Entertainment For Lively Minds
OED Online Word of the Day - Sturgeon's Law
Sturgeon's Law, n.
Pronunciation: Brit. /ˌstəːdʒ(ə)nz ˈlɔː/, U.S. /ˈˌstərdʒənz ˈlɔ/
Forms: 19– Sturgeon's Law, 19– Sturgeon's law.
Etymology: < the genitive of the name of Theodore H. Sturgeon (1918–85, born Edward Hamilton Waldo), U.S. science fiction writer + law n.1
Compare the following earlier use of the term, referring to a different aphorism:
1957 T. Sturgeon in Venture Sci. Fiction Mag. July 78 One who has reduced the cosmos to Sturgeon's Law: Nothing Is Always Absolutely So.
A humorous aphorism which maintains that most of any body of published material, knowledge, etc., or (more generally) of everything is worthless: based on a statement by Sturgeon (see quot. 1957), usually later cited as ‘90 per cent of everything is crap’.
Typically used of a specific medium, genre, etc., originally and esp. science fiction, and now freq. also of information to be found on the Internet.
The aphorism was apparently first formulated in 1951 or 1952 at a lecture at New York University (letter to the O.E.D. from Fruma Klass, the wife of science fiction writer Phil Klass (‘William Tenn’), 5 Dec. 2001), and popularized at the 1953 WorldCon science fiction convention (see J. Gunn in N.Y. Rev. Sci. Fiction (1995) Sept. 20).
[1957 T. Sturgeon in Venture Sci. Fiction Sept. 49 On that hangs Sturgeon's revelation. It came to him that s f is indeed ninety-percent crud, but that also—Eureka!—ninety-percent of everything is crud. All things—cars, books, cheeses, hairstyles, people and pins are, to the expert and discerning eye, crud, except for the acceptable tithe which we each happen to like.]
1960 P. Schuyler Miller in Astounding Sci. Fact & Fiction 162/2 Theodore Sturgeon once attacked it from the other side with what has become known as Sturgeon's Law: ‘Ninety per cent of everything is crud.’ The remaining ten per cent is what we call ‘good’ and ten per cent of that—one story in a hundred—is ‘really good’.
1977 Washington Post (Nexis) 29 Aug. b1 What we're in for in movies and television is a deluge.‥ If I may I'd like to quote (sci-fi writer Theodore) Sturgeon's Law: ‘90 per cent of everything is crap’. Television seems to bear that out.
1984 Computer Magazines in net.flame (Usenet newsgroup) 3 Feb., Is anyone else disgusted with what is happening to the computer magazines? I realize that Sturgeon's law is a strong force‥but this is getting putrid!
1996 PC World (Nexis) Dec., ‘Ever heard of Sturgeon's law?’ He shook his head. ‘“Ninety percent of everything is crap.” If that's true of anything, it's true of the Web. Ninety percent of everything on it isn't even worth the time it takes to download’.
- More from bigsteviecook.
- Login or register to post comments










Arthur C Clarke's
Third Law seems appropriate to these days, too:
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic
I quite like
Larry Niven's acronymic and mild expletive, TANJ (There Ain't No Justice)
TANSTAAFL
There ain't no such thing as a free lunch.
It occurs in my favourite book by Robert Heinlein, The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress.
This made me think about cars...
So i went to the Top Gear website (via Google) and found that 2,030,846 new cars were sold in the UK in 2010 and the best sellers were (in order)
01 Ford Fiesta
02 Vauxhall Astra
03 Ford Focus
04 Vauxhall Corsa
05 Volkswagen Golf
06 Volkswagen Polo
07 Peugot 207
08 BMW 3 Series
09 Mini
10 Nissan Quashqai
Are they in the top decile of all cars sold in the UK? Depends what you mean by top, of course. Plainly, they're mass-market cars, they're affordable (in a sense), they'd look a bit silly going round a track in an F1 race and in performance terms they are not top decile. But in terms of mass market cars in the UK they may well be the top 10% where everything else is crap. (I give you the Kia Picanto for comparison's sake, or the Daewoo Matiz.)
All of which is a long-winded way of me realising that 90% of everything is crap is a scaleable phrase, the meaning of which really hinges on what you mean by 'everything'.