As sort of an antidote to the traditionally testosterone filled best of lists, Wears the Trousers Magazine have come up with 100 best albums by women in the 00s. Some interesting inclusions and omissions:
other nominations:
KT Tunstall - Eye To The Telescope
Lily Allen - Alright Still
Robert Plant & Alison Krauss - Raising Sand (ignoring the fact that Bobs a bloke)
And I'm fully prepared for the derision, laughter and generally being ignored, but I did quite like ...
the first Dido album
You're right. The Unthanks probably should have been in there somewhere. Nice to see someone liking Little Jackie too. Imani Coppola is such an underrated performer.
I think there is better to come from El Perro Del Mar, and probably Lisa Hannigan too.
Have only had a quick squint at the list, but personally I thought Ys was terrible, and why pick PJ Harvey's least interesting album for the top 10? The marvellous Uh Huh Her is head and shoulders above "Stories From The City..."
to me, Uh Huh Her is PJ's weakest album by far. We didn't even discuss it at the panel meeting! Stories is by no means perfect (I personally prefer White Chalk) but it was such a bold record for her to make, especially as she clearly had no intention of ever making another album like it.
but if we're talking her entire catalogue, Is This Desire? is my favourite. I love the third-person narratives, the inspiration she took from Flannery O'Connor's stories of Southern hardship, the artwork. Everything. Powerful in a whole other way from the likes of Rid Of Me.
And one of them (Portishead) is questionable whether it should count.
(The others are Kate Bush's Ariel - which despite many others' comments I still find too winsome and insubstantial - and Juana Molina - who is excellent in the quirky way Kate used to be).
PS Reminded me of a joke headline I saw the other day - "kd lang changes name to KD Lang").
e.g. does an album by Portishead count as "an album by a woman"? Do they just mean woman singers? Anyway, my two penn'orth
The inclusion of Effluence and the Latrine is a travesty that shall never be forgotten and I'd have liked to have seen:
Amanda Palmer - Who Killed Amanda Palmer?
Charlotte Gainsbourg - 5:55
Amy Winehouse - Frank (better than Back to Black IMHO)
Isobel Campbell and Mark Lanegan - Ballad of the Broken Seas (if Rigid Digit can nominate Plant/Krauss, I'm nominating this)
She and Him - Volume One (actress Zooey Deschanel's band - a far better idea than it sounds)
CSS - CSS
Camera Obscura - Let's Get Out of this Country
St. Vincent - Actor (better than the one they included, I reckon)
The Go! Team - Thunder, Lightning, Strike (if they count as a "woman" band)
I actually only discovered Siouxsie recently via her 'Last Manta Ray' (edited video version from her KoKo gigs in 2008, on Sky Arts 1) around October last year. By Gawd that woman is a performer! I dug into the Banshees' content on Spotty and boy did I missed out!
A few duffers along the way but the highs outweigh the lows.
Through The Looking Glass - a covers record. Absolutely brilliant.
The Creatures are great too (just Siouxsie and Budgie).
Careful on Spotify - there are other Creatures & they ain't Siouxsie!!
(I was a teenage Cure fan, almost a Goth, but never quite had the cheekbones or the pallor for it...)
Roisin Murphy
Goldfrapp and
Yeah Yeah Yeahs for me especially. Robyn's another one.
Would agree with poster who mentioned Shakira, Girls Aloud and Lady Ga Ga (come round to appreciate the latter lately).
But Florence and The Machine - why do people rate that? It's beyond me. What an unpleasant, droning, poor singing voice and otherwise unremarkable music.
Generally though women are outdoing the guys musically of late I would say for invention, imagination, interest.
I've got about a fifth of the list. Personally my absolute favourite is Aimee Mann's Batchelor no. 2. I've been trying to love Joanna Newsome for years but I just can't get past her voice...
is on the list :) Top 30 no less! Marissa is wonderful. She recorded a gorgeous cover of 'All My Trials' for our recent compilation album, a tribute to Odetta.
HOWEVER, that never stops me from making a little list. I've watched "High Fidelity" far too much in the past few months to ignore list making as a valid pastime.
no particular order, but these are superb:
Gemma Hayes - The Roads Don't Love You
Gemma Hayes - The Hollow Of Morning
Bjork - Vespertine
All Saints - Studio 1
Amiina - Kurr
Bat For Lashes - Fur And Gold
Buffalo Daughter - I
Camille - Le Fil
Eileen Rose - Long Shot Novena
Emiliana Torrini - Fisherman's Woman
Feist - Let It Die
Hafdis Huld - Dirty Paper Cup
Karine Polwart - Faultlines
Lady Sovereign - Public Warning
Lily Allen - Alright, Still
Little Jackie - The Stoop
Martina Topley-Bird - The Blue God
Regina Spektor - Soviet Kitsch
Scarlett Johannsson - Anywhere I Lay My Head
Tanya Donelly - Beautysleep
The rest of my music is either a mix or mainly man made music.
The Best 5 from the above actually in order of preference:
1. Gemma Hayes - The Hollow Of Morning
2. Buffalo Daughter - I
3. Scarlett Johannsson - Anywhere I Lay My Head
4. Lady Sovereign - Public Warning
5. Bjork - Vespertine
Possibly, but is gender any more arbitrary a way of classifying music than alphabetically/ chronologically/ genre/ etc? We all love a list here, and this is just another such.
