Entertainment For Lively Minds
Best Dylan Track (Again)
I know this has been done and probably overdone but there's a few newbies around here (including me) since it was last discussed. Anyway, he's back on Spotify and that calls for some celebration.
What's your favourite Dylan track? You can only choose one (say your world is on fire or something) and it can be from anywhere.
My choice - as with most people's - probably depends on mood, time of year, weather, pints drunk etc. However, after careful consideration there is one song I turn to often for multiple, one-after-the-other plays. It's Just Like Tom Thumb's Blues. Still not sure what it's really about but there's a spooky lot of my life in there - how could he know?
Probably obvious choice but (to quote Simon Armitage on something else entirely) what's the good of having a party if you don't invite your friends?
- More from JudeMaccready.
- Login or register to post comments










Mississippi
Just to prove there is some love for his later work.
Blues.
I read recently in a book that Alan Lomax heard his Father, John, once singing an old blues/prison song with the verse: 'It aint but the one thing I done wrong, I stayed in Mississippi just a day too long.' Can't find any record of it elsewhere.
One? Just one?
That's very tough, but today my answer is Desolation Row.
I'm struggling very hard to stick to the spirit of the post, and to not mention dozens of others under the cover of, 'on another day it might be ...'.
After much soul searching
And for pure unashamedly personal reasons "Forever Young"
RIP Stuart
Toughie
but I will have to plump for Girl From The North Country.......no Ballad In Plain D! Girl/Ballad/Girl/Ballad/Girl/Ballad!!
Sod it I am going to toss a coin;
It was Heads for Girl From The North Country
Phew, I'm going for a lie down!
Sorry for not sticking to
Sorry for not sticking to the spirit of the post - that was much more of a tougher decision than it needed to be! A real Daddy/Chips moment!
Just as well
You weren't also going for One More Cup Of Coffee - you might have ended up with Girl In Plain D Cup.
'I Don't Believe You' and/or
.....'To Ramona' both from Dylan's (contentious opinion alert) best LP.
Not a Dylan fan
at all. But I do rather like Jokerman.
Tough
But it would have to be Positively Fourth Street for me
Visions of Johanna
From Blonde on Blonde
Easy
'Visions of Johanna'. The live version off Biograph.
Wait, is this best or favourite Dylan track?
Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands is my favourite, but it's probably not quite his best.
First vote for the obvious one
I'm a big Dylan fan and have all his albums, so there are loads that I could have chosen, but I'll go with the first one I ever heard - Like a Rolling Stone.
Here's the second
It's thrilling, interesting, breathless, relentless, passionate, ramshackle, tight. It's just brilliant. He's never been better.
Sod other opinions. (SOO)
Couldn't choose one favourite
but just for today let's go with I Threw It All Away.
Tangled Up In Blue
The first time I listened to Blood On The Tracks I played this song six times before going on to the next track. It took me two and a half hours to listen to the whole album, which made it excellent value.
Is the right answer!
A fantastic song - lovely melody and a narrative that shifts perspective every other line. Ace.
Love Minus Zero/ No Limit
Two of my three favourite Dylan songs have already been mentioned, so I'll go for this miniature masterpiece off "Bringing It All Back Home".
Subterranean Homesick Blues
Obvious I know, but in 1965 it must have sounded like it was beamed in from space. It was the first Dylan tune I heard and loved and it still sets my brain on fire...
Not Dark Yet
What a lyric. Dylan recognising that the flame is dying and coming to terms with life.
Ooh...
I thought of a number, but if I really had to pick just one it'd be Mr Tambourine Man, wonderful song and his loveliest singing.
Blind Willie McTell...
Just staggering that he even left it off Infidels.
Visions of Johanna
The perfect blend of music and lyrics; although as ever it's a close call with 'Blind Willie McTell' as runner-up.
No make it
'Blind Willie McTell' at No 1 with Visions of Johanna as runner-up. As Doug rightly says it's staggering that this masterpiece was left off 'Infidels'. Potentially it could have been the best album of the 80s (also - see 'Foot of Pride' among other tracks).
As a succinct blend of music and lyrics..
you'd go a long way in my opinion to better "Don't think twice, it's alright". It says it all in 4 verses
I played and sang this in the jam room on the Cayamo Cruise in 2009, alongside a teenage girl who said it was her favourite song. I was flummoxed by the way her speech patterns and rhythmic delivery were so different to mine that it was almost as if we were singing 2 different songs. When I asked her how she knew it she told me it was by her favourite artistes The Indigo Girls and Brandi Carlile, both of whom were on the cruise. I'm not sure she'd heard of Bob Dylan
Their version is very good by the way, whereas I doubt his is much cop these days
The cops don't need you
and man they expect the same.
So Just like Tom Thumb's Blues for me too, but if Jude has claimed that one I will go for Black Diamond Bay, from Desire.
I have a 3rd if necessary. You can't eat only one, can you?
Some fine choices
- but "It's Alright Ma (I'm Only Bleeding)" is the answer. OOAA as ever.
A Public Execution
... by Mouse & The Traps.
Lots to admire, lots to return to again and again...
I couldn't pick a "best" and, like lots of the above, my favourite changes from day to day. But for me, the only song sung by Dylan to bring a genuine lump to the throat and tear to the eye is a cover of a song written nearly a century ago. It's a rarity, and I can't find it on Youtube. I don't even own it any more, though it's not far from the mental pile of records that I never need to play again, because it's just... there. The B-side of Watching the River Flow, which is where I first heard it. A simple gem, beautifully sung and played:
Spanish is the loving tongue
Soft as music, light as spring
It was a girl I learned it from
Living down Sonora way
Well, I don't look much like a lover
Still I say her love words over
Mostly when I'm all alone
Mi amor, mi cora sole.
Haven't seen her since that night
I can't cross the line you know
They want me for a gamblin' fight
Like as not it's better so
Still I always kind of missed her
Since that last sad night I kissed her
Broke her heart, lost my own
Adios, mi cora sole
Broke her heart, lost my own
Adios, mi cora sole
Adios, mi cora sole
Adios, mi cora sole.
Some hate it
but I think that Is Your Love In Vain? is my favourite, closely followed by I Threw It All Away.
FWIIW
Tangled up in blue.
Wonderful song from my favourite BD album.
Not Dark Yet.
An amazing, personal confession of a song about life that like most of Bob's great songs the listener can at least relate to part of it and hear somebody else articulate it in poetic form. I was never in his 60's or 70's material, I got into him from Infidels onward without the prejudice of comparing everything to Blowin In The Wind et al. 'Sugar Babe' is another one too.