Entertainment For Lively Minds
Concept Albums: Part I: The Good
(Keep in mind that this a column only for my own enjoyment. Bon Appetite)
Concept Albums are strange beasts, and I thought I'd have a look at the concept of concept albums (heh), and review some of my favorite examples.
The purpose of a concept album is often to tell a story, or something to that effect. Some genres (as you might have figured, we are talking about sub-genres of the the incredibly large and appendaged genre of rock here) are more likely to conceive these albums, and no genre creates as many concept albums as progressive rock. The telling of tales seems to be incorporated in the foundations of many prog rock bands. Songs often follow a coherent storyline, or re-tell legends or myths, or , so it only seems natural that the next step for a prog rock band would be to devote an entire album to telling a story.
However, concept albums aren't exclusive to progressive rock. The Who released "Tommy" in 1969, and that album is still one of the best examples of an entirely devoted concept album (although it's usually referenced to as a "rock opera"). Starting from the first song, the listener is submerged into Pete Townsend's story of a post-war child messiah. For this album, The Who continued to drift away from their British invasion sound, and adapted a majestic, orchestral sound. The songs were multi tracked more than ever before, with piano and brass instruments (contributed by bassist John Entwistle) joining the guitar, bass and drum sound of previous Who records. Just like in an opera, Townsend has several motifs which he spreads across the span of the album( "See me, feel me, touch me"). The storyline is consistent, and it's evident that Townsend carefully planned the story. The result is the feeling that you are watching a movie, through your headphones (as some might recall, there was a movie made sometime in the 70's, but I wouldn't recommend it, since it's horrible.)
Another classic example of a well made concept album is "The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway", Genesis 1974 masterpiece. Containing a complex storyline referencing the bible,centuries of British literature and and folklore, the album is story of Rael, a NYC street kid who finds himself in a Dante-esque journey into his own absurd consciousness. At this point, Genesis had become a cult band, and for this album they seem to have deliberately popped their sound up. Most of the songs are more traditionally structured and the choruses are catchier. This is not a bad thing, and the music matches Peter Gabriel's multi-layered story perfectly. Strange guitars, jazzy drums and fiddly organ riffs creates a wonderful wall of sound, and the listener finds something new every time.
Now, it might seem that I'm some old prog nut stuck in the 70's, but fret not, I love contemporary music as much as I love the music of the 70's (this makes sense, since I recently celebrated my 18th birthday). Anyway, i'm happy to report that the spirit of the concept album lives on! I'm a big fan of Coheed and Cambria, a modern prog rock act. This band has released 4 albums so far, and their output goes from smooth, RnB-ish acoustic ballads to balls to the wall metal and back. Their albums make up the basis for a story about cyborgs, inter-planetary wars and a messiah. This tale, called the Amory Wars, is continued in comic books released by the bands frontman, one Claudio Sanchez. The music of Coheed and Cambria is some of the best released this millenia (don't you love that such a lustrously naive comment is still possible to make?). Blending the sound of modern rock with the progressive influences of Rush and Yes, the result is very exciting, and I have yet to meet someone who doesn't like it after a few listens (except hiphop and chart pop lovers of course, but lets take them out of the equation, since their perception of good music is obviously severely flawed.) Taking ingredients from 30+ years of good music, Coheed and Cambria steers their spaceship succesfully through prog rock, metal, emo (but in a good way!), and pop punk, to arrive at four fantastic concept albums that no prog rock lover, regardless of age, should be without. I recently played this to my father, (a prog rocker who recently turned 50), and he's currently blasting it in his car, singing along to Sanchez insanely high-pithched vocals. On a side note, try to pick up Claudio Sanchez solo project, "The Prize Fighter Inferno", yet another concept album, where prog, folk and electronica live togehter in a happy, although weird, relationship.
There you have it, three (or seven) good examples of concept albums. I hope I have given you, the reader, some new recommendations, or that I have rekindled the concept album flame inside you.
But of course, where there is good there must always be bad, and there are several stinkers in the concept album family. However, we'll save that for next time, where I'll write some more incoherent reviews of concept albums. Tata!
- More from HolyJack.
- Login or register to post comments









At last I don't feel like
At last I don't feel like the youngest person on this site into these bands!!
I prefer 'Quadrophenia' to 'Tommy'; 'Quadrophenia' has a concept one can relate to much more easily, I feel. I never saw the film of 'Quadrophenia' but I did see 'Tommy' and maybe that's what's put me off 'Tommy' a bit as that film is horribly overblown- it's slathered in horrible synthesisers and features singing turns from actors who really should have known better!
