Entertainment For Lively Minds
Non-cartoon children's films
I love Toy Story and its sequels as much as the next person. I've seen plenty of great animated films (both CGI and "trad"), yet every now and then, when I watch a really well-made live action film, I remember how different they can be, and how refreshing.
This thought has been provoked over the last couple of days by watching Fly Away Home with my daughter, who's getting on for six. I wasn't sure how much she'd enjoy it, as it's very different from just about all the films she's seen; and right at the start, before the credits have even rolled, the main character's mother is killed in a car crash (this is sensitively handled and not graphic at all, obviously). The main selling point was that there are a lot of baby geese in the film.
Anyway, she absolutely loved it - and so did I and Mrs R. I'd seen it before, but had forgotten what a beautiful, touching and uplifting film it is. Synopsis: 13 year old daughter (Anna Paquin) of divorced parents has to move from New Zealand after her mother's death back to her birthplace in Ontario, to live with her father (Jeff Daniels). Her sadness and difficulty adjusting are relieved by finding a batch of unattended goose eggs, which she hatches. The comes the big question: what to do when they learn to fly...
I can't recommend this film highly enough. And now I'm wondering if there are any other films in this sort of category that the Massive could recommend.
- More from Rosbif.
- Login or register to post comments










The Red Balloon (1956)
Now available on Youtube. Possibly common knowledge, but its director also invented the game Risk!
Really?
I had no idea but thanks - I always find that sort of unexpected juxtaposition cheering.
I Saw This As A Child
I've never forgotten it. Magic.
You could check these out...amusing for adults too!
The Princess Bride
Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
The Railway Children
Tom Thumb (Russ Tamblyn, Peter Sellers, Terry-Thomas)
The Neverending Story
Charlotte's Web
Not really in the same category
But Nanny McPhee is mostly human. Haven't dared show them Chitty Chitty Bang Bang because I was terrified of the Child Catcher as a kid. Mind you, we have got into the habit of saying "It's the Child Catcher!" whenever we hear an ice-cream van and I'm pleased to say the kids are beginning to join in, though they don't seem to believe it.
Haven't seen Fly Away Home, but will definitely get it. My son is obsessed with waterbirds so he'll love the geese even if he doesn't care for the rest of it.
Yep!
Nanny PcPhee is sheer bloody joy from start to finish. We have it on DVD, though not the second one, which was also very good.
I did knock.
You know what?
I've never seen the Princess Bride. I've felt for some time that this is an inexcusable lacuna in my film watching experience.
I've thought of another one, not a film but a TV series: the 1992 version of The Borrowers, with Ian Holm and Penelope Wilton, which I found last year in a charity shop, on VHS. Delightful stuff.
You really should
If you're near a Fopp, I picked up the 2 disc dvd the other weekend for a fiver.
The Box of Delights
If you've never seen it, track this down immediately.
Seconded
It's magnificent
The Amazing Mr Blunden
Terrified me as a child.
Or there's the bizarre but sweet Melody with Mark Lester.
And try The Parent Trap, Freaky Friday and Enchanted, which my niece and nephew were gripped by over Xmas.
The Princess Bride
One for the slightly older child. Lots of swash and/or buckle
A couple of weeks ago I showed this to my 8 year old son for the first time. He loved it and when he had a friend round last week he asked if they could both watch it. His friend loved it too. They spent the rest of the afternoon re-interpreting it in the garden.
It's maybe one of the earlier films to add a layer of humour for grown ups ( "land war in Asia" for example) to what is ostensibly a kids film but it does it without cynicism or calculation.
The great thing is, my friends and I have been quoting it at each other for years and now I have an 8 year old doing the same. I was so proud last week when Robert jumped out at me, sword in hand, and declared "Hello! My name is Roberto Montoya. You are my father, prepare to die!"
Oh yes, and as a special bonus, the USS Nimitz cap that Rob Reiner wore in "Spinal Tap" can be seen in the film. Apparently it was a requirement Mark Knopfler insisted upon when negotiating to compose the score.
Stardust
Not as good as the Princess Bride, but what is? In the same sort of genre - a genre film with a sense of humour.
Both Nanny McPhee films get played a lot.
The Bridge to Tarabithia was greatly enjoyed until one of the characters in it died - which rather turned them off.
And of course Harry Potter goes down well (my 2 are 9 in 2 weeks and can cope with the scary bits - others may not).
Tangled was apparently enjoyed a lot. And the Wizard of Oz too.
If uplifting family fare
is what you're after:
The Secret Garden. Agnieszka Holland's film is a wonderful adaptation. It's powerful and affecting in places but, importantly, its power is not without suitable context and exposition for a child to understand its meaning through self-realisation. Both my daughters have been visibly moved by the story but not upset.
Bridge to Terabithia is another very affecting film but may be better suited to a slightly older child (7/8+)
Jim Henson movies
Not exactly human, but not exactly animated either. The first film i can remember going to the cinema to see was The Muppet Movie. And there are few better interpretations of a Christmas Carol than their version.
I'd also recommend The Dark Crystal - certainly one of my all time favourites. The evil Skeksis terrified me when I was little, but in a good way - their dinner scene is an all-time classic.
And then there's Labyrinth too...
Holes
Doubtful whether it would hold the attention of a six year-old, but this is one of very few kids' films which I've managed to sit through and enjoy. Jon Voigt and Sigourney Weaver grotesque-ing it up as overseers of a boot camp for delinquents where the inmates are required to spend all their time digging holes in the desert. The reasons why are revealed as the story unfolds. Good fun.
Have an up....
Stumbled across this one a few weeks ago, Sunday afternoon, I believe. Was sucked in and thoroughly enjoyed it.
the Incredible Journey
I loved this as a child.
