Entertainment For Lively Minds
"First half good, second half not so good"
Such was the post-match mantra of former England manager Sven-Goran Eriksson, whose team often set off in pulse-raisingly promising fashion, only to fold like the garden furniture of Terry & June. (The relative merits of this approach were thrown into stark relief when his successor's ineptness made David Brent resemble a management guru.)
We're not here to discuss football managers (although Swedes are welcome), but Eriksson's oft-repeated assessment can be applied to lyrical couplets penned by the great, good and gormless. There's no talent bar on the ability to turn out a memorable phrase – songs written by monosyllabic monkeys may contain a few key words which stick in the mind – but, as with great singles and albums, it's not what you do, it's what you do next: how to follow up that fantastic phrase without sounding like a rhyming dictionary on autopilot. And even some of the legends of what we call rock, in texts which will be dug up by future generations and regarded as holy words, have fallen foul of the brilliant line which is followed by an absolute stinker.
Consider The Who's Substitute, as excitingly concise a pop song as you're likely to hear. Riff established, chorus reached and enjoyed, there's a pause for breath before the second verse starts with "I was born with a plastic spoon in my mouth", a 60s-perfect synthesis of class pride which can't be bettered. But Townshend has to go somewhere, and sadly he goes everywhere at once: "The north side of my town faced east and the east was facing south". Preposterously wordy and not half as clever as it thinks it is, its saving grace is that it only lasts a second and it's gone, buried in a welter of music and (better) lyrics.
Then there's Pink Floyd's The Dark Side of the Moon, rightly lauded as a fantastic album (although I could probably survive a fair few months on a desert island without hearing Any Colour You Like). Nestled toward the end is the corking "Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way", something akin to a mission statement for the country. Sadly, what it nestles incongruously amongst is some bang-average wittering about time and writing, like Ted Hughes' The Thought-Fox revisited by a tired deadline-pressured hack with a sixth-former's eye for words, so the song ingloriously collapses into the teeth-grindingly self-referential situationist joke of "The time is gone, the song is over, thought I'd something more to say." So did I, but you've let me down, and if that's your point, it commits one of entertainment's biggest crimes by being obvious and dull.
And as that's not something I want to be accused of, I'll shut up.
- More from Gary Parkinson.
- Login or register to post comments










"Time" has great lyrics from start to end
I love the end, which technically is called "Breathe (Reprise)".
Oasis - "Don't Look Back In Anger"
"I don't believe anyone fells the way I do," is a great lyric. Then he adds "About you now" to turn it into generic dribble.
Tis Wonderwall not ...Anger,
Tis Wonderwall not ...Anger, but you're entirely right. I have a theory that there's only three lines in that song that make sense – the one you quote, the quaintly tongue-tied "there are many things that I would like to say to you but I don't know how" and the cautiously optimistic "maybe you're gonna be the one that saves me" – with the rest being unintelligible gibberish, from the title down.
None of the three choice lyrics is a startlingly original thought, but they combined to send a certain stratum of a generation swaying drunkenly together. Not to mention, as Noel Gallagher has pointed out, "making me a millionaire four times in a week".
more on this here:
http://www.wordmagazine.co.uk/content/the-rush-page-impressions
if you follow the link there's hundreds of people's suggestions for examples of lazy lyrics. Substitute is there.
The opposite can also be true
I love the Marc Cohn song "Walking in Memphis" even though its a grabbag of Memphis cliches, "There's a pretty little thing, waiting for the King, down in the jungle room" etc. It's terrible and for all the insight he shows you'd swear he'd never even been to Memphis.
Then he redeems it with one line. He mentions being invited on stage during a gospel show and "I sang with all my might, she asked 'Are you a Christian child?' And I said Ma'am I am tonight."
That line speaks more of a love for music than the rest of the song put together.
I'd always read the line
"The time is gone, the song is over, thought I'd something more to say." as a knowing acknowledgement that while we are all always planning what we are going to do next, when the final breath is taken there will always be things left unfinished.
I'd not judged it as an inglorious collapse into a teeth-grindingly self-referential situationist joke, as you put it.
As the man in the NHS glasses said, "Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans."
Furry nuff
Judge how you will, my foxy friend, and it is on the whole a fine song (including the Breathe reprise). But if that parting thought is indeed a memento mori of his own mortality, it still feels like an inglorious intrusion in the first person into what has previously been a second-person study, As such, it's ear-bendingly awful, to these lobes at least. Apologies if the seed of doubt is planted, but then it would only add another dimension to the disappointment of the acknowledgement you mention...
Seriously, d'you think it's as aphoristic as the previous line?
Feel free to add other examples. And thanks, badartdog, for the link - one which helps maintain The Word's clickthroughs, in a pleasing way – but that pile of poor lyrics doesn't really cover the disappointment I'm driving at, when a corker is followed by a stinker...
Our lives are merely trees of possibilities.
Marc Bolan said that.
( Mind you he also said 'Call Me Rabbit Fighter').
"Oh Deborah
Always look like a zeb-uh-ra."
Er, so she specialised in chewing the cud, being really stripy and getting chased by lions?
Or, to put it another way,
dug-a-ree-dug-n-dug-a-ree-dug-ree-dug, ah, Debora.
the Beatles, " When I get home"
I always loved the couplet
"Come on, if you please,
I've got no time for trivialities "
but then a couple of lines later you get
"When I'm getting home tonight, I'm gonna hold her tight,
I'm gonna love her till the cows come home"
which just didn't sit right for me.
Judging by this then
it must be animal references that ruin rock lyrics. I'm sure there are hundreds of udder examples.
P.P.S.T
Poor Pun Stops Thread.
Not
necessarily.