it first time round either!).
United States Live
It's a four-CD set of an eight-hour performance piece by Laurie Anderson, and I bought it because I love Big Science, which is made up of excerpts from it. The thinking being: love Big Science; will REALLY love United States Live.
I put it on and swiftly realised it was going to be a 'difficult' album, so I put it to one side to come back to another day, when I had the proper time to devote to it.
That was about 15 years ago.
How about 'no play' guilt
I've got a free INXS cassette single that came with a pair of converse and a free Foo Fighters CD single (prob from the Guardian) which remain in the shrink wrap.
plus I've got a bunch of 10" and 12"s picked up at a Virgin surplus stock sale for 29p/50p a throw years ago and never listened to - Rancho Diablo, Come, Tiny Monroe and Bandit Queen anyone? ( the same batch included Slint's s/t 10", should've bought up all the copies of that...)
Ooh, I liked Tiny Monroe and Bandit Queen...
What titles are they?
Blimey - have dug out quite a few of these
The Tiny Monroe is the Cream EP; the Bandit Queen one the Miss Dandys 12".
Bought in a pre-internet listening "have heard something about these must give 'em a listen" spree, along with (apart from the Slint one) 12"s by the following , which have probably had a single listen - Boo Radleys, High Llamas, Buffalo Tom, Bark Psychosis and My Life Story, and aan unlistened to 10" by Shiva Affect (?). Total outlay (including COme and Rancho Diabolo) -a fiver.
Ah, I've got both of those (on CD, too)...
...otherwise I would have offered them a good home ;-)
Jealousy on the Cream EP is a proper good tune, if you'd care to give it another listen.
They will get a spin now I've found them
eventually...
Ray Davies
I was given the collaborative album See My Friends for Xmas. I listened to it as I cooked Xmas dinner, but haven't bothered since.
I was tempted to buy it, but
I was tempted to buy it, but heard that musically it is a bit of a turkey.
Really?
I've heard it's a cracker. Knocks the stuffing out of his earlier stuff.
The version of Waterloo Sunset
with Jackson Browne is sublime.
Ray
Maybe I shouldn't chicken out of buying it then! I heard the Mumford & Son's track, which was very good. I don't think it's been a big seller though and hasn't flown off the shelfs!
A quick scan of the shelves reveals:
Rory Gallagher - Big Guns
Air - Moon Safari
Be Bop Deluxe - Postcards From The Future
Velvet Revolver - Liberated
Rocket From The Crypt - Scream Dracula Scream
Shane MacGowan & The Popes - The Snake
To alleviate the guilt, I have removed these from the shelves and piled them next to the stereo for aural consumption in the next copule of days
Moon Safari
That is a great album. Play it with the lights off for added effect!
Can I ask what "Postcards from the Future" is?
Is it a compilation? I was a big fan of Mr Nelson as a teenager but can't remember that.
It is a Compilation
subtitled: Introducing Be-Bop Deluxe
Purchased because I'd only heard 'Ships In The Night' and wanted to hear more - but is I now realise I've only heard once
The 'proper' Be-Bop Deluxe CDs have letters along the edge
such that, when they're shelved in the correct order, they spell 'BE-BOP DELUXE'.
Air On A Shane String
The Air and Shane MacGowan albums are two from your list that I own and you will certainly enjoy them, when you get round to listening to them!
seconded...
I'm 100% behind David on this; I've only got the two albums that he mentions, out of the ones on your list, and they're both belters. They really are. Go on. Dig out Moon Safari now and just fall for the lushness of Ce Matin La
The Snake
was played tonight - enjoyed it. Why did I only listen to it once?
Must listen again sometime.
Would've made a better Pogues album than 'Waiting For Herb'
Moon Safari tomorrow (possibly with the lights off)
Guilty as charged
PJ Harvey is one of my all-time goddesses of rock "who can do no wrong". So I cringe at my inability to have played "White Chalk" more than once (I even had to check the album title just then). It was just sooooo depressing and awful it never got played again. But still keeps a place on the shelf. Because, because, because, OK?
Really?
White Chalk's the only one since Down by the Water that honestly gets regularish spins (apart from the LPs with John Parish). Great record.
I gave the last PJ Harvey/John Parish album
to a friend. Couldn't stand it. Despite initial excitement, I find myself flicking past 'Let England Shake' when it comes up on my iPod.
I sometimes wonder if I buy her albums because I'm supposed to like them, rather than because I do!
Bang on..
..with that one. Ace single, utter dirge beyond that. 'Stories from the City..' was definitely Polly's high water mark, *ducks below parapet*.
Oh yes, a recent trip
to London saw me return with - The Knife 'Tomorrow,in a Year', Andrew Bird 'Fitz and the Dizzy Spells', Current93 'Honeysuckle Aeons' Sunn O)) 'Monoliths..' and Aethenor 'en form..'
Of the above, only 1 has been played more than once, 2 have yet to see the light of day, and I have had them for nearly 2 weeks now.
Have also got a number of fopp 3 quid specials that have not even made it out of the sellophane yet! But i'm not stressing about it, I know eventually there will be a time when I want to listen to one of these discs
Three from a fairly extensive list...
Midlake 'The Courage of Others'- a yawnathon
The Gaslight Anthem 'The '59 Sound'- repetitive Springsteen bumlickers
Iron & Wine 'The Shepherd's Dog'- v. disappointing as 'The Creek Drank the Cradle' is totally lovely.
It won't stop me buying new stuff though!
Persevere with the Midlake one....
It all sounds a bit samey and dense at first, but after a few plays I absolutely fell in love with it. Even re-bought it on vinyl when the price went down to a tenner. Gorgeous album, helps when you're more familiar with the songs.
I have a few
Joanna Newsom Y's I frankly couldn't play all the way through - not sure have even listened to it once in its entirety. Bloody awful.
On a visit to FOPP London I bought an album by an Aussie band who I think were called the Drones - just looked for the cd to check but can't find it. Anyway sounded great in the shop, awful when I got it home.
Also only played a Los Lonely boys cd once but must have been in a bad mood - I will look that one out because I suspect a second listen would be more favourable. Or not.
Have One On Me
A triple album and I can honestly say perhaps only three tracks that I like. Pretty bad ratio?
The Black Swan
By The Triffids. When I go to the attic for the Diesel Park West album I might drag it down too. It must be 20 years since it had a spin.
'One Mechanic Town'
it's worth it for this tremendous blast of a song alone. Not ever been that struck by the rest of it though.