Entertainment For Lively Minds
A Lost (Northern) Soul
Posted by Joe R on 11 June 2009 - 9:02pm.
I know very little about Northern Soul. In fact, everything I do know about Northern Soul comes from reading Stuart Maconie's Cider with Roadies.
Whilst cooking the other day (Thai mango chicken stir-fry, since you ask), I heard Marc Riley play a fantastic Northern Soul record on his 6Music show: Born a Loser by Don Ray. It was so good it gave me the urge to go out and buy lots of Northern Soul but I could probably do with some direction.
So, what should I be buying? Classic albums, underappreciated gems and comprehensive compilations, I'm open to them all and your assistance would be greatly .
- More from Joe R.
- Login or register to post comments









The Northern Soul story
Volumes 1-4 are a good place to start. Boy have you got some fantastic music to discover. For example
And this
Spotify
It can be a _very_ expensive area to collect in.
As far as I know, there are very few "albums" - it's a singles genre. Look on Amazon for the compilations, and check 'em on Spotify before you start buying "The Snake" for £45.
EDIT : looks like Paul Beard will help you Keep The Faith!
Always willing
Used to go to Wigan Casino and Stafford's Top Of The world alldayers in 1979/80 and growing up in Stoke, Northern was everywhere. still go to nights here in Barcelona.
Doesn't get any better than this
The most expensive single ever. Frank Wilson, Do I love you?
Dobie Gray is a dude... Out On The Floor
You can't have a proper stomp without, seven days is too long!
Answering with a question....
Funny but I was considering asking the Massive about Northern Soul as well.
Prompted by seeing a new compilation that looked like such good value I was suspicious. It's part of that series '101...' (not sure which record company puts them out).
So - '101 Northern Soul Hits' - 15 quid or so - have any of the experts seen it and is it a good place to start?
I'm an enthusiast as opposed to an expert
but it does look a very good starter - Al Wilson, Dobie Gray, Major Lance, Willie Tee, Gloria Jones ...
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Northern-Soul-Anthems-Various-Artists/dp/tracks/...
Looks like a pretty good “Northern Soul for beginners” comp
I’d say it was perfect and, as you say, pretty good value for someone new to Northern Soul. All the biggies are on there. Careful though. This stuff’s addictive. And before you know it you’re listening to the most dreadful rubbish. This, for instance, is one of my favourites: all out of tune and sounds like it was recorded in a garden shed. I absolutely adore it though
you have to be careful..
with compilations.
As the majority of northern records were basically none hits - the artists basically made nothing.
Subsequently some Northern players/dj's got the original singers to re-record their tracks, which are pale imitations of the original singles.
Check out some of the Kent compliations, the Talculm soul comps and Goldmine comps - all good starters. I'd recomend The Wiagn Casino Story & The Wigan Casino Story continues, both on Goldmine and well worth a tenner each or so. They'll give you a good start to the more popular stuff - then start digging !!
Good starter
http://hmv.com/hmvweb/displayProductDetails.do?ctx=280;-1;-1;-1;-1&sku=5...
This is a pretty good 2CD comp to start with, although it's not the Volume 2 it's advertised as (there only has been one volume of this). It's quite mainstream, with some chart hits thrown in, but fine for the novice to begin with.
The Greatest Northern Soul All Nighter Ever
Might sound like it's going to be cheesy but it's a cracking introduction to the music. Some absolute classics in it's tracklisting.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Best-Northern-Soul-All-Nighter-Ever/dp/B00005CBW...
Great minds....
...wow...what are the odds?
How do you define "Northern Soul"?
Yes, yes, I know all about Wigan all-nighters and all that, but what was the criterion to become labelled as such, or was it just anything that the DJs there played at that time, the more obscure the better? I don't mean to belittle the genre, if inded it is, but would any "soul/r'n'b" song become Northern by being played there and then? Mrs Path, mancunian by adoption and of the right age* says it is all in the specific drum pattern. Is that right?
*I ain't saying!
Mrs Path is more Wigan than Blackpool
“Northern Soul” is uptempo old soul stompers from the ’60s that were played in clubs in the north of England in the ‘70s to a devoted clientele.
