Entertainment For Lively Minds
A great song is a great song...
Posted by niallb on 23 April 2010 - 9:13am.
I must have a 6 or 7 versions of this wonderful Goffin & King song. Dusty's is still the definitive one for me but Nils' great interpretation runs it a close second. BTW, I would humbly submit that this is one of the greatest popular songs ever written.
Anyone else out there have 2 great versions of a song that does it for them?
- More from niallb.
- Login or register to post comments










'Nobody's Fault But Mine'...
The Led Zeppelin version...
...and the Nina Simone version.
Goin' Back
niallb, I can't thank you enough for introducing me to Dusty Springfield's version of this song. In the short time since you flagged it up here, it has become incredibly important to me.
Thanks
Its one of those from the 60's that my mum used to sing in the kitchen with the radio on. When mum passed away 3 years ago the song took on some deeper meaning and I can't hear it now without thinking of her and hearing her voice, in the kitchen, Two-Way Family Favourites on the radio ans Sunday lunch cooking. One day, I'd love to tell Carole King that. Thanks again.
"Annan Waters"
Both Nic Jones's version and Kate Rusby's version get a big thumbs-up from me.
Good Morning Little Schoolgirl
The hard-rockin' blues treatment from the Yardbirds:
And the acoustic treatment from Rod Stewart:
By the way, agree with you that Dusty's is the definitive version of Goin' Back, but hats off too for the Byrds' take on it.
Good Morning Little Schoolgirl
Sorry, I have to throw this in there:
Pah!
Albino White Man Sings the Blues Alert
Great version by Johnny Winter on Johnny Winter And Live too
http://open.spotify.com/track/5Rr5W8P66sMiE0VCpiLYrE
As usual, "there's a Grateful Dead for that..."
"I Don't Like Mondays"
I rather liked the Boomtown Rats song but I was totally blown away by Tori Amos' version.
Iko Iko
The Dixie Cups:
The Grateful Dead:
tracks
The original:
probably my favourite song on "Innervisions", because rather than sounding like an overworked State Of The Nation treatise, it comes across as nothing more than a beautiful afterthought tossed off to take the album past the 40 min mark; all great pop songs share that illusion of effortlessness.
The cover:
Because it proves that it is possible to dance and smile at the same time without looking like Lionel Blair.
Not that there's anything wrong...
Pete Molinari / John Martyn - Satisfied Mind
Pete Molinari's take on Satisfied Mind (here with BJ Cole from the Bush Hall) along with John Martyn's version on Sunday's Child are delightful.
Like a Prayer
I always thought there was a masterclass on reinterpretation with these two versions of "I Say a Little Prayer" by Dionne Warwick and Aretha Franklin. Are there other versions? I hardly care.
Dionne's take, like so many of her great hits, trades on an understated lightness that gives way to the full Bacharach (and oh, if her niece could do the same).
Aretha, unsurprisingly, takes it to church, fully testifying in the company (at least on record) of who I take to be her sisters. Sometimes I can hardly believe they're singing the same song, but both always stop me in my tracks.
For a more recent version of this phemomenon, how about Gnarls Barkley's "Crazy". In its initial flush of newness, it inspired a proliferation of versions by Ray Lamontagne, Nelly Furtado, and so on (to be found on this here interweb).
Pale Blue Eyes
Paul Quinn/Edwyn Collins
Velvet Underground
junkies
cowboy junkies also did a great version of Sweet Jane
The Ronettes and Beth Orton
Both sublime.
Headless Heroes
This is superb , you've gotta love Alela Diane , gorgeous voice
Wow...
Never heard that version before. Fantastic, as you say lovely voice on that girl. Thanks!
glad
glad you like it, it is an amazing album of covers
she also has 2 solo albums well worth a listen
Joanna Newsom gave her a start apparently -wiki
Shipbuilding
Sorry had to go with three.
shipbuilding
yeah the Robert Wyatt version is a classic
something very mournful in his voice
I really, really like...
...the Suede version. In fact, it was that version that got me into Elvis Costello. God bless the first "Help" album.