As for 'The Lamb...', I agree that the 1st disc is fairly accessible but I think the 2nd was their most dense and complex- 'The Waiting Room' is bizarre but I like it a lot. With 'The Lamb...', I think they came slightly unstuck by the end because I believe the music and the lyrics were not written at the same time and to me, the 4th side of the album has always been slightly weaker- as if they are running out of time and/or ideas.
I never got into Coheed and Cambria- that vocalist gives me the heebee geebies!!
Other concept albums I like:
The Strawbs- Grave New World
The Pretty Things- SF Sorrow
Pink Floyd- Dark Side Of The Moon, The Wall
Fairport Convention- Babbacombe Lee (was playing this the other day and I really adore it, very underrated)
XTC- Skylarking
A lot of albums that get dubbed 'concept albums' are actually not- The Small Faces' 'Ogden's Nut Gone Flake', Rush's '2112' and Yes' 'Close To The Edge' spring to mind, as all of these only had one side of vinyl which was thematically linked.
If somebody could explain what the concepts of The Moody Blues' albums were in plain English, I'd be grateful!!
Moody Blues in plain English
Well, Days of Future Passed is a day in the life of an ordinary person (with an orchestra). In Search of the Lost Chord is about the search for fulfilment (it turns out to be the mantra "Om"). On the Threshold of a Dream is about dreams. To Our Children's Children's Children is about the moon landing and legacy.
After that I'm not sure, I think they stopped doing concept albums thing after Seventh Sojourn.
Peter Gabriel's Ovo is a good one and probably the only proper concept album he's done since leaving Genesis (unless you count "not using cymbals" on the third album as a concept).
A Question Of Balance
has a unified theme that extends from the cover art (try including that in the "concept" now we're in the age of 5 inch square CD artwork! Sigh.) through every song, whether it's about finding balance in one's personal life, or balance in our collective occupancy, and exploitation, of the planet Earth. One of the best assembled, and most cohesive "concept" albums ever done, I think.
Moody Blues and sleeve artwork
The Moody Blues artwork was fantastic. I know their stuff because my Dad is a fan and I remember spending my younger days looking at the sleeves for ages.
I also recently realised that one of the reasons I like the Big Room at Real World studios because it reminds me of the inside gatefold sleeve of ELO's Out of the Blue. Well... a little bit.
Coheed And Cambria
I've tried, I really have. But why is it so much like hard work? They can play the arses off most bands, and they're obviously prodigiously talented technicians, but there's just not enough of a range of darkness and light in the musical landscape. I have retired, exhausted, from the playing field that is their enormo-concept. Maybe in another lifetime, I'll discover them before I turn 20.
Off the top of my head....
....and there is no prog rock here!
My favourite concept albums would be -
Desperado - Eagles
Good Old Boys - Randy Newman
Greendale - Neil Young
The Revolution Starts Now - Steve Earle
Also not prog
The Ballad of Sally Rose by Emmylou Harris
Living with War by Neil Young
The Houston Kid by Rodney Crowell
A Secret life by Marianne Faithfull
A few:
Aimee Mann - The Forgotten Arm
Marillion - Brave
Queensryche - Operation Mindcrime
Explosions in the Sky - The Rescue
Kate Bush - The Ninth Wave (technically side 2 (explanatory note for younger readers etc etc) of Hounds of Love)
Kate Bush - Ariel (a Sky of Honey)
Tori Amos - Scarlet's Walk
Pink Floyd - The Wall (for those moments when you feel too happy and optimistic with life)
Finally, and I fully expect to be laughed at, Jeff Wayne's Musical Version of War of the Worlds is still fabulous.
Seconded.
The War Of The Worlds is a great occasional indulgence. You need a darkened room, you need to get comfy (glug, glug, chink) and you need to listen to the whole thing to the end. It's like a visit to the flicks, but the only limit is your own imagination. Brilliant.
I heartily agree with WoTW...
...one of the first albums I went out and bought with my own cash as a young teenager (along with Thin Lizzy's Jailbreak and a double album of ELO 1 & 2).
We went to see the live version which Jeff Wayne toured a couple of years ago and it was astonishing! They'd sourced a good few of the original artists to perform... Justin Hayward (you couldn't imagine anyone else singing his parts, could you?), Chris Thompson... even had Chris Spedding on guitar and Herbie Flowers on bass. Also had Hugh Burns and Laurie Wisefield playing guitar too.
If they ever tour it again I can't reccommend it highly enough. Never thought it would really work live but it did - in spades!
Greendale
Ah, Greendale. Always meant to pick that one up, but I haven't got to it yet. Going to see Young in about a week, maybe he'll do a song off it.