The law of exceptions

This one developed out of a discussion I had with my best mate a few months back.

Essentially, everyone has their favourites when it comes to music. Equally, we also have our bugbears, the ones we don't like; never did and never will. However, during the course of this tannin-fuelled chat, the two of us came to the realisation that we may dislike particular acts to quite alarming degrees. Nevertheless, we both had to admit that there would invariably be at least one track by a 'despised one' that we actually quite liked, really...

Time was this phenomenon would go under the heading of 'guilty pleasures', but I've never really got that one. Personally, if it does need to be used, then apply it to genres only, not particular artists.

Some examples? Sure:
The Osmonds - Crazy Horses (still no excuse for Jimmy Osmond, though)
Bucks Fizz - New Beginning (horribly 80's, but I just love the African/Adam and the Ants - style drums.)
Celine Dion - I'm Alive (the horse-faced one proves she can sing about matters other than love and its loss. Plus, she even sounds like she's enjoying herself.)
James Blunt - Wisemen (finally comes up with another emotion other than 'miserable obsessive')
Whitney Houston - It's Not Right, But It's OK (stops over-singing and learns that breathing in more than twice a minute is a good thing.)

And you know what? It works both ways. No, don't give me that; you know that there's plenty of horse apples dropped by even the best of them.
How about:
Lou Reed - Metal Machine Music (severe case of WTF if ever there was.)
Madness - Money, Money, Money (ill-judged ABBAmania band wagon jumping.)
Stevie Wonder - I Just Called To Say I Love You (mawkish mess. 'Nuff said.)
Peter Gabriel - Steam (sorry - didn't you already do 'Sledgehammer'?)
Aretha Franklin - Who's Zooming Who (the 80's weren't kind to many evergreens, were they?)

There are evens exceptions to this rule. I have yet to enjoy anything by Leona Lewis, or dislike owt by XTC - and I'm not expecting that to change.

I'm not expecting anyone to agree with me on these choices. Taste is always a personal thing. The thing is, though - I defy anyone out there to tell me there isn't a single example they can provide from their own musical tastes or collections that would prove this point.

Go on - I dare you.

Take That - Back for Good

One of the greatest pop songs ever written. Honest.

Also '....Baby One More Time' by Britney.

And the 'horse apples'...

'A Quick One' by The Who. Mini Rock Opera? No. Collection of half-baked ideas cobbled together around an embarrassing underage sex vignette? Oh yes.

'Psycho Street' by Richard Thompson.

Paul Waring | 9 April 2008 - 8:19am

..//..

Have to agree with 'Wisemen' by James Blunt. Heard that before he was big (on Mark Radcliffe show I think) and I thought it was excellent and that he was a kind of a British Bright Eyes.

I read on here a rumour that Barry Gibb had written 'Back for Good' and gave it to them in return for Take That covering 'How Deep Is Your Love'. Yes, BFG is an outstanding track.

My own examples include the Stereophonics 'Hurry Up and Wait' - I despise everything else those guys have done but love that track. Also Chris Rea's 'Stainsby Girls' - great song and I like nowt else by him. I adore REM but can't see anything in 'The Great Beyond' or 'Imitation of Life' and yet these are fixtures in any REM live set.

kb | 9 April 2008 - 9:31am

Therapy

I like One by U2. I'm so embarrased about it that I re-named the artist on my ipod as 'insufferable twats' in case anyone looked, which of course they never do.

I also like 'Writing To Reach You' by Travis.

Chimney Singing Crow | 9 April 2008 - 11:19am

I think Take That have had several moments

BFG is certainly one but also Patience, Never Forget and also (possibly lastly) Rule the World are also good quality pop songs.

Help Yourself by Tom Jones is alright by me as well.

Leedsboy | 9 April 2008 - 12:42pm

But, sticking with Tom Jones...

....why is it that when even the Burritos cover Green Green Grass of Home, it still sounds crap. If only because of the association. (I dare say if I had heard the Burritos first, I would be praising Boyo Jones.......)
But it isn't the clunker in the (proper, up to last of the Red Hots) Burritos canon, that is still Hippy Boy.
Sorry, I realise this is the diametric opposite of this threads request. Again.

Retropath2 | 9 April 2008 - 7:38pm

Additional...

I'm a fan of The Beautiful South and was sort of gutted when they split (but they'd started going soft). However, I can never for the life of me, understand just WHY 'Choke', their second album always makes it into the appropriate lists. I find it to be unlistenable tosh, apart from the singles and two of the album tracks.

Actually, I know precisely why it makes the grade; it contains their only number one song. Great, yes, but there's a lot better.

spikeyboy | 9 April 2008 - 9:28pm

here's a few off the top of my head

good by bad

backstreet's back - backstreet boys
the safety dance - men without hats
beautiful - christina agueliera

bad by good

delilah - queen
we suck young blood - radiohead
maxwell's silver hammer - beatles
the crunge - led zeppelin

lit doof | 22 April 2008 - 6:56pm

blimey...

I think I'll have to agree with all of those....

spikeyboy | 26 April 2008 - 4:21pm