Intelligent Life On Planet Rock
Are we ready for analog radio switch-off ?
There has been surprisingly little comment about the proposed switch-over to digital radio and switch-off of analogue radio.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/mediatechnologyandteleco...
I'm a fan of my DAB radio, Radio 6 wakes me every morning , but I am not totally sure it is the bright shining future yet. For example :
- the quality of the signal and of available equipment is still wildly variable. I had to buy three radios before I got a decent one. Even on this one you have to reprogramme if you travel the country, and so end up with multiple entries in the menu.
- from a green point of point it is very power hungry. Just see how long batteries last. To illustrate, one of those wind-up radios will deliver an hour's listening from one minute's winding. The DAB version will give you six minutes only from one minute's winding.
- similarly, does the government really want 200 million FM radios in landfill overnight ?
- the quality of some DAB stations remains inferior to a good FM signal, and shows no sign of improving. the BBC , for example, offer many channels but its bandwidth has therefore been chopped up into quite small pieces. They did talk about acquiring more but it hasn't happened yet.
- in the age of international cooperation, especially among the EC countries, it is surely perverse to abandon FM, which can be used from one end of Europe to another, and take up one version digital radio which is not accepted by all countries who are holding out for a more up-to-date system, and other countries plan not to switching over at all.
I suspect politicians would not dare do it until the TV digital switchover took place and had been pronounced a roaring success, as opposed being an unexpected General Election issue in, say, Granada-land.
What do the Massive think ?
- More from Doods.
- Login or register to post comments







I can get neither FM nor DAB reception.
so only listen to the radio in the car or via podcasts.
The big issue, surely, is the rarity of in-car DAB equipment and, I suspect, the reluctance of manufacturers to fit it as standard given the uncertainty of the future of DAB (well, uncertainty outside the UK, anyway)
It's an interesting question
I blogged about it elsewhere the other day and one of the interesting responses suggested that the move to digital gives a degree of control to the broadcasting authorities and the government that they've never had before.
Well call me a cynic
but I should imagine that some button counter in the government is looking at the frequency spectrum that FM covers and already counting the money that the sale of it for - let's presume data traffic - it could bring in to the coffers. The whole thing seems unduly hasty though - digital TV was a step backwards in quality, DAB while more fun is also a step backwards in quality. It's possible to listen to a slightly dodgy FM or AM signal, not a digital one.
FM is far too useful and far too democratic - you can buy an FM radio for pence and use it worldwide. That's not going to happen with a digital radio.
Yep
<>
How true, my radio signal broke up if the set was sitting within about 3 feet of the cast-iron fire surrounds in my old house. The TV signal at the new one is also pretty unreliable - it seems worse when there's a lot going on on screen such as sport or a Leonard Cohen gig ;-)
The pips, the pips!
Given the time delay with digital radio (which varies from radio to radio), what'll happen about the time signal?
I look at the time in the display
Have always assumed that this was correct (I use it to reset my watch every morning anyway).
Just how crap
is your watch?!?!
Fairly
Its an automatic and it will cost what I bought it for to get it serviced. It runs fast so it stops me being late.
TV sell-off already the model
I remember once when Johnny Carson, when his show on Channel 4, getting a cheap round of applause for saying how there was not a licence fee in the US because the airwaves belonged to "you, the people".
Leaving aside the licence fee issue, no government, certainly not this very mildly leftish government has ever regarded the airwaves as belonging to the people, but rather to the state, and as such it was the state's prerogative to sell when and if it so chose.
I feel this is at the root of this, together with the Panglossian faith of these self-styled technocrats who then could care less when real problems emerge (I foresee big problems when the digital switch-over hits the big cities : it is nearly upon us, but my mother's area still can't get loads of channels), plus a more general idea that the point of government is Helping Business to Sell Stuff is at the root of this, rather than a great Orwellian conspiracy to block dissent for when the tanks roll in which is at the root of this.
If there is a coup then I doubt that anyone will look to Radio Free Tower Block as the centre of resistance. It seems now you would be better off with Twitter.
A similar viewpoint over at What Hi-Fi ?
http://community.whathifi.com/blogs/industry_insider/archive/2009/06/25/...
Likewise
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/blog/2009/jul/01/dab-fm-digital-swi...
Don't hold your breath
A few points :-
When the UK does switch to Digital, it's highly unlikely it will be to DAB. The new format probably hasn't been invented yet.
As usual, finance is the reason that radio companies are pushing this. Transmission costs have doubled by broadcasting on both digital and analogue, with very little extra income.
That's also the reason reception is currently poor. One of 'attractions' of DAB was the ability to run almost unlimited transmitters on the same frequency, ending the ridiculous situation of some small stations broadcasting on 3 or 4 localised frequencies. Problem here is transmitters and transmission costs money, so everyone has opted for as few transmitters as possible (though it was rumoured that Jenny Abramsky had one installed for herself locally).
