Entertainment For Lively Minds
Acts that divide the household
Posted by Jed Clampett on 4 June 2011 - 12:55pm.
I am quite partial to Robyn but my wife has a violent dislike of her voice. I also rather like Duffy, but my son can't stand her.
Are there other artists who cause a household hullabaloo?
- More from Jed Clampett.
- Login or register to post comments










Manic Street Preachers
One of my only favourites which I can't get past the Mrs.
Me too!
I with Mrs Kidpresentable when it comes to the MSPs. Handsome Man loves 'em, I absolutely loathe them...
She's be pleased to hear it!
Anything about them in particular? For Mrs Presentable it's his voice and that their songs usually have a chorus of one-line-repeated-alot. I don't find either of these things problematic!
Why I don't like them...
Mostly it's the way they have too many words for the music, resulting in some strange emphasis, viz "Mo-torcy-CLE emp-TI-ness".
Just fit the words properly FFS! Elton and Bernie can do it with an ocean between them, surely it's not beyond the grasp of people who are actually in the same band?
It drives me incandescent with rage!
Early on in our relationship I subjected poor Honest Man to a drunken rant expanding the theme of my hatred. For around half an hour...
I'm not keen on JDB's voice either - too whiny, no light and shade.
Tom Waits..
I think his voice is a thing of beauty, everyone else thinks I am insane.
I would say Tom Waits' voice
*was* a thing of beauty - give me Small Change all day long - up until Rain Dogs, maybe Frank's Wild Years at a push. Thereafter I fear it may have begun to parody its former self.
Crikey, he was 26 when he made Small Change!
Loads
excluding those where one track, maybe two, is deemed "bearable", the main causes of division (and derision) are:
Sex Pistols
Damned
Ramones
Motorhead
Pink Floyd
Captain Beefheart
Brian Eno
Derek & Clive
Mrs D's enjoyment of the following is not reciprocated:
Bon Jovi
Spandau Ballet
Abba
If I want Mrs Fatman to go out...
...putting on His Bobness works wonders.
Fatboy Major and Fatboy Minor both think Willy DeVille's shit.
I am the only one of the Fatclan who doesn't believe that the X Factor is consistently won by someone who's ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!
His Bobness
Guaranteed to clear the room - winner hands down in the Boptist house.
Dub.
The FPO and Stimpettes just don't get it, to the point where they argue it's not even music.
Same here
Its living room-clearing powers are matched only by subtitled films in the child kryptonite stakes.
They'll come round eventually:-) Meantime, I get peace to read the paper.
me too
particularly if she's putting her make up on for some reason...
The Fall
My other half hates The Fall. In a 'how is this even music?' way.
I find that...
...Quintessence, the Mahavishnu Orchestra and Jeff Beck result in animated discussions and swift leavings of room.
Robyn
Jed, with respect to Robyn which Body Talk album is best in your opinion: Pt 1, Pt 2, or Body Talk itself, which seems to have tracks from both the other two but a few that are on neither?
IMO
You need the whole BT album. I love the way she released that record in bits, as and when she had the best material, but now there's no reason not to own it all. Without BT3, you wouldn't have Call Your Girlfriend, Get Myself Together or Starz 4Ever and I couldn't live with that.
I think of the tracks which are on BT1 & 2 but not on the final album as being B-sides, to all intents and purposes.
Pt 1 has all the main goodies IMO
but I tend to go the spotify/iTunes route.
Listen to the Robyn discography on spotify then buy what you need track by track. Then you can also add some corkers from the 90s.
--
Thanks Jed
and Bob too. I'll do some exploring.
Richard Thompson
I can understand. Ron Sexsmith I cant believe she doesn't like. Tom Waits is an enigma - I have heard her say how lovely some of his stuff is and then next day say what the bloody hell you listening to? Er, the same stuff you liked yesterday!!
I think they do it to wind us up.
Well, I don't live with my girlfriend...
But I think I'll be single pretty soon if I carrying on playing Radiohead records. I know. Don't even.
Your girlfriend
is a wise lady and arbiter of good taste indeed...