I would love an all-female list not to be necessary, but as a way of redressing the balance it is perhaps useful. And on "normal" lists women are few and far between, but of course maybe that is just because the music is genuinely not up to scratch...
Hannah said further up that she owned about a fifth of the list - I'm not sure I'd heard of that many. So reading this has raised my awareness, and who knows, perhaps will lead to me finding some great new music.
Yep. I've literally got everything she's released. I think she's superb. I bought the "4:35am" Ep the day it came out, having heard the track "Gotta Low" on an UNCUT free CD. Whilst I do really like the first album, I don't think it's up there as one of the best of the decade sadly, though some of the songs ("My God" in particular) are great.
Have you heard the "Oliver" EP that she released in 2009? That's worth getting as well. It's a few out-takes and is pretty much just her and a guitar, and as such can make grown men cry.
The Irish ones are always really underrated. For example. Damien Rice - superb talent. Largely ignored. Glen Hansard / The Frames - some of the best songs of the last 15 years. And has anyone heard of them other than the people that have watched "Once"? Not bloody likely. If you haven't heard anything by the Frames, then do check them out (and the "Once" soundtrack), as I think you'd really like them.
Definitely. It's a superb album. Mellow. Uplifting. Experimental. And short for those with a limited attention span. Plus Kevin Shields from My Bloody Valentine plays on it. And she's beautiful on the cover. It's a great album.
of the 4:35am and Work to a calm eps, followed by the first LP Night on My side, so would recommend that way in. Unfortunately, I don't seem to have had time to do justice to The Hollow of Morning yet....
I absolutely don't think that this list, or our magazine (which is entirely devoted to women in music), is condescending. People tell me that it's sexist. I say, yes, but at least it's up-front sexism rather than the insidious, institutionalised sexism that runs through almost every part of the music industry. A list like this is totally necessary when other end-of-decade lists barely contain 15-20% women artists. I don't think there is anything wrong with challenging that status quo with a publication like ours. It's a complicated issue, agreed, but that's how I see it.
GauntletGirl pointed me in this direction on Twitter and encouraged me to chip in, so here I am. Word is pretty much the only mainstream music magazine I bother with these days, so it feels like home already.
It just seemed to be a case of "look, women can make music as well as cakes and flower arrangements - well done to them!"
But I totally agree that there is a drastic imbalance in the music industry. Why is it always the male dominated bands and singer songwriters that get properly hyped, and when the women do its said with a degree of surprise (as Florence et al were last year).
But it is interesting that when you think of female performers you think of folk singers or pop singers. Hardly ever anything other than that. I suppose that's why I enjoy Buffalo Daughter and Lady Sovereign so much. They're going in the face of convention. And that is to be praised.
They appear to be limiting it to one album / artist and while I think Bachelor No 2 is Aimee Mann's best I'd like to have seen Lost In Space and The Forgotten arm there.
Nothing by Anne McCue, but I'd have thought Roll deserved to be there and Koala Motel would be a contender.
Neither of Caitlin Cary's albums, While You Weren't Looking and I'm Staying Out, feature and if Beth Gibbons and Rustin Man can feature the magnificent Begonias from Caitlin and Thad Cockrell should be there.
I'g have picked Patty Griffin's Impossible Dream ahead of 1,000 Kisses.
There's nothing by Tift Merritt but either Tambourine or Another Country deserve to be there.
Natalie Merchant's Motherland deserves a place.
World Without Tears is the correct choice by Lucinda Williams but West also deserves to be in there.
I'd have picked Rules Of Travel ahead of Rosanne Cash's Black Cadillac.
Unbelievably nothing by Kathleen Edwards. All three deserve to be in there, but I'd have settled for Asking For Flowers.
The Dixie Chicks - How can they ignore Home or Taking The Long Way?
Red Dirt Girl is probably the best Emmylou Harris album of the decade but I'm very partial to Stumble Into Grace too.
Suzy Bogguss's Sweet Danger is a notable omission from a fabuous singer.
Gretchen Peter's albums Halcyon and Burnt Toast & Offerings are worthy contenders.
Somebody else above mentioned The Greatest by Cat Power. I second that one.
Eileen Rose's Long Shot Novena and At Our Tables and probably Come the Storm as well.
I'll finish off by noting the omission of Nothing But The Truth by Eve Selis
I tried to get more country artists in the list but was ganged up on. I'm surprised you didn't list the Loretta Lynn album. REALLY wanted that in there. I love the Eileen Rose, Kathleen Edwards, Natalie Merchant, Tift Merritt and Caitlin Cary albums you mentioned. We've interviewed Eileen and Tift before. Posting a chat with Allison Moorer next week, which you might be interested in.
I've got 25 of the 100. I think it's a fascinating list, there's a lot of stuff there I'm now going to investigate, like My Brightest Diamond - having been impressed with Shara Worden when she guested with the Decemberists.
I don't find the idea of the list at all patronising; and to clarify, the intro states that they're looking at albums by solo female artists, or bands fronted by women. There's no shortage of good stuff, and a quick glance through my collection reveals loads of tremendous stuff not included in the list. Such as:
An Equal Love - Christine Collister -greatest singer in the UK, blah blah
Cara Dillon - beautiful and fresh
The Joy of Sing-Sing - Sing-Sing - storming album from former Lush guitarist Emma Anderson and singer Lisa O'Neil
Trampin' - Patti Smith - Still got it
Underdog Victorious - Jill Sobule - it's perfect
A Girl Called Eddy - it's even more perfect
Peddlin' Dreams - Maria McKee - great talent finally hits the bullseye
Frank - Amy Winehouse - I've said it before...
