Entertainment For Lively Minds

Word RSS FeedsWord Magazine on YouTubeWord Magazine on Last FMWord Magazine on Share My PlaylistsWord Spotify PlaylistsWord Magazine on FacebookWord Magazine on Twitter

John Terry / Anton Ferdinand Incident

Spartacus Mills's picture

Hot on the heels of the Suaraz / Evra controversy, England's skipper is being investigated by both The FA and The Fuzz for comments allegedly made to Anton Ferdinand, brother of his England colleague Rio.

Unlike the other case, there does appear to be clear video evidence, but Terry has apparently offered an explanation for the footage which, while a little convoluted, isn't completely implausible.

*If* Terry is found guilty, will he once again lose the captain's armband? Should he be dropped from the England set-up altogether?

0

If Terry is found guilty, Should he be dropped altogether?

*If* Terry is found guilty, will he once again lose the captain's armband? Should he be dropped from the England set-up altogether?

Yes, drop him like a stone.

Absolutely deffo.

2
jackthebiscuit | 25 October 2011 - 7:21pm

YEs

Yes, drop him.

Not because he is the most horrible man in football. (Takes some doing when you think about it) - But because he is no longer a very good defender. (see World Cup v Germany).

1
A lumberjack | 25 October 2011 - 7:35pm

Exactly

Was completely hopeless in that game, and has been pretty average since.

0
dai | 25 October 2011 - 7:51pm

If it can be proven

definately. Otherwise what message would it send out? Even if he was our best player (and I think previous posts have made that point clearly enough) there would be no case for him representing England again.

0
daddyclark | 25 October 2011 - 8:17pm

Should have been dropped

After the last World Cup for his little press conference.

In fact, he should have been shot.

This latest incident? His defence genuinely appears to be that he was shouting "Oi Anton.... I did NOT say [insert racist remark]." Seems fairly unlikely having seen the video.

I also think Villas Boas is a disgrace for coming out with support along the lines of "I'm surprised you people are so quick to question someone who represents you country". He's not the Queen Andre.

0
eminentdan1978 | 25 October 2011 - 8:57pm

I think this is just so much

sanctimonious claptrap. Footballers swear and call each other names during the heat of a game. Gosh. Who'd have thunk it, eh? I mean, you'll be telling me next they sometimes visit prostitutes. Or leave the scene of serious car crashes. Or have it away with someone who isn't their wife, and might be someone else's wife. Or illegally angle for transfers when they're still under contract to another club. Or get drunk in nightclubs. Or have one night stands with other single persons. Or drink drive.

Blimey, it's almost as though they're like so many us ordinary folks who aren't paid upwards of £60k a week and so don't seem to have to live their life by some other rather arbitrary and unrealistic standard.

Terry was a pillock (I've seen him quoted as shouting at Ferdinand that he hadn't called him the alleged phrase.) But you know what? When I played rugby to a reasonable standard I did, and would still, sledge anyone if I thought it would rile him and give me an advantage. So I deplore racism but I can't condemn Terry for what he may or may not have said. And I'd ask everyone here to seriously question whether they haven't, at some time, said or thought an equally racist thing in the heat of the moment.

4
Mark JF | 25 October 2011 - 9:00pm

Nope, can't agree with that

Use whatever language you like, call someone a c*nt or a pr*ck, question their parentage, inform them of the time you enjoyed carnal relations with their other half. I think the moment you bring race into it, it does become something different. If Terry did call Ferdinand a "black cunt", for me it is, unequivocally, worse with the racial element than it is without it.

You say "I deplore racism but I can't condemn Terry for what he may or may not have said." [my emphasis] Does that mean your sledging would extend to racist epithets?

17
Rosbif | 25 October 2011 - 9:53pm

At the end of the day,

any of the alternative insults you're proposing are sexist or demeaning or bullying and open to equally valid criticism. I'd love to live in a world where this sort of thing didn't happen but I know for sure I'm guilty of occasionally thinking these thoughts and muttering them under my breath. I suspect a great many other people are as well. It's rather like Jimmy Carter's "I've committed adultery in my heart many times" comment.

