Best guest appearance on a record
Getting a guest vocalist or instrumentalist on your record is often one way of broadening your appeal.
Only this month (as reported in The Word), Billy Bragg has got Robert Wyatt to duet with him, while Elbow have employed the crooning talents of Richard Hawley on new album Seldom Seen Kid.
But is the guest appearance always worth it?
In an attempt to galvanise the 53 people left in the world who don't own a copy of Thriller (and as a 25th anniversary stunt), Michael Jackson has re-recorded his landmark album with 'popular artists of the day', including Fergie and Akon - god help us!
My personal favourite appearance and submission for the best in the category is Jools Holland's piano solo on the end of The The's Uncertain Smile. A good song, made unforgettable by a little tinkling of the ivories.
Any other suggestions?
- More from robram.
- Login or register to post comments








jools again
on 'good thing' by the Fine Young Cannibals; Jools might well be a one-trick-pony, but he carries it off well!
No, Jools Holland RUINED Uncertain Smile...
...like he does whenever he muscles in on any act on ...Later. The original without his boogie-woogie was miles better.
Fair enough
difference of opinion.
Can you suggest someone who did make a vast difference to a tune, instead?
Jacko
Although I can't say I am a fan, Beat It was made by the rock-guitar of that Van Halen chap.
Tit for tat?
EC on Georges weeping guitar and L'Angelo Mysterioso (aka George) on Badge.
And latterly, if voice is an instrument...
....the equivalent you rub mine and I'll rub yours of Davey Spillane on the standout track on Traffics latterday Far from Home, Holy Ground, and Mr Winwoods reciprocal pipes on Forever Frozen off Pipe Dreams.
Plus, whilst we're on a folk tinged hue, am I alone in thinking James O'Grady enliven thr Oysterbands LPs on which he appears?
Here goes...
...always loved Phil Collins' various appearances on albums of the 70s and 80s. Contributes some superb drumming to Brian Eno's 'Another Green World' and John Martyn's 'Grace And Danger' (and backing vocals on that one). I have always loved that massive 'gated' drum sound he had on Peter Gabriel's 'Intruder' and 'No Self Control'.
Rick Wakeman had a spate of appearances on David Bowie albums, although some of them were done when he was a session player so I'm not sure if it's valid here; anyway, his playing on 'Hunky Dory' is exemplary and actually, in my mind, plays a large part in what makes that album so great (think the opening chords of 'Changes', 'Life On Mars' etc.). He also played mellotron on 'Space Oddity' and some nice piano on the marvellous 'Absolute Beginners'.
Stevie Wonder
His harmonica solo on the Eurythmics' "There Must Be An Angel". Bliss.
Nearly put that in
although I realised that Mr Wonder does tend to lend out his talents out willy-nilly.
He also played a similarly great harmonica riff on Chaka Khan's I Feel For You
Nightingales
on Prefab Sprout's "From Langley Park To Memphis", also featured some nifty Wonder harmonicarization.
oh forgot...
does Dusty Springfields vocal on 'What have I done to deserve this?' by Pet Shop Boys count?
I think it should. I also think it's marvellous!
Seperated At Birth
Keith Richards on "That Feel", "Blind Love" and "Big Black Mariah" by Tom Waits.
I think it was Nostradamus who first predicted that these two would go well together.
"Death Is Not The End"
When Nick Cave got Polly Harvey, Shane MacGowan, Kylie Minogue and various Bad Seeds around the piano for a rendition of Dylan's "Death Is Not The End", I was hoping it would sound just like "That Feel". It didn't sound drunk enough for my liking (except Shane of course), but it's still a reasonably good use of guest voices:
Billy Preston
On Get Back
Run Straight Down, Transverse City.
Warren Zevon was broke, so he sent the master tape to Dave Gilmour, who obligingly did his thing and sent it back. Neil Young did the same thing. Lifted both things immeasurably. Although there's never a track which isn't improved tenfold by Richard Thompson guesting on it, his appearance is always greeted with a hearty "Hello Richard!" round our way - Any Trouble's "Open Fire" being a good example. The Crowdies' "Sister Madly" is a rare, but brilliant exception - an all too brief, and atypically jazzy excursion.
But whose idea was it to hoick Slash into the middle of a Bob Dylan song? Well, I say 'song', it was "Wiggle Wiggle" and I say 'into' - he's not really there, is he?
Details, please, Skirky, old bean.
Which version of Open Fire? Surely not the Stiff original, unless it is a "well kept secret appearance".
Talking of RT, as we were, his appearances on Michael Doucets Cajun Brew, esp his own song, Woman or a man, is exemplary. Likewise his appearances on the Los Lobos curiously unlauded (cos I think it's great)The Ride, which has several guests on different tracks. Not so good, surprisingly, on last years Peter Case's Sleepy John.
