Entertainment For Lively Minds
Music DVD
Posted by prettyvacant on 22 January 2009 - 11:37am.
My randomizer turn fired out The Who's "Slip KId". I have not heard the track for ages, so I decided to listen to "The Who by Numbers" album. However somehow I got sidetracked to their DVD "Live at the Royal Albert Hall" so I viewed that instead.
I failed miserably in my mission as no tracks from said album feature on the DVD. Nevertheless I really enjoyed listening and watching The Who. Apart from music films like "Control" and "Spinal Tap" anyone care to share their favourite concert/video anthology DVDs? Others I watch include The Pretenders "The Isle of View", Pink Floyd "Pulse" and The Sex Pistols "There'll Always be an England"
- More from prettyvacant.
- Login or register to post comments










Off the top of my head...
The 3 OGWT DVDs (and the 9 unofficial OGWT DVDs) are always good for post-pub entertainment.
The Classic Albums DVD series
Urgh! A music war
Neil Young - Live Rust
Floyd - Live at Pompeii
Clash - Westway to the world
Led Zeppelin - DVD
The Last Waltz
Monterey Pop
Rolling Stones 25x5
The Rolling Stones' 25x5 is superb
I'm sure no-one involved in that documentary ever imagined they'd be around for another 20 years... I converted my VHS copy and assume it's never been officially released on DVD?
Totally agree
Superb doco and no it's not available on DVD.
I imagine there is some legal issue and I bet Allen Klein is not far away....allegedly.
I remember watching it when it first aired back in 1989 I would guess. Wasn't it 'Arena'?
I think it was...
...Arena. I recorded it off the TV back then and finally got a DVD copy a years or so back via the interweb
loved that
not so much for the music as the interviews - Charlie saying he'd only been in the Stones for 5 years. The other 20 had just been hanging about. And Keef saying of Brian Jones "you just know some people are not going to make it".
but the clip of them playing with Muddy Waters...
...in a club was priceless. Not so much for Mick's over the top performance but to see the smiles on Keef and Ronnie's faces to be playing I'm A Man with their hero.
9!
9 unofficial OGWT DVD's? Where? How?
What?
How the hell do I get hold of them, sir? If you'd be so kind...
Try your favourite bootleg torrent site...
They're compilations of OGWT appearances along the same lines as the offical releases. The quality is variable as some clips are sourced from VHS and, of course, there's no commentary but all your favourite classic OGWT clips are there.
Last time I looked, they were still available through The Traders Den.
This list seems to cover them all
http://www.thetradersden.org/forums/search.php?searchid=4909069
and look for the torrents called 'Old Grey Whistle Test Vol x'
You're a fine and lovely man
Thank you very much
Andy
The Last Waltz
Gah!!
How could I have forgotten that one!! Possibly the greatest concert movie of all
Your starters for ten
Personal selection:
Concerts
Floyd - live in pompeii,Led Zep - DVD, Prince - Sign O The Times, Talking Heads - Stop Making Sense, The Band etc - The Last Waltz
Great Video/TV clip Compilations
Complete Jam
Smiths - The Complete Picture
Best of Bowie (though way too much 80s on the second disc)
The Who - The Kids are Alright
New Order - A Collection
Fantastic live footage in a bad film award - Rudeboy
The documentary to which all other music documentaries should aspire to award - No Direction Home
Isn't all the Rude Boy live footage...
...on the Westway DVD?
Clash
"Fantastic live footage in a bad film award - Rudeboy"
On my DVD of Rude Boy, they have a handy "just play the music" option so you don't have to bother with the shite film.
rude boy
and didn't i read that a lot of that footage was overdubbed in the studio
kind of at odds with the 'no miming on TOTP" ideology
fabulous none the less
oh and fraser - can i still do the name amnesty and get real?
Amnesty
What would you like it changed to?
Fraser,
this may seem a little belated, but an earlier request went unheeded: any chance of a User Name Amnesty before and after list?
Get real??!!
Are you mad? Then if anyone Googles your name they'll find out way too much about you. The more your real name stays off the internet the better.
It probably is.
