No messing around. Your favourite album of all time please.

Apologies if this has already been done.

I am genuinely interested in your choices should you choose to share and if I am not already familiar with your choices I will feel obliged to investigate them further because it's you.

Here goes....my favourite album of all time.

PhotobucketThe Who "Quadrophenia"

This has been my favourite record for a good twenty years.
I love the sound of it which might seem obvious but I don't mean just the tracks but the actual sound of it, the way it has been produced.
It's so thick and heavy and meaty sounding.

Each band member is on top form.
The bass of John Entwistle sounds incredible, it's not hiding behind the songs, it's out there right in the thick of it demanding your attention.

It's a double album that doesn't out stay it's welcome.
Not one bad track on there.

And importantly together with the artistic merits of the album it MEANS something to me on an emotional level which is what in the end makes it my choice.

If just one.... Hounds Of Love / Kate Bush

Difficult to pick just one album, but would have to go with Hounds Of Love / Kate Bush. Loved it since the day it came out and is still always there in my "top 5 albums" .

chrisf | 31 October 2008 - 5:46am

Abbey Road

Quintessentially Beatles. Charm, wit, melody, screaming rock 'n' roll vocals, pretty English vocals, and side two. An unbeaten feast.

Vulpes Vulpes | 31 October 2008 - 6:57am

Seconded

Such a variety of great tunes. Not the first Beatles album that I grew to love, but certainly the most enduring.

AgentGraves | 31 October 2008 - 8:33am

Ok I've already voted but ...

...just dug out my copy of Abbey Road. It is awesome really, is it not. Can I change my mind. But hang on, just played Revolver again. Oh dear!

Steerpike | 31 October 2008 - 5:58pm

Achtung Baby!

Although, surprisingly maybe, I don't much like any of their other stuff.

spaco | 31 October 2008 - 7:17am

Certainly in my top 5.

Don't listen to it as much as I used to but Achtung Baby! was always an album I returned to again and again. Have to give it another go.

Con Coleman | 31 October 2008 - 12:03pm

my god

it's almost 20 years old!
Doolittle by Pixies has been my fave or thereabouts for two decades now.

badartdog | 31 October 2008 - 8:13am

Beat me to it....

Fantastic album, never tire of hearing the opening chords of Debaser.
Black Francis's screams on Tame send a shiver down my back

Surreal lyrics but great tunes....

David Sutherland | 31 October 2008 - 4:44pm

Felt – Me and a Monkey on the Moon

It struck a chord when I was 17 which remarkably resonates ever more strongly 20 years down the line.

Over the course of ten simple but perfectly formed songs, Lawrence looks back ruefully over his childhood and ten years of cult acclaim and total commercial failure. But also manages to look forward hopefully to the future.

The subsequent critical acclaim and total commercial failure of the first Denim album and Lawrence’s apparent mental, physical and musical (Go Kart Mozart anyone?) decline only makes it all the more poignant. This is as far from Landfill™ as it’s possible for indie to get.

Terrible title though.

Madrid | 31 October 2008 - 8:21am

The Quiet One

It has changed over the years from Exile on Main Street to St.Dominic's Preview to No Other (for a while) but the one I always come back to is George Harrison's All Things Must Pass, the defining achievement of any of the Beatles solo output and a match melodically for anything the four did together

Charlie Gordon | 31 October 2008 - 8:41am

There's an awful lot of music I haven't heard but...

if I have to pick one (which I assume I do, hence the thread) then it'd be No Cities Left by The Dears.

I know to most people they're one of those bands you've heard of but couldn't distinguish from countless others and I'm the first to admit that all their other albums are little better than average.

However, this album is astonishing. It has fantastic melodies, it's full of invention and the attention to detail in choice of instruments and production is truly amazing. I've no idea how many times I've listened to it but every time I discover something I hadn't noticed before.

Joe R | 31 October 2008 - 9:11am

Wouldn't

say it was my favourite but for sure The Dears are a terribly neglected band and far better than that other Montreal band The Arcade Fire. On a Canadian theme and slightly off topic Broken Social Scene deserve attention too.

Bang Em In Bingham | 31 October 2008 - 12:24pm

Abbey Road for me too

A quick look after 4 months of owning and listening to an ipod shows that this is the album I come back to the most.

Paul Wad | 31 October 2008 - 9:13am

Surely that means

it's just your favourite album of the last 4 months?

Joe R | 31 October 2008 - 9:16am

The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway

Unlikely to be adapted into a Broadway musical, seeing as the main character's dick gets cut off and stolen by a raven. Still great though

simonperrins | 31 October 2008 - 9:22am

Fun House

by the Stooges - Down On The Street was a revelation when I first heard it and I hear something new in it every time. PLus the performance of it at Don't Look Back was by far the best thing i have ever seen

Chimney Singing Crow | 31 October 2008 - 9:24am

As of today...

...it's Some Girls. But tomorrow it could well be The Stone Roses.

Kernow | 31 October 2008 - 9:28am

The Soundtrack of Our Lives "Behind The Music" (2001)

The Swedish psychedelic rockers third album was an absolute classic with tunes that The Who would have been proud of. Amazing songwriting, riffs, choruses you can't dislodge from your head for months after first hearing and every track a possible single - the mark of a great album.