Tale To Tell - The Mummers - Bjork without computers?
Choreography - Lauren Hoffman - A lot of people would love her if they heard her
The Roads Don't Love You - Gemma Hayes - already mentioned above, it's a classic
Nobody's Sweetheart - Sandy Dillon - Out of heartbreak comes great art
A Distant Bell - Caroline Lavelle - almost certainly the best singer/songwriter/cellist in the land
Nolita - Keren Ann - Full of mystery and magic
Clocks and Clouds - Rosie Brown - sensuous voice, gorgeous songs
Children Running Through - Patti Griffin - what a voice!
Kate Rodgers v Grand Central - one of the sweetest voices I've heard in years.
Leave To Remain - Kathryn Williams
Love Tattoo - Imelda May
The Beth Gibbons\ Rustin Man is bloody gorgeous
La Bush - Ariel
Ladyhawke
PJH - either the recent one with John Parrish or Uh Huh Her
The Unthanks - Here The Tender Coming
How could I forget the wonderful Ladyhawke? And also I'd mention (again) Where Rivers Meet by Kiki Dee and Carmelo Luggieri. Then there's the second Joan As Policewoman album, which I think is even better than the first.
I have 26 but wish I had 24 as I own both the Joanna Newsom albums but havent found anything worthwhile to do with them yet. In the olden days you could melt vinyl into interesting shapes.Any other creative ideas.
Not on the list but from last year I would add the Gretchen Peters album One from the heart, one from the head and also the Candi Staton album whose title I cannot recall.
... I only have twelve of these. Not terribly good is it? Was hoping to get all righteous about Mavis Staples as well only to find her on the list. And Nina Nastasia. Oh well. Whither Eliza Carthy and Anglicana though? Great album that.
I will say though, when I was young (and even more sexist than I am now obviously) accoustically inclined female singer songwriters were to be avoided. The sheer awfulness of Joni Mitchell's "Coyote" as heard on The Last Waltz had a truly negative effect on me which, I must confess, to this day, I'm still trying to shift. And I bought about five Joni Mitchell albums in a vain attempt to like her.
I wasn't exactly bowled over by her first, though it was never hard to listen to; and I love Like A Star. As you may know, she's suffered a personal tragedy (husband died of an accidental overdose) since then, and the second album is freighted with the repercussions of that, from what I've heard and read. Certainly, I was massively impressed when she appeared on Later a month or two ago. The first song she played, in particular, was stunning. And I recently heard another new song on the radio, also excellent. I think she might be about to move up a rung or two.
Really looking forward to hearing The Sea. Should hopefully get the promo this week. I think it will be a thousand times better than the debut, which had some lovely tracks but way too much filler.
Although it seems like an odd idea in this age to to be listing an artform by gender rather than genre but the voice is an instrument and so it's not really any different to listing best guitar albums. So here's my list
Girls & Boys - Ingrid Michaelson
Keep Your Silver Shined - Devon Sproule
The Sugar Tree - Amy Rigby
Seven Angels on a Bicycle - Carrie Rodriguez
Grey Will Fade - Charlotte Hatherley
Not The Tremblin Kind - Laura Cantrell
I'd also put a Black Box Recorder album on the list (but I don;t know which one) and I'm surprised Lily Allen isn't listed but it may be due to it being and American list.
for Carrie Rodriguez - love her albums with Chip Taylor - is the solo stuff equally as good? Laura Cantrell is also great but it seems a long time since she released anything - was her last album in noughties?
CR's first solo album has a lot of Chip Taylor involvement so is a natural progression and excellent for it. The most recent album is slightly different and I think it's weaker for it but it retains a healthy amount of fiddling. Both albums are available to listen to in full as streams from her website (click on Media Player).
It does seem a long time since the last Laura Cantrell album ... because it is, only an EP in the last 5 years but all her albums were released in the Naughties so I could have picked any one of them. I think she's been taking time off to start a family.
got kicked off the list at the final hurdle. I fought hard for that album but was outvoted. As for Keren Ann, she was a fairly early casualty in the cull. Unfairly early, probably.
I love both the A Camp records but neither was really in contention. Colonia was on our best of 2009 list though.
Despite the fact that she only passed away a few days ago and I wrote of my love for her music, I forgot to include The Living Road in my list. Poor, Crowther, very poor.
My favourites from the list would probably be Kate Bush, Emmylou Harris and Marissa Nadler.
Good to see lots of 'world' and 'folk/roots' on there, but puzzled by the list appearing to overlook jazz (unless I missed it): would've been good to see a vocalist like Claire Martin or Viktoria Tolstoy feature, or a gifted pianist like Geri Allen or Hiromi.
I agree that the inclusion of female-fronted bands is perhaps a bit odd, in itself. The voice isn't everything. It made me think of how vital Rennie Sparks's contribution to the Handsome Family is, even though she rarely takes a lead vocal.
