Entertainment For Lively Minds

Word RSS FeedsWord Magazine on YouTubeWord Magazine on Last FMWord Magazine on Share My PlaylistsWord Spotify PlaylistsWord Magazine on FacebookWord Magazine on Twitter

Headphones advice

butterflycollector's picture

Afternoon All,

In a couple of weeks, I'm going to do some headphone shopping. I've got some nice wireless Sennheisers that are fantastic for my bedroom and some standard Ipod ones for rough use of my Ipod (Cycling etc and work).

I need to get a quality pair for my Ipod when I'm out and about.

My budget is around £100-150.

Any ideas?

0

Shure...

...every time. I've had 3 pairs now at around your price point and they sound fantastic, excellent build quality and their customer service is great. My 2nd pair developed a fault in one ear after 2 years (actually about 3 days out of warranty). I enquired about getting them repaired but they sent me a brand new pair. I couldn't believe how good they were.

0
ainsley009 | 7 November 2010 - 5:25pm

Seconded

SE 115 I think mine are. And buy some Comply (I think) buds to fit on them - supe comfy.

0
Leedsboy | 7 November 2010 - 5:50pm

Thirded

Left mine in a pub. Very sad :-(

0
uproar13 | 7 November 2010 - 6:27pm

Fourthed...

... or is it fourthded? Anyway, I will never consider any other brand than Shure for my iPod now & I've tried most. Only thing is, don't get the very cheapest one they do, go to the kinda £80 bracket (or higher if you've got the cash). Make sure they come with foam ear plugs - they are far & away the best fit I've ever had. And you can buy replacement earplugs really easily online.

0
Susie Baby | 7 November 2010 - 6:32pm

panasonic ergo fit

I like these. But then I suspect I'm the only one on here that does. At £10-15 you don't feel as heartbroken if they break. Which unless you do something stupid, they don't really.

Current pair have lasted about 20 months. Not bad considering they get used every day, slept on, scrunched up in pocket, etc.

The key thing for longevity is to keep the jack plug safe. If the connection on that remains in your pocket, then a damage is less likely to occur.

Plus they have really good bass and sound for the price they are. And you can wear them turned up in a train quiet zone, and they don't leak sound.

Cheaper earphones would also allow you to treat your family with the rest of the money. Or something...

EDIT: Just looked on Amazon and they're currently £6. With a 4.5 star rating, that's pretty good value in my opinion. Panasonic RP-HJE170E-K

1
badger_king | 7 November 2010 - 6:26pm

Yuin PK1

Stupidly good iPod headphones, better than any 'name brand' (for big cans I am a Sennheiser freak). Quite a long burn-in required but they get really warm after 150 hours.

Only available online, you might find them for about one hundred pounds.

0
James EB | 8 November 2010 - 2:10am

Do not get Monster brand buds

I went through 5 sets of Beats by Dre ear buds, with one month being the longest I got out of a pair. Fortunately the shop I bought them from (Harvey Norman in Australia) were very good and kept replacing them until we finally decided to call it quits and give me a refund. The only reasons we could find were that either a) The shipping container overheated, causing glue and rubber degradation, b) They were counterfeit (counterfeit headphones are very common on ebay and such) and c) They were just overpriced pieces of crap. Through a process of elimination we decided that 'c' was most likely.

0
Podicle | 8 November 2010 - 3:42am

Keeping it in the same thread...

What about the 300 quid mark for ipods?

I was thinking of Dr Dre Beats (also to use on flights)... anything better around this price range?

0
clivetemple | 8 November 2010 - 5:28am

I suppose it depends...

...on how you store your music. There must come a point where the quality of the hardware outstrips the quality of the music at the lower bitrates.

Normally I'm all for paying as much as you can afford, which will work if you are playing back at high bitrates or lossless.

0
ainsley009 | 8 November 2010 - 10:10am

Nice cans

I am using 320 and lossless and travelling on noisy buses and trains. I love my 2 1/2 year old Bose Quiet Comfort 2s, used almost daily, although the ear pads are going and I am not sure how easy they will be to replace.

I am seriosuly thinking about the newer model. Though I am also curious about headphones that allow you to answer a phone call---any experience with these ?

[parenthetically, I had assumed I would look a total dweeb wandering around in these--and I quite possibly do (in Peel voice)---but nonetheless they have drawn adniring comments from bus drivers and comely young cybercafe waitresses ...it's a funny old world]

0
SpaceBoy | 8 November 2010 - 11:07am

Only tried...