The music press were right behind them at this point, great reviews, some unbelievable gigs (imagine a band on stage that would make The Who and The Clash seem static) - other musicians rated them - Noel from Oasis took them on tour, Mani and Primal Scream loved them, even the delectable Kate Hudson declared herself a fan.

Shame that they never capitalized on the good will and support, mainly due to the fact of them being slightly older and more shall we say individual. Walking out on an interview with that complete twat Zane Lowe on MTV2, although admirable, didn't help them get their videos shown though.

Retro Man | 31 October 2008 - 10:05am

The Magnetic Fields...

... with 69 Love Songs.

I only bought it because I'd regognised the cover from a Top 50 albums of the year list in Melody Maker, whilst walking through Virgin on Northumberland Street in Newcastle.

To produce a 3-CD abum full of wit & melancholy; encompass all the emotions of love from 'love to hate' to 'hate to love'; and each track never lasting longer than it needs to always leaves me breathless.

I can think of only one track that don't like (and even then, it's more a mild dislike than anything), and considering there are 69 songs to choose from, is something of a minor miracle.

Reno Dakota | 31 October 2008 - 10:11am

I LOVE that album

and I assumed that was where your screen name was from!

I view it more as a project than an album though, I'm not quite sure it hold together as an album does in the traditional way, if that makes sense. Maybe that's just because of the sheer length of it though.

I can never get bored of it; I couldn't put it as my favourite, but I think it'd be my Desert Island Disc.

Joe R | 31 October 2008 - 10:57am

There is an iota of kindness in me.

I know what you mean - more a selection of songs than an album. I think it does work as 3 separate albums, rather than 1 album over 3 discs.

There were others in the frame for favourite album - DJ Shadow's Endtroducing, Orbital's Brown Album and others, but it's dark humour gets me every time.

It is, as you supposed, where I got my name from - and took advantage of Fraser's User Name Amnesty to get it.

Reno Dakota | 31 October 2008 - 11:36am

They're still long albums!

Since the majority of my listening is on an mp3 player (boo! hiss! etc.), I tend to just put it on all the way through, so I'm not hugely aware of where one disc finishes and another starts. But then again, I rarely listen to it all in one go, and maybe that's why I don't consider it an album. I don't know about you, but as much as I like their other albums, they're not a patch on 69 Love Songs.

Ah, the user name amnesty. Anyone remember who everyone else was previously? No, me neither.

Joe R | 31 October 2008 - 11:53am

'Love is like jazz'

This is my ipod's favourite song. It shuffles it in all the blinkin' time and it really, really annoys me. Yet I am too thirled to maintaining whole-album integrity to take it off.

Con Coleman | 31 October 2008 - 12:01pm

That's the one track...

... that I'm less keen on. Hated it on first listening, but don't mind it so much these days.

Of their other albums, I think i is 69 Love Songs distilled into one CD.

Reno Dakota | 31 October 2008 - 3:50pm

Even the track...

...Love Is Like Jazz? I have to admit that I even enjoyed that one after seeing them attempt it live, tongues firmly in cheeks.

Bigsby | 31 October 2008 - 10:53pm

Just received it from Amazon today

based on your comments above.

LOUDspeaker | 15 December 2008 - 4:29pm

I wish I had something obscure to boast about

but I don't. For me the greatest album ever recorded is The Wall by Pink Floyd.

LOUDspeaker | 31 October 2008 - 10:37am

One I always come back to

Violator - Depeche Mode

Neil Tennant and Chris Lowe said that they felt like giving up after hearing this - which, I think, was a compliment.

Effortless, dignified and confident. A band at the top of their game. The entire album just glides - even when the tempo swings from the glam stomp of Personal Jesus to the phat grunty electro of World in my Eyes and then the sleepy, near-death experience that is Waiting for the Night. And Enjoy the Silence is still a perfect pop song. Overall it has a polished feel that reflects the obsessive care taken to get it just...so. Even the lyrics stack up - which is not a strong point generally with this band.

"You wear guilt like shackles on your feet - like a halo in reverse" (from "Halo"). Oh yes and there is the usual smattering of pain and suffering etc as well as spooky interludes sampling the Eraserhead baby. Not many laughs but it is a very satisfying meal for hungry ears.

Austin | 31 October 2008 - 10:44am

Waiting for the Night...

....is a beautiful song

David Sutherland | 31 October 2008 - 4:45pm

Good shout

It's always the first album I play on a new piece of audio equipment and I never tire of it. Enjoy The Silence *is* perfect, and Clean is just majestic.

phonefreakhoney | 31 October 2008 - 8:20pm

Traffic's second album

Just called "Traffic", it is almost always overlooked, but is a fantastic album full of great songs. The musicianship is top notch & Steve Winwood is unbelieavbly great, whether he's singing, playing guitar or playing keyboards. It was the first album I ever owned &, after nearly forty years, I still play it frequently.

Raymo | 31 October 2008 - 10:49am

Yep

The first two Traffic albums are brilliant.

Bang Em In Bingham | 31 October 2008 - 12:25pm

An enduring love

Roy Harper's HQ. Released in that hot summer of 1975, it's one a still dig out every now and then and still get a frisson from.

Carl Parker | 31 October 2008 - 11:12am

Stormcock

Good as HQ is, it's 'Stormcock' from 1971, followed by 'Bullinamingvase' from 1977 for me...