You're right, our list completely overlooked many wonderful jazz artists. At the moment we don't have any real jazz enthusiasts on our writing team, which is something I ought to look at fixing for 2010.
My jazz tastes are fairly limited to what comes out of Scandinavia. In retrospect, I would have liked to have had Solveig Slettahjell and Silje Nergaard on the list. And maybe Lisa Ekdahl's latest. Going to check out Viktoria Tolstoy and Geri Allen now, thanks.
We did have a bit of a debate about including female-fronted bands, and while we all agreed that an end-of-decade list without Yeah Yeah Yeahs would be silly, some of the panel were a little uneasy with including Portishead. I can see why but kinda steamrolled over it at the time. One to consider for next time I think.
Interesting list, nice to see Shena Ringo get a mention though 'the Japanese Bjork' tag is a cliche (and wrong, I reckon - Ms Shena is much more conventional).
However the text in the list is wrong. The title Heisei Fuuzoku translates as Japanese Manners according to Wikipedia - the album your writer is getting confused with is Karuki Zaamen Kuri no Hana which translates as Lime, Semen, Chestnut Blossoms - they all smell the same, apparently.
I've just been listening to this, recently downloaded from emusic. It's marvellous: fresh, idiosyncratic, beautifully sung, played and arranged. Anyone else here discovered what Shara Worden's day job is?
Sheryl Crow - Detours. I may be alone here in my appreciation for La Crow, but I routinely love her stuff. Detours is one of my favourites of the last couple of years from anybody.
There were a lot of good albums by French female singers in the last decade. My favourite was "Bye Bye Beaute" by Coralie Clement, but there was also stuff by Keren Ann and Colleen among others.
Ladies? Making records?
Whatever next!
You'll be telling me a woman will be prime minister one day!
Jenny Lewis - Rabbit Fur Coat
A Camp - Colonia
Would be my first two thoughts...
My Best would be:
Kate Bush - Aerial
other nominations:
KT Tunstall - Eye To The Telescope
Lily Allen - Alright Still
Robert Plant & Alison Krauss - Raising Sand (ignoring the fact that Bobs a bloke)
And I'm fully prepared for the derision, laughter and generally being ignored, but I did quite like ...
the first Dido album
I think...
...they got the number 1 spot on.
And No.2...
...as well. Vespertine is rather good (or should that be genius, breathtaking, etc.,)
I haven't really thought this through properly yet
but I'd definitely have Liz Phair's eponymous album on my list.
Amy
Back To Black
Easy to overlook what a great musician she is.
some good ones
trailer Park - Beth Orton
Milk-Eyed Mender - Joanna Newsom
Ingenue - k d Lang
Sensual World - Kate Bush
Most anything by Laura Nyro, but Gonna Take a Miracle is a good starting point
WOOPS just noticed this was the noughties, soz
The Greatest - Cat Power
album title says it all
You can't mistake my biology
OK, in addition to the excellent suggestions above I'd like to add
'Chemistry' - Girls Aloud
'The Fame Monster'- Lady Gaga
'Sol Angel & The Hadley Street Dreams- Solange
'Seventh Tree' - Goldfrapp
'She Wolf' - Shakira
Where are the Unthanks in this list??
My favourites have been;
Erykah Badu
Amy W
Little Jackie
Lisa Hannigan
El Perro del Mar
Our Broken Garden
Unthankless
You're right. The Unthanks probably should have been in there somewhere. Nice to see someone liking Little Jackie too. Imani Coppola is such an underrated performer.
I think there is better to come from El Perro Del Mar, and probably Lisa Hannigan too.
No
Have only had a quick squint at the list, but personally I thought Ys was terrible, and why pick PJ Harvey's least interesting album for the top 10? The marvellous Uh Huh Her is head and shoulders above "Stories From The City..."
really?
to me, Uh Huh Her is PJ's weakest album by far. We didn't even discuss it at the panel meeting! Stories is by no means perfect (I personally prefer White Chalk) but it was such a bold record for her to make, especially as she clearly had no intention of ever making another album like it.
I can't even go there re: Joanna!
I always meant
to give Stories....another go, so perhaps I will...!
Not sure she has ever topped the power and originality of the first two albums though...
Perhaps
but if we're talking her entire catalogue, Is This Desire? is my favourite. I love the third-person narratives, the inspiration she took from Flannery O'Connor's stories of Southern hardship, the artwork. Everything. Powerful in a whole other way from the likes of Rid Of Me.
Is ThiS Desire
Blimey, had forgotten how much I enjoyed that one when it came out. Must dust off those LPs again...
I've got a grand total of 3 of these albums
And one of them (Portishead) is questionable whether it should count.
(The others are Kate Bush's Ariel - which despite many others' comments I still find too winsome and insubstantial - and Juana Molina - who is excellent in the quirky way Kate used to be).
PS Reminded me of a joke headline I saw the other day - "kd lang changes name to KD Lang").
Some sketchy criteria there...
e.g. does an album by Portishead count as "an album by a woman"? Do they just mean woman singers? Anyway, my two penn'orth
The inclusion of Effluence and the Latrine is a travesty that shall never be forgotten and I'd have liked to have seen:
Amanda Palmer - Who Killed Amanda Palmer?