What I should have said is, "I deplore racism but I can't condemn Terry for what he may or may not have said in the heat of the moment." I wish he hadn't said it, I wish I never had similar thoughts sometimes and I wish we were all perfect. But I understand why young men, full of testosterone, playing a game of football sometimes do what Terry is alleged to have done.

1
Mark JF | 25 October 2011 - 10:20pm

I'm guessing here...

That you've not been racially abused. There is something uniquely wounding about it, and it comes freighted with a lot of history and hidden assumptions. I know this may sound like special pleading, and there it is. I've been called a "fucking cunt" before (in fact iwas called just that a few hours ago); I'd take that over "fucking Paki" any day of the week, and even more so when I was younger. Abusing someone racially shouldn't be tolerated, on the football field or anywhere else, and must not be explained away with "all in the heat of the moment" weasel words.

10
Rosbif | 25 October 2011 - 10:34pm

Actually, it doesn't happen that often on the pitch

I played football at quite a reasonable level for around 15-20 years and was only racially abused once. I asked the referee if he'd heard it (he was stood two yards away) He replied that he had and he would deal with it. It's a straight red card offence, but he chose not to do anything so my club ended up reporting the matter to the League. The referee got into quite a bit of trouble over it, as did the player involved, and his club were quite happy for us to take the action we did.

2
YTDS | 26 October 2011 - 12:27pm

I totally agree with you Rosbif

Racism is ugly and not acceptable. However I think Mark was very brave to say what he did. It was an honest assessment and I, for one, dont think there was any malice linked to it nor did it imply that he had racist tendencies. The heat of the moment brings out all sorts of comments that we dont really think in a normal state of mind. I have a female work colleague who if riled enough will come out with very spiteful remarks and very personal too. She is not vindictive in normal life,in fact quite the reverse. It is a defence mechanism. Having said all that I have no sympathy whatsoever for John Terry. He is a nasty, obnoxious twat and hopefully he will get what he deserves.
The sad thing about all of this is that we appeared to have really come a long way since the dark days of the seventies but these 2 incidents have tarnished our reputation for tolerance. I sincerely hope it will not reverse the good name we have in this respect compared to countries such as Spain, Italy, Poland etc.

0
Steve Turner | 26 October 2011 - 12:56pm

People do get carried away...

But if I publicly called someone a bl**k c**t in earshot of others at my place of work, I'd not expect my feet to touch the ground as they kicked me out the door, testosterone or not.

And I don't think it's that hard to distinguish thinking something awful and actually saying it out loud.

6
eminentdan1978 | 25 October 2011 - 10:38pm

Heat of the moment

Forgive me if I've misunderstood you, but in an earlier post you seemed to suggest that Terry's alleged remark constituted 'sledging' - a calculated attempt to wind-up an opponent, thus giving an advantage. Now you're you're dismissing it as a rash remark, spoken in the heat of the moment. It can't be both can it? What do you think the FA should do if the England captain is found guilt of racially abusing an opponent? Surely it'd send a pretty damning message if they did nothing.

6
Spartacus Mills | 25 October 2011 - 10:48pm

Call me a sandal-wearing leftie

But I like to think that people should be able to do their job without being racially abused.

9
Spartacus Mills | 25 October 2011 - 10:24pm

I've been playing competitive rugby

And refereeing for about 30-odd years now.

I'm not sure I ever remember racial slurs being used. I've heard just about everything else.

I cleared an entire College sideline because of homophobic slurs.

If I hear a player using a racist or homophobic slur, they'd be off. Like a shot. And as much for their own protection as the fact that they deserved it. Because in total honesty, if someone slotted him, I'd be VERY tempted to ignore it.