Mike Hull | 1 November 2008 - 5:55pm

I was thinking about this the other day

I'll have this: it lasts for under 40 minutes, all the songs on it bar one are covers, it's far from their best known work...but I'll have it every time. As loud as possible.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Beat-Soul-Everly-Brothers/dp/B0009A6MVC/ref=sr_1...

And that's my review on Amazon, under the name of M.T. Finger.


Lucas Hare | 31 October 2008 - 11:44am

It's gotta be Joni

Hejira is my favourite album. Why? Superb songs, with lyrics that are brimful of wit, wisdom, passion, extraordinary imagery, sublime chord changes; they're both minimalist and expansive; solipsistic and transcendently about the human condition. The musicianship is unimprovable throughout (and that includes Joni's stunning rhythm guitar), while her singing is magisterial. Look, she's made me spout a load of purple prose probably fit only for pseuds' corner. Ah well. Hejira it is.

Azeem | 31 October 2008 - 12:13pm

I think it's also

Jaco Pastorius' finest hour.

Vulpes Vulpes | 31 October 2008 - 12:38pm

Better than a bit of Blue

Blue always gets the plaudits, but Hejira is a superior album I think. The only way I can describe it is that it's an album that sounds like one long track, but in a really, really good way.

Joe R | 31 October 2008 - 12:43pm

Well

for me its the timeless,endlessly playable "Solid Air" by John Martyn. Well for this week anyway.

Bang Em In Bingham | 31 October 2008 - 12:27pm

A close 2nd

That album runs HQ close in my affections.

Carl Parker | 31 October 2008 - 3:33pm

Nick Drake

Bryter Later. Difficult to pick from the three really but this was my first introduction to Nick Drake in the late Seventies - I still have the original LP's. Perhaps not the purest Nick - that would probably be Pink Moon. But there is more light and shade on Bryter Later. Oh and it has Northern Sky - perhaps my favourite song of all time.

Steerpike | 31 October 2008 - 12:31pm

Hazey Jane II...

... the song that is responsible for Belle & Sebastian's whole career.

Reno Dakota | 31 October 2008 - 3:56pm

All three are beautiful

but you are quite correct "Bryter Layter" is his best, a wonderful record that works almost as a suite somewhat like Van's "Astral Weeks"

Bang Em In Bingham | 31 October 2008 - 4:58pm

Sorry I`m late

As a very late latecomer to the phenomenon that is the late Nick Drake, I cannot think of an album which gets me all woozy and slightly giddy in the way that `Five Leaves Left` does. It is simply superb. Sorry for overusing the word `late`. I don`t want this thread to end up another `list` list so I`ll keep schtum on my other favourites for now.

gerry d | 31 October 2008 - 8:23pm

That's pretty much what I was going to type (Bryter Layter)

That's pretty much what I was going to type (it was either that or Selling England By The Pound or Close To The Edge).

Neil Jung | 1 November 2008 - 11:01pm

Boring

Quite often it's 'Exile On Main St' but this week it might be 'The Beatles'. I think it's the playfulness, inventiveness, variety of styles and emotional range. It helps that I never had my own copy until recently and I am currently infatuated with it. But I always had a soft spot for that one.

Sven | 31 October 2008 - 12:35pm

Uncanny...

I was dithering between those two classic doubles as I scrolled down, Sven. At the moment, the White Album pips it for me too.

Jon | 31 October 2008 - 1:14pm

ABC - The Lexicon Of Love

The greatest pop album ever.

Ultimate 80's production from Trevor Horn and team but it absolutely refuses to sound dated. Its lyrics use language in what was then was a very new way and are almost as good as Jarvis's or Morrissey's and the album is full of fantastic tunes. There is not a duff note on the record let alone a bad song.

And it is one of pop music's truly revolutionary moments. Bye bye boring old guitars. In a blink of an eye the new wave morphed into new pop.

And another thing.....truly iconic sleeve design.

"If I was given a pound for the moments I'd missed
And got dancing lessons for all the lips I should have kissed
I'd be a millionaire
I'd be a Fred Astaire" Bang!

dolly | 31 October 2008 - 12:53pm

ABC - Lexicon of Love

I recently met Martin Fry in the queue for The Simpsons ride at Universal Studios and afterwards went back to this album. I'd forgotten how good it is. Every song a winner and just makes you feel good. Still it's not as good as London Calling

Peter Ellis | 6 November 2008 - 10:08pm

Another one for Nick Drake

Although I prefer Five Leaves Left

Mind you, if I look at my last.fm listening habits, Richard Hawley's Coles Corner has been a stalwart for the past couple of years

robram | 31 October 2008 - 1:12pm

Its probably a 3-way split

between

Sparks - Kimono my House - just a classic album, so many great songs and just different from anything else then and now.

Icicle Works - The small price of a bicycle - long-time Icicle Works/McNabb fan and this has some of the best singles on it, plus the album tracks allow the band to try out different styles that all work. Very much of the '80s but still stands up.

Bonzo Dog Band - Hard to pick which one but possibly the Doughnut in Granny's Greenhouse, although Gorilla comes a close second. humour does belong in music, especially when played by fantastic musicians.

Janice | 31 October 2008 - 1:15pm

Bobcat

My vote has to go to Blood On The Tracks...