Charlotte Gainsbourg - 5:55
Amy Winehouse - Frank (better than Back to Black IMHO)
Isobel Campbell and Mark Lanegan - Ballad of the Broken Seas (if Rigid Digit can nominate Plant/Krauss, I'm nominating this)
She and Him - Volume One (actress Zooey Deschanel's band - a far better idea than it sounds)
CSS - CSS
Camera Obscura - Let's Get Out of this Country
St. Vincent - Actor (better than the one they included, I reckon)
The Go! Team - Thunder, Lightning, Strike (if they count as a "woman" band)
15 out of 100
Not great. Mind you, some notable absences, including other LPs by PJH, MIA, and Gillian Welch which would have boosted my score somewhat...
an auld 'Trad' Goth writes
I actually only discovered Siouxsie recently via her 'Last Manta Ray' (edited video version from her KoKo gigs in 2008, on Sky Arts 1) around October last year. By Gawd that woman is a performer! I dug into the Banshees' content on Spotty and boy did I missed out!
A few duffers along the way but the highs outweigh the lows.
check Hyena with Robert Smith on geetar
My fave of theirs is -
Through The Looking Glass - a covers record. Absolutely brilliant.
The Creatures are great too (just Siouxsie and Budgie).
Careful on Spotify - there are other Creatures & they ain't Siouxsie!!
(I was a teenage Cure fan, almost a Goth, but never quite had the cheekbones or the pallor for it...)
cheekbones
never had them either, didn't stop me
Eeeewww Lordi I had some great times and Goth chicks just look thee best! :D
That...
...they do. :-)
I've still got a crush on Siouxsie.
Six I've loved have been...
Joni Mitchell - Both Sides Now (2000)
PJ Harvey - Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea (2000)
Gillian Welch - Time the Revelator (2001)
Lhasa - The Living Road (2004)
Kate Bush - Aerial (2005)
The Unthanks - Here's the Tender Coming (2009)
Some good things there
Roisin Murphy
Goldfrapp and
Yeah Yeah Yeahs for me especially. Robyn's another one.
Would agree with poster who mentioned Shakira, Girls Aloud and Lady Ga Ga (come round to appreciate the latter lately).
But Florence and The Machine - why do people rate that? It's beyond me. What an unpleasant, droning, poor singing voice and otherwise unremarkable music.
Generally though women are outdoing the guys musically of late I would say for invention, imagination, interest.
All of the Goldfraap albums - marvellous music and varied styles
Interesting link, thanks.
I've got about a fifth of the list. Personally my absolute favourite is Aimee Mann's Batchelor no. 2. I've been trying to love Joanna Newsome for years but I just can't get past her voice...
Marissa Nadler
At least one of her albums deserves to be on the list - possibly Songs III or The Saga Of Mayflower May.
She is an amazing talent.
Songs III
is on the list :) Top 30 no less! Marissa is wonderful. She recorded a gorgeous cover of 'All My Trials' for our recent compilation album, a tribute to Odetta.
Spotify it, it's lovely: http://open.spotify.com/album/43Y4V0Ij3KazZTRAkAs9b8
not going to read top 100
I'm feeling a bit bunged up and I can't be arsed
and I also feel the idea is a bit condescending.
HOWEVER, that never stops me from making a little list. I've watched "High Fidelity" far too much in the past few months to ignore list making as a valid pastime.
no particular order, but these are superb:
Gemma Hayes - The Roads Don't Love You
Gemma Hayes - The Hollow Of Morning
Bjork - Vespertine
All Saints - Studio 1
Amiina - Kurr
Bat For Lashes - Fur And Gold
Buffalo Daughter - I
Camille - Le Fil
Eileen Rose - Long Shot Novena
Emiliana Torrini - Fisherman's Woman
Feist - Let It Die
Hafdis Huld - Dirty Paper Cup
Karine Polwart - Faultlines
Lady Sovereign - Public Warning
Lily Allen - Alright, Still
Little Jackie - The Stoop
Martina Topley-Bird - The Blue God
Regina Spektor - Soviet Kitsch
Scarlett Johannsson - Anywhere I Lay My Head
Tanya Donelly - Beautysleep
The rest of my music is either a mix or mainly man made music.
The Best 5 from the above actually in order of preference:
1. Gemma Hayes - The Hollow Of Morning
2. Buffalo Daughter - I
3. Scarlett Johannsson - Anywhere I Lay My Head
4. Lady Sovereign - Public Warning
5. Bjork - Vespertine
Lovely stuff.
Condescending?
Possibly, but is gender any more arbitrary a way of classifying music than alphabetically/ chronologically/ genre/ etc? We all love a list here, and this is just another such.
I would love an all-female list not to be necessary, but as a way of redressing the balance it is perhaps useful. And on "normal" lists women are few and far between, but of course maybe that is just because the music is genuinely not up to scratch...
Hannah said further up that she owned about a fifth of the list - I'm not sure I'd heard of that many. So reading this has raised my awareness, and who knows, perhaps will lead to me finding some great new music.
Gemma Hayes!
Have you got the "4:35am" and "Work to a calm" EPS? Superb!! Also the "Night is on my side" Lp - fantastic talent...
Hayes-aholic
Yep. I've literally got everything she's released. I think she's superb. I bought the "4:35am" Ep the day it came out, having heard the track "Gotta Low" on an UNCUT free CD. Whilst I do really like the first album, I don't think it's up there as one of the best of the decade sadly, though some of the songs ("My God" in particular) are great.
