Entertainment For Lively Minds
IT/ Hard drive help required
Posted by billyous on 17 September 2009 - 11:34am.
Last year I replaced the hard drive in my Macbook with a larger, 500GB drive. The "new" drive now won't boot and I've replaced it with the original. My question is, is there a device (cable?) which will allow me to connect the non-booting drive to the Mac, via the USB, and recover all the files (music, pics)?
- More from billyous.
- Login or register to post comments









you can
get stand alone cases for pc hard drives.
Thanks anyway, but...
this is for a laptop drive.
Same thing applies - just
Same thing applies - just buy a 2.5" drive enclosure. Like this one http://www.amazon.co.uk/2-5-SATA-USB-External-Enclosure/dp/B001EL0SQ0/re...
Could try buying a enclosure
Could try buying a enclosure for the faulty hard drive which should enable you to connect it via a USB. You should then see the drive as an external drive and maybe be able to the see the data if it just the boot data that's buggered. And then use the dive as an external drive once you've got you data off.
Thanks Lee
Just Googled "laptop hard drive enclosure" and there is indeed such an item.
(Thanks Chris G)
** Ah, Lee, you beat me to it. Again, THANKS!
There are housings
available for desktop-format drives where you plug the drive into the approprate interface inside the housing and connect the housing to your computer via USB. I don't know about laptop-format drives, but I can't see why the same thing shouldn't exist.
This will of course only be of use if the drive still spins up and proves accessible. What did it do or sound like when it failed? Is there still a warranty on the drive?
If the fault is mechanical (i.e. with the drive itself or the head that read it), you've probably lost your data, though you could pay quite a lot of money to a data recovery company to try and retrieve it (outcome uncertain).
If it's the controller at fault (i.e. an electronics problem) there may still be a chance of replacing just that, though laptop drives are pretty heavily "integrated" due to their small size, and there may not be a separate controller circuit board that can be swapped out/in.
Drives are so cheap nowadays that few people will even consider repairing them (professionally).
Sorry for repetition
I tend to do slow, deliberate (ponderous even).
DLM
All I remember is the usual start on the Mac (little circular counter), followed by the default blue screen, and then..... nothing. That's as far as it would go. The minimal outlay for the enclosure is worth the risk.
Time Machine
If you have it on your version of OS is designed for these kind of situations. And could give you a use for you spare hard drive if it is just software glitches.
You don't need a box
You don't need to buy an enclosure. The most flexible solution is an adaptor that you plug one end into the USB port and any drive (IDE, SATA or 2.5in IDE) into the other end. They all come with a power supply. Maplins sell them if you want one today but mine was about £10 from an ebay shop. I've used mine with OSX, Vista, XP and even my Humax PVR discs.
Here's one:
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/USB-2-0-to-IDE-2-5-3-5-5-25-hard-disk-drive-HDD-Ca...
I'm sure you've all been anxious
to know if I resolved my HD issue (ahem). Well, thanks to your helpful replies, I've managed to save the entire contents. I bought a caddy (I'd ordered it before your response, John W) from Amazon and I was able to access all the files within 5 minutes of the postie's arrival. Thanks again, one and all.
hurrah!
I love it when a plan comes together...
Pleased to hear it was pretty painless
and straightforward. I think I'll be suggesting to someone I know with a laptop (and a dead hard drive replaced with a new one) that he buys the lead JohnW mentions, or a close relative.
Wayhay
Now all you need is a fool proof back up habit.
To be honest, DLM
I find the caddy to be a better solution. It's a neat little aluminium enclosure, which comes with drawstring bag for storage. The Mac displayed a warning, stating that I couldn't write to the HD until I re-formatted it -- that can wait, for now. At least I've saved all my photos and music.
Horses for courses
I have a couple of 2.5 inch drives (that I replaced in the PC with bigger drives) in caddies that I use all the time they are a perfect solution for a permanent installation. The lead I have is brilliant for the odd occasion when I need to plug in a bare drive any time without needing to slide it into a caddy and it avoids the need to have 3 different types of caddy available all the time. Before I got the lead, if I needed to get data off a bare drive I would have to open up a populated caddy, take the drive out and put the temporary one in then strip it all down again.
The lead is a toolbox item not a desktop, briefcase item.