Doug B | 31 October 2008 - 1:17pm

Jordan The Comeback Prefab Sprout

Lush, bizarre, funny and moving

Dave P | 31 October 2008 - 1:40pm

A former love, gone wrong

I loved Jordan when it came out. It was my favourite album of 1990. But when I played it for the first time in a long time not that long ago I just found the production really dated and wearing.

Carl Parker | 31 October 2008 - 3:37pm

Same here

I played it to death in 1990 and raved about and swooned over it. I played it in the car the other week & realised a lot of it sounded horribly thin : too much sheen, gutless drums and Wendy Smith's infuriating breathy 'vocals'. From Langley Park to Memphis holds up much better.
Favourite album? The White Album. Yes, half of it is throwaway and self indulgent, but the best bits are better and more plentiful than any other album's best bits.

Graham Johns | 31 October 2008 - 4:23pm

Prefabs

I find most of their stuff is tainted with that horrible "shiny"
production, which is too bad because there is a treasure trove of great songs hiding underneath.

Bang Em In Bingham | 31 October 2008 - 6:15pm

Scott 3...

...because is still speaks to me after all this time while simultaneously reminding me of who I was when I first heard it and saw my life transform.

I hardly ever listen to it now, mainly because I like to have it preserved for when I really, really need it.

Con Coleman | 31 October 2008 - 1:45pm

Only one !

You can´t have only one, it depends on your mood, time of day, where you are in life, if your moving around or sitting down....Oh alright then ! A Black and White Night: Roy Orbison and guests

On The Fence | 31 October 2008 - 2:02pm

easy

King of the Delta Blues Singers - Robert Johnson

It's a compilation, and the cover is a painting based on the fact that (at the time of original release) no-one knew what he looked like. There are more complete sets of his work, and this one misses key tracks, but it is just a perfect album in terms of sequence and feeling, and I believe I will never find anything I like better, even though there are many others that I cherish and listen to as much.

earlgreyjnr | 31 October 2008 - 2:14pm

Stone Roses and/or Primal Scream

Can't fault it really and it will always sum up a period when life seemed very exciting. Screamadelica runs it a close second though for exactly the same reasons.

Jamie_Bowman | 31 October 2008 - 2:51pm

Kraftwerk

Find a place in your heart for Kraftwerk's Trans Europe Express, the perfect response to anyone who says that electronic music is soulless

Scoop | 31 October 2008 - 3:45pm

Pawn Hearts by Van der Graaf Generator

Back in 1971, aged 14, when I first heard this, I couldn't believe what I was hearing - it made all the other Prog Rock I'd been exposed to that year seem ever so polite by comparison. Saxes wailed, Hammill screeched like a banshee, the words were bloody terrifying, and there were sounds that I still can't figure out - as if they came from some Lovecraftian dimension of musical terrorism enacted by demons. And nearly every year since then, I've dug out first the LP, then the first CD issue, and now the much-better remastered CD, and played it at least half a dozen times before returning it to the shelf. And I still find it deliciously terrifying, and the biggest treat I can ever give my ears. An absolute masterpiece.

Paul Vincent | 31 October 2008 - 3:53pm

Not the most original choice

The Bends by Radiohead is just such a complete album (no skipping required) that I always find myself coming back to it.

Agree with Doolittle posted above as another good one for similar reasons to The Bends - you can listen to the whole thing without getting restless.

milkybarnick | 31 October 2008 - 4:50pm

Stone Roses

For me nothing comes close to The Stone Roses by the Stone Roses. Never tire of listening to it, never skip a track. Also contains my favourite ever moment of music on my favourite track, I am the Resurrection, at around 2m25s, where lamentation switches to exultation - exhilarating.

The only album where I specifically listen to the percussion too.

longtonian | 31 October 2008 - 5:25pm

Takk - Sigur Ros

I never tire of the tunes, the beauty and the lovely oddness that this has despite being the purest of pop.

Lee Rimmer | 31 October 2008 - 6:16pm

Have you tried...

Med Sud I Eyrum Vid Spilum Endalaust (the one radio presenters are too scared to pronounce) is easily superior to Takk... And thats going some. But its still Nick Drake for me.

gerry d | 31 October 2008 - 8:33pm

I love them all

and the new one is fantastic. I've just played Takk to death since it came out and never ever fail to love it. The bit where the brass band comes in on Se Lest always makes me smile.

Lee Rimmer | 31 October 2008 - 8:52pm

Lordy...

... difficult one. The awful Sly and the Family Stone gig at Bournemouth is sufficiently far away for me to say There's A Riot Going On again. I love the swampy, messed up quality an awful lot.

ganglesprocket | 31 October 2008 - 6:39pm

Sly

I too has the misfortune to attend a Sly concert at the Nickolodean (birth place of The Band)in Toronto in 1982. 15 minutes on stage and then "Goodnight" the show ended with the band knocking on his dressing room door trying to get him to come out or at least to be let in. No dice. What a nightmare. I just bought the remasters of Riot, Stand and Fresh and they are superb. Thank God he left us these masterpieces before he set off on his voyage to the planet Zog.

Bang Em In Bingham | 31 October 2008 - 7:20pm

Violator - Depeche Mode

Sleek, pulsing, crepuscular... just perfect.