...briefly the ones that came with my iPhone. Since then, if I get a call while I've got headphones in I just speak into the phone mic and leave the 'phones in. I don't like answering a call without looking at the phone so it's in my hand anyway by that point.

0
ainsley009 | 8 November 2010 - 11:17am

Can I also suggest...

...a pair of custom earpieces. I wrote about my experiences with these but I'm not allowed to post the link so here it is :

Custom Earpieces

I have wanted to try some custom earpieces for sooooo longand the opportunity finally arose. A birthday with nothing else I could think of approached, or nothing else, at least that didn’t cost a heart-stopping amount of cash that we don’t actually have.

I’m a bit spoilt when it comes to headphones. Many years ago I invested the (then) ridiculous sum of £250 in a pair of Sennheisers. These were absolutely spectacular, of course, but suddenly you are ruined for anything else. Try a pair of cheap ‘phones (in-ear, over-ear, it makes no difference) and you just can’t help but make the comparison. Add to that the way that less expensive ‘phones tend to move about, especially the in-ear types, and suddenly you’re on the receiving end of a very disappointing experience.

When the iPod came into my life, clearly I needed a pair of ‘phones that were portable. Sound notwithstanding, I just can’t bring myself to wear BIG ‘phones out in public, so I bought a pair of Shure in-ears, the E4C’s. These were eventually replaced by Shure (another story, but a big thumbs up to Shure for honouring their 2 year warranty, even right at the death) with a pair of 310’s. These sound great (they cost around £140 but you can shop around on the nets for the best price) but despite coming with a range of earpieces the best fit for me was the yellow foam type, the ones where you squash the foam first, stick it in your ear and then it expands and “seals” the ear canal. This works OK but they still pull out at the slightest provocation.

Which brings me to the custom earpieces. I saw an ad with a company called Hi-Fi Headphones for custom made earpieces but ones that fit a range of ready-made ‘phones. At around £90 these seemed reasonable (admittedly by comparison to other custom-made earpieces) so in I plunged.

The procedure was straightforward.

Pay !
Get a voucher for a visit to a local Audiologist
Visit audiologist. They spray foam into your ear which moulds to your ear canal and the outer bit. Only takes a couple of minutes to go off and that’s it.
Wait about 2 weeks and the postman delivers a nice little leatherette pouch with two clear plastic earpieces. The Shure’s push into these and the whole thing pushes into your ear.
But…there was to be a disappointment. The promise was a secure fit, great sound isolation and great sound reproduction, due to the fit and the way that the sound is directed into the ear canal. The reality, however, was that the right ear felt uncomfortably loose, the actual ‘phones themselves didn’t seem to fit particularly well into the earpieces, looking like they were made for something with a 90 degree angle, and the quality of the sound was really poor. I put this down to the fit, and the slightest movement of my jaw altered the bass response of the sound considerably. All in all £90 had bought me a worse fit and worse sound quality than the £1.25 foam ear pads.

Not happy.

Anyway, a call to Hi-Fi Headphones and a subsequent call to ACS, who actually make the custom bits, resulted in a second appointment to have my ear impressions taken. On the second visit it became clear that the consultant either wasn’t used to the process specifically for audio earpieces or wasn’t aware that that was the purpose of the first visit. This time round I was made to bite down to open up the ear canal and the 2nd set of impressions was obviously longer in the ear canal on the right hand side.

When the new earpieces arrived the difference was huge. As I said, the shape of the earpieces was better and the fit was now snug on both sides. Sound isolation and quality was world’s better and now there was no change to the sound quality or bass response no matter how much you jiggle your head around or even pull on the cable.

Now that they’ve been made correctly, I can’t recommend these enough. They sound great and are MUCH more comfortable that ANY other in-ear buds that I’ve tried – and I’ve tried lots of them ! They also fit a pretty wide range of ‘phones, so if the worst happens and you need to replace your ‘phones (or upgrade or course) then you aren’t wasting your £90.
/

0
ainsley009 | 8 November 2010 - 11:25am

Ive lost 2 pairs of sennheiser

noise cancelling PXC 300

and for, ahem, an older gent with poor upper register hearing they are execellent

So I'm on my third pair now.

0
Junior Wells | 8 November 2010 - 7:12am

I bought a pair of AKG

I bought a pair of AKG Headphones for £45.00 from Amazon and have been very impressed with them.
Previously I have been strictly Bose only but spent more time worrying about breaking them than actually using them!! The sound on the AKG's is pretty impressive & for the price you can't grumble.

0
seanioio | 8 November 2010 - 10:55am

Interesting FT review this week

of these in the OP's price range

http://www.howtospendit.com/#/articles/2964-technopolis-v-moda-crossfade...

I find Margolis pretty reliable---he may express himself in code but it's usually possible to tell what he thinks of a product.

0
SpaceBoy | 8 November 2010 - 11:11am

You only need

a pair of Sennheisers HD-25-1 II
I used to use them for DJing and now use them for everyday use.
They cancel out all external sounds, you could get run over by a screaming ambulance and you wouldn't know about it. (not recommended)
When I'm at the gym it blocks out all the awful pap music they churn out too.
They are very durable and I have only gone through two pairs in twelve years. My first pair would have lasted longer if I stopped yanking the wire when it was caught on something in my bag.
They are also the pro choice for sound engineers and on location sound recordists.

0
jimmyshoes01 | 8 November 2010 - 11:14am

Does anyone have any experience...

...of the Bose Quiet Comfort 3 'phones? Since I lost my Sennheiser buds, I've been thinking about getting some properly decent headphones, and I tried the Bose in the Apple Store recently. I was blown away - the noise-cancelling seems like it would be especially useful on the rattly old Victoria line, and the detail and smoothness of the sound knocked me out. I also like the wirelessness.

Is there any reason, other than that they're £300, not to buy these fellas? Any other 'phones in the same or lower price bracket that do what the Bose do?

0
Bob | 23 November 2010 - 1:05pm

They're great

as Tony the Tiger would say. But they will make you look like a salesman for HP or IBM which isn't cool. Try some Shure ones - hardly noticeable on and with a little bit of rock heritage. And better value for money.

0
Leedsboy | 23 November 2010 - 1:52pm

Well, I've

used the Etymotic noise cancelling ones with the adjustable foam tip but I have now gone through 2 pairs because the cord has split in the same place and they are now mono - bloody infuriating because the sound is good but cannot afford to keeping sheeling out 80 quid every now and again. I have tried the Bose noise cancelling ones and the sound is great but they keep dropping out of my ears.

0
Francis Barry-Walsh | 23 November 2010 - 1:20pm

If I went...

...Bose, I would abandon buds altogether and go over-the-ear. I'm done with in-ears, I think.

0
Bob | 23 November 2010 - 1:22pm

Try in ear buds

with Comply foams - really makes a difference in comfort.

0
Leedsboy | 23 November 2010 - 1:54pm

double

post

0
Bob | 23 November 2010 - 2:12pm

Oooh.

Thinking seriously about some Shures with Comply TX foams now. If it fits my ear and stays in, I'm happy to stay with buds - I just got so narked with constantly adjusting and pushing back in.

0
Bob | 23 November 2010 - 2:12pm

I have spent a fortune

on in ear buds over the years. None would stay in. The combination of the Shures really going in deep (you sort of screw them in after squashing the memory foam) and then the cable routing over and around your ears means I can even run with mine in.

I tried a pair on at the Gadget Show thingy at the NEC and was sold on the spot.

0
Leedsboy | 23 November 2010 - 2:31pm

Running

That's what interests me. I'm in the process of shedding lots of weight (2 stone so far!), and I want to start running again. Right now, I'd be stopping every 10 seconds to put my fucking Apple buds back in (since I lost the Sennheisers, they've been my only option). And running without music simply isn't an option: exercise is bad enough, but it'd be intolerable without something to take my mind off.

0
Bob | 23 November 2010 - 2:36pm

I got these

http://www.advancedmp3players.co.uk/shop/Headphones.6/Shure.44/SE115-/Sh...

They are a cheapish (compared to Bose at least) start. They gave me a free pair of Comply foams to see if I liked them - I did and bought a box (its good to change them every 6 months before the colour gets too disgusting for words.....

0
Leedsboy | 23 November 2010 - 2:57pm

Small update.

On Leedsboy's advice, I got a pair of Shure SE115s and some Comply tips. The lot came to £75 (£60 for the 'phones and £15 for three pairs of tips). They're astonishingly good bang for the buck, and will be with me for many years, I hope. It's so nice to have really good sound when I'm commuting and/or running.

Cheers, LB!

0
Bob | 6 December 2010 - 2:51pm
Privacy Statement    ©  2006 - 2012 Development Hell Ltd