2
sitheref2409 | 26 October 2011 - 1:29pm

i have never

been racist.
each to their own eh.

as for Terry, he has previous with Ledley King

0
gaz | 27 October 2011 - 2:49pm

Right

John Terry has been since the day he beat up a door man with Dennis Wise a rancid sore on the fetid arse that is English football. He is beyond redemption, to hear his media trained platitudes in front of the camera while representing England sums up the worse excesses and smoke and mirrors state of the English game. He has possibly devalued the England shirt almost beyond recovery, I really would like to talk to Frank Lampard on his own and ask him "John Terry? What do you really think?" The generation of England players that Terry represents have destroyed English football for many of us, one of my truly great pleasures has become an incidental side show. David Beckham may be a simple clothes horse who had the tendency to be embarrassing while trying his damndest to the the best he could be but I long for the days when his handsome, smiling, honest, decent face represented my country and he could play, really play. John Terry was a decent centre back for a couple of seasons, he has never had pace or skill just a decent sense of position and a bravery probably linked to his stupidity. If he is not dealt with now by the FA, not the useless Capello, then it is a truly sad day when anything can be forgiven and another million children think it's ok to call someone a black cunt, for fucks sake!

44
Dave Amitri | 25 October 2011 - 11:16pm

Nail, head etc

2
fortuneight | 26 October 2011 - 11:06am

...to take a leaf out of the Dave Amitri book...

To pre-empt the FA's response, I believe the great Justin Currie has a song for this occasion - "Nothing Ever Happens".

0
Bamber | 26 October 2011 - 11:14am

Well said Dave...!

But it just goes to show the disgusting state of English football that he is still England captain after all the despicable things he has done. I won't support England until the last sorry dregs of scum like Terry and Ashley Cole are out of the national team for good.
What happened to Capello's so called hard line after the World Cup debacle? What do the pathetic spineless cretins at the FA do? Nothing! Their lack of discipline just fuels the egos of these sad (but very rich) fucks - Bramble, Tevez, Ferdinand, Rooney, the list goes on and on...

0
Retro Man | 26 October 2011 - 12:40pm

You'd have to assume

that the FA & Capello want to brush stuff under the carpet on the basis that such pond life are nonetheless (allegedly) talented pond life, and a win is a win, having morals doesn't get you cups etc

Terry's many indiscretions have been mostly off the pitch so they've attempted to argue it's what happens on the pitch that counts. Now it looks like something has.

I can see that Anton will be leant upon hard not to ruin a "fellow professionals" career. I'd like to think that one day Terry would get what's coming to him, but I'm not optimistic

2
fortuneight | 26 October 2011 - 1:05pm

Terry as a player.....

Ignoring all the horrible side shows around him, is just hugely average.

In fact he may well be luckiest man in the world. Having played alongside Franck LeBoeuf, Marcel Desailly, Ricardo Carvalho, Rio Ferdinand and Sol Campbell at Chelsea and with England over the years, he's had players that had both the pace and intelligence to cover his many many foibles. Put Terry next to Alex, Huth, Gallas or Ferreira and you saw a very very limited centre back. OOAA of course.

1
Six Dog | 27 October 2011 - 2:20pm

Spot on

and if he is found guilty (and to be fair I'm not 100% sure he is - he could have been calling AF a Blind C**t and I'm sure that will be his defence )he should be dropped by England - period - and if Chelsea had the bottle his contract would be torn up (it won't be, I know).

Has AF had anything to say and if not, why? He has a duty to the game (not to mention the wider community) to give his version - he won't because there're all in the same "clique". This will be covered up one way or another.It's not in anyone's interest (inside football) for this to carry on. JT is a complete "dick head" he happens to have been around at the right time to make serious money out of the "beautiful game" and I absolutely share your opinion that he and his like have ruined the game for many of us - sadly they will continue to be icons to the young and as you say it will be OK to say stuff like this because JT did.

1
Gooner1050 | 27 October 2011 - 6:39pm

Doorman incident

I think JT's confederate that day was Jody Morris.

0
Carl Parker | 31 October 2011 - 7:33pm

Not sure whether I'm allowed..

..to comment on football threads anymore without some sort of approval from the in-house sports editor.

Anyway - Terry should have the book thrown at him & certainly stripped of the England captaincy for the 2nd/3rd time ?

His defence is as shaky as Tevez's - although the support he gets from the UK football journalists is a joke - JT this & JT that - anyone who watched Sunday Supplement will know what I mean.

I also can't understand the "clear the air" chat with Ferdinand after the game. Be interesting to hear how this was played out - I hope it wasn't in someway a word with a threatening undertone - like don;t even think about complaining Anton - especially as it's being reported that they shook hand as and Terry thought the matter had been settled.