Error Gorilla | 31 October 2008 - 6:52pm

The Train and the River

by The Jimmy Giuffre Trio.
Clarinet/sax, bass and Jim Hall's peerless guitar. Recorded when I was 8 and I've loved every note since I first heard it 10 years later.
My All - side 2 Track 1 - is just perfect.

davecowps | 31 October 2008 - 7:24pm

probably

nick Cave and the bad seeds- The Boatman's Call

or it could be the double album Abattoir Blues/The Lyre of Orpheus,

then again i do love Pixies - Doolittle

and Pink Floyd - Wish you were here

and Tom Waits - in the heart of Saturday Night .

i used to be be decisive ....

vgom | 31 October 2008 - 8:11pm

Call me a hippy, but...

how nice is it to read a thread that is nothing but positivity and enthusiasm. A break from "Most Annoying Blank" type threads (my vote: Long lists of everything that's wrong with the world).

Now, back to your scheduled programme.

simonperrins | 31 October 2008 - 8:28pm

Elipsis alert...

Can I add that its also very refreshing that this thread has not yet (and might never) descend into `my favourites more obscure than your favourite, blah, blah, blah`. Come on the mainstream!

gerry d | 31 October 2008 - 8:38pm

perhaps we have all

been watching the news to often !

vgom | 31 October 2008 - 9:15pm

it's tough.

I really can't decide on one, just one, for all time.

Right now I'll say Ghost in the Machine by The Police.

That's the first one I'd buy if I had to replace all my music from scratch.

Em | 31 October 2008 - 9:59pm

'For Your Pleasure' by Roxy Music

No contest.

Flagpole Corner | 31 October 2008 - 10:02pm

Predictable, but...

it's Pet Sounds. There are some moments on that record that make you think it is perfection.

Plus, it's got a couple of duff (ish) tracks - Sloop John B and the title track, but somehow that doesn't diminish it.

Bigsby | 31 October 2008 - 10:56pm

A second vote for .....

...Quadrophenia...

Closely followed by "Wish You were Here" and Physical Graffiti". I was 4 when the first came out and 5 for the latter two, whatever that might mean.

nicktf | 31 October 2008 - 11:21pm

Elvis is King

It has to be Costello.
Difficult to decide between "Imperial Bedroom" and "King of America" but current fave has to be "KOA"

Nigel Stephenson | 1 November 2008 - 8:42am

Elvis is indeed King

And for me King of America is my favourite album of all time.

I assume compilations don't count - if they do it would be Simon and Garfunkels greatest hits.I will probably get pilloried on this site but to me they were better than the Beatles.

Agree with Paul Vincent about Van Der Graaf Generator - they blew me away at the same time and I remember seeing them live in Birmingham at the Locarno. What a brilliant band. I want to invest in some Peter Hammill solo stuff particularly the first 3 or 4 albums with the bonus material. Any of the later stuff any good?

Steve Turner | 1 November 2008 - 11:05am

It's an arguable point

I don't see why you would get pilloried. It's a fairly slim body of work to maintain an argument about, but work of high quality nonetheless.
It's not like trying to argue that Beaver and Krause say, were better than the Beatles.

Carl Parker | 1 November 2008 - 12:27pm

Later PH material

I'm not personally familiar with any of Peter Hammill's solo albums beyond Chameleon / Silent Corner / In Camera, all of which were (as you're probably aware) excellent VdGG albums in disguise (much of the material had been written as band numbers prior to their disbanding). However, an old school pal - the one who got me into der Graaf originally - continues to buy everything Hammill or the band release, and reckons Hammill has not only maintained the quality of his earlier songs, but has improved with age. Another friend always spoke highly of PH's "Sitting Targets" and "pH7" albums.

Paul Vincent | 7 November 2008 - 9:50am

Fatima Mansions - Viva Dead Ponies

well you said no messing about

spt | 1 November 2008 - 11:39am

probably my second choice

or third after Valhalla Avenue - the most criminally neglected band.

badartdog | 1 November 2008 - 10:28pm

Oops - missed your response

VDP gets it for me and for any interested int he detail, this is why

http://soundsxp.com/artman2/publish/albums/The_Fatima_Mansions_Viva_Dead...

spt | 17 November 2008 - 2:02pm

The Specials - Specials

The first Specials album is the one I always go back to and still sounds fantatstic today, its just full of classic 3 minute pop songs.

The Specials were probably also the best gig I ever saw at the Bristol Locarno, with the Selecter and the then unknown Dexys as support. Awesome night.

GregN | 1 November 2008 - 12:15pm

Got to be Station to Station

Got to be Station to Station but always love Blood on the Tracks and King of America. But Station to Station just stuns me every time

darlimi1 | 1 November 2008 - 2:04pm

Born To Run

by Bruce Springsteen. My unfailing 'go to' album anytime. It bridges the earlier, more wordy work and the later more concise songs but it retains the stories, characters, epic scale and human foibles he chronicles so well. 7* on a scale of 5.

Mark JF | 1 November 2008 - 5:14pm

Blood On The Tracks

Had loads of Dylan albums but sold them when I realised I was only playing CDs. This was the only one I replaced and keep coming back to. There are many artists I love but still this album still intrigues me the most.

Tony Donaghey | 1 November 2008 - 6:22pm

Wild Wood

does it for me. Paul Weller at his finest, although Primal Scream - Vanishing Point runs it a close second..

the mvps | 1 November 2008 - 11:19pm

Challenging the nomination...

...of Fatima Mansions as 'the most criminally neglected band' (much as I love them), I'll throw my hat in the ring with "I Was The King, I Really Was The King" by Animals That Swim.

When attempting to sell ATS to friends (before I got tired of trying and gave up, resigned to keeping them a private pleasure), I used to say they were like Tindersticks on happy pills - beautifully crafted narratives in the lyrics, tunes to die for, and the glorious trumpet work of Del Crabtree (who also blew up a storm on Bark Psychosis' "Hex", which would be in my top 10).

"East St O'Neill" is the most beautiful account of urban ghostliness imaginable ('On wet days, the ghost sits in the kitchen... he's not grey or wraithlike, but bright and solid like a new bike'), and "The Greenhouse" should have been Number 1 for a year, and the rest... ah, the rest are bloody marvellous, too.

shagg1y | 2 November 2008 - 5:00am

dearth of black artists in these selections

robert johnson and sly crack ( no pun intended) a mention

no aretha, ray charles , james brown, prince, hendrix,

tonyhunter | 2 November 2008 - 12:03pm

no marvin gaye

no michael jackson, no bob marley. Does anyone else know any black artists?

badartdog | 3 November 2008 - 8:46am

Marvin Gaye's...

'What's Going On' is mine, also up there would be Linton Kwesi Johnson's 'Bass Culture', and Anita Baker's 'Rapture'. Can I include some soul compilations that I made up myself or does it have to be a 'real' album?!!

humphreym | 6 November 2008 - 8:55am

Rapture

As with my comment on Prefab Sprout elsewhere on this thread, I found that shiny 80's production impossible to listen to when playing it for the first time in many years.

Carl Parker | 6 November 2008 - 3:21pm

Today

After The Goldrush

..but it's a Sunday, so it might have been Solid Air, or A Love Supreme, or Blonde On Blonde, or Koyaanisqatsi

Monday morning? A Southern Rock Opera or Europe 72. Tuesday? Stand In The Fire. Wednesday? Neu. Thursday? The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway. Friday? Henry The Human Fly or Sweetheart Of The Rodeo. Saturday? Maggot Brain or Second Toughest In The Infants.

No messing about: I can't just pick one, ever. Ask me for my top five - I'll only give you three because I hope I haven't discovered the other two yet.

James EB | 2 November 2008 - 4:28pm

No reflection on your post at all James EB...

But it reminded me of a guy I used to work with who was, if you will, a chilling hybrid of David Brent and Alan Partridge.

He told me that he was a "music nut" and his tastes were "raaather, shall we say, eclectic!". When I asked him what music he liked he genuinely said "Ooh let me see...now this morning I was listening to the Eagles. On the way home it could be anything from ELO to Alan Parsons to the Rolling Stones. It really could be anything at all!"

Austin | 3 November 2008 - 6:08pm

I forgot about...

'A Love Supreme'!

humphreym | 6 November 2008 - 8:56am

Aja..

...by Steely Dan
I could go on for hours. A work of true genius by the mighty Becker and Fagen (and A-list supporting players) at their absolute peak.
I listen to it again and again and again and never tire of it. (The DVD in the Classic Albums series is fantastic too).

Roy Levy | 2 November 2008 - 8:29pm

there's a hole in your logic

Always preferred Pretzel Logic myself - though you can't go too far wrong with any of their early albums.
The cool kid at my sixth form recommended it back in 1979, when I was too busy trying to be a punk to listen. Turns out he was right - I don't play the Buzzcocks or Sex Pistols any more.

paulwright | 3 November 2008 - 7:58pm

Sparks- Exotic Creatures of the Deep

I am a big Sparks fan and I am thrilled that the Mael brothers are able to make an album that has to be their best.It is best listened to on headphones.

Andrew Bissonnette | 2 November 2008 - 9:56pm

The Con

Tis a tough one, but I'd have to go with The Con by Tegan and Sara, it really strikes a chord both lyrically and melodically. It's very insightful, layered, inspiring, creative, thoughtful and thought-provoking. A close, joint-second would be Bone Machine by Tom Waits and the Here Comes the Night recordings by The Frames.

sermonsinstones | 3 November 2008 - 12:04am

Another vote for Born To Run

It transfixed me at the age of 17, when I bought it back from WH Smith in Watford and put it on my record player, and it continues to do so today, whether on CD or iPod. The past, present and future of rock'n'roll, all wrapped up in 45 glorious minutes.

Tim Turner | 3 November 2008 - 3:56pm

Bowie

Loads of favourites, but the one I always come back to is 'Hunky Dory'. An absolute masterpiece.

Andy Mackenzie | 3 November 2008 - 4:16pm

I'd echo the 1/3rd vote above for

Tom Waits - Heart of Saturday Night. I missed it first time round due to being 4 years old, but was introduced to it by a chap I worked with around 10 years ago. My son had just been born, and I was doing a 3 hour round trip to work, and this album accompanied me every step of the way. I love the feel of the record, the lyric of the record, everything. TW in general I love, including his more 'challenging' albums, and I got to see him in Edinburgh earlier this year which was awe inspiring, but this record just gets me every time.