Have you heard the "Oliver" EP that she released in 2009? That's worth getting as well. It's a few out-takes and is pretty much just her and a guitar, and as such can make grown men cry.
The Irish ones are always really underrated. For example. Damien Rice - superb talent. Largely ignored. Glen Hansard / The Frames - some of the best songs of the last 15 years. And has anyone heard of them other than the people that have watched "Once"? Not bloody likely. If you haven't heard anything by the Frames, then do check them out (and the "Once" soundtrack), as I think you'd really like them.
Thanks
for the tips Badger. Will look out for that Ep and give The Frames a go too...
Oliver
I think it was iTunes only. So look there, if not I'm sure someone's put it up illegally somewhere. Not that I condone that sort of activity.
Looks like as you say
According to her official website...
http://www.gemmahayes.com/music.htm
Been meaning to check out Gemma Hayes for ages
and you've convinced me to do it. But given that I loathe and detest iTunes, could you kindly recommend another of her albums to start with??
The Hollow of Morning
Definitely. It's a superb album. Mellow. Uplifting. Experimental. And short for those with a limited attention span. Plus Kevin Shields from My Bloody Valentine plays on it. And she's beautiful on the cover. It's a great album.
Listen on spotify here if you have it:
http://open.spotify.com/album/2NM02tFSdUaS8kZX5HKe1K
I'm a big fan
of the 4:35am and Work to a calm eps, followed by the first LP Night on My side, so would recommend that way in. Unfortunately, I don't seem to have had time to do justice to The Hollow of Morning yet....
Brilliant!
Cheers muchly, your royal highness! I will definitely go check that out. (Yes I do have Spotify... don't know what I'd do without it)
Not condescending
I absolutely don't think that this list, or our magazine (which is entirely devoted to women in music), is condescending. People tell me that it's sexist. I say, yes, but at least it's up-front sexism rather than the insidious, institutionalised sexism that runs through almost every part of the music industry. A list like this is totally necessary when other end-of-decade lists barely contain 15-20% women artists. I don't think there is anything wrong with challenging that status quo with a publication like ours. It's a complicated issue, agreed, but that's how I see it.
Just to say...
I'm really glad you posted here Peapookachoo. Enjoyed reading all your posts in this thread!
Thanks!
GauntletGirl pointed me in this direction on Twitter and encouraged me to chip in, so here I am. Word is pretty much the only mainstream music magazine I bother with these days, so it feels like home already.
I did only say a bit
It just seemed to be a case of "look, women can make music as well as cakes and flower arrangements - well done to them!"
But I totally agree that there is a drastic imbalance in the music industry. Why is it always the male dominated bands and singer songwriters that get properly hyped, and when the women do its said with a degree of surprise (as Florence et al were last year).
But it is interesting that when you think of female performers you think of folk singers or pop singers. Hardly ever anything other than that. I suppose that's why I enjoy Buffalo Daughter and Lady Sovereign so much. They're going in the face of convention. And that is to be praised.
Some of my favourites missing
They appear to be limiting it to one album / artist and while I think Bachelor No 2 is Aimee Mann's best I'd like to have seen Lost In Space and The Forgotten arm there.
Nothing by Anne McCue, but I'd have thought Roll deserved to be there and Koala Motel would be a contender.
Neither of Caitlin Cary's albums, While You Weren't Looking and I'm Staying Out, feature and if Beth Gibbons and Rustin Man can feature the magnificent Begonias from Caitlin and Thad Cockrell should be there.
I'g have picked Patty Griffin's Impossible Dream ahead of 1,000 Kisses.
There's nothing by Tift Merritt but either Tambourine or Another Country deserve to be there.
Natalie Merchant's Motherland deserves a place.
World Without Tears is the correct choice by Lucinda Williams but West also deserves to be in there.
I'd have picked Rules Of Travel ahead of Rosanne Cash's Black Cadillac.
Unbelievably nothing by Kathleen Edwards. All three deserve to be in there, but I'd have settled for Asking For Flowers.
The Dixie Chicks - How can they ignore Home or Taking The Long Way?
Red Dirt Girl is probably the best Emmylou Harris album of the decade but I'm very partial to Stumble Into Grace too.
Suzy Bogguss's Sweet Danger is a notable omission from a fabuous singer.
Gretchen Peter's albums Halcyon and Burnt Toast & Offerings are worthy contenders.
Somebody else above mentioned The Greatest by Cat Power. I second that one.
Eileen Rose's Long Shot Novena and At Our Tables and probably Come the Storm as well.
I'll finish off by noting the omission of Nothing But The Truth by Eve Selis
country smackdown
I tried to get more country artists in the list but was ganged up on. I'm surprised you didn't list the Loretta Lynn album. REALLY wanted that in there. I love the Eileen Rose, Kathleen Edwards, Natalie Merchant, Tift Merritt and Caitlin Cary albums you mentioned. We've interviewed Eileen and Tift before. Posting a chat with Allison Moorer next week, which you might be interested in.
Great list
I've got 25 of the 100. I think it's a fascinating list, there's a lot of stuff there I'm now going to investigate, like My Brightest Diamond - having been impressed with Shara Worden when she guested with the Decemberists.