On a football level - think it's time for both Ferdinand Snr & Terry to move aside anyway - neither have performed to any sort of international standard for at least 2 years.

1
the mvps | 26 October 2011 - 11:21am

This is awkward

in that if he is found guilty he definitely should be expelled from the England set up at least for a period of time. But this Anton Ferdinand what is he like? If he has played the race card when people who know him, have played with him know that he is no saint himself then they will be annoyed and it will split the dressing room.

If it's out and out unprovoked racism - unlikely - then simple to sort out, if it's a slagging match that got out of hand then the press should not stir things up.

0
niscum | 26 October 2011 - 11:44am

'the race card'

I dislike that phrase, to be honest. If Anton Ferdinand believes he has been racially abused, he has every right to report it. As does Patrick Evra.

5
Spartacus Mills | 26 October 2011 - 11:55am

Anton Ferdinand didn't start it, I don't think

I think it was the YouTube video that started the furore and John Terry had to respond quickly to quash it early (failed).

I suspect Anton will finish it though by publicly stating to the FA that he does not think Terry said anything racist and that he is not racist. There is an 'English Footballers Club' and "JT" is the leader, Anton's cousin is 2IC with SG and FL lieutenants. Ranks will be closed on this matter and JT will remain England Captain.

3
kb | 26 October 2011 - 12:21pm

well if Anton

hasn't got a problem other people should butt the fuck out then.

2
niscum | 26 October 2011 - 1:07pm

Anton Ferdinand

The fact that he hasn't gone public doesn't mean he hasn't got a problem. The fact that QPR have complained suggests he probably has.

1
Spartacus Mills | 26 October 2011 - 1:10pm

Seems a bit harsh

Player is racially abused.

If he complains, he's "playing the race card".

If he doesn't complain and others do so on his behalf they should butt the fuck out.

6
eminentdan1978 | 26 October 2011 - 1:11pm

So, the only person who has the right to be

offended by a racist remark is Anton? Nah.

Season after season, football "banter" includes making hissing gas oven noises at Spurs fans, plane crash jokes at Man U fans, the list is long and tedious. I'm not Jewish, didn't lose any family in the Munich crash. But I find it offensive.

4
fortuneight | 26 October 2011 - 1:36pm

llike I say

what is Anton Ferdinand like? may be a paragon of virtues abused by a racist bully or it may just be a bit more complicated.

Anton's a big, wealthy boy - he doesn't need trouble makers pushing their agenda off his situation; he's got a right to get on with his life without being made a poster boy for people with no interest in his well being.

0
niscum | 26 October 2011 - 2:03pm

As I understand it

the complaint is being pursued by Anton Ferdinand's club, QPR, who neither appear to be trouble makers with an agenda or people with no interest in his wellbeing.

3
skirky | 26 October 2011 - 2:30pm

Speaking as a sport refuse-nik

I would just like to use the slogan "Hate Football, Hate Racism".

Unfortunately footballers are not employed for their intelligence and social decency, just how they can kick a ball. Therefore you get the bluntest tools in the box who will resort to racism in an attempt to get one over an opponent. "Heat of the moment" = all part of the game, if you can't take it.... machismo bullshit.

Any talk of someone playing "the race card" is excusing the racist idiot. I picture fat blokes sitting in pubs saying 'well they're too sensitive that lot, its only a joke, anyway he is black, whats wrong with that".

The 'beautiful' game, eh?

-----

Rosbif: "I've been called a "fucking cunt" before (in fact iwas called just that a few hours ago)" -yeah sorry bout that mate but i still say that "cocksucker" is hyphenated and it was a triple word score!

3
DogFacedBoy | 26 October 2011 - 12:59pm

talking of

machismo bullshit.

1
niscum | 26 October 2011 - 1:09pm

Once again

The point has been comprehensively missed.

3
Rosbif | 27 October 2011 - 1:09pm

I've been called a "fucking cunt" before

I've been called a "fucking cunt" many times.

Perhaps it is because I am one.

0
jackthebiscuit | 27 October 2011 - 3:36pm

Yes, Scrabble

a thugs game.