Ah yes, the first 'Help'
Also gave us the Manic Street Preachers' version of 'Raindrops Keep Falling On My Head' which was all kinds of lovely, and just as nice as the original.
More Wyatt
First:-
Best:-
Doesn't he look the spit of David Blunkett there?
(Robert, not Davey!)
Well if we're on a Wyatt kick, I humbly offer...
Liz Fraser is no slouch with this one.
The original is a corker as well. Only versions on you tube seem to be live ones though...
forget
also Liz Frazers amazing version of Song to the Siren
Power Trio
Well done. If we were to spin off to songs that have three great versions, things might not so easily come to mind.
Song To The Siren is almost a trio...
Obviously there's Tim Buckley
Equally obviously there's This Mortal Coil
But I personally have a weakness for James Yorkston's version as well. Not on youtube and spotify ain't working for me tonight. But do look it up, it's pretty good.
thanks
i found it here
http://www.jamesyorkston.co.uk/musicfiles/SongToTheSirenJamesYorkston.mp...
free download
yeah i quite like it
:-)
Robert Plant did a cracking version of it on (I think)
the Dreamland LP.
'My Way of Giving' comes to mind.
Small Faces:-
Chris Farlowe:-
Unfortunately, Rod Stewart's version doesn't seem to be on the web...
My favourite song bar none
Ry Cooder/Chicken Skin Band
Fantastic Slide and Vocals
(Can anyone enlighten me on the names of the singers - they are just brilliant on this)
Backing singers
Two of the three are Bobby King and Terry Evans. They issued a couple of records on Rounder and Terry Evans has released some good solo stuff.
Thanks Stimpy - wondered if it was those two...
I have a CD of King/Evans Live and Let Live! which reprises a similar version to the one above and is good set of rock/blues overall.
So, any offers on the third?
More Stevie
See Also
Always On My Mind
Brenda Lee did the original, Elvis' is probably the most famous but I hold a candle to these two versions:
Willie's version just seems to nail the emotion of the lyrics while the WEG hitmakers capture the melodic genius and, with its genre busting arrangement, nail its timelessness
agree
can only agree with you on both counts
Two off the top of my head.
Any Day Now
is one of the most heart-rending songs written. There's a great version by Ronnie Milsap but my favourite two are the 6os "original" by Chuck Jackson, a voice similar to James Carr - but my favourite version in many ways is by Paul Carrack whose mellow soulfullness lends the song that twisting powerless feeling you get when someone you love has left you without yet leaving
"Any day now, when your restless eyes meet someone new..."
Chuck Jackson
Paul Carrack
Once again, I must intervene!
Two More.
Somewhere In Between
A great second incarnation of the song:
Pilooski's remix was top-notch, too:
Lack of Afro did a sterling version on Mark Lamarr's God's Jukebox, which I took to owe a bit to the Pilooksi remix.
Teenage dreams, so hard to beat
More Goffin and King…
Up on the Roof. There’s the Drifters’ version…
and Laura Nyro’s…
...and Kenny Lynch's, and Little Eva's, and James Taylor's...
Up On The Roof
My brother couldn't even enjoy The Drifters doing this. The song was ruined for him by Robson and Jerome.
That's a shame
Because a great song is a great song. Although I cannot call to mind The Jags "I've Got Your Number" without thinking of the Peter Glaze annihilation of the same at the end of Crackerjack. He must have really hated The Jags.
"Hummingbird" Leon Russell & BB King
King of the Mad Dogs
King of the Blues
Two More (Speaking of Leon)
Wait, make that three (below)
Trifecta, Hat Trick, or such
Speaking of Leon (and is anyone else keen on his forthcoming T-Bone Burnett-produced set with Elton John? God, I'd love it to be good), I only recently made acquaintance with this, the rather dark original:
Shortly afterwards, Richard Carpenter found the bittersweet symphony in the song, sung marvellously by Karen, and perhaps now recognised -free of any ironic detachment - as a great record:
Naturally, having recently disparaged Sonic Youth elsewhere, I'll nibble on my words, for this, with pronounced maximum piano chord goodness: