Entertainment For Lively Minds
This has just got to stop...
Posted by Graham_Arden on 14 January 2008 - 8:34pm.

I mean, Yes I know some people had unfortunate childhoods and it must have been really shit, but the readers of these books just seem, to quote young Mr Lydon, to holiday in other people's misery.
I presume that WH Smiths don't have much room to spare, because there science section consists of about three books.
- More from Graham_Arden.
- Login or register to post comments










ReadItSwapIt
Talking of books, do people on this site know about this great site where you can swap books you've done with for ones you do want? I get a large percentage of my books on there.
http://www.readitswapit.co.uk/TheLibrary.aspx
Regarding the tragic life story section, I suppose these trends come and go in publishing. I wouldn't read one but I there must be people that read nothing but. It's a shame if other genres are getting pushed out though.
What a great idea
Can we do the same for CDs and DVDs. I've got series 1 of The Wire DVDs and I want Nick Lowe The Doings box set, any takers?
I bet...
that if that website was set up for CDs the music industry would go on and on about lost revenue and most likely try and get the site shut down.
I'll swap you series 5 or 6 of The West Wing for your Wire.
Oh God you're so right to bring this up...
Yes... titles like "Forgotten Angel", the harrowing tale of a sweet little deaf and dumb girl brought up by voles in a forest because her crack-addicted parents were too busy watching Jeremy Kyle every day to care for her.
I went into a Waterstone's bookshop the other day, and saw that the shelves were groaning under the weight of those "my life was / is crap" books. I mean, why don't we all write one? Everyone I know has had something terrible happen to them. Now where's my quill?
Chapter One....
.....
You do realise I've just sneezed coffee through my nose reading that...
Perhaps I should write a book about it?
Sorry about that...
David Hepworth made me do a very similar thing this morning with his immortal line "this huge figure might be reached by counting each member of, say, Iron Maiden as an individual creative entity".
How's the book coming along?
It's not going well....
I think I may need a few more sessions with my therapist.
Yes... I get the picture...
My book really started coming along when under deep hypnosis I dragged from my subconscious the burried memory of my teddy bear's head being ripped off by my neighbour's rabid Dachshund...
Yes... I get the picture...
My book really started coming along when under deep hypnosis I dragged from my subconscious the burried memory of my teddy bear's head being ripped off by my neighbour's rabid Dachshund...
I
wouldn't touch these books with a bargepole.
But the one about voles I might.
Seriously
Is that real?
I'm afraid so..
It was taken in the York branch of WHS about two months ago. I was jut so surprised when I saw it that I took my camera phone out.
I was even more surprised when I noticed Posh Spice's book was on the display (second shelf up). What a tragic life she's lead!
It's very real
I popped into my local branch of WH Smiths (Wimbledon) at the weekend and there it was, first aisle in the book section. I think it's new - pretty sure it wasn't there at Christmas. Naturally, having repaired home I ranted at length about it to my long-suffering wife who punctuated proceedings with the odd Sybil Fawlty-esque "yes, dear"s and "ooh, I know"s.
An Antidote
read Andrew Collins' Where Did It All Go Right? As cheerful a memoir as you could wish for.
Posh
Is that Victoria Beckham on the second row from the bottom? I realise she's probably not responsible for the way in which her book is displayed, but a tragic life? I mean, that track with Dane Bowers wasn't well-received, but apart from that she seems to have done OK.
Yes.
It is indeed...
I think...
her perfume sales might have dropped after Xmas, and she reportedly broke a nail on the Spice Girls tour. She got it bad, that girl.
Posh's Tragic Life...
...is dealt with here. This site was one of a a whole column of links in the Ads By Google column on the right of the screen as I was resding the posts on this thread.
It's can't be that hard a life
when you've got a decent book contract, respectable sales and a (hopefully) large part of the population saying "yes, isn't life tragic? How wonderful they could overcome the agony of their ingrown toenails." Any chance we can have autobiographies that are actually fun to read?
Although for the rich and famous to convince that it isn't all easy, while still maintaining the burden of wealth and fame... it's a tribute to their publicists.
Justifiably cynical lot, aren't we?
I Tell You Whats Tragic
the flagrant mis-use of the word Tragic.
From despair to... voyeurism
I remember a period after the Manics' Richey James disappeared when teenagers suddenly wrote hundreds of increasingly desperate letters to the Melody Maker, describing how extraordinarily terrible their life was and how Richey had been a figurehead for them. Each letter tried to outdo those that came before it: extreme disability, acute allergies, multiple bereavements, etc, all described in melodramatic detail. Many were probably genuine, masses of them must have been grossly exaggerated, some surely were pure fiction. Unfortunately it became a suburban teenager's version of the Four Yorkshiremen sketch, and it was unintentionally hilarious.
A former bookseller writes
I was an assistant manager for Waterstone's when these books first became huge hits, on the coat-tails of Dave Pelzer's A Child Called It. We were discussing what to write on the header we were going to put at the top of our small display case of these books (there called 'dumpbins' if you want to practise your jargon).
My suggestion - 'Boo-Fucking-Hoo' - was generally regarded as insufficiently sympathetic, and in retrospect that may be the point when I realised that I had fallen out of love with the book trade.
The big question
Gatz, as a former bookseller you'll know. Who buys 'em? Is there a particular demographic group hoovering this tripe up?
Who buys them?
They're almost exclusively female and, this always struck me as odd, often either in groups of young women or shopping in mother daughter pairings (in which case either party might hand over the cash but both will seem interested in reading it).
LOL!
That would have been so great... people coming up in droves and asking "Can you tell me where the Boo-F***ing-Hoo section is, please?". "Yes, Madam... just over there, by the Lifestyles Of The Obscenely Rich And Talentless books."
I have fond memories of working in a branch of said bookshop and being amazed by the people who asked me to show them where the Mind, Body & Spirit section was. I always wondered where they had stashed their black pointy hats and brooms.
It can only be a matter of time...
...before they treat their other sections with similar candour and we find the Jackie Collins filed under "S&F" (shopping and fucking). That picture makes you wonder how they refer to the section next door which appears to contain the Andy McNab books.
McNab
I've often wondered if Andy McNab's first book would have sold anything if it had been titled, instead of "Bravo Two Zero", simply "B 20".
Honest signage
A whole re-design of waterstones could be called for along the honest lines.
Cookbooks/food = Nice picture books full of things you'll never cook.
Hardback/booker friendly fiction = books we say we are reading.
(Books actually reading = Harry potter, lilac covered chick lit and Jerry Clarkson's old columns).
Graphic novels = comics
Self Help/diet/personal finance = books that make us better people simply by buying them (usual unread)
Popular History - Glorified war comics for blokes who should no better.
Poetry = Only if we must and if the cafes not too big
Local history- generally dismissed but often really interesting books
Graphic novels
I'm with you on that Chris. It's one of those things that has irritated me for years. I'd suggest the section be named Fat Comics.
I hear
That they're turning these shelves into a movie.
Fraser,
is this for real?
'The film follows a chain of smaller moments that ultimately leads to the discovery that beneath self-absorbed and self-loathing characters you'll find a lot of hurt and many defense mechanisms raised against a compassionless, manipulative society.'
That's
Exactly what I was wondering.
Is it
a remake of the Monty Python miner's sketch?
Not appearing at...
a multiplex near you soon.
Music books...
Dead pop stars by people who never knew them