0
DogFacedBoy | 26 October 2011 - 1:47pm

Had a right tear-up the other day

Ran into a group of Boggle's top boys on the platform at New Street. Well we fucking rattled them, I can tell you! SCRAB ARMY!

3
Spartacus Mills | 26 October 2011 - 1:51pm

Boggle's top boys

stop lego GB yobs

1
Captain Underpants | 27 October 2011 - 4:34pm

Oh, DFB.

You and your bling-encrusted gangster mates sitting around with a Shorter OED, arguing over the existence of the word "qo", the remains of Big Tony mouldering in the corner after his ill-advised outburst in the middle of that game of Cranium. Will you never learn to rein in your relentless hard-man persona?

0
Bob | 26 October 2011 - 1:58pm

Its just all I know innit

and Tony had it coming, we put the tiles bag over his head and trowled him with those things that you put the letters on that haven't got a name. We never did find that letter "K"

0
DogFacedBoy | 26 October 2011 - 2:01pm

Check his tattoos for typos.

2
Bob | 26 October 2011 - 2:03pm

I mean "ZA"

"its short for pizza", he says, "I saw that posh bird, Vicky Coren say it on the telly". He's only been watching BBC4! BBC farking 4! Can't be having that - its not right!

0
DogFacedBoy | 26 October 2011 - 2:28pm

I started

getting into Yahtzee pretty badly. Got the shakes and kept throwing number twos. Had to stop, cut down by playing Pass The Pigs once a day

0
DogFacedBoy | 26 October 2011 - 1:57pm

One leaning jowler

There's only one leaning jowler
One leaning jowwwwwwwleerrrrrr
There's only one leaning jowler

0
Spartacus Mills | 26 October 2011 - 2:01pm

Pssssst!

I've got 5000 examples of the 'Countdown Conundrum' on a dodgy DVD. Wanna copy? Hardcore it is, really logographic stuff.

0
Vulpes Vulpes | 26 October 2011 - 2:48pm

I've got some Countdown DVD's

but they are all of Rachel Riley taking an "F" turning her back to camera and saying "thankyou"

2
Dave Amitri | 26 October 2011 - 8:05pm

In the history of the Premiership....

.....has a club ever 'lost it' more than Chelsea did on Sunday?

We have:
(1) the Terry incident,
(2) the manager being investigated by the FA for criticizing the ref,
(3) the manager openly slagging off a member of the opposition (Derry),
(4) two sending offs (neither of which are being contested, giving a lie to the 'ref had a 'mare' line),
(5) a spectator reporting 'an incident',
(6) the Chelsea 'official' web-site belittling the opposition after the game,
(7) a 1-0 defeat against a team that Man. Utd. etc. will probably beat twice, and, as a backdrop to all this,
(8) all the neutral observers that I've heard (Neville, Redknapp, the ex-referee that Sky employ etc.) think the ref did well.....it was the guy doing the Villa-WBA game who made the real howlers!

Please tell me if I've missed anything.

It's hilarious.....but Chelsea, believe me when I say this, we are not laughing at you, we are laughing 'toward' you!

Ranger.

1
ranger | 27 October 2011 - 3:20pm

Sometime contributor to the mag, Giles Smith

and, forgive and correct me if I've got the name wrong, wrote an rather inflammatory article on Chelsea's official website belittling Queens Park Rangers.

Probably way off the mark, but I'd suspect that Giles Smith and similar metropolitan writers were not part of the 6,092 hardcore who stood in the Shed when Chelsea played a top flight game vs Oxford United in February 1987.

Part of me is very sad at what Chelsea have become, the other half laughs.

The ultimate noveau riche.

" I AM CONSIDERABLY RICHER THAN YOW! "

0
Six Dog | 27 October 2011 - 3:54pm

6,092 hardcore fans

I have posted about this on a different thread, but when did Chelsea become a big club?

Where were all the "die hard fans" when they were crap?

Bring back Mickey droy.