Robert Dougal's enigmatic utterance
at the close of "The Man Who Found God On The Moon" from Mike McGear's rather splendid solo album, adventurously titled "McGear", is a rather nice touch, finishing off proceedings with a wistfully English quirkiness.
"Is the guest appearance worth it" - Yes, usually:-
Roger Troutman on Scritti Politti's "Boom There She Was" (Provision)
Eric Clapton on John Martyn's "Couldn't Love You More" (Glorious Fool)
Eric Clapton on the title track of Roger Waters' (Pros & Cons Of Hitch-hiking)
Prince on Kate Bush's "Why Should I Love You" (The Red Shoes)
Jimi Hendrix on Steve Stills "Old Times, Good Times" (Stephen Stills)
Paddy Moloney on Mike Oldfield's "Ommadawn"
Green Gartside on Elvis Costello's "I Wanna Be Loved" (Goodbye Cruel World)
Joni Mitchell on Seal's "If I Could" (Seal 2)
Joni Mitchell on James Taylor's "Long Ago And Far Away" (Mud Slide Slim)
Jerry Garcia on Thomas Dolby's "Beauty Of A Dream" (Astronauts & Heretics)
Robert Fripp on David Bowie's "Fashion" (Scary Monsters...)
and for my money Macca absolutely wiped the floor with Jacko on the original "The Girl Is Mine" (Thriller)
Talking of Green Gartside,
How about Miles Davis on Oh Patti. Absolutely sublime.
Who could forget...
Billy Corgan's magnificent contribution to New Order's Turn My Way on Get Ready? Or, indeed, Bobby Gillespie's input to Rock the Shack on the same album? Two perfectly ordinary tracks made almost unlistenable...
Different bass player
Absolutely love Just Above My Rocking Horse's Head by Richie Havens. Big factor is the bass playing of Steve Stills. Even better is Revolution Blues by Neil Young, with the great feel from the rhythm section of Levon Helm and in particular Rick Danko on bass.
Chet Baker
Chet Baker's trumpet solo on Elvis Costello's "Shipbuilding". Lovely.
Was that Chet Baker?
Respect! (I had always thought it was Elvis' dad, the secret lemonade drinker himself, not least as he trumpets on one of the dodgier free-form experiments on Goodbye Cruel World)
Tubular Bells
Viv Stanshall introducing various instruments on Mike Oldfield's Tubular Bells. Stroke of genius.
Open Fire feat. RT
Opening track on Any Trouble's "Wrong End of the Race" - a veritable smorgasbord of guest contributions as it happens. Billy Bremner on rhythm, Iain Matthews on BV's, a whole song and then RT's patent open string / fretted bend strat-attack to close. The album's also notable for The Sutherland Brothers on BVs's, a crack New York horn section, Alan Dunn on accordian, Bobby Valentino on fiddle, a Robert Kirby string arrangement and I understand there may be a kitchen sink featured somewhere among the proceedings. Also, and this is a sadly undermentioned facet of the whole process, they got Bob Clearmountain to remix one track. Yes, I AM rather familiar with it, since you mention... Last spotted reissued on BGO records and well worth adding to any list of "Should have been huge" bands anyone may be compiling.
Damn.....
just when I thought I could make do with the 2 stiff originals on vinyl, some bastard comes along and points out I can't. I knew I should have bought it when I spotted it in Swordfish, Brum, 7 or 8 years ago. True thanks, Skirky
All well and good
except the only way we can currently check out your recommendation is via "Used and new from £45 million quid" on Amazon.
Time for a Word Magazine "Re-issue it NOW, or the budgie gets it" campaign?
2 "Spring" to Mind
Sinead O'Connor on "Kingdom Of Rain" from "The The - Mind Bomb",
just terrific, and
Thom Yorke on "The Mess We're In" from PJ Harvey's Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea.
Superb Music.
RE MC
Trout by Neneh Cherry is notable for Michael Stipe’s attempt at social commentary through the medium of rap. Sample lyric:
“Parents and teachers get together get cool
Children need to learn about sex in school
Children need to learn about sex in school
You think they don't do it?
Don't get fooled
Parents don't turn your back on the pack
Teachers want to teach but the law says whack…”
Not so much a guest appearance more a takeover
'Smooth jazz' trumpeter Chris Botti more or less guests on his own track Midnight Without You, letting The Blue Nile do the donkey work. Result : one of the best Nile songs with added (and brilliant) trumpet.
Paul Buchanan also makes this. He wouldn't appear in the video so they got Peter Kay in. An obvious choice, really.
What about Johnny Cash with U2?
Last song on Zooropa: The Wanderer. One of the most out-there things Cash ever did, I'd imagine. Amazingly atmospheric song and production, bit of a hidden masterpiece, even.
What about this
Bonio's best moment!
(OK, New years Day and Sunday Blody sunday were pretty damn good, but it is just that , as we dear readers know, he is such a twerp. Pity really.)
No contest.
Emmylou Harris on the two Gram Parsons solo albums.