I know it is a whole new thread of its own, but I'd want my gravestone to read "If I exorcise my devils, well my angels may leave too. When they leave, they are so hard to find". Perfect.

sweetleftfoot | 3 November 2008 - 5:02pm

Highlander rules...

there can be only one!
Impossible really isn't it?
I am surprised that Revolver hasn't been mentioned yet - it would be close for me. Along with Pretzel Logic, Blood on the Tracks, and the more obscure choices of Ride's Going Blank Again, and Microdisney's The Clock comes down the stairs.
But the tyranny of the Ipod means I rarely listen to whole albums anymore... My favourite track would probably be Tomorrow never knows.

paulwright | 3 November 2008 - 8:05pm

There's a lot of 'classic rock' here...

Born in Manchester in 65 my favourite has to up the post-punk massive quotient here...

Unknown Pleasures - surely the strongest debut album of all time. Perfect from start to finish, and they didn't even bother to put Transmission on it!

'Iconic sleeve design' too

trevelyan wright | 3 November 2008 - 8:43pm

C'est la Guerre (or is that Say La Gear?)

C'est la Guerre just ran 3rd in this year's Melbourne Cup (that's a horse race). First round on Mark methinks

Atheleane | 4 November 2008 - 5:09am

Beck

Sea Change, although a couple of his albums are contenders. is this the only nomination from the last ten years?

Gav Leonard | 4 November 2008 - 12:10pm

Second vote for Beck's Sea Change

only heard it for the first time a month ago and it is a corker.

plumb1909 | 6 November 2008 - 10:10pm

The Stone Roses

Predictable indie kid choice - but still the one I come back to. Still the one that opened up a whole new world. The record that saved my life!

John Waite | 4 November 2008 - 3:01pm

Miss America by Mary Margaret O'Hara

just never dates.

"A thing of such beauty, must be called love"

Gramsci | 4 November 2008 - 5:23pm

Really?

I sold my copy.

Neil Jung | 4 November 2008 - 11:23pm

Sorry but...

Im going to plump for Metallica's Master of Puppets which probably tells you a few things:

am still emotionally and neurotically 17 years old
probably need to get out more
am likely as anything to be posting on the "wrong" website

But I love it and if you dont agree you're wrong etc etc

MatDavies | 4 November 2008 - 5:52pm

Picking a fave Beatles album is damn' hard!

A favourite album would have to be a Beatles album, no doubting it, infact, if the question was 'name your fave non-Beatles album' it would be a lot easier to answer it: 'Sound Affects' by the Jam, 'Hunky Dory' -Bowie, 'Entertainment' by Gang of Four, 'In Utero' by Nirvana, 'Unknown Pleasures' by Joy Division or 'Sticky Fingers' by you bloody know who. That is of course not counting 'best of' albums, because 'Who's Best' 'Best of Bob Marley' and scores of others would be in the running. BUT.............I could narrow it down to one after a lot of hair pulling! But as far as BEATLES albums, it gets very messy.

I would have to, again after a lot of hair pulling and teeth extraction, have to pick two albums, and regretfully leave two others out. The two runners up would have to be 'Abbey Road' and 'Pepper', because I think both those albums are classics that surpass anything any other band in the history of rock have produced.

My TWO faves are: The White Album and Revolver. The White album simply because it has tracks on it in which the band members are pretty much shining as solo artists, but with the other three members supplying the best backing instrumentation and harmonies I could ever know: John Lennon shines on this album more than any other, from the poignant beautiful delicate 'Julia' and 'Dear Prudence', to the weird and spectacular 'Bungalow Bill', 'I'm So Tired' and 'Sexy Sadie' and 'Glass Onion', to the in your face rock and rollers like 'Yerr Blues' and 'Everybody's Got Something to Hide Except For Me and My Monkey'. George hits one of the best songs of his entire career with Clapton's out-of-this-world lead guitar on 'While My Guitar Gently Weeps', and gives us a unique post-pyschedelic slice of 'Savoy Truffle' and 'Piggies', plus the underrated ballad 'Long Long Long'.

McCartney gets the most weirdest and wildest here as well with 'Why Don't We Do It In The Road', the unfinished but catchy and bizarre 'Rocky Raccoon' and the short and insane 'Wild Honey Pie'. He pummels us with arguably one of the 1960's most heavy rockers 'Helter Skelter' (which is up there with Zeppelin in my view) and then takes us down with uncharcteristically 'uncorny' ballads such as 'I Will' and 'Blackbird'.

So you get the 'solo' Beatles, but you also see them pull together, as a 'band' on 'Yerr Blues' (done in a different studio, a small one, and almost entirely live), on 'Birthday' (even Yoko joins in!), 'Back in the USSR' and on 'Helter Skelter'.

It also has one of my 'top five' Beatles songs EVER on it: 'Happiness is a Warm Gun'. So there's solid reason for THE WHITE ALBUM to be one of my all time faves.

And of course 'Revolver'! Truth be told, if I had to choose between the two albums this would probably win out, purely because it drips with psychedelic acid weird and wonderfulness. 'Taxman' is the first song in the (albeit waning) 'Beatlemania' stage of their career to open an album with a song not about boy/girl, instead the listener gets a wild rock song, laden with the trademark harmonies, about........taxes!

Then one of the reasons why they stopped touring: 'Eleanor Rigby' (how could you play this live in 66?), with it's despondant lyric, gloomy but alive in sound and texture. Cynicism is firmly planted in the Beatlemaniacs head when my 2nd 'top 3' Beatles song EVER appears. 'I'm Only Sleeping' is just hypnotic, with the sedating drawl of Lennon's ode to peaceful 'outside of society' ode. backwards guitars, backing vocals that send tingles down your spine, and a backbeat that just skips along in an acid haze.