But I'd still recommend the entertaining if ropey socially conscious plotline. I've got lots of affection for bands trying to act in movies. They never said anything about learning lines when I answered the ad in the back of the NME....
Not one of the classics
but The Wedding Present's '*PUNK' was a really good film - there's not that many decent concert films around from the Golden Age Of Indie.
REM's Tourfilm captures them when they just made the cross from 'pretty big' to 'Cor - they're going to be MASSIVE'
Could you do me a favour and
talk up the Wedding Present. I've got a 6 CD box set of Peel sessions and I just can't work up the enthusiasm to listen to it beyond the rather mediocre first disc.
Well
They're not as Marmiteish as The Fall - I'd say the first disc would be a bit ramshackle but when they get into their songwriting stride around Seamonsters (probably disc 2 or 3) that's where you'll find the gold. If you don't like Brassneck you're not ever really going to love The Wedding Present.
Brassneck
I'll give that track a listen as it might get me interested in them.
Sparks
"L'il Beethoven live in Stockholm" & "DeeVeeDee live at the Forum" are absolutely brilliant, especially the latter as you get a set of "old" played by a full band.
The visuals and humour aswell as the sheer excellence of their music and performance comes across perfectly on these DVDs.
Other favourites in the collection:
"Dig!" eye-opening documentary surrounding two bands Brian Jonestown Massacre and Dandy Warhols. Packed full of drug abuse, clashing egos and violence, be it band vs audience or inter band punch-ups.
The BJM implode trying to "keep it real" while the far less talented Dandy Warhols make it huge by "kissing the record company's ass" and stealing all the BJM's ideas and wasted glamour.
Talking Heads "Stop Making Sense", maybe a bit dated now but a masterpiece of live concert video.
The Jam "Complete Jam" - stuffed full of everything TV apperances, video and live, beautifully packaged.
The Who "Kids Are Alright", stunning live performances and hilarious antics on various TV shows.
Wilco "I Am Trying To Break Your Heart", intimate and moving film about an artist struggling against his record company - and winning!
Various artists
I think I like to watch festival-type, multi-artist affairs best: Monterey Pop, The Last Waltz, Isle of Wight, even Woodstock - there's the whole entertainment of audience goings on, behind the scenes stuff, chat from bands. It's less controlled than when all one act. Plus those festivals were a new thing then - all more interesting than film of a modern festival would be. I prefer those kind of films to ones that are just a one band show, where it's more like what you'd get on a CD anyway - e.g. Neil Young 'Weld', best heard rather than seen.
'Stop Making Sense'
is right up there with 'The last Waltz', and if you are of a certain age I'd recommend 'The Concert For George' as a superbly filmed and sequenced record of what was probably the last great hurrah of that sixties generation of musicians.
anytime i've seen the final segment of that (George concert)
with Joe Browne and the ukulele, i've found that I appear to have, ahem, something in my eye...
rest of it is good too, obv
Me too...
that performance by Joe Brown is one of my all time favourites. A simple song, beautifully sung and played... and I bet there wasn't a dry eye in the Albert Hall. Just gorgeous...
I was there
and there wasn't.
Hendrix at Woodstock
One I always keep going back to. The most recent release features another filmed version of the same gig called 'A Second Look'. Filmed in a completely unauthorised fashion by a then young film student. Apparently he simply set up on the stage next to Billy Cox unchallenged. Everyone thought he was with someone else.
It's black and white, worn, intermittent footage and gives an almost static view of Hendrix apart from a handful of slow sweeps at the crowd and the rest of the stage. It's interesting in that it shows up how ultimately pointless the rest of Hendrix's musical entourage effectively was. The multiple percussionists and Larry Lee on guitar. They may aswell not have been involved in anything at all. Hendrix was the focal point whether he wanted to be or not. He may have wanted to expand his sound in his last couple of years but bringing in ineffectual conga players and another guitarist to simply play inaudible rhythm seemed a half-hearted way of achieving it.
Doesn't bear repeating viewings but worth seeing to see Hendrix perform sans the usual annoyingly ill-focussed, drifting camera work then in vogue with directors.
Would have to agree that 'Stop Making Sense' is outrageously good. As well as being great to watch it shows just how funky they were as a unit. Brilliant.
Erm..
