Guided by Voices?

It struck me the other day that the singers I really like all tend to have the same "type" of voice - quite deep (normally baritone in men) and what is frequently described in the music press as "pure".

Examples on the male side are Scott Walker, Neil Hannon, Rick Danko, James Grant, while for women it's people like Karen Carpenter, Ute Lemper, kd lang, Sylvie Lewis.

At the same time there are voices I really dislike, for example the sort of rough and screamy style most commonly associated with heavy metal (Robert Plant/Ian Gillan etc). It's not that I don't like the music style per se (I love Thin Lizzy, perhaps because Phil Lynott falls into my preferred vocal style)

So - am I just odd? Do other people have favourite voice styles? And has the style of the singer got you into a band, or even put you off one you would otherwise have liked?

Stop singing funny

I'm fairly sure that my decades-long aversion to Yes and Supertramp can probably be put down to my run-away-screaming reaction to most falsetto vocals.

Archie Valparaiso | 6 August 2008 - 9:53am

Not odd at all...

I have the same dilemma over certain bands...for example I really want to like The Decemberists, but the guy's voice just grates like fingernails down a blackboard!
I can't handle the trend for whiny, nerdy voices at all - give me a big booming baritone any day!

Maybe, it's my age but I do like a bit of crooning in my rock - nothing better than when Iggy does it (check out his recent cover of Monochrome Set's "He's Frank" with Fatboy Slim).
His collaboration with Ryuichi Sakamoto on "Risky" was another superb Iggy vocal.

Bowie, Nick Cave, Scott Walker, Jim Morrison, Andrew Eldritch (I was never a goth by the way...), David Sylvian...

Mind you there are always exceptions, one of my favourite bands is Sparks and most of their songs are in falsetto!

Retro Man | 6 August 2008 - 9:55am

Baggy mouth strikes again

The baggy/shoegazing/whatever-you-want-to-call it era of the late 80s to early 90s produced so many weedy, fey male singing voices that I'd end up screaming at the stereo for them to "Man up!!"

I also struggle with the Plant-style scream, though Plant himself gets away with it.

I love the Beastie Boys' music but as for their voices - why would I want to listen to some kids having a tantrum? Go to your room!

And I've complained before about that supposedly emotive style of singing that insists on putting a brief, croaky catch in the voice at the start of every line. Sharleen Spiteri is a regular offender.

Nick White | 6 August 2008 - 10:15am

The great in small doses

There's another school of singers who are so instantly recognisable because of their unique vocal mannerisms that I can only really listen to isolated tracks by them, never full albums. For example, much as I like Antony Hegarty's singing, I wouldn't consider going to a live show because I know I'd be all Antony'd out after the first four or five songs.

Similarly, I think I've enjoyed all the Neville Brothers shows I've seen because the vocal duties are fairly evenly shared by all the brothers - any more than half a dozen warbly-Aaron jobbies would have been just too much to take.

Archie Valparaiso | 6 August 2008 - 10:20am

French does it for me

I cant understand a word but i can listen to french sounding vocals all day.........

Commoner | 6 August 2008 - 10:47am

Most singing voices

are fine by me. There are however two vocalists that mean I can't ever listen to their material:

Robert Plant. Neil Young.

It's their voices, they just don't sit with me at all. I don't know what it is, they just grate on me.

SimonL | 6 August 2008 - 10:56am

Dylan is that man for me

I know he's a genius/icon/whatever but I really hate his nasally whine. I'm quite happy to listen to Dylan covers and appreciate his songs, so long as I don't have to hear him sing them himself

The Amorous Hum... | 6 August 2008 - 11:00am

The Flaming Lips

I absolutely love the *idea* of The Flaming Lips - the intelligence, the concepts, their weird and wonderful live shows - but I can't get past the fact that Wayne Coyne couldn't carry a tune even if he was given one of those big blue Ikea bags to carry it in.

Paul Waring | 6 August 2008 - 12:16pm

I like Vyvienne Long covering Flaming Lips "Yoshimi"

Poor video and she sounds nervous - but hey she usually plays cello for Damien Rice

Commoner | 6 August 2008 - 12:25pm

Totally with you Paul

not fond of any singers who sound like they've just got their privates caught in the fence. Add to that list Mercury Rev and Neil Young.

Simon Ford | 7 August 2008 - 9:44am

grungy constipation growling

That guy out of Pearl Jam and Kurt from Nirvana started it now there are millions of copyists. Actually Paul Rogers also has it.
Its supposed to equate to singing with feeling I guess. But boy does it grate on me

Bang Em In Bingham | 6 August 2008 - 12:28pm

Different voices on one track can be difficult

But i love this one from The Boss & Co

Commoner | 6 August 2008 - 12:30pm

I love...

...many types of vocalist, from those Bowie/Ferry/David Sylvian/Scott Walker-style vocals to the dramatic, late 60s/early 70s Elvis Presley or even Roy Orbison.

I also love the UK vocalists that came from the 60s blues boom such as Robert Plant, Rod Stewart, Steve Winwood, Steve Marriott or classic soul vocalists like Stevie Wonder, Ray Charles, Otis Redding and Levi Stubbs. Howlin' Wolf had a pretty fearsome set of pipes on him too.

I personally have a soft spot for rock/metal vocalists like Freddie Mercury, Rob Halford, David Byron, Ronnie James Dio, Ian Gillan, Bruce Dickinson and Bruce Dickinson- though I reckon I'll be alone on that here!

Jon Anderson apparently doesn't sing with a falsetto- he says it's an 'alto tenor'- but yeah, I can see why he'd put people off (though I've always liked his voice). Roger Hodgson is definitely even more of an acquired taste.

As for singers I personally really, really dislike, all these 'regional' vocalists like Alex Turner and Kate Nash I really can't abide. I have to confess that I too would like The Decemberists a lot more if it wasn't for that vocalist (especially on tracks like 'O Valencia'- nice tune but the delivery is so whiny!).

JJ | 6 August 2008 - 12:40pm

There are many vocalists…

…whose voices grate on me in some way or whose intonation I find irritating, but the only one who repeatedly makes me want to "run-away-screaming" (© A. Valparaiso, 2008) is Chad Kroeger of Nickelback - his is the voice guaranteed to have me reaching for the off button.

David Weeks | 6 August 2008 - 1:43pm

I can't be doing with any vocalists

But I'm fond of countless singers

Stan Halen | 7 August 2008 - 12:40am