Entertainment For Lively Minds

Word RSS FeedsWord Magazine on YouTubeWord Magazine on Last FMWord Spotify PlaylistsWord Magazine on FacebookWord Magazine on Twitter

Lynn Barber's "An Education": I smell a rat

Richard Lowe's picture

My daughter and her friends are all over My Education and all went to see the film and are now passing round the book and panting for the DVD to come out.
I've just read it. It doesn't ring true. It just doesn't add up. I smell a rat.
I like Lynn Barber and think she's a really good journalist/interviewer, not least because if you read about someone she's encountered you get quite a vivid flavour of them: their appearance, mannerisms etc. But not about this man she claims to have had this weird affair with, approved of and encouraged by her parents; the man who whisked her off for dirty weekends all over the shop; the man who, when she thought about it (or is that "it up") forty odd years later had such a profound influence on her life; the man who wound up in prison (where? when? convicted for what exactly?) but came out just in time to take her to tea in Oxford with her boyfriend.
"Yeah ... right" as the modern girls would say. They're lapping it up though.
Anyone else read it? Am I now so riddled with rancid cynicism that I'm the only one who didn't buy it?

0

An editor

once told me that, by her reckoning, at least half of all memoirs are fictionalised, or at best embellished - just to make them saleable.

0
Prestonia | 17 March 2010 - 6:37pm

Not seen the film

But I read Piers Morgan's Diaries and they read to me like they'd all been written in one session. And I have known hacks who were famous for always getting really good interviews. I'm not saying they made a lot of it up but, well, they could have. If you keep off the controversial stuff and make the interviewee sound witty, nobody's going to argue.

0
David Hepworth | 17 March 2010 - 7:11pm

The dvd is out

At least I was given a copy on my birthday yesterday by a friend who knew that I enjoyed the book (worth the cover price for the descriptionof her mother's elocution lessons alone).

0
Gatz | 17 March 2010 - 9:44pm
Privacy Statement    ©  2006 - 2012 Development Hell Ltd