The story (based on a true one - ?) of three pets, a cat and two dogs, who lose their owners when they are all on vacation, and try to find their way back.
I may be wearing child-tinted spectacles, but it pleased my younger self.
Enchanted is a good Disney live action film...
...charming and very funny; and Amy Adams is great.
Amy Adams
I've decided is the next FPO when the current incumbent gets bored.
"Whale Rider" and "Skellig"
These two are probably best experienced after the age of about eight, possibly ten. Both are adaptations of novels, and both do a great job:
"Whale Rider" (2002) - Very moving story of a Maori girl's difficulties with tribal traditions:
"Skellig" (2009) - Also very moving - story of a strange man found hiding in a shed (played by Tim Roth):
Whale Rider
The scene where the little girl is on stage and breaks down talking about her grandfather....
Big boys don't cry?
Arse.
Me too.
I showed "Whale Rider" to a class of twelve year olds, and during that scene I suddenly found the need to study some paperwork very, very closely.
Mind you, when I read the novel of "Skellig" to the same class, the final scenes reduced me to the same state I was in when I watched "The Railway Children" in the seventies. Soppy old sod.
"I've Got Your Snort!"
Another doozer from the "Strange man in a shed" genre is Whistle Down The Wind.
Although I enjoyed the first Spy Kids film very much (The others not so much)I can't help thinking that choosing non-cartoon kids' films is a bit like limiting yourself to your favourite non-Jamaican reggae acts..
Well...
It would be silly to limit oneself to non-cartoon films. I started this thread because I don't think I know enough of these sorts of films. I want to be able to introduce my daughter to all sorts. It's not about one or the other.
Yes I get that
because you expressed it very well in the OP. I, on the other hand, mustn't have expressed myself nearly so well if you thought that's what I meant. Wuz just remarking that it hurt my brain trying to think of non cartoon films whereas I could rattle off loads of 'toons..
btw Has nobody mentioned The Wizard Of Oz?
Archina's Choice
Nim's Island. She was going on for six too when she discovered it. She's watched it at least once a week since then, and that was over a year ago. (Her brother is less impressed, incapable as he is of coming to terms with the idea of a film with no dragons in it at all.)
Because of Winn-Dixie
A 10-year-old girl, abandoned by her mother when she was three, moves to a small town in Florida with her father, a preacher. While there, she adopts a stray dog whom she names after the local supermarket where he was found. With her goofy pooch by her side, she meets an eclectic group of townspeople and rekindles an almost lost relationship with her father.
It's just charming and never fails to make me blub like a wet and a weed.
The Children's Film Foundation
made dozens of quality British films between the 50s and the late 70s for the 'Saturday Morning Pictures' audience.
During my childhood I don't think a week went by when I didn't see that familiar title sequence of the pigeons scattering in Trafalgar Square. Doesn't seem to be on YouTube though :-(
CFF
They're still (just about) available as DVD's:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Saturday-Morning-Pictures-Vol-DVD/dp/B00006JI29...
Just play
the first 5-6 seconds of this clip...
Whoa! Proustian rush or what?
Of course, it were all black and white in my day but I can taste the Kia-Ora now :-). Thanks RD
another vote
For The Princess Bride...
Good enough for me...
The Goonies
naughty kids, gadgets, baddies, hidden treasure and pirates.
Bliss.
Before Ironman...
...Jon Favreau directed this.
It's a great film, my 7 year old daughter loves it (as I do). There's just one (minor) swear word in it, but it's in context. I think it was marketed as 'Jumanji in space' at the time of release, though I'm not a huge fan of that film.
Swear words
That reminds me: there is also one minor swear word in Fly Away Home, a muffled "holy shit" which won't scare the horses.
Fly away home.
Great family film. It is a superb film, & all the better if you are watching it in the company of a seven year old.
a few that are popular in our house...
- Addams Family Values (better than you might expect - very black humour)
- Shorts
- The Mask
All much enjoyed by 6yr old, 12 yr old and dad. (Dad and 12 yr old also really enjoyed Attack the Block but that does have quite a lot of rude words in it.)
so shines a good deed
The Gene Wilder Willy Wonka.
Every single time.
Ah but
would you allow your children to enter the shop of that sinister 'candyman'-singing chap?
"Boy"
New Zealand film.
Brilliant
Unreserverdly
recommend Whistle down the Wind and The Railway Children, both of which made a huge impression on me when I was a kid and can still watch them now, and I still howl. Also loved Born Free, though watched it as a grown up and found Virginia Mckenna's acting totally insufferable. I also remember an Italian film called Marcellino pane e vino which I saw in the mid sixties, all about a cute orphan kid adopted by a monastic order. It's the kind of story that would have far too many unpleasant modern resonance these days but I remember it as a lovely film. Have no idea whether it was ever made available to the U.K market though and never seen it since.
Matilda
I'm surprised this modern classic hasn't been mentioned yet.
Bugsy Malone
One of the greatest musicals...
...with one of the greatest final scenes...
If only all riots could end like this.
Not Grease
Never having seen Grease, and familiar only with the hit songs, I thought nothing of letting my then primary school-age daughter and chums watch it. Bad mistake.
I think it was the mention of 'sloppy seconds' that made the tea shoot out of my nose.
No questions asked though. I like to imagine that much of it went over their heads.
Not forgetting
ET - of course
Star Wars
The best kids film of all time. Conceived by Lucas as a childrens "Western in Space" - stolen by nerds and comic book guys(me included).
The Secret Of Roan Inish
Anyone seen this? An unusual offering from one of my favourite directors, John Sayles. It's a very sweet telling of an Irish folk tale; contains seals and a Selkie. Trailer below.
Singing Ringing Tree
If you feeling particularly cruel you could buy her the DVD of the Singing Ringing Tree. Bound to give her nightmares - it still does for me.