Entertainment For Lively Minds
Boy Bands
The resurrection of Take That over the past few years has been interesting, if only for the fact that a Boy Band has been permitted by the record-buying public to go away, grow up and return as actual men, albeit to a rose-tinted perception from many fans that some of Peter Pan's immortality has conveniently airbrushed stray grey hairs and "laughter lines". On some level their return offers hope to all men that revisiting the promise of youth need not be the vicissitudes of a mid-life crisis.
The transience of Boy Bands always seemed to be part of their appeal, their role to provide a soundtrack for a couple of years (at most) to a key stage in a (predominantly) teenager's life and then be cast aside as part of the Corinthian mantra "to put away childish things". Did Lee, Jimmy and Spike from 911 watch Toy Story 3 and empathise more keenly than I with the plight of those sad and neglected toys?
I've never knowlingly bought a record by a Boy Band, unless you include The Beatles as an example of one. However, there are songs that have stayed with me down the years and to a large degree have helped certain memories burn brighter than others, usually those of old girlfriends, spectacular 'crash and burn' chat-up attempts and significant societal events such as the failure of the England football team to live up to the nation's unwavering irrational belief in their sporting competence.
This morning The Wanted's Glad You Came has been played loudly and repeatedly by my eldest daughter. Like her I can't stop singing it and I don't want to. It's not only stirred up great memories from my youth but, damn it, it makes me feel good and there's something liberating about a 44 year old father being introduced to a new song by his 8 year old daughter. To these ears there's very little in the way of pop music around in the charts and at least with a song like Glad You Came it provides a way in to music in my own collection that might interest her on another day, something to tide her over when The Wanted lose their appeal: I'm betting on October 2012 as the month of their eviction notice.
And let's be honest there could be at least 10 years of this endless cycle and recycle of gurning, gyrating pretty boys with too much hair and teeth.
911- Bodyshakin'
- More from Ahh_Bisto.
- Login or register to post comments










Manufactured pop
Good for you Ah-Bisto!
I have long since stopped being sniffy about the genesis or origin of songs and have learned to enjoy songs on their merits rather than conventionally held view on it being 'cool' or ' real'.
In my book Take That have at least 5 excellent songs in their catalogue, which is many more that some of my very favourite Indie/ Rock bands.
Likewise, Girls Aloud have been the best single band of the last 10 years, and Cher Lloyd's last 2 singles have been terrific (although i guess neither are boy bands).
You cant beat a great disposible pop song!
Consider yourself seconded
It is one of the benefits of not being young (don't think I was ever hip) that you can judge a song on its merit of whether you like it or not rather than who it's by. Maybe it's a bit of nostalgia but as you say Take that have at least 5 good quality songs. That said I wasn't brave enough to nominate them for the good band / rubbish name thread but I was tempted. At risk of stretching a point bring on the Spice Girls revival.
The Beatles as boy-band?
No, in that they formed themselves, before meeting a manager that was more a fan than a Machiavellian manipulator.
The Monkees, though, probably fit the bill as what we'd call a boy band today. And they were great!
911
It really pleased me to find out a couple of months back that one of 911 was married to one of B*Witched. It seemed like a perfect late 90s, B-list pop group pairing.
Anyway, I could post Everybody (Backstreet's Back) but I'm sure Bob will be along to do that before the day's out, so here are a couple of great 90s boyband tracks from across the pond.
(*NSYNC - Bye Bye Bye)
(Hanson - MMMBop)
Boyzone
My brother wrote most of their first 2 albums. I love songs like Key To My Life, Paradise, Isn't it A Wonder and their first number one, Different Beat(all his compositions.) He then did all of B*Witched hits, nominated for an Ivor Novello award for U.S top 10 hit C'est La Vie. Proud? I don't talk about it EVERY day! I'm on my poxy Blackberry otherwise I'd'post some videos. Nuthin' wrong with a boy band.
hmm,
Whatever turns you on
One Direction
My daughter went to see them recently - her first ever gig - and her excitement when she got home was familiar to me when I was in my teens. I wouldn't begrudge her the slightest fraction of her appreciation of them.
OK, so on this site we might not really appreciate such bands, but if 1D gets her onto a musical track in life then isn't it a good thing?
Reminds me of the comment about comics: a child who reads them grows up into an adult who reads books (whereas a child who reads nothing grows up into an adult who reads nothing).