Entertainment For Lively Minds
Favourite HJHM album pre-'Rubber Soul'
Posted by Remote Control on 21 March 2010 - 12:42pm.
I know The Serious Albums like the back of my hand but have neglected the fresh, early rock'n'roll records since a (less pretentious/portentous) kid.
Maybe in the light of the mono remasters, which of the earlier albums do you most rate?
- More from Remote Control.
- Login or register to post comments









A Hard Days Night
Thirty or so minutes of sugar rushing perfection. No flab. No filler.
AHDN
Out of the mono box I found A Hard Day's Night faultless. All killer, no filler, the only all Lennon-McCartney Beatles album: what a roll they were on.
AHDN too
Actually my favourite Beatles album of any era.
The Other Film
Help - my favourite pre-RS HJHM LP
Help
I keep forgetting how much I love nearly every song on this album.
AHDN of course, of course, of course,
but in terms of raw excitement, you can't beat the original UK mono pressings of "Please Please Me" and the "Long Tall Sally" EP for thrills aplenty.
I hate to bug the purists, but I also love the duophonic sound of the US-only "The Beatles Second Album".
I would never advocate that you do anything illegal, naturally, but if you google the letters "pb" joined together with the letters "thal", you may find an interesting Blogger site where the merits of these recordings are discussed in greater detail.
AHDN again
"If I Fell", "I Should Have Known Better", "I'll Be Back", "When I Get Home", "And I Love Her". Seriously, what's not to love?
For Sale
Easily my favourite album by the boys.
HELP!
Help!, You've got to hide your love away, You're gonna lose that girl, Ticket to Ride, Its only love, I've just seen a face, Yesterday... so that's 50% of the album made up of pure classics (about 10% more than AHDN)...
...and I'm almost too embarassed to ask at this stage but what does HJHM stand for??
whoops, should've been 'HJH'
http://www.wordmagazine.co.uk/content/word-jargon-and-jokes-a-guide
(I try and fit in, use camouflage, always get it wrong... :P )
All of them
But if I had to put them in some sort of order, I'd say...
Hard Day's Night
Help!
Please Please Me
With The Beatles
Beatles For Sale
But they all have their moments and would never treat them as less 'serious' or important as their later albums, which all have their moments of self-indulgence.
The one thing you could never accuse the early albums of is self-indulgence!
Seconded
These records are, if anything, better than the later ones because they're just pure undiluted pop attack and they were playing as a group. I tend to favour:
Hard Day's Night (the greatest example of sustained songwriting quality in pop ever - the songs on the second side weren't even in the film, for God's sake)
Beatles For Sale (largely because of the way it starts)
With The Beatles - It Won't Be Long, All My Loving etc.
Help! (what a great, great song that is)
Not a fan of Please Please Me but that's just me being picky.
Thirded
My order would be:
A Hard Day's Night
With The Beatles
Help!
Beatles For Sale
Please Please Me
AHDN first for the reasons stated above, PPM last because they haven't quite nailed it, that happens in the subsequent months when WTB plus From Me To You, She Loves You and I Want To Hold Your Hand are recorded.
It's A Draw...
HELP - because the first half is pure, uninterrupted brilliance, AHDN because its great and all L & M.
I am now going off to don the headphones to listen again while the FPO fawns over Larkrise to Cranford or whatever it's called.
AHDN
The only one my parents had, so like a baby chick following whatever creature it first sets eyes on, it's been imprinted on my brain. Even at the age of 4, I knew that John singing "You Can't Do That" made me feel all sort of funny...
..I have to say I love Help!, Please Please Me and A Hard Day’s
... Night. But I never quite got With the Beatles or Beatles for Sale. They have the odd moment (It Won’t Be Long, All My Loving, Eight Days A Week, What You’re Doing) but there’s far too much filler and the covers are largely uninspired (save the great Money)… Although Please Please Me follows a similar template it has the thrill of being their first proper foray into the studio and a raw innocent charm..
And I still need someone to explain why No Reply is so good (maybe I’m not picking up those “aeolian cadences”)
But the late period is still the best – I would argue that it is the presence of “Strawberry Fields”, “Penny Lane” and “Day in the Life” in their catalogue which elevates them to godlike status
As a student in London..
... 1982 - own room at last at 18 years old - as a long promised indulgence with the money I had earned that summer shelf stacking - bought myself MY OWN hi-fi from the various peculiar shops up and down the Tottenham Court Road (they were AWFUL places to buy something but you could dig out some bargains) - first record I bought to play on it was AHDN, a record I had known since childhood. That first chord - all so impossibly happy and exciting and excuse me I have something in both eyes and the eyes of several random passers-by.... I remember MOJO describing it as the sound of four disgracefully talented young men on rum, coke and amphetamines which is sort of true but that misses the joy of it.
The remasters have the rhythm section oomph that the CDs and stereo mixes lost - by god what a band
After all the recommendations for it on here...
... bought 'AHDN' Thanks for your comments. : >