I don't find the idea of the list at all patronising; and to clarify, the intro states that they're looking at albums by solo female artists, or bands fronted by women. There's no shortage of good stuff, and a quick glance through my collection reveals loads of tremendous stuff not included in the list. Such as:
An Equal Love - Christine Collister -greatest singer in the UK, blah blah
Cara Dillon - beautiful and fresh
The Joy of Sing-Sing - Sing-Sing - storming album from former Lush guitarist Emma Anderson and singer Lisa O'Neil
Trampin' - Patti Smith - Still got it
Underdog Victorious - Jill Sobule - it's perfect
A Girl Called Eddy - it's even more perfect
Peddlin' Dreams - Maria McKee - great talent finally hits the bullseye
Frank - Amy Winehouse - I've said it before...
Tale To Tell - The Mummers - Bjork without computers?
Choreography - Lauren Hoffman - A lot of people would love her if they heard her
The Roads Don't Love You - Gemma Hayes - already mentioned above, it's a classic
Nobody's Sweetheart - Sandy Dillon - Out of heartbreak comes great art
A Distant Bell - Caroline Lavelle - almost certainly the best singer/songwriter/cellist in the land
Nolita - Keren Ann - Full of mystery and magic
Clocks and Clouds - Rosie Brown - sensuous voice, gorgeous songs
Children Running Through - Patti Griffin - what a voice!
Kate Rodgers v Grand Central - one of the sweetest voices I've heard in years.
There are surely more too.
Um
Leave To Remain - Kathryn Williams
Love Tattoo - Imelda May
The Beth Gibbons\ Rustin Man is bloody gorgeous
La Bush - Ariel
Ladyhawke
PJH - either the recent one with John Parrish or Uh Huh Her
The Unthanks - Here The Tender Coming
Damn!
How could I forget the wonderful Ladyhawke? And also I'd mention (again) Where Rivers Meet by Kiki Dee and Carmelo Luggieri. Then there's the second Joan As Policewoman album, which I think is even better than the first.
Another vote for Ladyhawke
She's entirely terrific.
Hello Saferide!
They are a splendid Scandinavian band, slightly skewed pop, heartwarming and heartrending in equal measure.
I can't access youtube from here but I commend them to The Massive and I'll add a link later.
And, of course, The Unthanks.
and The Donnas
I think I've played "Turn 21" more than "Spend The Night", but they're both good.
as promised : The Donnas
as promised : Hello Saferide
<3
I adore Hello Saferide. Both albums have been fantastic. You've inspired me to play 'Arjeplog' on loop, thanks!
and Petra Haden
Her all-vocal version of "The Who Sell Out" was great :
Don't Stop Believin' was magnificent, too.
and her album with Bill Frisell was also stunningly good.
No Electrelane?
Would have thought "No Shouts, No Calls" would be there, and maybe their first (Rock it to the Moon) as well.
Others, off the top of my head:
Imelda May - Love Tattoo
PJ Harvey - Uh Huh Her
Nancy Elizabeth - Battle + Victory
Sleater Kinney - One Beat
From the list
I have 26 but wish I had 24 as I own both the Joanna Newsom albums but havent found anything worthwhile to do with them yet. In the olden days you could melt vinyl into interesting shapes.Any other creative ideas.
Not on the list but from last year I would add the Gretchen Peters album One from the heart, one from the head and also the Candi Staton album whose title I cannot recall.
I appear to be a sexist pig
... I only have twelve of these. Not terribly good is it? Was hoping to get all righteous about Mavis Staples as well only to find her on the list. And Nina Nastasia. Oh well. Whither Eliza Carthy and Anglicana though? Great album that.
I will say though, when I was young (and even more sexist than I am now obviously) accoustically inclined female singer songwriters were to be avoided. The sheer awfulness of Joni Mitchell's "Coyote" as heard on The Last Waltz had a truly negative effect on me which, I must confess, to this day, I'm still trying to shift. And I bought about five Joni Mitchell albums in a vain attempt to like her.
I wouldn't worry too much...
I've only got 5.
Missing in action.
Glaring omission in my book:
the wonderful Corrine Bailey Rae.
I would also include:
Rickie Lee Jones - Balm in Gilead
Natacha Atlas - Ana Nina
Imelda Maye
Sinead O Connor - Throw down your arms.
CBR
Dull, I'm afraid.....
Watch out for the second album
I wasn't exactly bowled over by her first, though it was never hard to listen to; and I love Like A Star. As you may know, she's suffered a personal tragedy (husband died of an accidental overdose) since then, and the second album is freighted with the repercussions of that, from what I've heard and read. Certainly, I was massively impressed when she appeared on Later a month or two ago. The first song she played, in particular, was stunning. And I recently heard another new song on the radio, also excellent. I think she might be about to move up a rung or two.
CBR
Really looking forward to hearing The Sea. Should hopefully get the promo this week. I think it will be a thousand times better than the debut, which had some lovely tracks but way too much filler.
It's an instrument
Although it seems like an odd idea in this age to to be listing an artform by gender rather than genre but the voice is an instrument and so it's not really any different to listing best guitar albums. So here's my list
Girls & Boys - Ingrid Michaelson
Keep Your Silver Shined - Devon Sproule
The Sugar Tree - Amy Rigby
Seven Angels on a Bicycle - Carrie Rodriguez
Grey Will Fade - Charlotte Hatherley
Not The Tremblin Kind - Laura Cantrell
I'd also put a Black Box Recorder album on the list (but I don;t know which one) and I'm surprised Lily Allen isn't listed but it may be due to it being and American list.