..Jazzin' for Blue Jean?
I'll get me coat.
Pixies Acoustic- Live at Newport
It's from the reunion a few years back so pot-bellys and signs of balding are all on display. Thje rapor the band members have with each other, and the audience, is really playful and they seem to be massively enjoying themselves. The songs really benefit from the stripped down acoustic treatment as well. There's a brilliant moment where Frank starts to play one song and the rest of the band launch into another. The band grinds to a hault and Frank addresses the jazz/ folk audience with the line 'we were jamming'.
Blur - Starshaped
Whatever you may think of the band, this is a very funny and enjoyable document of a band at the peak of their fame, losing it, drinking heavily and then getting it back together again. Worth it if only for the tour bus singalalongs and the footage of Glastonbury where Damon breaks his ankle after the PA falls onto it and Graham gets lost
Re: 'Slip Kid'
I think the Who attempted to play it on a few dates of the accompanying tour, but quickly abandoned it and never played it live again.
i have had and enjoyed
a nick cave video collection
a radiohead video collection
an rem video collection
punk by the Wedding Present
an rem live show (tourfilm?)
but i don't think i watched any of them more than 2 or 3 times
same problem
I enjoy them - but can't find the time to watch them more than once. Unlike CDs you can't do anything else at the same time (and I don't have external speakers for my tv so the sound is not brilliant).
Liked Radiohead video compilation, New order compilations, Talking Heads compilation (Storytelling Giant) and Stop making sense. Haven't seen The Kids are Alright for 25 years (30?) but would like to do so. Didn't get The Last Waltz at the time - maybe I should try again.
Led Zeppelin - DVD
Fancy several hours of Valhalla-endorsed majesty from Percy and pals? Then this is for you...
Still think they should have called it...
'Videos from Valhalla'...
Talking Heads - Stop Making Sense
Simply sublime. I love pretty much everything about it; the camera work, the structure of the show (starts with Byrne alone on the stage with a tape player and acoustic guitar, ends with 9 other members playing their hearts out), the lively performances, and of course the music (big Heads fan me).
Top notch.
A Few Favourites
Radiohead - Metting People Is Easy - makes me glad I'm not in the most critically acclaimed band in the world.
Scott Walker - 30 Century Man - A brilliant doc that reveals a lot about the man.
Joy Division - Joy Division - Probably the best rock doc I have ever seen.
Talk Talk - Live at Montreaux - recently acquired from Play for just 8 quid. Truly stunning. It's a crime that this band were so underrated. I really wish they'd get back together.
The Monkees - Head - If this one can count. It's like an extended weird psychedelic promo video.
Frank Zappa - 200 Motels - Just plain bizarre.
I loved Meeting People Is Easy when it first came out...
but I'm not sure it's worn particularly well... it's a bit moany! And here speaks someone who loves Radiohead's music more than any other on this here planet.
But the sequence in which Scott Walker's On Your Own Again is playing and (I think I'm right in saying) a fly is crawling on a window pane is absolutely beautiful and truly a work of art.
Festival Express
The Band, Buddy Guy, Janis Joplin and The Grateful Dead drinking and playing their way across Canada by train.
Imagine pitching that today.
Peter Gabriel Play
Shadows and light
is one I've revisited a few times (love the original album). See
Amelia
and Pat (Metheny's) Solo
for the flavour-if you don't like these you probably won't like the rest ...
A few weeks back we were discussing...
...Jaco's solo from this film.
Jaco
Thanks for gentle hint ... will look back. It was this film, shown in an OGWT special week in Autumn 1980 that introduced me to Metheny, and spurred my interest in JM. A great week as I recall.
Music on video/dvd
..doesn't really work that well for me. I have quite a few but rarely watch them, eg Neil Young's Heart Of Gold - I haven't even got to the end, but it was only £5. The better ones include Bruce Springsteen Live In New York, Symphonic Yes and Genesis Lamb Lies Down On Broadway.
Chrissie Hynde,
really enjoyed Sylvia Paterson's interview in the magazine. Anyone know of any books written about/by Chrissie and/or The Pretenders? Google search came up empty handed. Just with such a history and varied line up within the band I thought someone would have got it all down on paper by now.