Ofcom have stated that fm will continue, with a new raft of local community stations appearing.
The disaster potential of the TV switchover could easily result in the whole thing being shelved, by whichever party is in power by then.
DAB radio
We have our DAB radio in our bedroom tuned to Radio 4 and we awake to the Today programme. I only switched over to DAB because of the variable FM signal affected by the jets flying overhead.
DAB is okay - wouldn't rush out and buy new radios and its not as though you can convert to a digital signal like you can by buying a freeview box for your analogue tv.
Not strictly true
Due to the fact that where we are, our FM music stations are Radios 1, 2 & 3 which have nothing on during the day that I want to listen to and are even worse at weekends and Heart all our radio listening is digital and has been for a few years now. We don;t have any portable DAB radios but we do have an FM transmitter designed for use in a car which broadcasts whatever comes out of the hi-fi to the rest of the house which means not only can we listen to digital radio at the bottom of the garden we can also listen to our entire music collection on a battered old radio - handy too for the bathroom!
DAB radio
We have our DAB radio in our bedroom tuned to Radio 4 and we awake to the Today programme. I only switched over to DAB because of the variable FM signal affected by the jets flying overhead.
DAB is okay - wouldn't rush out and buy new radios and its not as though you can convert to a digital signal like you can by buying a freeview box for your analogue tv.
It could be
That with super-fast broadband finally appearing, wi-fi will be the radio delivery method of choice at home come 2015, with 3G or satellite as the in-car option. DAB appeared futuristic 10 years ago but has been outstripped by more versatile emerging technologies; it's starting to look like the radio equivalent of the 8-track.
DAB+ in Australia
Here in Oz digital radio went live on July 1st. The system used is DAB+, allegedly technically superior to the straight DAB used in the UK, but I've no idea of the differences. Am very happy with the set I bought (as a birthday present for my lovely wife), and the quality of the service. It definitely sounds better than FM (and we have a clear line of sight to the transmitters).
I have no doubt...
...that it'll be your typical scenario, once all the problems have been ironed out (in London) and everyone (in London) can receive a decent signal and everyone (in London) is ready for switchover then it will happen nationwide (and bad luck if you don't live in London).
The only stand-alone digital radio I have is in my campervan and to say the reception is crap while travelling is a bit like saying that Jonathan Ross is a bit fond of himself.
There are so many reasons why it won't happen for years...
Even though a date was announced, the government has its own targets - it will only happen once there's at least 90% coverage across the country and at least 50% of people are listening via DAB (it's currently at 20%).
Also, there's no real incentive to go DAB at the moment. With the exception of 6 Music, what do you get on digital that you don't get on a regular wireless? At least on TV, Sky drove digital sign-up through their sport offering to start with. Until digital content improves, there's no need for me to ditch my variety of analogue radios around the house.
Although talks have started with the manufacturers, there's also no real in-car DAB offering at the moment and I can't see how they're going to realistically achieve that very quickly.
Finally, the fact that it's the BBC who's theoretically going to have to stump up a lot of the switchover cost leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I understand that the commercial stations don't have masses of cash to prop it up (although I think that's a lot of bluster), but where's the incentive for them to put together good digital content, if they've not got anything 'on the line' as it were?
All in all, it's a bit of a farce!
DAB means more choice
What do you get on digital that you don't get on regular wireless?! There's loads of stuff. For me it's 6Music, NME Radio & XFM. Also during the football season it's much better listening to 5Live in the car on DAB rather than medium wave. That's just what I listen to. There are quite a few other stations available to suit different tastes.
Apart from the odd programme on Radio 4 there is nothing on analogue radio that I want to listen to these days.
The disenfranchised 10%
And what happens to the 10% of the country who don't have coverage, the poor sods? Chances are, they don't have access to WiFi or broadband either. So many of these government pronouncements seem to forget that not everyone lives in or near cities. (Christ, I'm starting to sound like my mum...)
I take it Long Wave and Short Wave will survive?
Everyone has coverage
I know it costs money but everyone in the UK is covered by digital radio from satellites. I know it's not portable but there's no technical reason why it couldn't be. Satellite radio works in the car in the US.
Renders 22 million (that's 22 million)....
vehicles obsolete with limited resale value. Take an manufacturer installed FM radio/cd/cassette unit out of a car leaves a whacking great hole.
They'd need an additional scrappage scheme to cover it.
*Never thought I'd end up sounding like Clarkson!*
Slight overstatement!
What about Revo units (or similar) or simple fit it yourself DAB radios with a windscreen mounted aerial?
Isn't even the most basic,
DIY car compatible DAB radio still somewhere north of £350?
No
My Blaupunkt DAB radio that I bought about 5 years ago for about £250 including the aerial does most things I want it to do. The only thing that I would like to do but can't is to record onto the SD card - the newer version that my wife has will do that and hers only cost about £200.
I have a feeling that any DAB switchover will only happen...
... if Labour win the next election. If the Tories win I suspect they'll have other priorities.