The mighty 'She Said She Said' and 'And Your Bird Can Sing' are just epic acid rock pieces, with lyrics that fall away from the puppy love the band were turning out only two years earlier! 'Here There and Everywhere', with the harmonies echoing every lyric, is probably my favourite McCartney ballad, and Lennon said years later it was his fave song from the entire Beatles catalogue. Even a fave album has a low point and 'Yellow Submarine' is the only track on the album I can happily skip, but to some (kids particularly) it is a classic.

'Got to Get You into My Life' out-Motowns Motown and always inspires me, and makes me think romantic love can exist (as corny as that sounds)....the dissolve into psychedelic guitar at the end is particularly epic. Similarly 'Goodday Sunshine' does the same, and it's just pure pop gold, polarlised by the forlorn and masterful 'For No One'. 'Doctor Robert' again shows the new evolved Beatles in full flight as a band, singing about a speed medico, and the harmonies and foray into dischords of 'I Want to Tell You' just blow me away.

Then you get the world's first techno track, 'Tomorrow Never Knows'! Groundbreaking on almost every level, looming, ominous, dangerous, droning, beautiful. The hypnotic sitar drawl and the drumbeat 'loop', compounded by everything from backwards guitar to toy piano at the end....Lyrically, the Beatles are coming of age, but I'll just make it easy and say I fucking love this song! And how many times have we heard it duplicated in the last ten years? I don't think the U.K music scene could live without it sometimes. This finale to this great album heralds the new Beatles, and it would have been just so fantastic if 'Strawberry Fields' was on it, because that's my favourite Beatles song and it wasn't recorded too long after this album.

Nuff said, I gave youa review when you just wanted a name, but fuck it, I enjoyed dissecting it anyhoo. Anyone who agrees can chat with me at davoid_dixon@yahoo.com.au.

-ziggy.

ziggysawdust | 5 November 2008 - 6:13am

Blonde On Blonde

I can't help it. Over the years (decades even!), this is the one I keep returning to and always hear something new on.

Otis Blue runs it close and so does the Stones 1st album. Oh and I never tire of Benny Goodman Live at the Carnegie Hall in 1938. Eclectic or just plain weird?

Gavin Adam | 5 November 2008 - 10:01am

Bring out the eye liner

Hard to pick just one but i would have to go for the Manics Holy Bible.

alto | 5 November 2008 - 11:48am

GP/Grievous Angel

Not really a single album but available for so long on a 2 for 1 CD format it virtually has become a double album - no collection should be without it.

Preston74 | 5 November 2008 - 11:49am

Forever changing

I have a real problem picking my favourite is so it pretty well comes down to 'what albums do I never tire of listening to?' - albums that I'll put on, and then simply feel the need to play over again as they are in some way addictive.
So skipping over the forever changing favourite ('Abbey Road', 'Sgt Peppers', 'Hunky Dory', 'Animals' ,'Hounds Of Love'), I find myself faced with a (four-sided) coin toss to decide if 'Permanent Waves' (Rush), 'Rain Dogs' (Tom Waits), 'Kid A' (Radiohead), or 'California' (Mr Bungle) is my current favourite...
...damn it! it's goig to have to be 'California' by Mr Bungle - at least for today that is. Not a grower - I liked it instantly and played it again imemediately - and not a duff track. I almost feel it's too short, as it always leaves me wanting more, and yet I'm sure anything extra would be superfluous and weigh it down. Simply marvellous.

Paul T | 5 November 2008 - 12:04pm

a rush to the head

c'mon folks, the Rush albums from the seventies are the greatest! Fly By Night, Caress of Steel, 2112, A Farewell to Kings, Hemispheres - i secretly play them in my shed and hope that my secret will not be revealed to the priests in the temple of syrinx! My missus has found out though and just shakes her head sadly...

John from Hull | 5 November 2008 - 11:50pm

Bowie

Station to Station. 37 Minutes of absolute perfection. Not a note wasted. Even the train sounds good!

Iain McKinney | 6 November 2008 - 10:38am

Bruce

Born to Run (and Thunder Road is my all-time favourite track). very surprised it's only got 2 votes so far.

stuart webber | 6 November 2008 - 1:27pm

Parallel Lines

I know it's not the greatest album ever made but it's the one that's had the biggest impact on me and made me the woman I am today! 4 classic pop singles, and a bunch of filler - but what filler!

Mazzy | 6 November 2008 - 3:02pm

Long Gone Before Daylight

By The Cardigans. Simply gorgeous.

Nasalhair | 7 November 2008 - 10:06pm

I beg to differ

and respectfully suggest that Super Extra Gravity is the superior album of icy pop music.

LOUDspeaker | 10 November 2008 - 12:06pm

Agreed...

extremely underated album .

Retro Man | 11 November 2008 - 2:35pm

I beg to differ back atcha

I do like SEG (particularly "I Need Some Fine Wine...", and "Good Morning Joan", although its alternate take "If You Were Less Like Me" on their "Best Of" compilation is much better) but for me "Long Gone Before Daylight" is far superior due to its consistency and sustained mood. It's a gorgeous album, whereas SEG is more varied and dare I say patchy. Nina is still a fox though.

Nasalhair | 20 November 2008 - 1:57pm