I think....
...they're UK based.
Great shout
for Carrie Rodriguez - love her albums with Chip Taylor - is the solo stuff equally as good? Laura Cantrell is also great but it seems a long time since she released anything - was her last album in noughties?
Carrie Rodriguez very good shock
CR's first solo album has a lot of Chip Taylor involvement so is a natural progression and excellent for it. The most recent album is slightly different and I think it's weaker for it but it retains a healthy amount of fiddling. Both albums are available to listen to in full as streams from her website (click on Media Player).
It does seem a long time since the last Laura Cantrell album ... because it is, only an EP in the last 5 years but all her albums were released in the Naughties so I could have picked any one of them. I think she's been taking time off to start a family.
Whither Keren Ann's
Whither Keren Ann's Nolita?
Amiina's Kurr & A Camp's Colonia would also be high up in my list, but there are many others I'm pleased to see there.
Amiina
got kicked off the list at the final hurdle. I fought hard for that album but was outvoted. As for Keren Ann, she was a fairly early casualty in the cull. Unfairly early, probably.
I love both the A Camp records but neither was really in contention. Colonia was on our best of 2009 list though.
My vote goes to...
... "The Living Road" by the late, much missed Lhasa de Sela.
It was nice to see the Hildur Gudnadottír album in the list, though. Fine record.
Shame on me!
Despite the fact that she only passed away a few days ago and I wrote of my love for her music, I forgot to include The Living Road in my list. Poor, Crowther, very poor.
ERK!
I am horrified that we overlooked The Living Road for our end-of-decade list! Such a wonderful album. Such a tragic loss.
Sigh...
I only have 12 of these - lots to investigate.
My favourites from the list would probably be Kate Bush, Emmylou Harris and Marissa Nadler.
Good to see lots of 'world' and 'folk/roots' on there, but puzzled by the list appearing to overlook jazz (unless I missed it): would've been good to see a vocalist like Claire Martin or Viktoria Tolstoy feature, or a gifted pianist like Geri Allen or Hiromi.
I agree that the inclusion of female-fronted bands is perhaps a bit odd, in itself. The voice isn't everything. It made me think of how vital Rennie Sparks's contribution to the Handsome Family is, even though she rarely takes a lead vocal.
Excellent point(s)
You're right, our list completely overlooked many wonderful jazz artists. At the moment we don't have any real jazz enthusiasts on our writing team, which is something I ought to look at fixing for 2010.
My jazz tastes are fairly limited to what comes out of Scandinavia. In retrospect, I would have liked to have had Solveig Slettahjell and Silje Nergaard on the list. And maybe Lisa Ekdahl's latest. Going to check out Viktoria Tolstoy and Geri Allen now, thanks.
We did have a bit of a debate about including female-fronted bands, and while we all agreed that an end-of-decade list without Yeah Yeah Yeahs would be silly, some of the panel were a little uneasy with including Portishead. I can see why but kinda steamrolled over it at the time. One to consider for next time I think.
Shena Ringo
Interesting list, nice to see Shena Ringo get a mention though 'the Japanese Bjork' tag is a cliche (and wrong, I reckon - Ms Shena is much more conventional).
However the text in the list is wrong. The title Heisei Fuuzoku translates as Japanese Manners according to Wikipedia - the album your writer is getting confused with is Karuki Zaamen Kuri no Hana which translates as Lime, Semen, Chestnut Blossoms - they all smell the same, apparently.
oops
Thanks badartdog. I'll fix that! No doubt a result of too many late nights trying to get this damn thing finished.
nice looking mag, peapookachoo
- is it saddle stitched or perfect bound?
haha
saddle-stitched... shhhhh!
also
THANKS!
Carla Bley for one
Her album "The Lost Chords Find Paulo Frescu" was a lovely throughtful jazz album.
A review here : http://www.wattxtrawatt.com/review1.html
I just found out she released a Christmas album too - I'll need to hunt that down
No wonder the Lost Chords found Paolo Fresu...
... he had those loud orange trousers on:
... and yes, it's a very fine record. I saw Carla Bley and Steve Swallow in concert a few months ago. Absolutely terrific.
The Smoke Fairies..
let's not forget them after their October 2009 appearance on Now Hear This. Fantastic debut.
Thorny problem
Dave Alvin & The Guilty Women ??
A favourite of mine, but I guess it is the inverse of a record that would qualify, as it is a bloke fronting a band of women.
I think...
Tanya Donelly - Lovesongs For Underdogs
Beth Orton - Central Reservation
Lisa Hannigan - Sea Sew
Breaking news: My Brightest Diamond are fab
I've just been listening to this, recently downloaded from emusic. It's marvellous: fresh, idiosyncratic, beautifully sung, played and arranged. Anyone else here discovered what Shara Worden's day job is?
I'd add
Sheryl Crow - Detours. I may be alone here in my appreciation for La Crow, but I routinely love her stuff. Detours is one of my favourites of the last couple of years from anybody.
Les Femmes
There were a lot of good albums by French female singers in the last decade. My favourite was "Bye Bye Beaute" by Coralie Clement, but there was also stuff by Keren Ann and Colleen among others.