Entertainment For Lively Minds

Word RSS FeedsWord Magazine on YouTubeWord Magazine on Last FMWord Magazine on Share My PlaylistsWord Spotify PlaylistsWord Magazine on FacebookWord Magazine on Twitter

Beeb Beeb Ceeb.

MrTaylor's picture

BBC4's 'When Rock Goes Acoustic' yesterday evening was mildly interestung with a lovely clip of Sir Keith of Richards waving a guitar about playing a 12bar blues. But for me as someone who plays and has listened to this type of music for over forty years I thought the programme, especially for a BBC4 effort, resembled more of a quite shallow VH1/MTV prog. Clearly the subject matter was aimed at youngsters being reminded of how 'cool' acoustic is as well as stadium/festival rock. I thought it was going to be a more intelligent history than interviews with the likes of Extreme, nice chaps they seemed..

Where was the style and technique of John Fahey, Leo Kottke, John Martyn? Even the Jimmy Page clip was when he was fifteen and playing skiffle. Richard Thompson would have been a ideal voice to explain the acoustic's allure and history. Hardly any mention of country blues, Eddie Lang, Nick Drake, Ry Cooder even. They didn't even manage to point out that one of Nirvana's songs om their 'radical' MTV Unplugged, which was just a commercial trend anyhow, was a Leadbelly song.

Oh well. Hereth end my tuppence worth.

1

It was rubbish, really, wasn't it...

A very rare example of an extremely poor music documentary slipping through under the normally-infallible BBC4 quality control radar.

I did like the bit where Keef snored after performing Satisfaction, though.

1
Patrick Crowther | 3 September 2011 - 12:51pm

It was

a great Jimmy Page skiffle clip, though.

0
Stephen Merrick | 4 September 2011 - 2:46pm

I did laugh

At the guy from Extreme talking about the people turning up at their shows expecting litling acoustic ballads and, to their horror, getting a metal show.

Then I remembered the song and wanted to kill him.

0
Vent My Spleen | 4 September 2011 - 3:36pm

More than words

I went to see Extreme at Wembley Arena in 1989 and it was a loud mess. I was very disappointed. I wasn't expecting an acoustic set though!

0
andrewdavidlong | 4 September 2011 - 4:07pm

Craptastic

possibly the poorest thing I've seen on BBC4, i suppose they can flog it around the globe, but most of the talking heads chosen to represent the subject were poor, Kitty Empire as the token woman, that poodle permed bloke from a US guitar porn mag etc. Nice to see Bert on, but even he was given little space to say anything really interesting. Getting a bit cheesed off with the "ironic" commentary of Mark Radcliffe too, clearly following the format of the band members series of a year or so ago.

2
soapdodger | 4 September 2011 - 4:15pm
Privacy Statement    ©  2006 - 2012 Development Hell Ltd