0
jackthebiscuit | 27 October 2011 - 6:48pm

And of course

Ron 'Chopper' Harris

0
duco01 | 31 October 2011 - 6:06pm

Absolutely

I only saw the game on tv but I couldn't believe my eyes as seasoned title contenders Chelsea unravelled before me. QPR did not play well at all (you could even make a case that they played better losing 6-0 to Fulham) and got worse as the game went on but so many of the Chelsea team had lost it by the end their superior footballing skills didn't matter as they seemed to forget they were playing a football match.
And all (as far as I could see) without the provocation of supreme agent provocateur Barton who on Sunday wasn't even in the top 5 gits on the pitch...

1
STD | 27 October 2011 - 6:14pm

I've since looked at the Chelsea website......

.....to see what the 'belittling' accusation was all about.

Don't know who wrote it, and don't care, but it was actually put out before the game as a preview, and spoke of this game meaning much, much more to QPR than Chelsea, 'their Cup Final', small club mentality etc. etc.

Fast forward a week and who did the game mean more to now?!

Alas the return game isn't until the third from last game of the season and the most odious club in the world may send QPR down.

Just as likely, though, is that Rangers will be safe by then.
If this is the case, I'd implore all Rangers' fans to boycott the £50+ tickets and go to Harrow Borough or Hendon instead, for Warnock to put out the stiffs and spend the weekend in his place in Cornwall, and for Chelsea to stew in their own juice.

1
ranger | 27 October 2011 - 7:12pm

"Has a club ever 'lost it' more than Chelsea did on Sunday?"

Probably not, but they ran themselves a close second on Saturday. I'm an Arsenal fan and I still can't believe Arsenal won given how shockingly three of the back four played.

I think even Spurs fans would have been delighted to see Terry flat on his face as van Persie ran off to score the fourth goal. (Come in Mr Topaz...)

0
Red Umpire | 31 October 2011 - 5:57pm

A Sense Of Perspective, Perhaps?

Now Teflon Terry is an odious man, and should he be found guilty of making racist remarks to Ferdinand, he should be punished severely... being banned from the Engerlund team for one year would be a good start. However much more serious crimes are committed on the field of play in The Premiership. eg Alan Huttons two ferocious tackles on Shane Long,surely they were worthy of much more consideration of being bad?
In my younger days I stayed in Aldershot and played for a decent team down there (Hello, T&L Sports, you still exist?). Now I was a combatative left sided midfield player.... think Billy Bremner without the skill. And the pace. And the ginger hair. On a regular basis I was called "A dirty Jock bastard"....sometimes by own teamates....that never bothered me in the least. What bothered me when one Bill Baxter, ex captain of Ipswich Town under Sir Alf, kicked me so hard on the left leg that my shin pad split from knee to ankle and my leg was numb for hours afterwards. It left a dent that is still visible some 31 years later.
Yep, sure, lets kick racism out of soccer, but I would rather be called names than have my leg shredded.

1
geacher53 | 27 October 2011 - 8:16pm

Ah,Bill Baxter, Bobby Robson had to "ask him outside"

when he took over Ipswich Town to sort out who was top boy at the club apparently. (According to Sir Bobs autobiog)

Can't see that happening these days.

0
BernkastelCues | 31 October 2011 - 4:50pm

That's the very chappie

I also would have asked him outside, but
A: We were already outside.
B: He was much much bigger than me.
C: I was greetin', looking at the amount of blood my leg was seeping.

0
geacher53 | 31 October 2011 - 9:36pm

Anton Ferdinand has 'strong feelings' on the incident

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/15528032.stm

This hardly suggests that he regards the incident as over.

0
tiggerlion | 31 October 2011 - 6:14pm

Terry

is an odious, arrogant, cretinous oaf who, incidentally, makes Lineker look like a celibate. One consolation is that his abilities as a player are declining at an ever-advancing rate.
He didn't 'slip' on Saturday; he threw himself to the ground when he realised he'd be hugely embarrased if he attempted to match Van Persie for pace.
Am I the only one who's suspicious about the provenance of these huge banners proclaiming his 'Legend' status? I reckon the name on the invoice is JT himself.

0
ianess | 31 October 2011 - 6:32pm

Alas....

.....for the England team, that your (correct) opinion will have reached a general consensus at the very least five years too late.

0
ranger | 31 October 2011 - 7:36pm
Privacy Statement    ©  2006 - 2012 Development Hell Ltd