There was however a schism within the “scene”. Ian Levine, a DJ at the Blackpool Mecca, started playing contemporary soul records alongside the “oldies”. Some welcomed this, others thought these “newies” weren’t proper Northern Soul. I’m with Levine, even though he is the man responsible for all those dodgy remakes that the mvbs warns about above. As Mrs Path says, the beat was the thing and some djs would play any old rubbish that had the necessary stomp factor.
Here’s the record that triggered all the fuss, the wonderful “It Really Hurts Me Girl” by The Carstairs.
Spotify link
Just listened to the Don Ray track on Spotify and it is a great track. If you have Spotify check out The Golden Age Of Northern Soul at http://open.spotify.com/album/2SOdKMWJPZu3iJi5eMSGL2Spot5i
You Must Get These Tracks
Exus Trek - Luther Inghram
The Magic Touch - The Bobby Fuller Four
Turning That Heartbeat Up - The MVPS
Blowing Up My Mind - The Exciters
Jumpin' Jack Flash - Thelma Houston
Gimme Shelter - Merrie Clayton
Let The Good Times Roll - Tony Newman
So Called Loving - David Essex
Stop Breaking My Heart - Tom Jones
You can grab almost all here..
http://planetmondo.blogspot.com/search/label/northern%20soul
The First Northern Soul Track
Or the tune often claimed to be the textbook template for Northern Soul is The Supremes 'Love Is Like An Itching In My Heart' and I wouldn't argue against it..
You can check the instrumental here..
As has been pointed out already…
Northern Soul is almost exclusively a singles medium, with the possible exception of R. Dean Taylor’s There’s A Ghost In My House which, although a sought-after 45 when it first broke on the scene, lost its collector’s cachet virtually overnight when someone discovered that it was on a Music For Pleasure Motown compilation that was available in every branch of Woolies for 50p…
There have been lots of good recommendations thus far, and it has to be said that you can quite easily scoop up thousands of pounds’ worth of ultra-rare Northern gems for the price of a couple of CD comps these days. The Talcum Soul series in particular is very reliable, but I’m going to give a shout for Ian Levine’s excellent compilation, ‘Reaching For The Best: The Northern Soul Of Blackpool Mecca’, which does a first rate job of chronicling the period in the development of Northern Soul where the more traditional 60s-oriented Wigan sound gave way to the smoother, Philly-era proto-disco favoured by the Blackpool dancers and DJs. Diane Jenkins’ ‘Towaway Zone’, The Mob’s glorious ‘I Dig Everything About You’ and, of course, the definitive Mecca classic, ‘It Really Hurts Me Girl’ by The Carstairs are all present and correct, and it shouldn’t be hard to pick up.
didn't The Hep
suggest a working definition of Northern Soul as stuff that sounds like Motown but isn't?
As a guide to "Soul" - period - I've always found Dave Godin's collections excellent companions
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Godin
Also check out Barney Hoskyns "Say it One Time for the Broken Hearted" as an introduction.
In one slim volume tells you all you need to know and all the stuff you need to listen to.
And whatever this is - I think it's wonderful:
Hard work, but worth it
For such an uplifting form of music, Northern Soul has always seemed most impenetrable of all pop genres to get a grip on: the culture that is, not the music (we are not talking The Wire here, the mag, not the TV series).
What is it , for a start ? The first few compilations I bought were all very obscure. For any other music you hear a track you like and want to hear another. But often these are not to be had, either for reasons of scarcity or because the artist was one of the many, many one-miss wonders. However lately the collections have the likes of Al Green, Lee Dorsey and even Paul Anka. Who's in? Who's out ?
As said elsewhere though, it is a singles medium. Compilations are available, but can be VERY variable, and even the best attract the derision of the die-hards (Northern Soul is the last bastion of the Snooty Record Guy. I don't mean this in a bad way ! Long may He continue...) , for whom it seems the only possible format is that ultra-rare seven-inch single to be found in a backstreet in Manchester, if you're lucky. Me, I have always found the fetish of ultra-rarity, as if it stands for quality, baffling.
Having said all of these frustrations, sometimes only Northern Soul will do !
Thanks to the Massive for the tips. Though I do have the late Dave Godin's fab collections and he described these are Deep Soul rather than Northern Soul. For similar, I recommend the Lost Soul compilation. If you can find it. And for Northern Soul the collection The In Crowd from a year or so back is a good start.
Paul Anka is always in
A Wigan Classic. "When we get there" is OK too