Here are some artists that I love, but Mrs duco01 isn't keen on:
Miles Davis, John Coltrane, Charles Mingus, Thelonious Monk, Eric Dolphy, Charlie Parker, Henry Threadgill, Joe Harriott, Wayne Shorter, Joe Henderson, Mike Westbrook, Neil Ardley, Ian Carr/Nucleus, McCoy Tyner, Horace Tapscott, Richard Muhal Abrams, Tomasz Stanko, Clifford Brown, Horace Silver, Cannonball Adderley, Charles Lloyd ...
Erm ... can you see a pattern emerging here, Massivers?
You might try easing her in gently...
...with Oscar Peterson...
Quite so.
If she can't handle Coltrane, try her on Kenny G first.
Then tell her they're pretty much the same thing. Likewise it's only a hop skip and a jump from James Last to Sun Ra. Simple!
In our house...
Our divides are mostly the opposite of what you'd expect.
I'm the one that has a certain findness for prog, decent reggae, old skool hip-hop and rap and some jazz (though not too much noodling if you don't mind), and I like RT more than Handsome Man does.
However, I can't abide the Manics (see above), I hate Too Rye Aye period Dexy's and I'm utterly unbothered by the Super Furrys - I don't hate them, they just do zilcho for me.
He OTOH can't stand my pash for dance, trance, 70s pop cheese, Carpenters or the very low-fi joys of Adem.
We meet in the middle of indie, 80s electronica such as Propaganda, and new bands like British Sea Power. There's enough we like together not to be a problem, thankfully!
Music
My wife can't stand listening to music, whereas I love it. I'm talking everything. She will dance to it, especially after a few scoops. When she is in, the house is a music free zone. I might get away with head-phones.
I suppose it's a bit obvious...
... but Peter Hammill can cause ructions & violence. Ms. Stoke has threatened to throw me and the CD out the window when I was giving it loads with Plague of Lighthouse Keepers; and the Stokeling has classed Gog as "the scariest music ever - not in a good way".
Mum
Could not stand "13" by Blur when I was growing up. I listened to it a lot. She called it noise. I called it genius. We parted due to musical differences. (or I moved out and went to uni, you decide)
Now a lodger with a family who blast out Queen and Abba and occasionally the Gaga. When putting on my choices (Massive Attack, Bjork, Scott Walker, etc,) its put down as being "suicide music". Really?? If I hear "Dancing Queen" or "We Will Rock You" sung by an out of tune 8 year old at 7 in the morning, I may consider it...
Bloody hell
If you listened to any,(from both sides)of that lot then death would be a happy relief imho.Be happy!
Mr Andielou really doesn't like it
when I play my '90s grrrl rawk such as Hole & Babes In Toyland. He's not mad about PJ Harvey, Patti Smith, Throwing Muses or Kate Bush either.
I have, of course, informed him on many occasions that his intolerance of female artists is a major character defect ;)
One man
guaranteed to put a strain on our relationship - Julian Cope. Now whenever I get asked "What's this?" and I detect that certain hint of distaste, my standard reply is Julian Cope whoever it may be.
The great divide
Ones I love, not Mrs Rosbif:
Christine Collister (I know, hard to believe)
Laura Nyro
The Unthanks
Tinariwen
Til Tuesday (in particular Welcome Home, one of my favourite albums, which Mrs R loathed)
Keith Jarrett
Vice versa
Julian Cope - when we saw him live. Worst gig I've ever been to
James
Gorky's Zygotic Mynci (or however the bleedin' 'ell you spell it)
Paolo Nutini
There is plenty we agree on, happily, particularly Divine Comedy, Bowie, Kate Bush, Decemberists, Ron Sexsmith, etc etc. And of current stuff we both love the Pierces.
Everything
The missus likes top 40 pop and R&B. I'd rather stick an ice pick through my head. She thinks my musical tastes - from punk to prog, from Dylan to Devoto - are awful.
We attempted a compromise on classical music, but she likes complicated piano concertos and I like renaissance and baroque.
We moved on to Abba. As my 4-year-old has been bombarded with 'Mammia Mia' since it went to DVD, she is on board and harmony reigns. But there is only so much Abba one can take.
Consequently, when we are together there is a lot of nothing playing on the stereo.
I like Supertramp and don't have a girlfriend...
let alone a wife. Are these two facts connected?