Entertainment For Lively Minds
If Beatles
Posted by John Medd on 10 September 2011 - 12:25pm.
cover versions were a motorway it would be strewn with pileups and fatalities. Not to mention the hard shoulder - nose to tail with breakdowns awaiting recovery. Cue Cilla Black: I don't think I've ever heard a cover version where the whole meaning of the song has been altered, nay butchered, by changing just a handful of words.
- More from John Medd.
- Login or register to post comments










Is it just me
or is Hank looking a bit Lennonish?
Marvin, Welch & Farrar
do you think they were trying to model themselves on Crosby, Stills & Nash? I mean, you can see the likeness, right?
Weird to see Hank
with long-ish hair there and, dare I say it, Cilla is looking a bit foxy in that clip.
Back to the matter in hand. Crap Beatles' cover versions don't come any crapper than William Shatner doing Lucy In The Sky
Oh I don't know...
http://youtu.be/jMVYUgn8p0U
And that's without even trying...I actually found the OP's example weirdly compelling.
Anybody know why I'm having no luck embedding YouTube stuff, by the way?
Because...
You're not using the embedding code, but the shortened page URL for sharing the video via Twitter, etc. They're different things.
Either:
a) just copy the URL of the YouTube page the video sits on into your entry, and we'll do the rest automatically, or b) click on "Share" on the YouTube page, then click "Embed", copy the HTML that appears, and paste that into your comment.
Thanks...
...but I've religiously been doing b), but all I end up with is a big blank space! I'll try a).
For me
it only works when I tick the box to use the old embedding code.
(If anyone can explain why and what the difference is between the new and the old embedding codes I'd be interested to hear it)
I've tested this
And it appears to work fine with both the old and new embedding code. What browser are you using?
Now I wish I hadn't asked...
...then I wouldn't have to admit to being so completely bored when it comes to anything computer related that the word "browser" means absolutely nothing to me...
I have had it explained to me before and immediately forgot it again.
*thinking hard before deciding to take a chance and hope not to sound like a complete idiot*
Is that the Windows Explorer thingy ?
A browser
Is the software you use to look at the internet. It sounds like you're using Internet Explorer (Windows Explorer is something else altogether). It's possible you're using Internet Explorer 6, which YouTube doesn't officially support, and may be the cause of the problems.
It is working fine
When you press "Preview Comment" a big blank space appears but the image is actually there. When you post it, we can see it and when you refresh your page you will be able to see it. It took me a while to figure out this was happening on one of my machines.
Good call but I'd argue that Cilla gets a free pass
due to her being the 23rd Beatle and an old mate of the band.
I'd forgotten about Marvin, Welch & Farrer, they were an attempt to reinvent the Shads for the 1970s as I recall. They always seemed to be backing Cliff or Olivia Newton-John.
Your memory is fine,Stimpy
They were always the guests on Cliff's tv Programme as was ONJ.It ran from 70-72 and the other regular guest was Una Stubbs.
Blimey...
...for your complete HJH covers hell experience, go to http://www.youtube.com/user/MrBeatlesCovers
Currently grooving to 'Piggies' by Theodore Bikel...that's the rest of the afternoon shot. Thanks, OP!
Rain
Petula Clark singing Rain - that's worth the price of admission. Thanks for the link!
the inverse of..
I recall eventually tracking down the original of the lovely 'Take A Giant Step', written by Carole Bayer Sager and recorded by Taj Mahal on his Giant Step LP. The original, or so it seems, was recorded by the Monkees, and at six times the tempo. For once, the cover was better than the original.
Carole...
...King, surely. And Gerry Goffin.
Petula Clark
again. Her version of 10CC's 'I'm not in love'. Too fast, and devoid of all the feeling the original had.
Whatsa matter big boys don't cry!
I'm Not In Love - Fun Lovin' Criminals
I've posted this before...
...a complete set of HJH covers on Spotify:
http://open.spotify.com/user/seamusr/playlist/34GzCs3wYBVaTUP1DhbSVE
Of course I'm biased
and this has been posted before but.........
Justin Currie "Strawberry Fields"
Cilla
In late 1963 or early 1964 I saw a Brian Epstein package tour at the City Hall in Sheffield. Gerry & the Pacemakers were the headliners and Cilla closed the first half. Also on the bill were Sounds Incorporated (who backed the solo artists as well as playing their own slot) and Tommy Quickly, an Epstein stable also-ran who had received a crumb from the Lennon & McCartney table in the shape of The Tip Of My Tongue. It was the first show of its kind I ever saw and my initial exposure to the then-new phenomenon of audience hysteria.
Cilla wore a full length pink chiffon ball gown and although her 20 minute set was hardly a walk on the wild side, she performed to deafening screams throughout, something I found incongruous at the time. Why were all those girls screaming at Cilla? All became clear when, in an accent so thick you could almost carve it, she introduced Love Of The Loved as "a song written by a couple of my mates in Liverpool, John and Paul” and the place went ballistic. Ah, so this was Beatlemania by proxy.
This was confirmed when The Pacemakers came on to close the show in collarless Beatle suits with cuban-heeled boots and played their hits amid a hail of jelly babies. Epstein was providing a touch of ersatz Beatle magic without actually giving us the real thing. It worked fine for a year or two, but by then the Beatles had pulled so far ahead of the pack that the façade could no longer be maintained and the rest of the Epstein stable were faced with a stark choice - family entertainment or obscurity.
You might enjoy this...
... was trying to establish whether or not I saw the package you mention, and stumbled across:
http://www.bradfordtimeline.co.uk/music.htm
You might say whoever did this needs to get out more, but you could also say he stayed in so the rest of us don't have to...
What a great site!
I couldn't find the tour in question, but thanks for the link.
Sammy Davis Jr's version of
Sammy Davis Jr's version of In The Ghetto really must be taken into consideration..
Some resourceful people
compiled a whole set of CDs of covers of Beatles albums, sequenced in the same order as the albums. It varies from the sublime (Ella Fitzgerald doing "Savoy Truffle") to the ridiculous (too many to list.) Rather nicely, they've included the originals of some of the Beatles' covers.
They're available on a torrent site near you - each album is titled "ReCovering..." followed by the album title (ie "ReCovering Please Please Me", etc.)
Oh, and perhaps I should add that I had nothing to do with the compilations - I just found them while searching for something else one day.
I'd like to nominate this horror ...
if only for the 'I'm counting in my head' dancing ...