....Don't want to make you cry or sing

I apologise for a long rambling start to what basically is a humble opinion sort of thread.

#1. I was reminded of a story often told by Danny Baker, how the young Marc Bolan used to boast that Ike Turner had asked him to play Rhythm Guitar on one of his recording. Marc's claim was scorned by the assembled crowd , who all knew Ike as the greatest rhythm guitarist on the planet.

#2. Mr Keith Richards is oft times named as the best rhythm Guitarist.

My question to the word blog people is, IYHO,whom is the best Rhythm guitarist known to you?

I have always had a soft spot for the playing of happy uncle Lou Reed.

always pleased to hear the views of others.

Speaking as a guitar player..

...who loves nothing better than to play rhythm: I have several favourites. Pete Townsend, Paul Weller, Prince, Nile Rodgers, Steve Cropper, Wilko Johnson. All of them are great guitarists full stop, but would be my recommendation to anybody wanting to study rhythm guitar.

SimonL | 14 August 2008 - 11:03pm

I think it's between

Bruce Welch, Wilco Johnson and Mick Green. I know you could argue that some of these also play lead, but it's their rhythm that drives their bands along.

I'm going to vote for Bruce Welch.

davecowps | 14 August 2008 - 11:12pm

It's whoever...

...played rhythm guitar with Buddy Holly and The Crickets. I can't even begin to imagine how some of those records are played. The power and effortlessness they have is immense.

Lucas Hare | 15 August 2008 - 6:20am

What is the rhythm for?

Rick Parfitt may well be the consummate example.
Or even Johnny Ramone?
Maybe the musos would prefer a more, erm, appreciated talent, so my shout would be Simon Nicol.

Retropath2 | 15 August 2008 - 6:52am

Good question

I'd second Nile Rodgers and Bruce Welch as two fine rhythm players. Did you know at the height of The Shads fame Bruce worked himself up into such a mania about having his guitar in perfect tune he eventually couldn't bear to do it? It would take him literally hours of constant adjusting before each gig. One of the others always had to do it for him.

Mick Green too, who I think shares the same mantle as ZZ Top's Billy Gibbons as one of the finest rhythm and lead players ever.

Andy Barrons | 15 August 2008 - 7:01am

My Top 10 in no particular order...

Johnny Marr - subtle, melodic and inventive

Nile Rodgers - made dancefloors heave the world over

Joni Mitchell - invented strange tunings that gave her music its own unique voice

Curtis Mayfield - guitar playing as sweet and soulful as his voice

Keith Richards - you want unforgettable riffs that you can dance to? Keef's yer man...

Bo Diddley - how many guitar players can claim to have invented a rhythm?

John Lee Hooker - dirty, horny, sexy guitar.

Jimi Hendrix - people often forget that his rhythm playing was as extraordinary as his lead.

Leo Nocentelli - The Meters' guitarist was mainlined to the fonk.

Pete Townshend - Power chords? Check. But so much more besides...

Patrick Crowther | 15 August 2008 - 7:31am

what is a rhythm guitarist exactly?

Not being difficult but when does rhythm become lead?

I assume that it's a movable boundary, based on playing chord sequences rather than single notes?

If so, my vote is for Billy Bragg. For years I never really got him - I thought he was just thrashing away and singing out of tune. After I started playing guitar, and tried to play some of his stuff, I soon changed my opinion. Deceptively simple, beautiful progressions and melodies, visceral stabs of treble - what's not to love?

ceepee | 15 August 2008 - 9:10am

"Thrashing away"

Forgot, johnny Marr is an exemplary rhythmicist, I think, aided and abetted (natch) by the fact that he once said that all he was doing was playing speeded up Fairport riffs, as played by my earlier proponent, Nicol, S

Retropath2 | 15 August 2008 - 9:34am

2 jims...

Jimmy Nolen and, believe it or not Jimi Hendrix, whose exemplary rhythm playing is often overshadowed by the fact that he is also the greatest lead guitarist ever.

shane pacey | 15 August 2008 - 12:25pm

No arguments with any of the above...

but Lee Mavers from The La's is an incredible rhythm guitarist. He has impeccable timing, and a real sense of how to use the space within his music - doesn't just strum away aimlessly.

Nick Orton | 15 August 2008 - 2:25pm

And there's more.....

Frank "Poncho" Sampedro: part of the underpraised 'Horse, backing up Mr Youngs rockier forays for years. Someone has to keep it all together, and that he does, with the solid undercurrent of stolid bass and straightforward drums. It works and it ain't broken.

Retropath2 | 15 August 2008 - 2:32pm

Sterling Morrison was a

Sterling Morrison was a really great rhythm player, would also have to mention the following as well:

Malcolm Young
Johnny Ramone
John Lennon
Joe Strummer
Bobby Womack
Eddie Cochran

jimmymack | 15 August 2008 - 3:56pm

A left-field shout

for Roky Erikson and Syd Barrett

two men who really had a strange ,but none the less, compelling approach to rhythm

simontyler | 15 August 2008 - 4:18pm

Glaringly obvious but, in latter years at least....

Bruce Springsteen...

Standing back to allow Nils Lofgren and Steve van Zandt to weave over the top

Anyone else brandishing a Telecaster is fine with me!

John Waite | 15 August 2008 - 5:43pm

Pete Townsend

It wasn't until I saw The Who live did I realise just how good a guitarist Pete Townsend is. Lead and rhythm all in one go.

Crowdedmouse | 16 August 2008 - 9:01am

Joe Strummer and his amazing pumping electric leg

has to be one of the best.

Although, I tend to think of a rhythm guitarist as one of two - is that what you mean? Someone like Strummer backing up Mick Jones?

If you're talking lead and rhythm all in one then I'd go for Wilko Johnson and then Bill Carter from Screaming Blue Messiahs.

Retro Man | 18 August 2008 - 2:58pm

Jimmie Vaughan. . .

is the best I've ever seen. (I'd even go so far as to claim - ducking for cover - that on the occasions when he steps into the spotlight he's also a better lead player than his late bro.)

Archie Valparaiso | 19 August 2008 - 5:46pm

More finesse

And restraint than SRV definitely. But for inventiveness, drama and passion then I'm an SRV man all the way.

Saw Jimmie Lee Vaughan live twice,once with the T-Birds and once solo, and he does indeed deserve all his accolades on his own merit; lionised brother aside.

Andy Barrons | 26 August 2008 - 3:08pm

Rhythm Guitar

I can't say I've ever been that impressed by anyone playing rhythm, it's often essential to the song but surely any good guitarist can do it well. However, I'll vote for Bo Diddley as he was a man who made his own rhythm.

kidpresentable | 20 August 2008 - 3:43pm